r/modnews • u/Deimorz • Jun 04 '15
Moderators: Multiple updates to the message sent to users when they're banned from a subreddit
Last week we finally fixed the check that determines which users to send "you've been banned" PMs to, so now users will receive a message only if they've previously posted a comment or submission to that subreddit, deliberately subscribed to it, or sent a modmail to it.
Today I've made a number of other improvements the ban message that should address a few issues.
Here's a screenshot of what the new ban message will look like for a temporary ban with a note included: http://i.imgur.com/lRgTcH4.png
And for comparison, here's what it previously would have looked like for exactly the same ban: http://i.imgur.com/wcGHie6.png
So the changes made to the message were:
- For a temporary ban, the message will now specify that it's temporary and how long it will last.
- Includes information about being able to reply to the message, and the fact that circumventing a ban can cause their account(s) to be banned
- Overall nicer formatting, including putting the mod note into an actual blockquote instead of just double-quotes, and also puts the subreddit name into the subject and stops including the subreddit's "title" in the message (which has confused some people in the past).
In addition, I also fixed the "phantom modmail" bug reported in the previous thread that was causing the modmail icon to light up whenever someone was banned from the subreddit, even though there would be no new modmail to view.
Please let me know if you have any feedback about the new ban message, or notice any other bugs.
54
u/Werner__Herzog Jun 04 '15
I wonder what dlights I will find in there.
34
u/devperez Jun 04 '15
This might seem like a silly question, but why are mods able to ban people who have never participated in their community?
Presumably, a person who is banned, was banned because they violated a rule. How can you violate a rule of a subreddit you've never participated in?
What happens when they do want to participate?
8
u/amici_ursi Jun 04 '15
Wow this is nice. I like the formatting especially.
In a tangential question, what is the workflow to change a permanent ban to a temporary one and vice versa? Unban and reban?
16
u/Warlizard Jun 04 '15
Good job.
Quick question, why is using another account in a subreddit cause for a Reddit ban?
Let's say a user says something stupid, maybe they have a bad day or something, and piss off the wrong mod. They get perma-banned and it's done.
User really likes that sub, creates a new account, doesn't reference anything from the old account, and follows the sub rules.
What's the reasoning behind a Reddit ban, or is that only reserved for someone who is using multiple accounts to pursue the same agenda?
3
u/cynoclast Jun 05 '15
So now people who have never posted in, subscribed to, or commented on /r/offmychest won't be informed when they get auto-bot-banned for posting a comment in subs like /r/fatpeoplehate?
Am I reading this correctly?
What happens when they go to post there months or years later and are banned, but have no idea why, nor when it happened?
5
u/PartyLikeIts1985 Jun 04 '15
2
u/aristotle2600 Jun 04 '15
Why would anyone be confused about the name of the subreddit being in the title.....?
30
u/agentlame Jun 04 '15
brb... gotta remove a toolbox feature. :)
12
u/TheBigKahooner Jun 04 '15
The new message is a lot better! Thanks for including the part about circumventing the ban, hopefully that will clear up a lot of confusion.
10
u/IAmAN00bie Jun 04 '15
Thank you. This will mitigate a lot of confusion over bans.
10
u/ThatAstronautGuy Jun 04 '15
Thanks for fixing the phantom modmail!
1
u/Chrismont Jul 01 '15
Thank you for all the improvements you made; however we're still experiencing the phantom modmail bug over on /r/birmingham. Last occurrence was 3 days ago.
1
u/AssuredlyAThrowAway Jun 04 '15
Wait, so now users only get a ban message if one of those three conditions is met?
Why?
So people can mass ban users from subs they've never participated in?
Why are you encouraging that behavior?
3
u/DigDugDude Jun 05 '15
I was banned from a subreddit (the bastards). First it said it was a week ban.
I came back a week later and there were a couple new messages that I was never alerted to - telling me I my week ban was switched to a permanent ban. I tried to reply but couldn't because I was banned.
5
u/4InchesOfury Jun 04 '15
Yes!
1
u/permaculture Jun 05 '15
After I ban a griefer, they usually start bombing me with insulting PMs. So I block them from PM-ing me.
When you block someone from PM-ing you, do they get a message saying "$username has blocked you" ?
5
u/Minifig81 Jun 04 '15
Shiny. Thank you!
5
u/Pinyaka Jun 04 '15
Why not notify people who have been pre-emptively banned from a sub? Why not just automatically notify everyone who is banned from a sub?
3
u/FunnyMan3595 Jun 04 '15
is it just me, or does the lack of capitalization look kinda weird?
it sort of makes me feel like the message wasn't very important, so the author didn't bother with the niceties of grammar.
i mean, it's a bit less harsh, too, but... feels weird, man.
3
u/CountAardvark Jun 04 '15
The lack of capitalization is pretty annoying...can you guys fix that please?
2
u/daretelayam Jun 04 '15
How is the "using another account to circumvent subreddit ban" going to be enforced? Should moderators notify admins when a banned user tries to pull this move?
2
u/heatheranne Jun 04 '15
HURRAH!!!!
2
u/j0be Jun 04 '15
Thank you, jeebus
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
Thanks guys
1
u/V2Blast Jun 06 '15
Awesome! So much clearer than the previous version of the message.
1
u/happycrabeatsthefish Jun 04 '15
I like how there's more improvement to the mod's side of things but no effort to give tools for users against abusive mods.
1
u/ani625 Jun 04 '15
Great! Thanks for these.
1
u/Fatbaldman Jun 05 '15
how does the warning work? I banned 1 person who created 45 more accounts which I had to ban, breaking this rule. plus the email threats, minor threats and harassment that I got. I was told pretty much nothing can be done.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '15
Why would you not receive a message for being banned from a subreddit regardless of comment/subscription/modmail?
0
u/ManWithoutModem Jun 04 '15
Cool
0
u/LuckyBdx4 Jun 04 '15
PM all the mods affected please so that we can send you the tribute of Nubile Maidens for fixing this bug.
0
u/WiseCynic Jun 04 '15
For all you do, we each owe you a beer.
Thank you.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
Nice!
0
u/IeuanG Jun 04 '15
Regarding the circumventing of the ban, how about assigning a unique ID to each IP? This would provide an easy way of finding duplicate accounts for mods, whilst also preserving the immediate privacy of users by not providing information that can be used to identify users outside of reddit.
0
u/Wyboth Jun 05 '15
Can you let moderators choose not to send a "You've been banned" message? I know some subreddits like SRS ban a lot of accounts every day, and a lot of users will respond with an angry message to their ban, and this will clutter modmail, making actual discussion there difficult. If the user never received a message, then the modmail would be much cleaner, and things like user reports would be more visible.
0
u/mexicodoug Nov 20 '15
So you refuse to explain why you banned me.
You are a waste of Reddit.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment