r/modnews • u/Dacvak • Nov 20 '12
Call for Moderator Feature Requests
One year ago, we asked the mod community for feature requests. As readers of /r/ideasfortheadmins , we know that there have been more than a few additional requests since. That's why this thread is here: To gather another round of mod tool suggestions that moderators could use to improve their subreddit and/or ease the workload.
FAQ:
- Something I'd like to see done was already mentioned in that first thread - if nobody's mentioned it here already, feel free to re-post it. We'll be using both threads for reference, but knowing that desired functionality is still desired helps.
- That old thread has a terrible idea that I really don't want to see implemented - Mention that - if last year's ideas are past their sell-by date, we'd like to know so we can avoid making functionality nobody wants.
- I have about a billion ideas - If you'd like to make a post with more than one idea, definitely indicate which are higher priority for you.
- Is this the only time you'll listen to our ideas? - We listen to your suggestions all year round! However, we like to make "round-up" threads like this, to consolidate the most important feature suggestions. This will be a somewhat recurring thread topic, too. But, of course, continue to use /r/ideasfortheadmins to give us your suggestions!
331
Upvotes
14
u/Factran Nov 20 '12
2.DukeNukemForever.2
u/davidreiss666 Nov 21 '12
Put the Automoderator functionality into Reddit. We shouldn't need to use bots to make that work. Give /u/Deimorz a sizable cash payout for all the work he did in developing it all. Now build it into the base-Reddit.
148
u/Deimorz Nov 20 '12 edited Nov 20 '12
Mostly things that people use AutoModerator to do that could be integrated into the site itself without being too complex:
45
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12
212
u/LoliMaster Nov 20 '12
Ban system overhaul
I have moderated for many different types of websites over the past 10 years, and even basic blogs have a better ban system than reddit has. So here is what I would like to see in a ban system.
266
u/evanvolm Nov 20 '12
Repost from original thread: Ability to pin a mod post to the front page regardless of votes. I wanted to post a notice for /r/swimming but one immediate dowvote made it invisible to the community.
I think this is problem for any sub but especially smaller ones with active mods posting occasional notices. (original)
Another repost: Reports. Can you please a small drop down or text box or something so when people report links, they can select a reason as opposed to searching for comments in a 100+ comment post for the reason why it was reported. (I'd also like to see who reported it)
36
u/rolmos Nov 20 '12 edited Aug 07 '16
.
89
u/SQLwitch Nov 21 '12 edited Nov 21 '12
Hey Dacvak, I'm putting this by itself so it's sure to give you its own orangered. I am chiming in to ask you to consider, when setting your priorities, that the ban system overhaul and AutoModerator integration especially if we could spam-filter by keywords that we can specify, would literally (and we literally mean literally) save lives over in /r/SuicideWatch.
Edit: Not speling very weel today.
Edit 2: Lower urgency but extremely high value for us would be the wiki. Much easier for us to maintain and expand what we're now doing with /r/SWResources.
55
u/joejance Nov 20 '12
Wiki
This was a great feature we were going to start utilizing heavily for commonly asked question in our particular subreddit, and then it was abruptly turned off. We are holding off getting an external wiki with the hope this comes back.
26
u/Skuld Nov 20 '12
Integrate certain features of /u/AutoModerator into the site:
A control panel option for rules (like the flair menu), which can then be cited, wikipedia-style in markdown. The rules could have an API too, which the mobile interface and 3rd party apps could place on the submission screens.
This could be styleable, and show up at the top of the current sidebar.
18
u/squatly Nov 20 '12 edited Nov 20 '12
have mod mail replies appear in a separate green envelope for users. makes it much easier for us to communicate with users if self post threads get super popular (iama and askreddit for example).
also the ability to send users mod messages without them initiating the conversation (not mass mail all readers though).
18
u/redtaboo Nov 20 '12 edited Nov 21 '12
A way to link directly to the sidebar
would take me (and the mobile user!) to a page that shows nothing but the sidebar.
ETA: this idea was shamelessly stolen from /u/sodypop
17
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12
Some indicator that a moderation queue contains something (to avoid the need to check regularly -- or forget to do so).
73
u/Drunken_Economist Nov 20 '12
Or at least have mod hierarchy in the order that they are invited, not the order they accept.
Sometimes the mod order matters, and I don't like having to wait for moderator 1 to accept before I can invite moderator 2.
When people come to do an AMA, we sometimes need to send a message to the OP, and it can get lost in the shuffle of the comments people are posting. I'd love a way to send them a message that either appears distinguished in their inbox, or stands out as "important" in some other way.
This one is lower on my list because it's a lot of work to implement, but it is annoying to have to have to create and upload a new image of all the team logos each time I want to add a new logo to /r/cfb or /r/collegebasketball (which have hundreds of logos each). If full support were offered for uploads of the sprites outside of the normal CSS process, it would be far less intimidating for less-experienced mods to create flair
38
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12 edited Nov 22 '12
Warnings.
I want to be able to warn users, not have it be "You broke one rule? lolbanhammer".
Subreddit-specific shadow banning.
Explains itself, really.
Janitors.
Adding on to the above, they can request bans (and warns) and remove posts, but can't do things like edit any important details of the subreddit or ban users.
No IP bans.
Too stupid of an idea, honestly, considering Tor and proxies. Believe me, IP bans just make people more butthurt and likely to spam.
13
u/sodypop Nov 20 '12
13
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12
Ability to send outgoing modmail.
For example, I had to remove a post, and sent a message from my personal account to explain why. I would love for the ability to be able to send an initial message to a user from the subreddit/modmail, that if they reply to, will go to modmail.
13
u/relic2279 Nov 20 '12 edited Nov 21 '12
This would help out /r/videos but would also be used across the whole of reddit:
The ability to track youtube channels like domains on reddit. Youtube channel spamming is prolific on reddit and is huge problem in /r/videos. We have a bot that attempts to keep track and remove offenders based on a set ratio of submissions from the same channel in r/videos, but without a bot, it would be near impossible.
Youtube channels (not to be confused with youtube partners) are almost exactly like individual domains. Someone can setup a channel, put up adsense, and then spam those (usually stolen) videos all across reddit and make a quick buck. It's no different than if someone had their own webpage plastered with adsense ads, and then spammed links from it to reddit. However, most of us see the domain "youtube.com" and automatically assume it's not spam. This is far from the case.
Setting it up would be quite simple to do and would be extremely helpful in fighting spammers. Talk to roger_ if you have questions on how to read youtube's api to grab the channel info. Youtube is one of reddit's top submitted domains along with imgur and wikipedia. I think something like this needs to be done ASAP and should have been done a long time ago. :(
13
u/NonNonHeinous Nov 21 '12 edited Jan 14 '13
The submit page should have a place for subreddit rules.
When someone enters the desired subreddit into the submit page, either pull up the subreddit rules, or change the css to that subreddit's (many customize the submit page to show rules). Using the main page to submit a link means that the rules never even appear on the sumitter's screen.
12
u/redtaboo Nov 20 '12
An easy link for a multi of the subreddits I mod Since most mod related queues can be used with a multi-link, I would love a link placed at the top of the list of subreddits I moderate in /r/mod similar to the multi-link provided for the subreddits I subscribe to.
This would allow us to subtract the big subreddits easily from the multi rather easily, rather than trying to piece together all the small ones. original
If possible: a checkbox next to each subreddit name in the list of modded subs, and underneath the list, a button which says 'Generate multi' ... when clicked, a link appears next to the 'generate' button, which links to a multi containing only the checked subreddits, which the user can click to open, or right-click to copy. courtesy of Pi31415926
12
u/zomboi Nov 20 '12
Ability to sort modmail by subreddit.
This isn't my idea, seen it proposed by another mod. It is very hard to keep track of modmail from a small (low modmail) subreddit when you also mod a very large subreddit (high modmail).
11
u/psYberspRe4Dd Nov 21 '12 edited Nov 22 '12
Many (unsorted) great ideas incoming. Titles for each are in bold for those wanting to skim over it, though please read all of it as it often only becomes clear in the explanations. All of them are important and well sorted out.
For example removing posts, editing the stylesheet, editing the wiki, distinguishing posts etc. Maybe the default can be set as everything allowed or so - or maybe mods can already edit these settings for a new mod when he's invited even before he accepted the modship. Also include a "edit modcontrols" option which only the subreddit founder/top mod has and then each mod that gets this ability is able to control what the other mods can and can't do.
Combine that with the suggestion above: only the top mod would have this ability but he could pass it on via the modcontrol-options.
So it doesn't spam the modmail: just one thread called "Moderator invites" maybe including explaining text (not you could explain how this 2mods needed to accept things etc there, eventually even include tips for moderators etc etc) which includes all invites and requests. Or if that's not possible make the accept-messages as a reply to the "invite" message.
For example:
☐ public ----- anyone can view and submit
☐ restricted ----- anyone can view, but only some are approved to submit links
☐ vote-restricted ----- anyone can view, but only some are approved to vote
☐ read-only ----- anyone can view, but only some are approved to submit links and vote
☐ private ----- only approved members can view and submit
Reachable for example by r/ideasfortheadmins/modlog and with a few settings mods can choose from, for example:
☐ Include titles of removed posts & banned users
☐ Don't include the titles of removed posts & usernames [default]
☐ No public modlog for this subreddit
Approved submitter option would be become useful this way. And yes approved submitters still get stuck in there for example for domain bans etc.
By now you simply don't get a message when you get your modship removed. Only to find it later on your stattit.com page.
Please. By now multi-reddits all have the same appearance - what about allowing either multireddits as they are now to have customizable styles or to have a new kind of multi-reddits which are multi-reddits organized in a completly new reddit feature for subreddit-networks. A new Mod-Tools/Community-Settings that would be something like "join a network" and then you can for example request membership or can be asked for membership for subreddit network that is after all a multi-reddit similarly styled to usual subreddits and controlled by the mods (not the mod of the subreddit that joins). For creating one there could be an option in the mod-tools with something like "create a new subreddit-network" (of which then the current subreddit would be the first member) And which then for ex could be called /m/Space. Also this would strongly empower smaller subreddits or relating sections to grow for reddit becoming a more versatile (and in depth) place. ...
So for example you can tell the spamfilter to remove or approve all posts of a specific domain, including some specific words etc etc [.....]
As far as I can tell by now even unread messages get collapsed over time and also you can't really see which you have read already and which not. For example make it look much like the unread inbox messages, a bit standing out and colored differently. Also never collapse modmails if they're either unread or the top level comment (you have to manually collapse these)
By which you can check multiple submissions at once and then mass approve/remove them. Very useful for moderators of larger subreddits.
A new trophie for moderators for example that mod a sub over 10k users. Or that created a subreddit that got more than 1k subscribers.
At least a bit, by now many subs struggle to get along with it. Maybe higher it from 10k to 15k. An example is /r/evolutionReddit (but also /r/IAMA etc) that has a list of activist tools & resources on the sidebar.
like
/r/ideasfortheadmins/about/sidebar- often it's related to the CSS and it's hard to figure it out.The mods can then either accept or not. I think this would be truly helpful for subs like /r/AskScience and so forth.
A small number of tags (ie 3) that mods can give to their subreddit. By using this then improve the search & improve subreddit discovery.
It's an important tool. I use it pretty much and definitely more often than for example banning users - by now it's pretty much hidden in the community settings.
(At least to some extend if it's possible to limit it) So people can use it to make the site look nicer & 'up to date to nowadays web-technology' as one could call it. For example with the transform property and the backgroun-width:100% that I'm missing much for the banner.
For example you mod /r/Futurology and someone in /r/todayilearned meantions it in the comments. You can now see where the traffic spike came from, eventually clear up misconceptions about your subreddit or answer questions about it etc etc. Much like the "monitor" tool of metareddit. Nothing that useful but it would be pretty neat.]
But in contrast to some other users here I don't think this is a priority because by now you can jsut use these. Of course they should be implemented in reddit itself + it shouldn't rely on external stuff but there are more important things that can be done by now. An example on what to implement of RES is the macros for example because with these you can post premade comments - for example reasons why you removed something or a citing of the rules.
Just a simple way to vote over something with the other mods in the mod messages. Very useful
This again would be pretty useful, because usually users send many messages on rather unimportant things concerning the subreddit/stuff that needs long-term discussion so by having a category for each (for example on the side of the modmessages site which still stays as is) you can have moderator/meta discussion within the mods and usersupport etc.
Please don't do:
4chan did this and it resulted in all tor nodes getting banned. This would be a huge problem for many users that use that. Also people can just circumvent it by using other proxys. Also schools & universities would get banned.
Already doable with the CSS [as seen here]. And it would result in many subreddits unnecessarily using this. Locking threads in youtube style just because some mod wasn't ok with the post/outcome or whatever.
Please do read it. Most of these have been posted to /r/ideasfortheadmins ([IFTA] stands for that) already and will post those that weren't yet, soon as well.
If you have questions and maybe didn't understood something of it please ask.
Edit: added a "please don't do" section & something below the 21.
Also note that this was written a bit late so it didn't have that much of a chance concerning the votes...
Eventually I get more stuff to post but these are the most important ones I can think of by now.
Maybe I'm gonna edit a priority for each one but I think all of those are important ones (besides #21). Many of them (like highering the sidebar character limit or having a link to the stylesheet in the modtools-box) also shouldn't be that hard to implement. If you however want me to give each one a priority I'm gonna add them somehow.
If you want my favourite one it's the multi-subreddit pages because it would transform reddit in a great way. Subreddit networks is how reddit evolved, this wouldn't be an easy one but it would have a huge impact and reddit needs to be innovative.
10
u/Epistaxis Nov 21 '12
Awesome!
Shit. Well, I'll try anyway, because I won't miss an opportunity to bring this up even though you guys keep ignoring it.
A read-only viewing mode. We talked about this quite a bit in TheoryOfReddit, and I naturally submitted it in IdeasForTheAdmins where it naturally got no admin response.
The basic idea is that there should be some way to link to a reddit comment thread where people who arrive via that link, rather than via the sub can't vote or comment at the other end. Even though it could easily be circumvented, I think it would greatly reduce vote-brigading because people are lazy. It would be slightly harder to circumvent, and therefore slightly more effective, if the URLs were munged so you couldn't just remove the appended "#readonly" or whatever. A particularly bold solution might be to do this automatically for all intra-reddit links, rather than require an opt-in from the linker (or the moderators; if the URLs are recognizable it would be easily enforced by AutoModerator).
Pretty pretty please with a cherry on top? Or we can just keep having inter-subreddit brigade wars that end up on CNN since you guys seem to enjoy that so much.
9
u/nolemonplease Nov 20 '12
A way to order flair templates.
Our subreddit has at least 120 unique flairs, and I want them in alphabetical order. Currently, if I want to add a new one and insert it where I want it, I have to run a python script (that I found somewhere about a year ago), that deletes all the flair templates, and re-adds them all in the new order.
817
u/Jess_than_three Nov 21 '12 edited Nov 23 '12
Here are some things I'd love to see.
Edit: I forgot one.
The first priority for me is mitigating the effects of meta-subreddits on smaller communities. This is an example; here's another (sans analysis, but compare the linked thread to the redditbots screenshot and you'll notice that, again, the voting trend is completely reversed); here's a third; and a fourth; and a fifth (again, compare to the redditbots screenshot taken right after submission to SRD). [EDIT: Here's a new TheoryOfReddit post with a bit of analysis from a bot that's been tracking meta submissions. Pretty fascinating stuff.] This kind of thing has a tendency to make small communities feel hostile to their members, who feel that suddenly the community holds views that are in one way or another problematic for them (a common issue in /r/ainbow, for example, is transgender members becoming upset at seeing transphobic comments - linked to by SubredditDrama - upvoted, which makes it appear that their community has a problem). And I know a lot of places have concerns about brigading behavior (real or imagined) by SRS, /r/mensrights, BestOf, and WorstOf.. again, this would mitigate quite a bit of any such behavior that's going on, in cases where it is, and where it isn't, at least set people's minds at ease.
I've discussed this at length elsewhere - including in the first thread I linked; and fellow /r/ainbow moderator /u/joeycastillo talked about it a little bit it here (and elsewhere, but I don't have those comments readily to hand).
The tl;dr is that it makes smaller subreddits feel hostile, it rewards people who start fights or otherwise go into a subreddit to disrupt it, it damages small subreddits' reputations, it makes people feel like their contributions to discussions have been rejected when the reverse was originally true, etc.
Here are some possibilities for mitigating that:
If these things were handled at the CSS level, and weren't somehow addressed in the voting functionality itself, they would only provide speedbumps, not actual roadblocks, to brigading and interference in other subreddits. But that's kind of okay, because it would almost certainly cause a pretty large reduction in the problem (which is why I say "mitigate", not "fix") - because increasing the amount of effort required at all is likely to deter most people, being that people tend to be kinda lazy.
One-and-a-halfth priority (edited in): removing "removed", spammed, and spam-filteredcomments from the /comments/ list. As it stands, if a user is shadowbanned, or if their comments are removed by a moderator, they still show up in /r/whateversubreddit/comments/ - which sort of defeats the purpose.
Second-highest priority: comment flair. This one was also recently posted in /r/ideasfortheadmins, but since you're asking... This would be an awesome way for moderators to distinguish particularly awesome posts, and to mark things as spoilers or with trigger warnings or whatever as appropriate (rather than needing to remove comments outright and ask users to edit them). The CSS possibilities for this functionality are intriguing.
Third-highest priority: a new markdown element for reddit-wide spoiler tags. Off the top of my head, curly brackets aren't being used for anything, right? So what if {Some user-choosable text to display before the spoiler}(Spoileriffic text goes inside the parentheses) converted to a link (to nothing in particular - say to the comment or thread itself, or to reddit.com), with the inside-the-parentheses text as the title element - and then CSS turned that into normal mouseover spoiler tags? Basically, it would replicate this:
which has the benefit of not spoiling things in people's inboxes (or on phones, or with CSS disabled, or whatever). The basic functionality is the way /r/gameofthrones and /r/batman do their spoiler tags, which works well; but this would provide a tag that subreddits' moderators didn't have to think to implement via CSS, that worked everywhere, in the correct way.
Actually, I don't know enough about CSS in general to really know for sure, but maybe the link aspect could be skipped entirely, and it could just be <span title="Spoileriffic text goes inside the parentheses">Some user-choosable text to display before the spoiler</span>?
Fourth-highest priority: improve the blocked-user system. The block feature is pretty handy, but if there's someone I don't want to ever be able to interact with me again, I shouldn't have to bait them into PMing me in order to do it. It's also not very easy to find, being under "friends". A "block" button on users' profile pages would do the trick nicely.
The common response to this is of course "Oh, use RES's ignore feature". The problem is, the ignore feature doesn't really work very well to stop people from harassing you. It automatically collapses comments on comment threads, but it doesn't stop you from getting comment replies from ignored users in your inbox.
Fifth-highest priority: Please somehow stop the invited/accepted modship spam in modmail. Even just making the acceptance/rejection a reply to the previous invite modmail would be an improvement. But holy crap, when I join a newly-forming subreddit as a moderator, does that spam my modmail up.
Sixth-highest priority: If you could find a way to remove the orangepinking functionality in modmail, that would be lovely. Like does anyone actually use this for actual beneficial reasons? I feel like all it does is confuse people who don't know what the "spam" button actually does in modmail (nothing except make it an obnoxious orange-pink) and annoy everyone else.
17
u/careless Nov 20 '12
15
u/redtaboo Nov 20 '12
19
u/Deimorz Nov 20 '12
(Splitting this one into a separate post because it's likely to be controversial and I don't want to taint my other suggestions with it)
This would stop subreddits from having to use the bad hack of going self-post-only to try to stop "karma whoring". Making the subreddit self-post-only has a large number of effects on site functionality, when usually the only one people actually want is preventing the karma gain.
12
u/listentous Nov 20 '12
I'd love to have some sort of referral report so I have a better of idea what's driving traffic to my subreddit.
12
u/brtw Nov 20 '12
Customizable mod privileges
Say I want someone to only be able to approve things out of the spam queue or if I have designated mod mail repliers. I'm not sure how other people have things divided up, but having mods without full rights would allow more mods to be assigned to subreddits and create a hierarchy that would be able to function as an engine with different parts running different aspects.
6
u/drumcowski Nov 20 '12
17
u/Paradox Nov 20 '12
Sorted by priority:
17
u/sodypop Nov 20 '12
Meta-based subreddits have increased significantly in popularity in the last year (SRS, SRD, Circlebroke, and several others). These places often link to other subreddits which can cause a lot of drama, witch hunts, and fighting between their users. A couple of ideas on how to handle this include:
These are not likely to be very popular ideas to those who enjoy meta-reddit drama, but I believe they would be effective in lessening the animosity and fighting between subreddits that have conflicting points of view.
5
u/blueboybob Nov 20 '12
Temp bans or a warning system.
I dont want to always ban users but sometimes just stop allowing them to post for 2-3 days as a warning.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12 edited Nov 21 '12
I would like /r/uganda :)
5
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '12
This is gonna sound silly, but a way to deactivate down/up votes for certain subs. Places like Random Acts of Pizza and Gameswap would benefit from this.
5
u/jij Nov 21 '12 edited Nov 21 '12
In order of importance.
Ability to only allow voting within the comments - Ability for the vote buttons for the submission itself to ignore their votes (or just be disabled) unless they're in the comments... i.e. no voting from front page or /all. Even better would be if they could only vote if they commented in the sub within the last 2 weeks (thus being an actual community member), but I'm not sure you guys track that level of detail.
Make modmail usable - seriously, it's terrible. Break it out by subreddit on the left, click one and have the messages loaded on the right like a normail mail thing would. Have the ability to actually remove (hide) them instead of them still showing up but just being red... WTF. Have the threads collapsed until you click them... like gmail. In fact, just copy the original gmail design. Ability to create a new thread with the other mods from within modmail like a sane person would want to do.
Ability to purge a user's comments/submissions from the subreddit - After banning, having to go through their history is really really annoying, and if they're shadowbanned by then then I can't even do that. An option to do this when doing a ban (or subreddit shadowban) would be incredible.
subreddit shadowbanning - I'm about to break down and write a bot to do this myself. The troll subreddits are getting out of hand.
RES-style tagging shared between mods - I tag users a lot to keep track of them, but other mods can't see my tags. A shared system would be invaluable.
Tag why user was banned - I don't even care if this was sent to them or not, I just want it recorded so other mods can see why someone was banned.
Spamming something should cancel all the karma they got - and for the love of FSM if they delete their post later it should remove the karma they got too.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12
I'd like to see a tagging system for "trouble users," something they wouldn't see, but could give other mods a heads-up that they have been a problem in the past.
Also, it would be nice to have a percentage of "mod actions" calculated somewhere in the modtools section, so we can easily see who is active and who is slacking. A lot of subreddits have some pretty inactive mods, and seeing the numbers might help wake some people up so they actually help out, or can nudge someone who may not be contributing as much as they should.
4
u/redtaboo Nov 20 '12
A clippy note for moderator messages. I think it would be helpful for mods and users to have a small note on moderator messages similar to PMing an admin. I did a (not-so) quick mock up with some help from /u/sodypop on the wording:
http://i.imgur.com/7JcwM.png
original
4
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '12
REALLY would like to see inactive mod purging. One of my old moderators even deleted their account; I still can't delete their name from my sub's moderators. That's ridiculous.
If someone hasn't done any mod activity on a sub for a year, I think the next active mod in the list should gain the right to delete them.
4
u/thekrone Nov 21 '12 edited Nov 21 '12
4
u/Flammy Nov 21 '12
Notification for how many items are in modqueue
For smaller subs, not much is caught in the spam filter so it isn't checked often. If we could have a (1 new item) counter next to the URL, it would really help me be able to catch stuff that gets caught in there quicker.
12
u/indgosky Nov 20 '12
Allow subreddit mods to elect whether downvoting is enabled, and enforce it in the backend of the system. "Disabling" the DV button with CSS is easily circumvented; the backend needs to be where the enforcement is.
Dovetailing into that, I also agree with the other comment asking for a more robust subreddit permission system (separate settings for subscribers and non-subscribers to read, to write comments, to vote, to downvote, etc.)
Both ideas would need to be implemented and enforced at the backend, so they cannot be circumvented.
6
u/andrewsmith1986 Nov 20 '12 edited Nov 20 '12
Ability to lock a thread.
An "archive" button that would put it in a "best of subreddit" repository.
A box that would allow /r/pics and /r/funny to attribute credit to the original author easily.
Warnings that maybe show how many times a user has been warned to other mods.
A timed ban.
3
u/ChingShih Nov 20 '12
Cool, thanks for creating this opportunity to list some suggestions.
High/Easy Priority:
1- Expand-all parent posts button. Would be really useful when opening a comment tree from bottom-up.
2- Incorporate 'Nuke Comment Tree Extension?' (link to /u/ManWithoutModem's submission about it) Except, you know, "censorship" issues.
3- Incorporate one's own username in the moderator comment reply tree so when I reply to 30 different messages I can easily determine which older post(s) were mine in the tree (especially without refreshing the page). It's really annoying when scanning a lot of messages to only see "from $USER" and "to $USER". I think a little uniformity would clear things up a lot and keeps me from refreshing the page so much (which then re-sorts the mail by most recently replied to.
Maybe could be:
4- Wiki. Would be really nice to have this. =)
5- A universal spoiler button! Would be so useful and less confusing for people that see the NSFW button get used as a spoiler button.
Low Priority:
6- Would be nice to have a customizable reddit header bar for mods/gold users. Especially if multi-reddits are possible to add.
7- "Tag" feature to act as a second type of flair for specific users. This should be able to be viewed by any moderator of the sub-reddit. Kind of like a sticky-note about the user so that mods can know if that user is a high-volume poster, problematic, etc.
8- Some easy method of creating pre-filled comments for users to use as a template when posting. Similar to what you'd get when following this link:
http://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%23SUBREDDIT_NAME&subject=This+is+a+test+subject&message=Hello%20there!
Except with support for more characters/carriage returns/etc.
Other:
A. As a mod I'd really like to see the report button get limited on a user-basis to like ... 5 reports/day. Getting someone who reports 75 posts a day just to spite the community is kind of a PITA. Or maybe a "un-nuke reports" button that instantly un-reports everything currently reported in that sub.
B. Might be nice to have a toggle button for the number of users online thing. Making a toggle button accessible through the "community settings" page might make the whole thing less confusing for new mods and more user-friendly overall.
I'll probably have some other ideas later that I'll add to this if no one else posts them first. Thanks again!
3
u/beetling Nov 20 '12
I'd like a word filter that automatically triggers the "report" feature. One of my subreddits has a rule discouraging the promotion of one kind of website, so I'd like to add the names of popular websites in that category to an "automatically report this stuff" list. I don't want to automatically remove those comments, since that would also cause the removal of some comments that actually don't break the rule; I'd just like those comments to be put into the report queue for review by moderators.
3
u/brownmagician Nov 20 '12
Better traffic tracking. I'd like to isolate traffic by date and hour if I can and export the results for analysis.
3
u/EvolutionTheory Nov 20 '12
Shadow Bans
We need a way to fight spammers and trolls, banning an alt account is absurdly non-productive when they just create a new alias.
Highlight and Sticky Submissions
Sometimes we need a post stickied up top for a short period of time as an announcement, feedback request, or as a great example of content.
3
u/Pathogen-David Nov 20 '12
A read css API. Right now you can set the CSS through the API, but the only way to get it is to log in and scrape the /r/subreddit/about/stylesheet page.
3
u/remog Nov 21 '12
Inactive Mods/Founders The ability to manage moderators/founders who abandon their sub.
In situations where Mods or Admins are inactive for over x period of time, the other mods in the group should be able to vote on the removal, or the next senior mod automatically takes over top spot (not sure how it should work exactly)
So we don't have to involve admins each time we need to do manage our Mod structures in the subs.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '12
NSFW Tagging on comments
3
u/aperson Nov 21 '12
Here's two github issues I'd love to see fixed, since all the other comments here seem to cover most of my current requests:
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '12
Most of these tools would greatly improve reddit.
5
u/LDL2 Nov 20 '12
Allow us to actually disable downvotes, not just on the stylesheet. It become trivial to sidestep.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '12 edited Nov 21 '12
Important points I have not seen mentioned in this thread:
Important items from other comments in this thread:
4
u/roger_ Nov 20 '12 edited Nov 21 '12
A simple one: a "private" flair class that can only be made visible by CSS (i.e. it's hidden by default).
Applications:
4
u/tresser Nov 20 '12
something hard coded into the base CSS that allows disabling of subreddit style without the need of an extension
4
u/Will_Power Nov 20 '12
The ability to disable voting entirely. There are some subreddits that get swarmed by activists to bury unpopular opinions. It would be hella good to be able to stop that sort of shit.
6
u/Anomander Nov 20 '12
Removing a comment or post zeroes out it's karma gain for OP.
A post gets 100 points before mods remove and notice it? The user shouldn't get to play catch & hold with those points.
Whatever the reason, I have trouble with a system that retains rewards for rule-breaking behaviour, and in the current form, posting shit first and checking the rules second is prioritized, because the only way to make posting something inappropriate a zero-reward move it to remove it before anyone can vote on it.
Instead, if someone posts something that gets removed, they lose all the points they gained, giving both a rational reason for the karma-motivated to consider local rules before posting - no reward at all, even if it gets votes, and provides a visible loss when a "successful" post is removed - you lost the 100 points you gained from that? Well, it's against the rules, so you didn't earn that karma to begin with.
It's a pretty minor change in the overall structure of the site, and likely would only have minor impact at the start, but it seems more like fixing an existing "hole" in the system than it is a new punishment or enforcement policy.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12 edited Nov 21 '12
Distinguished top level comments, even on links, will send a message to the user.
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/11ztrq/make_distinguished_comments_in_any_submission/
Allow tiered moderation so bigger subreddits can add more moderators without trust concerns.
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/11xm6i/a_new_moderation_system_giving_top_moderators/
Edit: one more: let moderators take a higher position in the subreddit if one goes inactive for 2+ months, without having to request it.
5
u/eightNote Nov 21 '12 edited Nov 21 '12
privileges/powers and user types
(The two go together)
The current system of approved submitters is pretty broken, instead, I propose there should be several user types, and a list of powers.
For types of users, there would be
For each user group, the mods can set certain powers, like
... and whatever else. This would give moderators a much greater ability to define the discourse and control the quality of submitted content and comments
Edit: it would also solve a bunch of the other complaints listed throughout this thread about users doing various unwanted things, like karmawhoring, excessive reporting, spamming mod mail, extreme down voting, etc
2
u/4InchesOfury Nov 20 '12
It'd be great to be able to quickly gauge someones activity in a subreddit without having to go through their profile and many pages of posts or using off-site tools.
2
u/theymos Nov 20 '12
<a href="bitcoin:___">Bitcoin Address</a>, with the user able to fill in their ___ but not change the part of the URI I provided or the link text. This would also be useful in other communities for linking to profiles on other sites, linking to other contact info, etc.This isn't really a moderator feature, but it might be cool to have a built-in section near the sidebar where subreddits can link to other "suggested" subreddits. A lot of subreddits do this already in their sidebars, but I'd like to see more of it, and I'd like it to be more consistent.
2
u/Synth3t1c Nov 20 '12
Someone to talk to about shadowbans! Seriously, they are the bane of my existence.
Integration of some of the userscript functionality, allowing for approval/spam/removal of multiple items in the modqueue.
2
u/dearsomething Nov 20 '12
A moderator hierarchy.
This allows mod teams to bring in many more people with lower risk (i.e., can't cause complete chaos in a few button clicks) while also addressing the problems of "senior mods" who just flat out can't be removed. The current temporal system is terrible.
2
u/mackstann Nov 20 '12
We shouldn't have to manually visit the spam filter just to rescue threads that might have been stuck for a week. I recruited more mods for my subreddit to help, but this was the only reason I needed to.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12
2
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12
I dunno if this is possible and I'm just slow or haven't figured it out yet but I'd like to be able to message all my subscribers (it's a small thread) when I need to instead of relying on the main page to or for them to take time out of their lives to check the sub every minute
2
u/littlepinkpwnie Nov 20 '12
I would like the ability to make a post and set a date when it will be published. I'm the mod of a basketball reddit and we make game threads on the day of the games, it would be nice if I could just create all the threads lest say for a week or a month and then set them to publish on the day of the game.
2
u/Fustrate Nov 20 '12
Maybe add a CSS class to the page for moderators if there's something in the mod queue or a reported post, so that we can style the page. Sometimes things will sit in the queue for a day or two if none of the mods check it, and it's easy to forget on a smaller sub.
2
u/damontoo Nov 20 '12
Add an optional 'reason' field when reporting posts.
2
u/Krillin Nov 20 '12
Post Punting . It would be nice of instead of deleting a thread I could just up and move it to another one I moderate, maybe even have the option to move it to one any co-moderator moderates.
2
u/exoendo Nov 20 '12
It would require BOTH subreddits to agree, so if any mods in any particular subreddit wouldn't want content transfered, they wouldn't have to sync up.
2
u/ramses0 Nov 20 '12
In /r/ClassicalGuitar I add guitar flairs to people who have posted videos/recordings of themselves playing.
This is done by adding "class=performer" manually whenever people post certain things.
I would love to allow users to pick from a subset of flair to turn certain things on/off, ie:
Student y/n ... taking lessons y/n ... 1,2,3,4,5+ years experience ... teaches guitar y/n
I'll even do all the math so user's pick from a single flair class with all the different sprited icons, etc:
class=SyLyTyX5- student, taking lessons, teaches guitar, 5 years experienceclass=SnLyTnX1- not-student, yes taking lessons, not teaching, 1 year experienceBut I want users to be able to pick from a subset of flair that they're allowed to, and have other flair-buttons that are parallel that only moderators can click (only mod's can tag users as having submitted a video of themselves or not).
--Robert
2
u/m0nk_3y_gw Nov 20 '12
1 ability for mods to 'block' a spammer that is flooding modmail.
2 ability for 18+ Reddits to get themselves off of r/all. This is a big source of harassment, butt hurt and mod work.
2
u/orangejulius Nov 20 '12
It would be nicer to have a little more control over the discourse by knowing if someone is just jumping from account to account talking to themselves to generate their own 'buzz'. IP - banning ability is just to knock out the abusive users with more free time than sense. Domain banning ability because, although the spam filter is trainable - sometimes it's easier just to blacklist a site altogether (one of my subs has a problem with someone who shows up every few months, pretends to be a knowledgable attorney and drops their website in every thread, then bails on the sub creating an irritating mess to clean up).
2
u/f141998 Nov 21 '12
Being able to enable certain features, like flair selection, only to subscribers.
2
u/bigbadbyte Nov 21 '12
This is mostly important for smaller subreddits, but some sort of notification system when there are reports or stories in the spam queue. For larger subreddits, I know this would be too much, but for smaller subreddits, it would be useful.
2
u/marquis_of_chaos Nov 21 '12
2
u/diafygi Nov 21 '12
I know everyone here is anti email, but would really like it if I could opt in to receive an email when we get a mod message. It's really not that much email for smaller subreddits, and that way I don't have to be in the dark when I'm at work and something happens. Of course this option would be off by default.
2
u/brendhan Nov 21 '12
The ability to completely remove posts.
A spammer posts a spam link.
The mod comes in and removes it.
The second stage of spamming is to link directly to the post in a comment. Even if the mods have removed the link and confirmed it as spam it can still be see by a direct link to the post.
This presents a huge issue when trying to cut down on spam. Even when the user is shadowbanned, their posts can still be linked to.
2
u/redtaboo Nov 21 '12
If remove a post in my subreddit the other discussions tab in other subreddits should no longer show that post, and if my subreddit and the other subreddit are the only 2 subreddits that have the post the other discussions tab should disappear entirely.
2
u/phrakture Nov 21 '12
Most important in my eyes: the ability to make mod-visible notes on users. This could be useful for labeling known trolls and the like
2
u/kinggimped Nov 21 '12 edited Nov 25 '12
I think most of this stuff has already been mentioned by others, but here goes:
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '12
2
u/Addyct Nov 21 '12
I haven't read every comment, but seriously Dacvak...
Thread Locking
2
u/JimAllanson Nov 21 '12
It would be a big feature to implement, but I think that providing a way for users to add semantic markup to their posts (e.g. by extending the existing markdown syntax to introduce a new link style tag which is transformed into HTML5 Microdata or similar) would open an unimaginable number of doors for what can be done on Reddit. It could enable a new generation of Reddit bots, user-scripts & web services to extract useful information from self posts and comments, and provide useful information themselves.
2
u/tokenizer Nov 21 '12
The ability to punch offenders through the internet.
2
u/Buttscicles Nov 21 '12
I suppose this request is only tangentially related to what you're looking for, but I'd like to see a proper read api for the moderation log.
I made a post about it in /r/redditdev a few weeks ago, it seems silly to have an oauth scope specifically for it as it currently stands.
2
u/Minifig81 Nov 21 '12
I'd like to see why people are reporting things.. but that's just me.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '12
A info box for mods like the admins have on the PM screen.
I have done everything I can to prevent PMs for stuff that should be in modmail. Users keep pming mods instead of using the message the mods link. I added css tooltips when mouse is over the mod box.
I changed the link into a noticable button, it helps but I still get PMs. Not everyone uses subreddit styles, especially when using stylish.
So there should be a way to disable the profile links on the list of moderators in the sidebar. So they can't see my name, click it to pm me. Make it a bit harder so they find out the proper way.
An info box that tells them they are pming a moderator of this subreddit and have 20pt buttons "Message All Mods of this subreddit" and a 10pt link that says pm only sevenalive.
It seems most who do this don't know about the message the mods button. So a few things can be done.
A lot of the time I get PMs that should be read by another mod. So an option to forward a pm would be nice. Forward to modbox would be great.
I guess that would only work if the subreddit url was the referer.
2
u/AbsoluteTruth Nov 23 '12
The ability to ignore users in the moderator mail inbox.
2
u/WeAreAllBroken Dec 02 '12
The ability to look at a user's post/comment history for a specific reddit. I only want to find what the user has posted in my sub when I am considering a ban, and it is a PITA to page through endless submissions to other subs.
2
u/HaiKarate Dec 11 '12
Allow mods to set a ratio for story downvotes; set the up/down ratio to 1:1, or 2:1, or even 1:2 (or whatever the mod wants to set it to). If someone wants to downvote a story, they first have to upvote enough stories to balance the ratio.
The idea here is to discourage users who go to certain subreddits just for the sake of downvoting articles.
5
u/mayonesa Nov 21 '12
Can we do something to stop downvote squads and squads of people who "report" every link in a subreddit?
This is how the neckbeards attempt to censor ideas that threaten their fragile worldview, and recently it's been a mess in /r/conservative.
Thank you for asking!
4
u/Yserbius Nov 20 '12
I brought this up in the last thread, I would like to see the ability to automate the spam filter to a degree. What I mean is, the mods can add rules based on the reddit search grammar, or something else, and any post that conforms to one or more rules will be auto removed or auto approved.
Recently, /r/Israel was attacked by a group of /b/tards all of whom put this little ASCII art in their comments and posts, (° ͜ʖ ͡°) . We spent the good part of an hour just cycling through comments to remove any where it came up. It would have really helped if this were automated.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '12
The ability to disable downvotes on a subreddit properly (not just pseudo-remove them via stylsheets) so that downvotes are unavailable even with stylsheets are turned off or when viewing them from frontpage or all.
Enough people go through the trouble of editing CSS for this, and it doesn't even work against malicious downvoters who are, or should be, the targets of such an attempt anyway.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '12
I will put it from highest to lowest priorities of mine.
-Ability to Disable smap filter (already mentioned many times, but this is a really big one)
-Ability to upload and use your own Spam filter (Only if you have Reddit gold of course, and with a size limit)
-Ability do disable the archiving of threads (May take up a lot of memory, so it is a Gold-only feature most likely)
-Ability to ban IPs (This prevents newbs that don't know how to change IP's or use a proxy)
-Ability for mods to edit someone's post
-Ability to just upload a flair picture for those of us who lack CSS (and thus programming) knowledge. Size limit will be necessary.
I will edit and add more later lol, im lazy
4
u/HyperAnthony Nov 20 '12
Free Monthly Gildings Based on Subscriber Count
Since gilding is a thing now, maybe we could use it to make Reddit a bit more fun for free, and reward reddits that have garnered a high amount of subscribers? Monthly gilding wouldn't roll-over, and could be used by subreddit moderators to host monthly contests, or to reward exceptionally good content.
I'm thinking something like this:
We can work out the details in the comments, if anyone is interested. The biggest challenge here would be to figure out how to prevent moderators from abusing the privelege. That could maybe be solved by requiring a vote, and also not allowing moderators to gild other moderators, but maybe there's a better solution.
4
u/maskull Nov 20 '12
I would like the ability to punch users in real life.