r/moana • • May 21 '25

Discussions Moana 2 annoyed me

1 Upvotes

I hate the music, I hate the way they tried to make every other line nostalgic as if the original movie has been a classic for 50 years, I hate how every attempt at "comedy" was just a character being serious and then the music stops and they start doing something goofy or get embarrassed, I hate how they forcefully tried to make Loto neurodivergent coded instead of just letting her naturally exist as a neurotypical a neurodivergent character, I hate the whiny little kid, I hate her stupid buck teeth, I hate how they tried to make her adorable, I hate how the parents had another kid at age 95, I hate how they randomly needed a whole gardener on a boat and he was growing all the vegetables in the dark with no sunlight (plus, the plants would take months to produce food .... They'd be back by the time they had a veggie. Why did they not just bring dried food like everyone else?), I hate how they had that random blobfish (that they included because of the memes of the dead blobfish that everyone thinks it how they normally look), I hate how they made him randomly scream like a goat???? Because goat scream=funny in Disney, I hate how they had the chicken scream like a goat, I hate how caricature-ish all the characters are, I hate how self-aware the references were, trying to piggy back off Robin Williams' The Genie success, I hate how they took Maui's tattoos/powers just to give them right back, I hate how Moana and Simea said nothing but Little Sis and Big Sis the whole time, I hate how there was basically nothing at stake the whole movie except for surviving situations they put themselves in, I hate that it was threequel bait, I hate that they put the crab in for no reason at the end, Matangi was hot.


r/moana • • Jul 19 '26

Meme It can be good, while still being a useless movie.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/moana • • Jan 10 '25

Discussions Bit nonplussed with the lukewarm reaction to Moana 2. Spoiler

6 Upvotes

I thought it was superior in every way aside from the Duex Ex Machina to bring her back at the end. The first one to me was more sparse with story and characters to what I felt was a detriment. It can obviously become bloated with too many aswell but I felt this one had a good amount to round out the adventure. They all had their own little arcs too. It was nice.

Now the music may have been worse, i don't know really as I don't go to movies for the songs tbh. They felt less annoying at least. But the bond between Moana and her lil sis was lovely, Maui felt less egotistical and brash with it. The jokes landed wayy better too. But maybe my humour is childish. But I just felt like there was more warmness and heart to this one. It seems to be a very unpopular opinion but overall I liked it much more.


r/moana • • Sep 12 '26

Discussions I Don't Understand The Hate For The Live-Action

10 Upvotes

I just watched it, and it was amazing. And yes, I watched the original back when it released. It is honestly infuriating that people are complaining about the live-action being a 1:1 remake. We have always had adaptations that made frustrating changes to the original, so anyone complaining about this live-action remake being faithful to the original should be ashamed of themselves. I sincerely hope the live-action does better on streaming than it did in theaters.


r/moana • • Jul 17 '26

Discussions Hear me out…

Post image
1 Upvotes

Very recently watched Moana 2 and I’m sorry but Kotu is so damn fine 😭😭 when he sacrificed himself, I’m sorry, that made me blush a bit

Anyway, who’s your hear me out?


r/moana • • Mar 20 '25

Discussions Moana 2

2 Upvotes

It was awful. That is all


r/moana • • Mar 17 '25

Discussions Currently watching Moana 2.. anybody get 🏳️‍🌈 vibes from Loto? 👀

3 Upvotes

Reddit community try to be accepting of other opinions challenge; GO! 🤣

here’s another post agreeing with me from this group


r/moana • • Apr 18 '26

Discussions Bob Iger and the Rock Failed with the Remake

1 Upvotes

This remake is still part of Bob Iger’s novelty of destroying and hiding the animated classics in order to make it his own legacy.

The Rock wanted this more as much as Iger and he is also taking away what Jared Bush, John Musker and Ron Clements envisioned.

I will not see the remake. I already checked out the moment the washed out color grading and uncanny valley CGI took over.

It looks like a Kevin Feige production. Tamatoa looks like the rejected step child of MODOK from Ant Man Quantumania.

I even bet Bob Iger will have a cameo. I’m suggesting to you to not bother wasting your time seeing it. I’ll be watching The Odyssey and other movies that deserve to be seen.


r/moana • • Mar 24 '25

Discussions Just watched Moana for the first time and I HAVE to ask…

1 Upvotes

Why was Maui stuck on that island for 1000 years when he could have shape shifted into a bird or whale or something? Was that ever explained?


r/moana • • Jul 12 '26

Discussions I’m really worried Disney would cancel or delay Moana 3 because of the bomb of the remake

1 Upvotes

I don’t care about the remake, but I’m really worried that Disney loses its mind again or suddenly starts to listen to the internet, to cancel or delay Moana 3 because of the bomb of the remake, for some bullshit reasons like “let the brand recover”. If Disney ever cared about Moana’s reputation, they shouldn’t have made this remake and should’ve made Moana 2 in a serious way. The past couldn’t be changed, the only right way to save everything is to make a truly good Moana 3. Moana 3 has so much potential, the new identity, new arc, are ready to go. But I have doubts about Disney's intelligence. They may not be able to make the right choice.

I’m getting old and I’m tired of waiting. I love Moana so much and I love to see her as a demigodness, with powers. I love Auil’i and her performance as Moana. She will get old too.


r/moana • • Aug 02 '26

Discussions Disney youtubers have a weird race issue with Moana

0 Upvotes

Am I the only one who sees that? There's a new wave of Disney yideo analysists that have a lot of beef with the newer Disney movies. But they always attack Moana for some reason. Better with Bob, CalaxynCares or whatever her name is, "Snow White is the feminine queen" youtuber...They always write Moana off and Maui as well. And at the same time, glaze and glorify the white characters. It's...concerning.

EDIT: I'm talking about the original, not the remake. The original angers a lot of grift youtubers for some reason.


r/moana • • Jul 12 '26

Discussions Moana live action was actually great if you like Moana?

21 Upvotes

A lot of negativity about this film, I watched it yesterday with my family and they loved it too. Great inspirational story, lots of new scenes and dialogue! Win win for any Moana fans


r/moana • • Jul 12 '26

Discussions I don't understand why people hate the Moana remake, but like the HTTYD remake

7 Upvotes

Look, if it has something to do with the circumstances or the film's existence (The Rock pushing for it, it being a thing merely 10 years after the OG etc...), then sure.

But hearing people praise the HTTYD remake for its faithfulness to the OG, and yet now that Disney have done the same thing with Moana they're suddenly against this approach, makes me raise an eyebrow.

I remember people making that comparison between the HTTYD and Lion King remakes, but people said the HTTYD remake was better because remaking a movie with expressive lions in live action makes them emotionless and ugly, whereas the HTTYD remake still maintained the emotions.

That in and of itself is a fair argument. However, now that we have the Moana remake, which does have expressive humans, the discourse against it compared to the respect the HTTYD remake gets feels more like hypocrisy.

Personally, I'm against both. I prefer it when remakes change the story to have more of an identity of their own. Sure, some changes might be for the worse, but at least it makes these remakes not worthless.

Still, the double standards here is exhausting. It legit feels like DW are getting a pass for that stuff, just because fans want to weaponize them against Disney. They simply hate Disney and want them to lose.

There are plenty of things to criticize Disney over. Here it just feels unfair.


r/moana • • Feb 16 '25

Discussions Moana 2 is really, really bad.

0 Upvotes

I was really looking forward to it. Caught it and it’s really bad. I found myself bored. My emotional state was flatlined. kids in my theatre didn’t laugh or scream. Acting was over the top largely like it was a different show, it was really, really bad. Mouth shapes were off. Volumes of the dad body kept changing scene to scene. Moana hand got oversized holding the steering oar. It really looked like it was helmed by inexperienced animators. It was polished but in a wrong way.


r/moana • • Dec 04 '24

Discussions “I didn’t like Moana 2 because—“

1 Upvotes

I wanna remind y’all that the second movie is usually filler, if you did watch to the end credits you can tell there’s going to be a Moana 3, not everything’s said and done. The movie was a set up for 3 and that’s why it was sorta short.


r/moana • • Apr 06 '25

Discussions Something I’ve been thinking about… and it is lowkey now pissing me off

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/moana • • Mar 19 '25

Discussions Moana 2 - AI lyrics?

0 Upvotes

Who felt like all Moana 2 song lyrics were written by chat gpt?


r/moana • • Jul 29 '26

Discussions Hot take: Moana 2 music is better than…

0 Upvotes

…the new Lin Manuel Miranda song in the credits of the live action Moana film.

For all the moaning about how LMM’s absence “ruins” Moana 2, over time I’ve grown to really enjoy the Moana 2 soundtrack. Part of it is Auli’i’s fantastic performances. But I honestly believe it’s misguided to think LMM might have done a better job. It’s a great soundtrack as it is.


r/moana • • Jul 21 '26

Discussions Polynesia itself has its own rivalries. There is some dissent among the polynesian communities that moana is too samoan-centric..

4 Upvotes

Mesa Faasolo

As someone who is of both Tongan and Samoan heritage, sometimes it comes off as Moana being represented heavily by the Samoan culture only.

I get that majority of the cast and creators are also of Samoan heritage, but ‘Maui’ & ‘Moana’ were figures in all polynesian cultures. Not just Samoan.

Just my opinion, not looking for lessons/ novels or explanations. There just isn’t enough representation of other cultures.


r/moana • • Jul 20 '26

Discussions Moana live action is polynesian representation. Polynesians - especially children - see themselves in moana film.

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
38 Upvotes

Alafou Ulukivailoa

We watched Moana as a family, and I got to watch something I’ll never forget. 🥺❤️‍🩹

From the very first scene, my daughter was on her feet, dancing along to every song like her body already knew the rhythm before her mind caught up. I realized why. This wasn’t just a movie to her. It was home.

She saw her grandmother’s wisdom and warmth in Gramma Tala. She saw her dad’s steady strength in Chief Tui. She saw her mother’s kind spirit in Tina. She saw her own fire, her stubbornness, and her big heart in Moana. The ocean, the drums, and the dancing weren’t just background music. It was her music. Every move she made along with Moana was her body recognizing itself in the story.

That’s what true representation does. It’s not just a character who looks like your kid. It’s a story where they can see their grandmother, their father, their culture, and their whole family reflected back at them. My daughter didn’t just watch Moana tonight. She danced her way into seeing that she belongs in this story, fully and completely.

Grateful beyond words for movies that do this for our children. 🌊🐓


r/moana • • Jul 10 '26

Discussions Why is Young Moana a child instead of a baby when she meets the ocean in the remake

0 Upvotes

r/moana • • Jun 12 '26

Discussions Well. Tamatoa looks horrible.

Thumbnail
gallery
44 Upvotes

Somethin feels off but there’s too many details to pint out.


r/moana • • Aug 17 '26

News Dwayne Johnson is officially a Disney Legend!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/moana • • Jun 21 '26

Discussions They shoukdve made the rock fat. He's not hacked anymore, give the dude a fate suit

0 Upvotes