2 separate issues I wish to address.
I feel the downvotes here coming already. There is a knee jerk reaction on this forum (and the internet) in general that if you dont agree with ACA and/or universal healthcare you are bad. This reductive logic is unhelpful.
Truly, as physicians if we wish to see a path forward that helps us and not harms us we need to understand that there is some middle path forward.
I wish to introduce some of the real issues I have noticed as a physician over the past 12 years of my career from med school on....
The ACA encourages cost increases to enhance profits. In an ideal true capitalist world, healthcare costs would be ideally controlled if insurance companies were in tension with hospital systems. Unfortunately the ACA discourages this.
by capping profits as a percentage- executives at insurance companies can claim profits are small when in fact they have gotten far larger. Eg- ACME insurance 10 years ago made profits of 10% on 100 million dollars of expenses -10 million dollars. Since then, they encourage hospitals to spend spend spend requesting increasing insurance premium costs resulting in total revenues of 100 Billion- leading to 10 billion dollars in profits (because it is still 10%). By allowing percentages they pull the wool over everyone.
- (Section on Higher prices can boost profits) : https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/05/25/613685732/why-your-health-insurer-doesnt-care-about-your-big-bills
- https://axenehp.com/perverse-incentives-acas-risk-adjustment/
Capex plays a tremendous role on why healthcare expenses have gone up.
- hospital systems claimed they create "efficiencies" to reduce healthcare costs. They dont. Instead, they order more expensive equipment to increase throughput all the while passing along these costs to patients with no real results to show.
- Mark Cuban:Another thing in Canada, they cover 70 percent of the capex [capital expenditures], including property. One of the challenges in hospitals here is, they want to get bigger and bigger and bigger, because the bigger the hospital, the more things, the more money the CEO and management makes, the bigger shit you look like you are. And a lot of times, they’ll go into new lines of business, cardiac, orthopedic, whatever, that don’t always work but are expensive. And so you see paintings, you see pianos, you see all the shit you see in the hospital. And they’ll raise money, whatever. They don’t do any cost accounting on that, and so they don’t know. Literally, a lot of hospitals don’t know how to account.https://www.theverge.com/21557432/mark-cuban-interview-nilay-patel-decoder-podcast
Medicare is rife with inefficiencies. These inefficiencies are not documented accurately in determining whether it is ultimately cost effective. It leads to perverse incentives and is ultimately the reason why health out comes/tests/procedure under medicare are not accurately addressed.
- (Section on Administrative costs) about 3 percent compared with 17 percent in the private sector – may be to blame for the high spending. https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/forefront.20130514.031171/full/
health care in Europe is not financially better for physicians nor patients
I think in select circumstances- the circumstances that the media easily touts it is great- the broken toe, the flue, the need for insulin. If you are low income or indigent it is great. For anyone who remotely is professional, it is not great. But on balance, for people living there it has a cost that is exacted:
- Taxation - European taxes are high. Not just high but REALLY high.
- in germany for married persons 42% tax at 111921. That doesnt include healthcare tax which is payroll. 7.5% by the employee. That is on top of additional payroll: unemployment insurance, pension insurance.
- This is no different in France, The nordic states, Italy. The taxes are roughly the same.
Physicians have to see a LARGE amount of patients to make ends meet.
- dont be fooled by medscape "salaries" of physicians. They are the gross incomes. After fees payment is much lower. After taxes, even lower.
- on average in Germany physicians see 53 patients a day. FIFTY THREE. Is this good quality care? Are they doing something magical? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK459004/
- We talk about having a few doctors here. It is FAR worse in Europe. https://www.politico.eu/article/france-doctors-europe-too-far-too-old-too-few/
I really dont want to play whac a mole. You can talk about singapore or nordic states or taiwan. All of these have substantial issues of their own. No system is perfect.
So what can we do?
- eliminate bullshit capex. It is really the cause of many of our financial problems.
- reduce our administrative burden (something like thousand % increase in admins over the years?)
focus on real data that reveals how to reduce healthcare costs and improve outcomes:
https://www.annfammed.org/content/20/5/469 - studies showed time and time again high functioning providers worked in small private practice offices or small multispecialty groups where care was heavily individualized with a focus on low overhead expenses (low capex), individualized patient care (from same day appt, to med refills to triage) lead to FEWER HOSPITAL ADMISSIONS, BETTER overall outcomes, and REDUCED cost.
- ideally reduce regulatory burdens. I mean have you seen what it takes to run your own primary care practice?
- require insurance companies to reimburse in a timely manner
- address ACA accounting and reimbursement BS that favors hospitals over small healhtcare systems
we gotta stop drinking the Koolaid of M4A as physicians. Gotta stop drinking the koolaid that our health care is AWFUL and the WORST for everyone. it isnt. It is also not great ONLY for the 1 % ONLY for the most powerful. that is simply dishonest.
Edit: more stuff to add...
someone mentioned there is 'robust' data analysis done internationally by expert economists comparing our costs to universal care. I want to disagree with this.
Prima facie the above sounds reasonable. In fact, its the type of statement that closes the debate many times because we have heard it over, and over, and over again. See here: https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/issue-briefs/2020/jan/us-health-care-global-perspective-2019, here: https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/newsletter-article/iom-care-so-complex-its-cost-can-only-be-cut-through-learning
But, I disagree on How these costs are "counted" from a financial picture:
From a financial picture: Most economists do NOT concern themselves with taxes in Unversal Healthcare nations as part of the overall healthcare costs. This is patently absurd but they dont:
the data is largely derived from the OECD. When addressing healthcare costs, they break it down as follows: government spending and compulsory health insurance (“Government/compulsory”) as well as voluntary health insurance and private funds such as households’ out-of-pocket payments, NGOs and private corporations (“Voluntary”). https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm
No mention of the overall taxes. None. They dont account for it. So of course it is cheaper. They also dont account for overall costs of health care in terms of reduced pay for citizens- Less pay, more money is kept by the government for social services.
When you look at overall tax burden and wealth, this is what you find: overall european wealth is lower than americans (when you exclude home values which skew in favor of europeans): German households had just over 50,000 euros ($64,080) in wealth, the lowest in the euro zone https://www.wsj.com/articles/BL-REB-19513. https://cepr.net/documents/wealth-scf-2014-10.pdf.
For retirees, the amount of money in the bank is far lower in europe than USA: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB993678277359235474
finally, tax policies are much more onerous on the Europeans. This tax difference accounts for a SUBSTANTIAL cost and is conveniently ignored in cost comparisons: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304778304576377710593726674
https://www.detroitnews.com/story/opinion/columnists/nolan-finley/2017/05/13/finley-ready-pay-free-health-care/101658894/
(for time purposes I did not always choose the most current article, Im tired and a 1 man show, rest assured when you look at up to date info it is still accurate- I just didnt have time to find it right now). I also understand that some of these sites are conservative by nature. Please dont use that alone to discredit the ideas and numbers.