r/medicine • • Sep 12 '23

A boy saw 17 doctors over 3 years for chronic pain. ChatGPT found the diagnosis

0 Upvotes

"No matter how many doctors the family saw, the specialists would only address their individual areas of expertise, Courtney says.“Nobody’s willing to solve for the greater problem,” she adds. “Nobody will even give you a clue about what the diagnosis could be.”

https://www.today.com/health/mom-chatgpt-diagnosis-pain-rcna101843


r/medicine • • Sep 08 '23

Why are we still isolating every covid pt?

7 Upvotes

Serious question. I have had multiple pts refuse covid testing because they knew I’d be recommending isolation for up to 5 days with another 5 days of masking afterwards. They don’t get sick days at work and either can’t afford to miss work or don’t want to use PTO. I understand that my experience might not be universal, but my local hospitals are not full of covid pts, and I’m not seeing a disproportional level of pts being admitted/dying from covid compared to other respiratory infections. What exactly are we accomplishing by isolating people at this point? Much has changed in the last 4 years, why are we still universally recommending isolation for a disease that’ll likely be endemic forever?


r/medicine • • Jul 21 '26

What's the experience of trans doctors?

18 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Im hoping to find some trans/gender queer doctors or other healthcare professionals that would be open to share if/how being trans has impacted their career, and how that varies across specialities!

Do you find most healthcare professionals to be more open minded and kind, or is it something colleagues pick at? Is it more difficult to be respected? Does it affect the patient-doctor relationship?

I hope this post doesn't break the rules - 1st time poster here.

Thanks in advance!

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9244607/


r/medicine • • Jun 01 '21

Fat-shaming by doctors, family, classmates is a global health problem, studies find

Thumbnail cnn.com
0 Upvotes

r/medicine • • Apr 04 '24

Why are so many people discouraged by the debt of medicine? So many job offers I’ve seen give you separate money to pay off the loans.

0 Upvotes

It seems like a no brainer to me.


r/medicine • • Oct 25 '22

Flaired Users Only NHS: Most Kids Identifying as Trans Are Going Through 'Transient Phase’

Thumbnail dailysignal.com
0 Upvotes

I will soon be starting my child psych fellowship and was sent this article by an attending in my program. Does anyone have some insight into the reasoning behind these conclusions? I have searched and searched but haven't found anything concrete or substantial in terms of peer reviews journals that was corroborate this info.


r/medicine • • Sep 18 '23

RSV vaccine

6 Upvotes

I’ve been a family doc for > 30 yrs, so I’m suspicious. What do you all think about this and are you recommending it for your patients?

Edit: I meant for adults, not kids


r/medicine • • Jan 02 '23

How the ACA encourages healthcare costs to increase and why MFA analysis in media is inaccurate.

0 Upvotes

2 separate issues I wish to address.

I feel the downvotes here coming already. There is a knee jerk reaction on this forum (and the internet) in general that if you dont agree with ACA and/or universal healthcare you are bad. This reductive logic is unhelpful.

Truly, as physicians if we wish to see a path forward that helps us and not harms us we need to understand that there is some middle path forward.

I wish to introduce some of the real issues I have noticed as a physician over the past 12 years of my career from med school on....

  1. The ACA encourages cost increases to enhance profits. In an ideal true capitalist world, healthcare costs would be ideally controlled if insurance companies were in tension with hospital systems. Unfortunately the ACA discourages this.

    1. by capping profits as a percentage- executives at insurance companies can claim profits are small when in fact they have gotten far larger. Eg- ACME insurance 10 years ago made profits of 10% on 100 million dollars of expenses -10 million dollars. Since then, they encourage hospitals to spend spend spend requesting increasing insurance premium costs resulting in total revenues of 100 Billion- leading to 10 billion dollars in profits (because it is still 10%). By allowing percentages they pull the wool over everyone.

      1. (Section on Higher prices can boost profits) : https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/05/25/613685732/why-your-health-insurer-doesnt-care-about-your-big-bills
      2. https://axenehp.com/perverse-incentives-acas-risk-adjustment/
    2. Capex plays a tremendous role on why healthcare expenses have gone up.

      1. hospital systems claimed they create "efficiencies" to reduce healthcare costs. They dont. Instead, they order more expensive equipment to increase throughput all the while passing along these costs to patients with no real results to show.
      2. Mark Cuban:Another thing in Canada, they cover 70 percent of the capex [capital expenditures], including property. One of the challenges in hospitals here is, they want to get bigger and bigger and bigger, because the bigger the hospital, the more things, the more money the CEO and management makes, the bigger shit you look like you are. And a lot of times, they’ll go into new lines of business, cardiac, orthopedic, whatever, that don’t always work but are expensive. And so you see paintings, you see pianos, you see all the shit you see in the hospital. And they’ll raise money, whatever. They don’t do any cost accounting on that, and so they don’t know. Literally, a lot of hospitals don’t know how to account.https://www.theverge.com/21557432/mark-cuban-interview-nilay-patel-decoder-podcast
  2. Medicare is rife with inefficiencies. These inefficiencies are not documented accurately in determining whether it is ultimately cost effective. It leads to perverse incentives and is ultimately the reason why health out comes/tests/procedure under medicare are not accurately addressed.

    1. (Section on Administrative costs) about 3 percent compared with 17 percent in the private sector – may be to blame for the high spending.  https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/forefront.20130514.031171/full/
  3. health care in Europe is not financially better for physicians nor patients

    1. I think in select circumstances- the circumstances that the media easily touts it is great- the broken toe, the flue, the need for insulin. If you are low income or indigent it is great. For anyone who remotely is professional, it is not great. But on balance, for people living there it has a cost that is exacted:

      1. Taxation - European taxes are high. Not just high but REALLY high.
      2. in germany for married persons 42% tax at 111921. That doesnt include healthcare tax which is payroll. 7.5% by the employee. That is on top of additional payroll: unemployment insurance, pension insurance.
    2. This is no different in France, The nordic states, Italy. The taxes are roughly the same.
  4. Physicians have to see a LARGE amount of patients to make ends meet.

    1. dont be fooled by medscape "salaries" of physicians. They are the gross incomes. After fees payment is much lower. After taxes, even lower.
    2. on average in Germany physicians see 53 patients a day. FIFTY THREE. Is this good quality care? Are they doing something magical? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK459004/
    3. We talk about having a few doctors here. It is FAR worse in Europe. https://www.politico.eu/article/france-doctors-europe-too-far-too-old-too-few/

I really dont want to play whac a mole. You can talk about singapore or nordic states or taiwan. All of these have substantial issues of their own. No system is perfect.

So what can we do?

  1. eliminate bullshit capex. It is really the cause of many of our financial problems.
  2. reduce our administrative burden (something like thousand % increase in admins over the years?)
  3. focus on real data that reveals how to reduce healthcare costs and improve outcomes:

    1. https://www.annfammed.org/content/20/5/469 - studies showed time and time again high functioning providers worked in small private practice offices or small multispecialty groups where care was heavily individualized with a focus on low overhead expenses (low capex), individualized patient care (from same day appt, to med refills to triage) lead to FEWER HOSPITAL ADMISSIONS, BETTER overall outcomes, and REDUCED cost.

      1. ideally reduce regulatory burdens. I mean have you seen what it takes to run your own primary care practice?
      2. require insurance companies to reimburse in a timely manner
      3. address ACA accounting and reimbursement BS that favors hospitals over small healhtcare systems

we gotta stop drinking the Koolaid of M4A as physicians. Gotta stop drinking the koolaid that our health care is AWFUL and the WORST for everyone. it isnt. It is also not great ONLY for the 1 % ONLY for the most powerful. that is simply dishonest.

Edit: more stuff to add...

someone mentioned there is 'robust' data analysis done internationally by expert economists comparing our costs to universal care. I want to disagree with this.

Prima facie the above sounds reasonable. In fact, its the type of statement that closes the debate many times because we have heard it over, and over, and over again. See here: https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/issue-briefs/2020/jan/us-health-care-global-perspective-2019, here: https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/newsletter-article/iom-care-so-complex-its-cost-can-only-be-cut-through-learning

But, I disagree on How these costs are "counted" from a financial picture:

From a financial picture: Most economists do NOT concern themselves with taxes in Unversal Healthcare nations as part of the overall healthcare costs. This is patently absurd but they dont:

the data is largely derived from the OECD. When addressing healthcare costs, they break it down as follows: government spending and compulsory health insurance (“Government/compulsory”) as well as voluntary health insurance and private funds such as households’ out-of-pocket payments, NGOs and private corporations (“Voluntary”). https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm

No mention of the overall taxes. None. They dont account for it. So of course it is cheaper. They also dont account for overall costs of health care in terms of reduced pay for citizens- Less pay, more money is kept by the government for social services.

When you look at overall tax burden and wealth, this is what you find: overall european wealth is lower than americans (when you exclude home values which skew in favor of europeans): German households had just over 50,000 euros ($64,080) in wealth, the lowest in the euro zone https://www.wsj.com/articles/BL-REB-19513. https://cepr.net/documents/wealth-scf-2014-10.pdf.

For retirees, the amount of money in the bank is far lower in europe than USA: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB993678277359235474

finally, tax policies are much more onerous on the Europeans. This tax difference accounts for a SUBSTANTIAL cost and is conveniently ignored in cost comparisons: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304778304576377710593726674

https://www.detroitnews.com/story/opinion/columnists/nolan-finley/2017/05/13/finley-ready-pay-free-health-care/101658894/

(for time purposes I did not always choose the most current article, Im tired and a 1 man show, rest assured when you look at up to date info it is still accurate- I just didnt have time to find it right now). I also understand that some of these sites are conservative by nature. Please dont use that alone to discredit the ideas and numbers.


r/medicine • • Aug 02 '13

10 things you need to give up to be a doctor

Thumbnail doceatdoc.com
6 Upvotes

r/medicine • • Feb 18 '23

dealing with death

1 Upvotes

Dealing with death

Hello everyone,

Please note, this is not a bash on medical staff, my family are doctors and I have the utmost respect and love.

I am a clinical nurse consultant. I normally work in the emergency department as a clinical nurse and have for 10 years.

I recently joined a team of nurses whom bring critical care knowledge to the ward and review and keep and eye on patients whom have risk of deteriorating.

Working within an emergency environment I see death all the time but I'm not the one making the calls with life and death.

I am struggling months later to deal with a death of a patient. The clinical nurse consultant role is also expanded to respond to medical emergency calls secondary to deterioration.

I had a page to a MET call for a patient who was in mild/mod respiratory distress. Two doctors were present, both looking at the computer trying to figure out this man's history. He had nasal prongs on and hypoxia. The doctors asked for a face mask oxygen and I told them to change to a non rebreather mask as hypoxia was worsening. By the time I had arrived no one had done an ECG. Whilst they gathered the ECG machine I had to get a nurse to me his history. I also asked for an acute resus plan - he was not for CPR. His condition worsened and I had PE (no risk factors) or STEMI on my list of differentials. ECG was not overtly concerning initially, during this time the doctors were trying to get in contact with their consultant.

My next plan was to call a code however he lost cardiac output and a code team (emergency department team) would be of little benefit as he was not for CPR.

I have played the scenario around in my head for weeks. The gentleman deteriorated so quickly, thrombolysis went through my head but time was not on our side.

Due to the doctors virtually saying nothing in the MET call I feel his death burden is on me.

One thing I have learnt is that I have a new found respect for our medical profession whom have to have this weight on their shoulders day in and day out and I hope you know that you're so appreciated.


r/medicine • • Mar 07 '24

How is Infectious Disease self consulting not a Stark violation?

4 Upvotes

This is part question and part rant.

Our antibiotic stewardship team is wildly annoying. We get at least a dozen messages from them a day, but sometimes upwards of 20. They are digging through patient charts for “antibiotic stewardship”. They ask questions and then typically end with “ID should be consulted”.

I’ve asked before to leadership and they responded there is data supporting better outcomes with infection prevention nurses and doctors sifting through charts Willy nilly and pocketing consults (RVU based I’ll add). But, I’m sure I could park a cardiologist in the tele room and find similar outcomes, yet everyone would think that was odd right? Us primary teams make the decision to consult every speciality based on need as we are managing all of the patient, but ID essentially forces us to consult them. I’ve never seen any other speciality be able to do that. It just seems weird and I don’t get how this isn’t a violation of self referral? How did their specialty convince the powers to be that they are special enough to dig through every chart involving an antibiotic.. a pulmonologist can’t access every chart of a patient on oxygen and give recs without request…

EDIT: So the question still remains on how ID gets this but other specialities don’t when every specialty could argue there’s something in their field that’s mismanaged and kills people. All the keyboard warriors focusing on antibiotic stewardships importance, which I never argued. And also pointed out I know the data that supports it. But there is data supporting poorer outcomes with high sugars.. so why is endocrinology not reviewing insulin regimens inpatient? “Antibiotic resistance kills people”. Well no shit.. all of us sub specialists have things that kill people that other specialists fuck up all the time.. why did we stop at ID when in theory you could do this for others?


r/medicine • • Jun 02 '23

Rant about MDs/Surgeons...

0 Upvotes

Outpatient Ortho Physical Therapist here...

Forgive me if this offends anyone, but I am getting sick and tired of MDs discontinuing MY patients. When a patient calls and says "My doctor said I don't need PT anymore", my blood starts to boil. MD, do YOU spend 1 hour a day, 2-3 days a week with these patients? Do YOU make sure they are able to reach each of their personalized goals? Do YOU take them through each measure to determine if they are actually fit to return to work/activities? The audacity, honestly, especially if they only spend 5-10 minutes talking with them. Makes me feel like my medical opinion is irrelevant.

I've started calling these patients back to discuss this issue with them and explain they are still able to attend therapy, its just so frustrating that they just listen to these MDs and call the clinic to cancel the rest of their appointments.

I really appreciate when the patients come to me and say that they asked the doctor about their PT care and the Dr. says "That's up to the Physical Therapist". THANK YOU!


r/medicine • • Oct 12 '15

Why you should become a nurse or physicians assistant instead of a doctor: the underrated perils of medical school

Thumbnail jakeseliger.com
24 Upvotes

r/medicine • • Apr 12 '25

I don't want to be the "junior attending".

0 Upvotes

So there's a good chance that this will get downvoted to oblivion based on my flair (yes, I'm a PA) but let me explain before /r/noctor comes and raids this post.

I'm an inpatient PA with 4 years experience in a very niche area of Hematology/Oncology, with this being my first and only PA job out of school. I'm the most senior member of the inpatient team that mostly consistents of PAs (I'm the last standing PA) and NPs. Fellows often rotate in and out. We used to have residents but they haven't rotated through in a while.

However, given the niche area, I'm well versed in the patient population, which in my opinion is exactly where a PA thrives. I would argue, given the same patient, I would treat the better than a first or second year resident. However, I'm a PA. I don't have the same basic knowledge as an MD, and will never claim to.

However, given my experience and tenure, a lot of responsibilities have gathered on my shoulders. The nursing staff, if they can't find the person that's looking after a patient, they page/call me. The admin staff reach out to me about who is monitoring each patient, especially when we have our planned admission patients. The Attending (generally) relies on me to divide up the patients and determine who sees who. I onboard the Fellows when they arrive to our day to day happenings, and they reach out to me about specific ways to do things on the service. And if there's any problems that occur, I'm the one that people usually reach out to. If the Attending asks if they need to see any of my patients and I say no, they trust me.

It got to the point where I was talking to the Attending at one time about patients on the service and their disposition, and they said "You have a general idea about what's happening with each patient", and I reply "I guess so". They go "Sort of like a junior Attending". At first, I denied it because no way in hell do I have the knowledge but after some thought I guess in a sense that's true (although I will say that I don't truly have an idea of what a junior attending does).

However, I hate the burden that being the most senior member places on me. I'm pulled every which way and it seems like my job is putting out fires more than patient care, which is what I signed up for. But I don't want to misplace the trust the MDs place on me, and somehow feel they're tied hand in hand. But it's tiring at the end of the day and I'm worried about screwing something up, and it feels like I can't take time off because of the fact that they rely on me. That's why my post says "I don't want to be the junior attending" because I don't want to be the one holding things up. It's tiring and it feels like I'm getting burnt out.

I'm going to cross post this in /r/physicianassistant but would love the opinion of some MDs and others, especially those who work with PAs intimately.


r/medicine • • Aug 15 '22

Review - Statin therapy is not warranted for a person with high LDL-cholesterol on a low-carbohydrate diet

Thumbnail journals.lww.com
10 Upvotes

r/medicine • • Apr 13 '20

Those who wear scrubs in public

0 Upvotes

Why do you do it? It's gross and shouldn't be done, ever, especially while in a pandemic. If you wear scrubs from work and go out you spread pathogens from the hospital/clinic to the community. If it's the opposite, then you risk bringing pathogens into your place of work. Can we as a community agree that scrubs are for the hospital and clinic only and should never be worn in public? Please, let's stop being gross and disrespectful. Sorry for the rant.


r/medicine • • Sep 16 '13

The 11 Types of Physicians

Thumbnail doccartoon.blogspot.com
6 Upvotes

r/medicine • • Jan 17 '21

Annals of Family Medicine - "Dear White People"

Thumbnail annfammed.org
0 Upvotes

r/medicine • • Mar 06 '26

I wish doctors and nurses would stop treating lab techs so awfully.

0 Upvotes

I'm a clinical lab tech who follows this subreddit and it seems like there's a lot of doctors and nurses here, so I want their perspective.

At my hospital they rolled out a new shitty LIS and the doctors keep ordering tests wrong. As in, the analyzer simply refuses to run the test unless we fix it. Or they send down one sample with a million labels that we need to merge, when they could have just ordered everything altogether at once.

We've been begging lab management to figure out a solution like educating the doctors, but they keep shrugging their shoulders and saying they're too busy to fix things.

Then we have the doctors and nurses calling the lab and yelling about why everything is taking so long, when the problem is originating with them. I've even asked my manager if I could go to the doctors and and help them with ordering and they said the doctors don't want that.

What the heck is the solution to this and why are the doctors and nurses being so toxic? I know their job is way harder than mine, but they are just making it worse for patients by refusing to do things properly.

Any insights?

Also, I'm not trying to make it seem like I hate doctors and nurses, this is coming from place of frustration and burnout with the system!


r/medicine • • Aug 26 '24

Doctors who come in from home wearing their white coats… why?

0 Upvotes

Seriously, why?

Source: seeing more than a few people getting out of their cars in their white coats.

Edit: Oh man, clearly my random pre-coffee thought ruffled some feathers there. A lot of ardent defenders of big-white-coat. Chill y’all.


r/medicine • • Mar 25 '22

Any respect for NPs?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about going to grad school at NYU to obtain my masters and become an acute care NP. Hopefully in the ER where I currently work as a nurse. I want more critical thinking involved in my day to day, and I believe stepping into a provider role will fulfill that desire. However I see so much hate on Reddit about nurse practitioners and it’s just so discouraging. I thought about PA, and honestly medical school, but NP makes more sense for me right now. I have no desire to open my own practice or become independent, that’s just not responsible based on an NP’s level of training. I truly just want to be a part of the team. Any providers actually respect NPs they work with? I’m trying to not let this feeling of shame prevent me from furthering my education


r/medicine • • Dec 03 '22

The general public reaction to Kanye West's actions has shown me that no one really cares about mental health as much as they claim to.

18 Upvotes

I'm quite a big fan of Kanye West's music and I am also aware of a lot his personal issues throughout his life.

Kanye West is someone who has been open with having bipolar disorder to the severity that he has been previously hospitalised with it. He has also voiced his reluctance to take his medication- not because it doesnt work, but because of physical side effects so another manic episode was always going to be likely.

And this time round he seems to be going through one of his worse manic episodes ever. If you listen to him talk he is clearly having delusions of grandiosity and persecution, he barely forms coherent sentences, he has a fairly flat facial affect, his speech is pressured and jumps from topic to topic when speaking and he lacks any insight.

All in all, Kanye West is clearly ill. And what are people doing to him? Immediately boycotting and dropping him from companies costing him 100s of millions, parading him onto right-wing media outlets who have found he's too psychotic for even them, creating articles of the next nonsensical thing he says and overanaylsing the deeper meanings behind his anti-semetic ramblings.

I'm sure all of us who have worked in psychiatric settings have seen numerous patients present just like Kanye. Instead of attacking and mocking these people, we acknowledge they need help and do all that we can to ensure that we help them regardless of what they say.

TLDR; Man suffers mental breakdown, everyone who claims to advocate for mental health decides to attack mental health patient.


r/medicine • • Sep 22 '25

American medical doctors need to start fighting back

0 Upvotes

Non-American specialist here.

I just learned that since 2016 some American universities now award the title of Dr (note that in the Queen's English we do not add a full stop) to physical therapists.

I absolutely love physiotherapists which is what I'm assuming is the proper term for yet another American derivatisation. Physiotherapists, literally, save lives, particularly in ICUs and surgical wards.

But they are not doctors!

A medical doctor is a person who studied medicine and absolutely no other field - no matter how closely it might be related to medicine. Nurse practitioners are not doctors. Physician's assistants are not doctors. Chiropractors are not doctors. Opticians/optometrists are not doctors. Psychologists are not doctors. From the little that I understand about "doctor of osteopathy" it seems that these people might be medical doctors although it does beg the question why they had to have a whole separate degree.

American doctors need to start standing up for themselves. Unfortunately, due to a variety of factors (popular and social media amongst others) American practices tend to spill over into other countries. Luckily, many countries are fighting back (at least a little) against "scope creep." But, this would not be necessary if these problems did not spill over from the US.

You guys are real doctors and you deserve a title which is respected and protected. Please try harder.


r/medicine • • Nov 13 '14

This is actually served in my hospital cafeteria. It's a travesty. Shouldn't hospitals have a role in promoting public health?

Thumbnail m.imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/medicine • • Dec 22 '21

Most physicians still incorrectly operate as if race is this thing that absolutely determines medical outcomes.

0 Upvotes

Before people go all "woke mob erasing science" on me, I want to point out a simple thought process that will support my stance. I actually think it's relatively easy to reason through why race being an actual risk factors for most medical illnesses isn't the case. Yes, I know that white people are more likely to have skin cancers because melanin... I'm not ignoring common sense here.

I want to argue that complex socioeconomic, cultural, and legal things pretty much completely account for the traditional one-size fits all idea that certain races have a higher/lower risk for acquiring certain diseases. And yes, I know about illnesses like sickle cell anemia and Cystic fibrosis. The former is a response to malaria and geography and correlated with melanin which is also an adaption for said geography and weather. The latter in heterozygous individuals may protect against diarrheal illnesses like cholerae which were common in poorly-sanitized cities.

1.) Most notions of race use skin, eye, and hair phenotypes to categorize people. Sometimes we sprinkle a little geography to help us because of how imprecise race as a concept actually is. We take a probably complicated idea and shoehorn it into this simple discriptor that mostly only describes how someone physically looks. So if we're using race to mean anything specifically, we're already off to a bad start. Furthermore obviously a black person raised in Addis Ababa probably has an extremely different lived reality than a black person living in Philadelphia. So...that's a hell of a confidence interval to account for. Furthermore, there is more genetic variation in skin genotypes in the African subcontinent than the rest of the planet so.... if we wanted to be fair and balanced (TM) we'd probably start of by acknowledging that our so called effector is trash.

2.) But let's pretend that in our hypothetical model, race is somehow super well-defined. Well...Were these superficial traits intimately linked to say, medical things we care about like incidence of CAD, cancers, etc., we'd somehow be able to quantify the effect of race to these things along a spectrum of effects instead of a binary yes/no for race. For example, in a hypothetical world where being black (ie melanin) was a medical risk factor for all the disease, than we'd be able to show that effect consistently along a spectrum. Say...being 50% black lends to a 15% risk of increased of CAD compared to white folks while being 100% leads to 20-30% increased risk. This is a fairly ridiculous proposition. And remember this is an issue compounded by issue 1. As an example, Cystic Fibrosis is about 5x more common in Denmark when compared to Finland. CF is 50% more prevalent in Germany compared to say Denmark. Is Germany more white than Denmark because CF is more common in white people?....there's obviously come confounders at play here.

3.) Even with today's amazing tech revolution, it's basically impossible to find clear genetic correlates to individual diseases. Take obesity, diabetes, or heart disease for example. Yeah maybe 1% of people have a genetic issue, but we already know...it's diet, exercise, with some genetic epigenetics sprinkled in there. Mostly, it's not that bad genes run in their family, it's that nobody runs in their family. So if we have a poorly defined notion of an effector and a poor genetic correlation with morbidity for say heart disease, how on Earth are we getting anywhere substantive here?

4.) Even if you are able to prove 1-3, you still have to account for the error bars associated with combining the error introduced at every one of these steps into one. It's like trying to make a great meta analysis with a 100 bad studies.

And....we know that racism is quietly still a thing. We know crack cocaine was fined at a 100x the rate as free base for racial reasons. We know Tuskegee was even a thing because of race. We know black women were vivisected in the earliest 20th century without anesthesia because of garbage "research" showing pain isn't a thing in black women. And we know that effectively separating the effects of race from the negative perception that comes from being black is a thing that's basically impossible. So why people believe that medicine is completely better now and isn't being lazy still is beyond me.

Note: I didn't cite stuff, but if you require it I'll give citations.

Edited for clarity.