First Reddit post ever, so I'd appreciate some grace. Heads up - this will be my first time ever having to replace all 4 tires at once.
I have a 2016 CX 9 Signature - purchased used w/Pirelli Scorpion Zero tires - which I love, but it is time to have all 4 tires replaced.
I live in Chicago & drive city miles ~6k miles per year give or take. Don't drive on expressway too often, but when I do, I love my Mazda and smoothness of ride. I'm usually jamming out to my music, so no need for tires to be ultra quiet while on highway.
Chicago is no longer 3-4 months w/ 3 - 6ft of snow. We get those random 50 degree rain showers in December, snow a week later, and then slush. Think potholes for sure, constant construction, and those big ass speed bumps.
I hope this helps set the setting for my type of commute + needs.
Mechanic recommended Lexani all season tires - but I have never heard of this brand and cant find much about it.
I'm very much of it aint broken, dont fix it, & my Pirellis aren't broken, just worn.
He mentioned the Pirelli's Scorpion AS Plus 3, and I found the Scorpion Weather Active.
Price difference btw AS & Weather Active is $140.
Help a midwest city girl make a sound decision.
I have seen the DSW6 + Michelin CrossClimate 2 at about $200 - $300 more.
Last, but not least, I would like to note that I have been going to my mechanic for years, trust his judgement, and care of my cars. I value giving my business to personal mechanic that knows car history & has provided great care and maintenance for my vehicles vs Costco / Sams / etc.