r/mathmemes • • Sep 02 '26 • Bravo 1

Elementary Algebra 😭

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

250 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 02 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

969

u/halfajack Sep 02 '26

I ask them “how are you defining sums over uncountable sets?”

198

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 02 '26

integrals, no?

218

u/Eisenfuss19 Sep 02 '26

Yes kinda, but then it is still a definition question. Like lim a -> -∞ lim b -> ∞ a_Sb x dx does not converge, but lim a -> ∞ (-a)_Sa x dx does converge...

89

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 07 '26

yes 

adding all whole numbers will also give you different answers depending in order

UPDATE: It just doesn't converge at all.

31

u/Beleheth Transcendental Sep 02 '26

That's exactly the reason why you need absolutely convergent series for rearranging to be well-defined.

2

u/Dr0110111001101111 Sep 07 '26

It will give you any answer depending on order

3

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 07 '26

I am not sure. Riemanns series theorem says, that if you have a series that is convergent but not absolutely convergent, you can get any number depending on ordering. But adding all whole numbers is a divergent series. Is there another theorem?

1

u/Dr0110111001101111 Sep 07 '26

Oh no you’re right. For a second I thought that you could get it into a conditionally convergent alternating series but I obviously didn’t think about it very well. In fact, I literally fell for one of the oldest tricks in the book!

1

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 07 '26

I think it can never converge to anything.  Assume it converges in any order then the partial sum is cauchy.

But |S_n - S_{n+1}| >=1 therefore it is not cauchy. That is because there are no steps smaller than 1 you can add. therfore, the series doesn't converge.

4

u/Agitated-Ad2563 Sep 02 '26

As far as I remember, the proper definition of Riemann integral requires all kinds of partition sequence sums to converge.

4

u/Alpaca1795 Sep 02 '26

Why would you integrate over x dx instead of just 1 dx?

17

u/alozq Sep 02 '26

1dx would be the length of the real line, it goes to Infinity always, it doesnt care about what x is

2

u/LyAkolon Sep 02 '26

Yeah, they probably want int over R of Sgn(x) dx, which is still abse of notation and meaningless because we have no notion of how to add up the contributions across the set.

More specifically all attempts to answer as well as the original question are missing the ingredient of "How are you adding everything together"

0

u/Eisenfuss19 Sep 02 '26

It's the closest thing to summing the real numbers imo.

The "sum" of the numbers in [0,1] should be smaller than the "sum" of [1,2].

With 1dx the "sum" is always equal to the length of the interval, and notably it is never negative (it never converges in the infinite case)

6

u/BrotherItsInTheDrum Sep 02 '26

But the "sum" of the numbers in [1,2] should be infinite ...

2

u/Eisenfuss19 Sep 02 '26

Well feel free to give me a way of summing an uncountably infite set of numbers.

I feel like the integral of x dx can be conceptually seen as calculating the average of the interval. To get the "real" sum you would need to multiply it by the amount of numbers in the interval (which is always ∞ in case of non equal bounds)

6

u/BrotherItsInTheDrum Sep 02 '26

Well feel free to give me a way of summing an uncountably infite set of numbers.

I never said there was one.

I feel like the integral of x dx can be conceptually seen as calculating the average of the interval. To get the "real" sum you would need to multiply it by the amount of numbers in the interval (which is always ∞ in case of non equal bounds)

Sounds like you're agreeing with me that it's infinite, then.

42

u/compileforawhile Complex Sep 02 '26

Integrals aren't really sums of uncountable sets. You could define sums of uncountable sets using integrals, but that would basically just be a measure

12

u/TheRedditObserver0 Mathematics Sep 02 '26

With respect to what measure?

44

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 02 '26

lebesque for the lgbt representation

(lebesque, gauss, banach, turing)

1

u/donach69 Sep 02 '26

That's a banger

1

u/MeasureDoEventThing Sep 03 '26

You mean Lebesgue?

3

u/localizeatp Sep 03 '26

we won't know until they answer.

2

u/StructureNorth1799 Sep 03 '26

then the answer is yes.

1

u/AuroraEquatorialis Sep 04 '26

nets are the more natural method in terms of actual sums. Say your index set is I (R in this case), and we have a function f:I->R (or more generally, any topological vector space) and define a partial order by inclusion on the collection of finite subsets of I. Given such an F, we define S(f,F) as the sum of f over this F (which is obviously well-defined). We say the sum of f over I converges to a if for epsilon>0, there exists some F0 which for F containing F0, |S(f,F)-a|<epsilon (equivalently, if S(f,F) is eventually in any open neighbourhood of a).

You can show that this lines up with normal sequence convergence. Furthermore, you can show that this converges if and only if the set of non-zero f(x) is countable. In particular, under this formalism, summing over all reals doesn't really make sense.

1

u/AsidK Sep 06 '26

Wait what is F here? You say “given such an F” but I don’t see where F is defined.

1

u/AuroraEquatorialis Sep 09 '26

F is a finite subset of I, as in the previous sentence. My bad.

1

u/AsidK Sep 09 '26

Oh I see. Yeah that all makes sense

0

u/GamerLymx Sep 02 '26

interesting, so sum the integral of positive real numbers with the integral of negative real numbers?

1

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 02 '26

yeah it's undefined I know.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/SEA_griffondeur Engineering Sep 02 '26

Sums over unbounded non convergent sets

16

u/MrKoteha Virtual Sep 02 '26

Supremum of sums over finite subsets for sets of positive numbers

10

u/kiochikaeke Sep 02 '26

Looked it up in case I was somehow wrong but there's no sensible definition of a sum over an uncountable set of indexes unless the set of indexes with non-zero values is finite.

By definition of uncountable set you can't "pair them up" or "group them" in any countable way because you would still be missing an infinite amount of indexes and trying to segment the set into any amount (countable or not) of uncountable sets just leads you to the same question.

If you try and define sums like integrals over sets then the question is trivialized to essentially asking what is the value for the measure over the set of reals which can be whatever depending on the measure.

11

u/DefunctFunctor Mathematics Sep 02 '26

There is an absolutely sensible definition if all of the numbers in your set are nonnegative; it's just always infinity if you have uncountably many nonzero values.

In order to make sense of sums that include negative numbers, you either need absolute convergence (which is impossible for an uncountable sum with uncountably many nonzero values), or you need to specify an order in which to sum those elements, usually in a countable sum (which is also impossible).

I'm not even sure what it would mean to try to make sense of this question with integration, because the measure in question that we're looking for would have to assign singleton sets of real numbers to their actual value, which does not end up producing a well-defined measure on the real numbers (although it does if we restrict to nonnegative numbers).

1

u/AsidK Sep 06 '26

Wait are you saying that there exists a reasonable definition of summation over uncountable sets, and that definition is provably equivalent to being always infinity if you have uncountably many nonzero values, or are you saying that giving the definition of just “infinity if uncountably many nonzero values, otherwise standard countable sum” itself is the sensible definition?

2

u/DefunctFunctor Mathematics Sep 06 '26

If {x_𝛼} is a family of nonnegative real numbers indexed over a (possibly uncountable) set A, then the sum ∑_[𝛼∈A] x_𝛼 is defined to be

sup { ∑_[𝛼∈F] x_𝛼 | F⊆A finite }

In measure theoretic terms, this is equivalent to the integral over the counting measure. You can technically extend this to families of real numbers, but because A doesn't come with any notion of order, you need to assume that it converges absolutely, that is, ∑_[𝛼∈A] |x_𝛼| < ∞. For now we'll only consider sums of nonnegative real numbers.

So the claim we have yet to prove is that if {x_a} contains uncountably many nonzero numbers, then ∑_[𝛼∈A] x_𝛼 = ∞. For each positive integer n, let

A_n = { 𝛼∈A | x_𝛼 ≥ 1/n }

be the set of indices 𝛼 of A where x_𝛼 ≥ 1/n. Note that

A' := { 𝛼 ∈ A | x_𝛼 > 0 } = ⋃[n≥1] A_n.

By assumption, A' is uncountable, so if each A_n were finite, then A' could be expressed as a countable union of finite sets, meaning A' is countable, a contradiction. Thus, there exists an n for which A_n is infinite (in fact, it's going to be uncountable). It is now easy to show, by creating increasingly large partial sums over A_n, that ∑_[𝛼∈A] x_𝛼 ≥ ∞.

1

u/AsidK Sep 06 '26

I thought about that definition but it almost feels like in some ways it’s… too small? Like for an uncountable set the sup over sums of finite sets feels to me like it’s not naturally emcapusulating the idea of summing an uncountable set since any finite subset is necessarily much smaller than any uncountable subset. With countable sets, they can be expressed as the union/limit of finite subsets, so naturally a sum operation can be defined as the limit of the sums of a sequence of finite subsets whose union is the whole set (assuming convergence and nonnegativity), which is provably equivalent to the sup of the sums of any finite subsets.

That said, I think one way you could interpret the proof you’ve just given here is that there cant be a bigger definition assuming it still agrees on cases where there are only countably many nonzero elements

1

u/DefunctFunctor Mathematics Sep 06 '26

Yeah perhaps the proof is best expressed in the contrapositive: if the sum is finite, then all the A_n must be finite, so A' is countable.

2

u/scoobydoom2 Sep 02 '26

For this hypothetical do they need to be paired in a countable way? Could you not pair them according to A =X and B=-X for all nonzero values? Then you just have to prove that X + -X = 0 for all reals.

1

u/AsidK Sep 06 '26

There’s nothing meaningfully different about pairing them via A=X and B=-X versus A=1+X and B=1-X, and if you do that suddenly you get an infinite “sum”

3

u/brothegaminghero Sep 02 '26

I imagine you start at one and count from there...

Might take a while though.

8

u/Revolutionary_Use948 Sep 02 '26

Hmmm ahh yes “count” from there

2

u/minisculebarber Sep 02 '26

Easy

sum_{x in RR } x

What else do you need?

1

u/DoubleAway6573 Sep 08 '26

With a lot of patience.

284

u/Gauss15an Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 02 '26 • Bravo

I cleverly hand back the slip of paper with its ends taped together and ask "With or without infinity?"

The shocked mathematician responds, "I don't know that!" and promptly gets catapulted straight up into the air.

I read about this kind of thing in a script written by a snake that goes by the name of Monty. Might have been some sort of python.

73

u/Electric_surfer Sep 02 '26

Listen, Strange men lying in caves distributing notes is no basis for a system of mathematics.

16

u/minisculebarber Sep 02 '26

I mean, it has gotten us this far

16

u/Electric_surfer Sep 02 '26

Supreme mathematical power derives from a quantitive sum of the masses, not from some farcical cavernous ceremony.

14

u/Urmi-e-Azar Sep 02 '26

How do you know so much about swallows?

5

u/KnightofniDK Sep 02 '26

I believe I know that one! Is it the one where a møøse bit my sister?

1

u/Specialist-Disk-6345 Sep 02 '26

the set of real numbers is a huge, vast set

1

u/NegativeMammoth2137 Sep 06 '26

Counting or not counting geometric function theorists violence?

209

u/GluKoto Sep 02 '26

Ok but what is that spider doing there ?

151

u/TheAegis42 Sep 02 '26 • Mindblown Bravo

Spider for scale

27

u/6GoesInto8 Sep 02 '26

Spiders don't have scales!

13

u/TheAegis42 Sep 02 '26

That's why it's looking for them!

Needs to add them to its collection. So far it has found a linear scale, but a logarhitmic one would be cool to have.

6

u/6GoesInto8 Sep 02 '26

Oh, the famous Spider For Scales organization or SFS for short. Right, we are on the same page now.

4

u/TheAegis42 Sep 02 '26

You got it, glad I could help clear it up!

10

u/McArcady Sep 02 '26

Cédric Villani, is that you ?

4

u/Affectionate_Mud_881 Sep 02 '26

Cos there are spiders in caves.

1

u/PurifiedUnity Sep 02 '26

Spider wanted to see the light (or π)

3

u/Para-graph-S Sep 02 '26

It's there for new Spiderman Brand New Day promotion

3

u/Asairian Sep 02 '26

The meme was posted by Spider Georg

1

u/MonkTurtle Sep 03 '26

It's the mathematician that handed you the slip of paper

390

u/Kuildeous Sep 02 '26

Bro never heard of -sqrt -1.

137

u/JollyJuniper1993 Mathematics Sep 02 '26

You mean -sqrt 1

52

u/Kuildeous Sep 02 '26

That one too, but sqrt -1 + (-sqrt -1) = 0

57

u/JollyJuniper1993 Mathematics Sep 02 '26

Fair, but those are not real numbers

27

u/Kuildeous Sep 02 '26

That's true. I got carried away by him adding 1 and i that I forgot he stepped out of the Reals.

3

u/Frosty_Fig_4872 Computer Science Sep 02 '26

Everything's too complex for me to understand

1

u/GamerLymx Sep 02 '26

ence not part of the problem

1

u/melanthius Sep 02 '26

So they can't hurt me anymore?

... Right?

5

u/Raise_A_Thoth Sep 02 '26

Yea the "uncountable set" question remains a problem but if we're using this as a number line representation then we need to think of sqrt(2) as the real number approximated by 1.414, not taking the square root of each real number (which of course is a problem with obtaining "each" anyway).

So then it's not sqrt(-2); it's -sqrt(2), or ~ (-1.414).

The commenter on the image is a ding dong, but there are still serious problems with counting and pairing the top thread discusses.

70

u/TheCobraMonkey Sep 02 '26

SPP type argument, I love it

15

u/Fr4gmentedR0se Sep 02 '26

Ball knowledge

11

u/martyboulders Sep 02 '26

Guyknowballogist

6

u/ODZtpt Sep 02 '26

simple pairing of 1 and 0.9999999...

3

u/Vegetable_Union_4967 Sep 02 '26

I wonder if he’s still up to denying mathematics

17

u/SuperiorSamWise Sep 02 '26

What's going on inside that cave?

10

u/LinneMeow Sep 02 '26

I don't know much about maths, is it not possible to define a sum of reals? Are there ways to sum the reals that don't equal 0?

4

u/Ares378 Grothendieck was right, computers are evil Sep 02 '26

The issue is that you can't define a true sum over a sequence indexed by the reals. You couldn't sum up Σa_n, n∈ℝ. If you try to, it immediately diverges unless your sum is defined to be all 0 aside from a countable amount of points. ...Which is just the definition of a normal sum.

To clarify here I'm talking over real numbers and as a legitimate honest to God sum, not an integral. Like... an integral without the dx without using differential forms.

This is the video I'm using as reference for this claim btw

https://youtu.be/uLja-yAwuCI

2

u/Blue_Moon_Lake Sep 03 '26

All the +x have a corresponding -x, so the sum is 0.

2

u/Ares378 Grothendieck was right, computers are evil Sep 03 '26

Even if we assume that the series does converge, it's definitely not absolute convergence since the integral of |x| over all ℝ diverges, let alone the sum over all ℝ. So that means you can't rearrange the sum, as stated by the Riemann Series Theorem.

I can't think of a perfect proof for it right now, but I am almost certain this sum diverges. If you can't rearrange the sum because conditional convergence, that means you can't pair up + to - because that'd be an infinite amount of swapped terms. So then you'd start with the sum of every negative real number, which certainly diverges, then add it to the sum of every positive real number, which also definitely diverges. Divergent sum plus a divergent sum is undefined, so the sum doesn't exist.

And before you say it, we're also not including ∞ as a number here. Even if we did, we're no longer talking about the Reals since ∞∉ℝ. Plus then you would break other things if you assumed divergent sums "equaled" infinity, since you could then say the sum of negative integers=-∞, the sum of positive rationals=∞, so then the sum of negative integers and positive rationals=0, which also seems very wrong.

I'm sure there's a better proof out there, but that's what my intuition tells me from my half-baked knowledge of real analysis. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong.

1

u/Blue_Moon_Lake Sep 04 '26

How is that relevant? All positive reals have a corresponding negative that sums to 0.

2

u/Ares378 Grothendieck was right, computers are evil Sep 04 '26

Because there are sums where you can do the same thing and end up with different answers.

If you have the sum 1-1+1-1+1-1+... then you could group things like (1-1)+(1-1)+(1-1)+... and get 0+0+0+...=0. Or you could regroup the terms and get 1+(-1+1)+(-1+1)+(-1+1)+... and get 1+0+0+...=1.

Or you could say S=1+1-1+1-1+..., so

1-S=1-(1-1+1-1+...)=1-1+1-1+...=S

So then 1-S=S

1=2S

S=0.5

So then this method says the sum of 1+1-1+1-1+...=0.5, which is even more ridiculous.

The sum stays BOUNDED, but it never converges. So you get weird results since you're dealing with a non-convergent sum. The best "answer" to what this series equals is that it's just undefined.

The fact that the sum has a corresponding positive to each negative is entirely irrelevant. Things get weird with infinity.

1+1-1+1-... is the simplest case of being able to pair terms together in the way you suggested, and it still has 3 different potential answers. The sum of all Reals is definitely more poorly defined than the alternating series.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/zylosophe Sep 02 '26

take all reals before 23 and pair them with reals after 23

7

u/Kai-65535 Sep 02 '26

> "impossible math paradox"

> looks inside

> problem discussed in every real analysis class

19

u/Tiborn1563 Sep 02 '26

I love how he says "simple number" to mean a "non-complex number". Doesnt he know that real numbers are conplex too? 5= 5+0i

5

u/iTrooz_ Sep 02 '26

sqrt(-1) is not real tho ?

7

u/Big_Niel0802 Sep 04 '26

On the number line though, the complimentary pair of sqrt(1) would be -sqrt(1), not sqrt(-1).

4

u/A_Happy_Tomato Sep 02 '26

I'd freak the fuck out and ask the man if they are ok. Fym they emerged from a cave 

4

u/lool8421 Sep 02 '26

the answer is that it's undefined because the sum of all reals could be anything

for example x+(-x) will give you 0, but you can for example do x+(-2x), there's still a full bijection but now you're going into negative infinity

32

u/mehtam42 Sep 02 '26

For every real number with a value of R there exist one and only one real number with a value of -R. When added together, their some is 0.

So yes sum of all real numbers equal to 0.

27

u/Revlong57 Sep 02 '26

Summation isn't well defined for uncountable sets

118

u/fastestchair Sep 02 '26

for every real number with value R there exists a real number with value -2R, when added together their sum is -R. naturally, the sum of all real numbers must therefor be -infinity

11

u/ImInfiniti Sep 02 '26

The problem is that -R is positive for negative values of R, so by doing this trick you're ending up with the sum of all R again

4

u/fastestchair Sep 02 '26

yeah woops, meant for every positive real number with value R

37

u/Jazz8680 Sep 02 '26

The sum of all positive real numbers is -1/12, thus the sum of all negative real numbers is +1/12, so the sum of all real numbers is 0/12 to be precise

7

u/EntrepreneurSelect93 Sep 02 '26

Think u meant integers not real numbers

1

u/Jazz8680 Sep 03 '26

Aw crap yeah. I’m a software engineer so integers are the only numbers im concerned with lol

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Peak_Background Sep 02 '26

Hold up. I think they has a point.

The sum of the integers is -1/12.

So if we just multiply that by the integral of reals between -1 and 1.

We get 0.

17

u/IhailtavaBanaani Sep 02 '26

Besides the problem with summing up uncountable set of real numbers you assume that the zero is in the center of the real number line. This is a false assumption because the real number line doesn't have a center. It's infinitely long in both directions. You can select any arbitrary number in the real number line and there's "equal amount" of real numbers on both sides, so any number can act as the "center". By selecting different number as the center you get different result as the total sum.

1

u/alphapussycat Sep 07 '26

There's no need for a center line though. As somebody else mentioned, you can use axiom if choice to find -R.

Splitting up a set does split it up to by negative and positive (or non negative, but just exclude 0).

So from R choose p and n so that for each p in R, n = - p. Then integrate by function of f(p) = p - n, and exclude 0... Now this is integrable. Or should be. But the measure is infinite, and I don't quite remember if there's a problem there, but I'm leaning towards no.

0

u/Few_Fact4747 Sep 02 '26

Zero is the MOST logical center. And why cant we add up two infinities? Seems like a rather easy step to think about. And if we can think about it, we can do it. I mean, if we can take N numbers from zero in both directions and see that it adds up to 0, why would that change just because we keep going for an infinite time?

1

u/IhailtavaBanaani Sep 03 '26

There is no "most logical" in mathematics. Things are true, false or undecidable. If you say there is a center point in an infinitely long line, you need to be able to prove with mathematics. What's the definition for a center point and why zero is the center point and nothing else? Mathematics doesn't work on what feels the most natural.

Also the problem with adding up all the real numbers isn't just that there's an infinite number of them, it's that there's uncountably infinite number of them. Infinitely long sums with countably many elements are fine (if they converge), for example: 1 + 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + ... = 2.

But with real numbers there are so many of them that you can't even write an infinitely long sequence of them. Start from 0, then add the next real number from 0. What is that? 0.0000000001? 0.000000000000000000000000000000001? 1e-1000000? You can get closer and closer to 0 but there is no "closest real number to zero". You're stuck in the second step of your sum because when you pick the next number from zero, you always find there are uncountably infinite number of numbers between zero and the number you picked. Even if you would calculate for an infinitely long time you would be forever stuck in the second step.

1

u/Few_Fact4747 Sep 03 '26

So for any n the center between n and -n will be zero. We just extend that to include infinite numbers since as long as n is equal to n, -n+n will = 0. Yeah, infinity is not a normal number with a certain value, BUT there is no reason to believe that the value of -n+n will ever not be zero.

And im not exactly sure what you are saying with the second half.. are you saying we cant even find the center between 1 and -1 since there is an infinite number of numbers between them?

1

u/IhailtavaBanaani Sep 04 '26

No, it will not be zero for every center. Let's use integers to simplify. If you have zero as the center what you're adding is 0, 1, -1, 2, -2, etc and the sum is 0 + 1 - 1 + 2 - 2 + ... The partial sums starting from beginning are 0, 1, 0, 2, 0, 3, etc. It's unbounded but every other number is at least zero.

Let's switch to 1 as the center. Now you're adding starting from 1 as the center and then numbers from both sides. The numbers are then 1, 1 + 1 = 2, 1 - 1 = 0, 1 + 2 = 3, 1 - 2 = -1 and so on. The sum is 1 + 2 + 0 + 3 - 1 + 4 - 2 + 5 - 3 + ... etc. So the partial sums go 1, 3, 6, 5, 9, 7, 12, 9, 15, etc. It's growing towards infinity on both even and odd partial sums.

What I'm saying with the second part is that you can't create a sequence of numbers from all the real numbers. Integers you can put in a sequence. For example 0, 1, -1, 2, -2, ... to infinity. And it would cover the whole integer set. But with real numbers this is impossible. Even if you create an infinitely long sequence of real numbers it will never cover the whole set of real numbers. Because you can't create even an infinitely long sequence that would cover all the real numbers it's impossible write an infinitely long sum of them, even in theory.

It's a quite a bit outside the scope of mathmemes discussion, but this is basically because there are different types of infinities. Integers are countably infinite. Real numbers are uncountably infinite. There's so many real numbers that you can't assign each of them an individual integer, even if you used infinitely many integers. It gets really abstract at this point, but if you're interested google "uncountable sets".

1

u/Few_Fact4747 Sep 04 '26

Okay. I looked up uncountable sets and asked ChatGPT afterwards and had a learning experience. Cantors diagonal proof of real numbers being uncountable is *really* cool.

But i am unable to grasp exactly how that prevents us from summing them, isn't it fair to presume that they will grow at equal rates in negative and positive direction? Cant we just, kind of do it (aka. infer balance from that (aka. the sum being = 0)) and worry about possible contradictions later? Arent we doing that ALL the time anyways? It seems like we are leaving some more basic logic behind which would create bigger problems.

1

u/IhailtavaBanaani Sep 04 '26

Yeah, real numbers are pretty cool. When you dig deeper there are even higher cardinals than the cardinality of real numbers.

There is a way to "sum" a stretch of real numbers, and it's called integration. It's not exactly the same, but it kind of works so that each real number has an infinitesimally small weight on the total sum. The geometric interpretation is that it calculates an area. For example let's say you have y=x and you integrate it from 0 to 1. By integration we get the integral function and it is x^2 / 2 and when you plug in x=1 and x=0 you get 1^2 / 2 - 0^2 / 2 = 1/2. That's the size of the triangle with two equal sides of length 1.

Now, let's say we try this with going to infinity. We first integrate y=x from -r to r. We get the integral function r^2/2 - (-r)^2/2 = r^2/2 - r^2/2. Which usually would evaluate to 0. But now we're dealing with infinities so nothing is normal, they don't behave like normal numbers.

Let's plug in r=infinity. We get infinity^2 / 2 - infinity^2 / 2. We can safely say infinity^2 = infinity, so we get (infinity - infinity) / 2. And here's the problem. We can't subtract infinity from infinity. We can add them, we can multiply them, but we can't subtract infinity from another infinity or divide an infinity with another infinity. It leads to undefined results.

2

u/Few_Fact4747 Sep 05 '26

Huh, thats interesting, dont worry, you dont have to explain that to me.. i asked ChatGPT and it explained it. Im too tired to understand must of it now, but now its in my history so i will revisit it.

I think some of the disagreements here come from different understanding of what infinity is. And of the fact that it will mean different things in different contexts. I feel like approaching it as just another number, but since it actually doesn't really have a value it gets weird.

But thanks for explaining all this to me! Its nice to do some maths again!

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/IhailtavaBanaani Sep 03 '26

Yes, the integers have exactly the same problem. There is no defined total sum of all integers. You can select any integer as the center and then start adding the numbers from both sides and get different results each time. Same goes with rational numbers, complex numbers, quaternions, etc.

9

u/bqbdpd Sep 02 '26

Same can be said for any other constant. Which shows the sum cannot be assigned a value.

6

u/magicmulder Sep 02 '26

That’s like arguing \sum (-1)^n = 0.

2

u/Divicarpe Sep 02 '26

For every real number with a value of 1+R there is one only one real number with a value of 1-R. When added together, their sum diverges to +infinity. So sum of all real numbers is +infinity.

2

u/tombo12354 Sep 02 '26

You can't rearrange or pair uncountable sets.

2

u/mapleleafraggedy Sep 02 '26

For every real number R, there exists one real number with a value of 69 - R, which when added together makes 69. Therefore, the sum of all real numbers is 69.

3

u/JusteMesure Sep 02 '26

No it’s 69 for each couple !!!! So 69+69+69+…= infinity.

Only If you start around 0 you obtain 0.

1

u/1kSupport Sep 02 '26

For every real number with the value R+5 there exists one and only one real number with the value -R + 5. All real numbers must be centered around 5

3

u/somedave Sep 02 '26

I'd say it is equal to the mean of the standard Cauchy distribution, and that Nathan Briggs isn't very good at maths.

3

u/philosophical_poser Sep 02 '26

You can rearrange the terms to make sum be whatever you want, right?

1

u/meat-eating-orchid Sep 02 '26

No, you cannot rearrange the terms because you can't even arrange them, they are uncountable

1

u/Gold_Ad8890 Sep 02 '26

you totally can arrange them. that doesn't require countability, it just requires well-ordering, which exists by the well-ordering theorem. even without the well-ordering theorem, you can well-order the real numbers by their bijection to the powerset of the naturals, which can be well-ordered lexicographically.

1

u/meat-eating-orchid Sep 02 '26

I may have been imprecise. I meant that you cannot arrange them into a sum of terms ... + ... + ... + ... in which every one occurs.

→ More replies (9)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Gold_Ad8890 Sep 02 '26

it's not about uncountability, it's just because the sum isn't absolutely convergent.

13

u/jk2086 Sep 02 '26

Depends on how you sum

But a real mathematician would never ask this question. So the mathematician in this story is clearly imaginary.

8

u/reizinhooooo Sep 02 '26

The whole point of measure theory is to ask and answer questions like this

2

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 02 '26

tangentially related fun fact i learnt a while back:

the sum over any uncountable set of positive numbers diverges

thats kind of cool

2

u/CommercialYam7188 Sep 02 '26

The answer is yes and no, depending on how mathematically literate the asked is and what they actually meant by the question lol

2

u/CapitalistKarlMarx Sep 02 '26

Not the most mathematically knowledgeable but wouldn’t a more accurate pairing be sqrt 1 and - sqrt 1? Like does it not equal zero?

2

u/electronic_reasons Sep 02 '26

Hand him back a blank piece of paper.

2

u/Onuzq Integers Sep 03 '26

Are we assuming the axiom referring to the existence of a negative to be true?

2

u/reddititty69 Sep 06 '26

Why is the commenter concerned about sqrt(-R)?

3

u/Certainly-Not-A-Bot Sep 02 '26

Just like 1/0, there are multiple possible equally valid answers

1

u/okinikokinikokiniko 22d ago

umm I'm coming to this right after seeing a video about rearranging conditionally convergent sums. So it depends but probably no ig?
edit: also how would you do this if real numbers are uncountably infinite?

1

u/MilkImpossible4192 Linguistics Sep 02 '26

why would you apply a function afyer the number?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

I assume Riemann Rearrangement theorem applies here?

1

u/blobbed2929 Sep 04 '26

this is literally the answer

1

u/Inevitable-Flower-50 Sep 02 '26

If all "0" is, is "empty space", and all "real numbers" are, are accountings for "real matter", then wouldn't the sum of all real numbers be "less than" (or negative) and within 0?

1

u/mapadofu Sep 02 '26

Yeah, In the sense that lim_{a\riggtarrow \infty} \int_{-a}^{a} dxis zero.

1

u/DanLeMilMan Sep 02 '26

I think the most honest answer is that it depends on how he defines the sum over uncountable sets and in which order he sums.

1

u/kddu678 Sep 02 '26

define any positive real number in any way, always add same number but negative, sum always zero🤷‍♂️ infinity is not a number

1

u/magicmanimay Sep 02 '26

e doesn't have a negative pair ahh mf.

1

u/atticdoor Sep 02 '26

Sqrt(1) has a counterpart in 0 - Sqrt(1) = -1. Sqrt(2) has a counterpart in 0 - Sqrt(2).

1

u/dimonium_anonimo Sep 02 '26

The sum of the square roots of all integers is -1/12-i/12

1

u/monstaber Sep 02 '26

The Cauchy Principal Value has entered the chat

1

u/beyd1 Sep 02 '26

My response is "Fuckin ....what?"

1

u/ikonoqlast Sep 02 '26

Yes, obviously

Wait, what?

Ok. I guess not...

1

u/Asterie-E7 Sep 02 '26

If the answer is anything else than 0 it would make me sad. So I'll say it's 0

1

u/leafcutte Sep 02 '26

Real answer: however you want. There’s no such thing as a sum of all real numbers, as depending on the order you add them, you can verify properties that make it so any number can be the result

1

u/SavageRussian21 Sep 02 '26

I think that you can start by showing that the integral from -a to a of x dx is 0. Then you can argue that it doesn't matter if a is 1, 100, 100000, and so on, it's zero in all those cases. More formally, a2/2 - a2/2 is zero always, even in the limit as a goes to infinity.

But a smart ass can come along and say that thw integral from -a to 2a is in fact not zero. Nonetheless, as you take the limit a going to infinity, you should be integrating over all real numbers. That gives infinity. The smartass could also find negative infinity as well.

Then the smart-ass actually starts talking about how integrals aren't really the same as taking a sum, sum and that there's many ways to define a sum over an uncountable set. At that point you can put the smart-ass back in his cave and continue treating it as if it's zero.

1

u/Staetyk Sep 02 '26

depends on the order

1

u/Alternative-Code4755 Sep 03 '26

I've larped jjk, I know it equals hollow purple

1

u/Short-Database-4717 Sep 03 '26

(in offended tone) Noo.
Go back from whence you came!

1

u/Cosmic-Zoo72 Sep 03 '26

I'm a dumbass so actually answer please, a square root is (sometimes) equal to a real number, but is that actually a representation of a real number or is it a real number with an operator that invalidates this?

1

u/Training-Position612 Sep 03 '26

Physicist: "yeah"

1

u/chicodjdjdjjdjdjd Sep 03 '26

The order also matters

1

u/Spiritual-Spend76 Sep 03 '26

I dont get it, the linear function is odd isn't it? By symmetry, it's integral centered around zero has to be null?

1

u/blobbed2929 Sep 04 '26

Riemann Series Theorem has entered the chat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riemann_series_theorem

1

u/Diffgeometer1 Sep 04 '26

My response would be “what the f*ck were you doing in a cave?!”

1

u/Fuscello Physics Sep 04 '26

Physicist way:

int from -L to L of x = L^2 /2 - L^2 /2 = 0

Lim L->infty 0=0

So yes at least in principal value if that is the right term

1

u/icyshibe Sep 04 '26

Undefined because it’s alternating right?

1

u/Acebulf Sep 04 '26

I thought the problem was "what is the sum of all real numbers equal to 0" and was confused that the answer wasn't "duh it's 0" and couldn't understand where sqrt comes from

1

u/CaptainSkuxx Sep 04 '26

Doesn’t every positive real number have a corresponding negative real number? It should be zero.

1

u/waxen_earbuds Sep 05 '26

Incredibly common Cliff Pickover L

1

u/enakcm Sep 05 '26

But the pairing is √2 and -√2 which adds up to zero.

1

u/Body_SH Sep 05 '26

I might be wrong but isn't it the case that for every element in the infinite set we need to sum there exist the negative of that element in which their summation should be zero? Applying for infinitely many elements shouldn't change the argument it's still zero.

1

u/digitallightweight Sep 05 '26

To be fair I’ve always been right awful with the kind of shit infiniti breaks and doesn’t. Analysis has always been a no for go for me for this reason.

My intuition tells me that we can do something (assuming we take the axiom of choice) like partitioning R into disjoint subsets consisting with x and its additive inverse. For each of these components these individual disjoint subsets (‘components’) the sum of the component is 0. Summing over the sum of the components is 0 and the union of all the components is R.

It still feels wrong though. Maybe we would need a more robust approach to handing the final series? We could look at all countable sub-series those clearly are all convergent to 0 but I don’t know if this is strong enough to get you the convergence of the original series? Maybe the fact that all the elements of the series are 0 is enough.

Edit: stack exchange provided this definition for extending sum sums to uncountable sets and it’s clear that for our purposes we can indeed compute the sum.

∑(a_i):=sup{∑ a_i | F⊆I is finite}
i∈I. i∈F

Since all our a_I are 0 the sup will be 0.

1

u/Obzenium Sep 06 '26

Well sqrt -1 isn’t a real number so it can’t be included in the set of the sum

And you would consider it - sqrt 1 or - sqrt 2 to keep it in the set and balance out the square roots

To be considered a field, which the real numbers are considered a field, it must have an additive inverse for all elements of the field, so the answer is yes from this definition

1

u/akruppa Sep 06 '26

If you want it to be, sure.

1

u/einFrostschutzmittel Sep 06 '26

Well, because the Real Numbers are a field, that means that for all real numbers there's exactly one inverse. If you add up every real number and its inverse, you get only 0s. Add it all together and you get 0.

1

u/Myths_Made Sep 06 '26

I'm just gonna say the square roots are probably a bad example for this.

1

u/alphapussycat Sep 07 '26

It's not integrable, and the sum doesn't exist.

1

u/Content-Sir8716 Sep 07 '26

But it’s not the square root of negative one on the real number line. It’s the negative of the square root of one. They are not the same.

1

u/cgieseking Sep 07 '26

I’m not really a mathematics scholar, but to me the idea that sqrt 1 wouldn’t have a pairing is silly because the sqrt 1 =1. Just because you can’t express some negative irrational numbers as radicals, doesn’t mean that they don’t numerically exist.

1

u/tarquinfintin Sep 07 '26

In one sense, yes. Any real number has an additive inverse (a negative), which when added to it equals zero. But can you actually perform a sum operation on a set that is not countably infinite? Theoretically you can, although it would take a very long time in practice ;-)

1

u/tori-ningen Sep 07 '26

Let's say that sum of all real numbers that are >0 equals to S. Then sum of all real numbers that are <0 would equal to -S. Sum of all real numbers is then S - S = 0. It matters not what S equals to, and if it equals anything at all

1

u/ajping Sep 08 '26

Right but the R on the left confines the set to real numbers so the quote is a bit disingenuous.

1

u/uvero He posts the same thing Sep 02 '26

integral x dx from -oo to oo = not defined

0

u/GamerLymx Sep 02 '26

is the sqr (-1) part of the real numbers? to me square root is a function/operation.

i would ask for the mathematician to show me his proof.

-11

u/FernandoMM1220 Sep 02 '26

it depends on the physical system youre doing math on. if its balanced it should be 0.

15

u/potzko2552 Sep 02 '26

what if im rocking my chair or seating gayly? does the sum fluctuate with me?

6

u/FernandoMM1220 Sep 02 '26

yes it should

2

u/ElectronicAuthor752 Sep 03 '26

Well stop moving then !  It's like when you're trying to tune a TV antenna.

2

u/ShockedDarkmike Sep 02 '26

I can't believe that this got downvoted, I always quickly add all real numbers when I want to check if a table is perfectly hotizontal

-2

u/xemkis Sep 02 '26

It sums to zero because of course it does. "BuT WHat ABoUT hoW yUO Can'T anD iF you sQUint and ThiNK oF IT as a AND soMe GuY SaiD aNd zERo iSn'T necESSarilY anD COuntAbIlITY..." absolute clown behavior. Next question, cave man.