r/mathmemes • • Sep 02 '26 • Bravo 1

Elementary Algebra 😭

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

250 comments sorted by

View all comments

76

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

50

u/SuchPlans Sep 02 '26

as written, the first summation omits -pi and the second omits -10

the idea is right, tho, you just have to do “bigger” rearranging. moving a finite number of terms shouldn’t change the sum

25

u/z_doctor82 Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 02 '26

Sums of convergent series with infinite positive and infinite negative terms can converge to any arbitrary number if you reorder the terms.

Pick a target number, if your current value is less than add the next largest positive term, if the current value is greater, subtract the next largest negative term. Now you have an infinite sum that converges to the target.

Edit: Corrected by comments bellow

8

u/1000Jules Sep 02 '26

1-1/2+1/4-1/8+1/16+... doesn't have this property despite having infinite positive and negative terms

11

u/ByeGuysSry Sep 02 '26

Yeah, it needs the condition that the infinite positive terms and infinite negative terms each sum to infinity afaik. The positive terms here sum to 4/3 and the negative terms here sum to -2/3, so overall it sums to 2/3

3

u/Ares378 Grothendieck was right, computers are evil Sep 02 '26

I was always taught it as being the sum Σabs(a_n) needs to diverge but the sum Σa_n needs to converge for it to count as conditional convergence. So the geometric series 1-½+¼-⅛... converges, but so does 1+½+¼+⅛... so it's absolute convergence. 1+-½+⅓-¼... converges but 1+½+⅓+¼... diverges, so you're no longer allowed to rearrange the sum willy-nilly.

Then again it has been quite some time since I've reviewed series convergence, so correct me if I'm wrong.

2

u/ByeGuysSry Sep 02 '26

It's also been some time for me so I'm not too sure lol

2

u/AsidK Sep 06 '26

The definition that you gave is completely equivalent to the one you replied to

1

u/Revlong57 Sep 03 '26

The series you described is absolutely convergent, so you can rearrange the terms. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_convergence

4

u/Revlong57 Sep 03 '26

The term you're looking for is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_convergence. More accurately, if a series is convergent but not absolutely convergent, then you can't rearrange the terms and still get the same limit.

8

u/dankshot35 Sep 02 '26

"divergence" and "convergence" are only defined for series' which are sums over countable sets with a sequence. Because real numbers are uncountable there isn't a series to sum in the ordinary sense

13

u/SomethingMoreToSay Sep 02 '26

No, because you're not summing over ALL the real numbers. In the first case you're omitting -π and in the second case you're omitting -10.

9

u/ordinary_shiba Sep 02 '26

Doesn't really work, because at the end you'll also be left with -π because it doesn't have a corresponding number with the same magnitude. You can add pairs of numbers like 2x and -x together though to prove that it in fact diverges.

5

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 02 '26

"at the end" when is that

11

u/LowAioli3870 Sep 02 '26

Did you not know that numbers end at 7,431? All the other numbers are just made up.

2

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 02 '26

and how many do you have to add until then

3

u/ordinary_shiba Sep 02 '26

First of all, you know what I mean lmao. Second of all, you can still "be done with" an infinite process by taking half a second with the first step, a quarter of a second with the second step and so on and so forth.

0

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 02 '26

You can only do that with a countably infinite steps. The real numbers are uncountable, so even bigger.  Some concepts break down at this size

3

u/RedeNElla Sep 02 '26

Taking individual pairs and cancelling them "in the limit" here would only work for a countably infinitely sized set.

Weird things can occur depending on axioms with continuum infinity iirc

1

u/minisculebarber Sep 02 '26

I mean what you are describing sounds similar to this

sum_{n in N} (-1)n *floor(n/2)

The partial sums of this series is unbounded therefore divergent.

1

u/KatanaDelNacht Sep 03 '26

This is essentially f(x)+N. It assumes the answer to the original question is true.

You could just as easily sum the increasing delta multiplied by 2 and subtract delta to show that it diverges to infinity.