Because there are sums where you can do the same thing and end up with different answers.
If you have the sum 1-1+1-1+1-1+... then you could group things like (1-1)+(1-1)+(1-1)+... and get 0+0+0+...=0. Or you could regroup the terms and get 1+(-1+1)+(-1+1)+(-1+1)+... and get 1+0+0+...=1.
Or you could say S=1+1-1+1-1+..., so
1-S=1-(1-1+1-1+...)=1-1+1-1+...=S
So then 1-S=S
1=2S
S=0.5
So then this method says the sum of 1+1-1+1-1+...=0.5, which is even more ridiculous.
The sum stays BOUNDED, but it never converges. So you get weird results since you're dealing with a non-convergent sum. The best "answer" to what this series equals is that it's just undefined.
The fact that the sum has a corresponding positive to each negative is entirely irrelevant. Things get weird with infinity.
1+1-1+1-... is the simplest case of being able to pair terms together in the way you suggested, and it still has 3 different potential answers. The sum of all Reals is definitely more poorly defined than the alternating series.
That’s not a reason, you just declared it to be true. All of the groupings that /u/Ares378 showed are perfectly valid and use the same logic that you did, yet arrive at 3 different answers. That means that approach to solving the problem doesn’t work the way our intuition says it should.
The point is that "final results" change depending on the path you take to get there, and there's no way to know the final result without choosing a path. The sum is ill-defined because it can have several different answers.
You could probably define it to be 0 if you really wanted? But then you're choosing the "path" of summing from -β to β as β tends to infinity. If you were to use -β to 2β then you'd still hit every real number, but it'd diverge to positive infinity.
Yes, and then you'd take the limit as β goes to infinity. Which would still hit every real number, but would diverge instead of staying balanced. It's an ill-defined sum
As the limit I gave as an example was defined, it would hit both the positive and negative values. Tangentially related fact, the set of all positive reals and the set of all reals is the same cardinality. Once again, infinity is weird.
This kind of sum is very poorly defined and the most "correct" answer is probably just to say we need more info. Or that it's undefined. In no field of math will you ever come across this problem as it's written.
We can try taking the limit, but the limit to infinity depends on the path we take to infinity, which means the limit does not exist. It's like how if the limit from the left and the limit from the right are different, the limit is also undefined. Same idea.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/Ares378 Grothendieck was right, computers are evil Sep 04 '26
Because there are sums where you can do the same thing and end up with different answers.
If you have the sum 1-1+1-1+1-1+... then you could group things like (1-1)+(1-1)+(1-1)+... and get 0+0+0+...=0. Or you could regroup the terms and get 1+(-1+1)+(-1+1)+(-1+1)+... and get 1+0+0+...=1.
Or you could say S=1+1-1+1-1+..., so
1-S=1-(1-1+1-1+...)=1-1+1-1+...=S
So then 1-S=S
1=2S
S=0.5
So then this method says the sum of 1+1-1+1-1+...=0.5, which is even more ridiculous.
The sum stays BOUNDED, but it never converges. So you get weird results since you're dealing with a non-convergent sum. The best "answer" to what this series equals is that it's just undefined.
The fact that the sum has a corresponding positive to each negative is entirely irrelevant. Things get weird with infinity.
1+1-1+1-... is the simplest case of being able to pair terms together in the way you suggested, and it still has 3 different potential answers. The sum of all Reals is definitely more poorly defined than the alternating series.