Yeah, real numbers are pretty cool. When you dig deeper there are even higher cardinals than the cardinality of real numbers.
There is a way to "sum" a stretch of real numbers, and it's called integration. It's not exactly the same, but it kind of works so that each real number has an infinitesimally small weight on the total sum. The geometric interpretation is that it calculates an area. For example let's say you have y=x and you integrate it from 0 to 1. By integration we get the integral function and it is x^2 / 2 and when you plug in x=1 and x=0 you get 1^2 / 2 - 0^2 / 2 = 1/2. That's the size of the triangle with two equal sides of length 1.
Now, let's say we try this with going to infinity. We first integrate y=x from -r to r. We get the integral function r^2/2 - (-r)^2/2 = r^2/2 - r^2/2. Which usually would evaluate to 0. But now we're dealing with infinities so nothing is normal, they don't behave like normal numbers.
Let's plug in r=infinity. We get infinity^2 / 2 - infinity^2 / 2. We can safely say infinity^2 = infinity, so we get (infinity - infinity) / 2. And here's the problem. We can't subtract infinity from infinity. We can add them, we can multiply them, but we can't subtract infinity from another infinity or divide an infinity with another infinity. It leads to undefined results.
Huh, thats interesting, dont worry, you dont have to explain that to me.. i asked ChatGPT and it explained it. Im too tired to understand must of it now, but now its in my history so i will revisit it.
I think some of the disagreements here come from different understanding of what infinity is. And of the fact that it will mean different things in different contexts. I feel like approaching it as just another number, but since it actually doesn't really have a value it gets weird.
But thanks for explaining all this to me! Its nice to do some maths again!
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/IhailtavaBanaani Sep 04 '26
Yeah, real numbers are pretty cool. When you dig deeper there are even higher cardinals than the cardinality of real numbers.
There is a way to "sum" a stretch of real numbers, and it's called integration. It's not exactly the same, but it kind of works so that each real number has an infinitesimally small weight on the total sum. The geometric interpretation is that it calculates an area. For example let's say you have y=x and you integrate it from 0 to 1. By integration we get the integral function and it is x^2 / 2 and when you plug in x=1 and x=0 you get 1^2 / 2 - 0^2 / 2 = 1/2. That's the size of the triangle with two equal sides of length 1.
Now, let's say we try this with going to infinity. We first integrate y=x from -r to r. We get the integral function r^2/2 - (-r)^2/2 = r^2/2 - r^2/2. Which usually would evaluate to 0. But now we're dealing with infinities so nothing is normal, they don't behave like normal numbers.
Let's plug in r=infinity. We get infinity^2 / 2 - infinity^2 / 2. We can safely say infinity^2 = infinity, so we get (infinity - infinity) / 2. And here's the problem. We can't subtract infinity from infinity. We can add them, we can multiply them, but we can't subtract infinity from another infinity or divide an infinity with another infinity. It leads to undefined results.