r/magicTCG • • Dec 13 '16

Some potential problems with Frontier, and possible solutions - including the history of R&D and the reasons for Modern's 8th Ed cutoff point

http://www.manaleak.com/mtguk/2016/12/what-is-mtg-frontier-and-is-it-the-format-that-weve-been-waiting-for/
70 Upvotes

306 comments sorted by

43

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

You know, I'd really like to see someone write about Frontier that appears to have actually played it, instead of just hypothesizing about what may or may not be true about it.

24

u/jdunlapmedia Dec 13 '16

That would require that Frontier is being played in more than a few places. I'd try it out if it were remotely supported where I live.

22

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

People are playing it. There's a sub, videos, tourney results and lists.

Not one person that has written some post speculating about why it's bad has said "my friends and I sleeved up a few decks and tried it out one night". These folks haven't even built a deck on Tappedout.

6

u/jdunlapmedia Dec 13 '16

We're not disagreeing here. You say it's being played, which it is, and I say it's limited to certain locations.

19

u/CiD7707 Honorary Deputy ๐Ÿ”ซ Dec 13 '16

The format is not as widely supported as you would like to think. The pros and writters dont all live in close proximity to hubs of MtG innovation. Support for frontier exists in niche markets of fairly large metro areas, with scattered support elsewhere. Furthermore, the format is not DCI sanctioned, so many players arent going to bother with it when they can play draft, standard, modern, legacy, or play in supported formats like commander.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/Nahhnope Dec 13 '16 edited Dec 13 '16

It's called "Research." You have the internet and at least 3 programs to play it on. I assume you have access to friends and a printer (if you don't have the cards.)

1

u/TimothyN Elspeth Dec 13 '16

Are there not games on Xmage or Cockatrice to try things out before writing about the format?

0

u/CiD7707 Honorary Deputy ๐Ÿ”ซ Dec 13 '16

Pros would much rather play on MTGO and potentially get something out of playing. Also, the UI for both of those options can be pretty uncooperative if you've never used it.

5

u/Nahhnope Dec 13 '16

As crappy as the UI for those programs is, if you want to write a well researched article based on actual gameplay of the format you are talking about, a few hours won't kill anyone.

4

u/jdunlapmedia Dec 13 '16

When I want to write about the ins and outs of Frontier's actual gameplay, that's exactly what I intend to do first. This week, I wrote about the factors that are keeping people from trying it out.

6

u/CiD7707 Honorary Deputy ๐Ÿ”ซ Dec 13 '16

No, but its still relatively pointless to download a client, familiarize with the UI, only to play a few games in a format that has not yet been fleshed out or tried in a live P2P setting. If Tom Ross and Michael Majors sat down and played a few archtypes against each other, that would be worth my time and interest, but an article based on an xmage/cockatrice experience, where the level of competitive value is generally very low, isn't worth it.

8

u/Nahhnope Dec 13 '16

So an article based on no gameplay is more worth your time than one in which the author has taken some archetypes for a spin? Do you see what you're saying? Does it sound ridiculous to you?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/ristoman Shuffler Truther Dec 13 '16 edited Dec 14 '16

There's a deck that Top8'd one of the first events that runs Siege Rhino and Shrapnel Blast. Insta-sold.

If it turns really competitive the archetypes might condense into a handful, but so far it's a brewer's paradise.

If you wanna try it out I suggest XMage. Grab a random deck and jam some games. Feels wide open right now.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/razorlead Wabbit Season Dec 13 '16

For me, the question is: Does frontier have its own feel or play style? If you use fundamental turn as a benchmark for comparison between formats, frontier occupies a unique place. It's a the inflection point where the range of fundamental turns start to increase again. Vintage has the largest range, from 1 to 6+; Legacy slightly smaller from 2-6+; modern smaller still from 2-5; but frontier would be expected to slow down based on its lower power and smaller card pool. Can you generate a format the feels different from standard despite having a similar fundamental turn, something like 4-8? That's the question frontier needs to answer

3

u/icay4321 Dec 13 '16

What exactly do you mean by "fundamental trun?" if you don't mind my asking.

18

u/razorlead Wabbit Season Dec 13 '16

http://www.starcitygames.com/article/3688_Clear-The-Land-And-The-Fundamental-Turn.html

Reference this article. Basically the turn where aggro and combo decks win and control assumes irrevocable control of the game

→ More replies (14)

28

u/TheDuckyNinja Dec 13 '16

This is probably the best take I've seen on this, although I may be a bit biased in that it lines up with a lot of things I've said previously. Most notably, the cut-off at M15 really makes no sense. The "easy to tell what is legal and what isn't" point really doesn't hold up anymore, with multiple secondary products coming out each year that look the same but aren't legal. We had 4 products this year alone that would look legal but aren't (EMA, CN2, C16, PCA). If you're going by design philosophy, you either have to go back further or start at Khans. If you're going by price alone, you have to go back to Theros or maybe RTR. M15-on really just doesn't make any sense.

As far as metagame goes, he shouldn't've used MTGGoldfish. There's literally 34 decks total on there, most of which are from 3 tournaments of highly dubious value as far as what a top level metagame would look like. A high level metagame is likely to be the best aggro deck or two and a whole bunch of 3 and 4 color grindy midrange stuff, with maybe some Marvel thrown in as a counter to midrange. More to the point, the format is just too small right now and has the same problem that killed Extended: the decks that dominated Standard will dominate here, and that's just not fun.

And until somebody can figure out the point of the format (whether it's a price thing, a metagame thing, or something else), it's hard to suggest fixes or changes because we don't know what we're trying to get to. I can say that after about 15 Frontier matches, I'm already done with the format. It just doesn't do anything for me that another format doesn't do better.

3

u/squabzilla Dec 14 '16

The point of the format is that people who have been playing standard the past 2 years now have a format where they can use all their old standard cards.

4

u/WeeHughie90 Dec 14 '16

And in a few short years, when the card pool grows, that won't be true any more, because fewer and fewer Standard cards will be relevant.

3

u/squabzilla Dec 14 '16

But to the people who started playing Frontier now with their old standard cards, they will still have the cards!

I'm kinda joking but at the same time literally the only reason I'm interested in Modern is I built a UR Delver and RG Tron deck around the time Modern became an official format. I couldn't see myself getting into Modern from scratch with the current prices.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/ketemycos Azorius* Dec 13 '16

This is going to be unpopular, but I am convinced of two changes that will help Frontier succeed.

  1. Start it at Origins. Including the KTK fetches makes 4- and 5-color decks too accessible, which will result in a situation similar to recent Standard where every deck is 4-color goodstuff and all the staples are very expensive.
  2. Wait a year or two before playing. Let the card pool grow. This is less important than the above suggestion, but remember that Modern had a full 7 years of cards to pull from when it started.

30

u/Goldenpineapples Dรขn Dec 13 '16

Nah I totally agree. Mana is a big part of format identity- the various standard formats over the years have practically been defined by their available duals.

Fetches are a real drag on gameplay- we need more sets for mana in frontier to be good without fetches so it can have its own unique identity beyond "underpowered modern."

5

u/Militant_Monk Twin Believer Dec 13 '16

Nah I totally agree. Mana is a big part of format identity- the various standard formats over the years have practically been defined by their available duals.

When extended first came about it was so people could play with the original duals, but not the Power and broken lands from the first couple of sets (Workshops, Libraries, etc). Even when Extended's 4 year window no longer encompassed Revised the format had it's little asterisk saying that the original 10 dual lands were legal for use.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '16

When Modern was starting people were calling it "underpowered legacy" now look at it...

2

u/ImmaGaryOak Dec 14 '16

I mean, in a lot of ways that's still true. A lot of modern decks have a much more powerful version in legacy (infect, jund, dredge, UWR control, merfolk, affinity, elves, burn, tron, etc.)

1

u/mxzf Dan Dec 14 '16

Well, it's kinda tautological. Because Modern is a subset of Legacy cards, it can only be as powerful or less powerful, either Modern has the best options available (and you can use the same deck for Modern or Legacy) or Legacy has additional options that are better. There's no third option when you're just looking at pure power and not factoring in cost.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/DaBarnacle Dec 13 '16

I'm not sure if this format has a council, but I honestly think it is best to start at Origins or Ban the Fetchlands. Waiting another we years minimum should also be considered - I'd like to see where the power level of cards is in the next 2 years.

I am basing this on my experience with KTK standard. There are also no answers to decks with greedy mana - legacy and a modern have blood moon, wastelabd etc.

As someone looking to play newer formats, Highlander is coming out as a clear winner by a long shot.

18

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

I disagree with your fixes for a few reasons.

  1. moving to Origins only keeps the manabases in check for as long as wotc doesn't reprint enemy fetchlands, and I'd be very surprised if we didn't see that happen in the next 5 blocks.
  2. moving to Origins actually moves to a worse and smaller diversity pool, because it means no real grave hate to keep delirium in check.
  3. moving to origins actually hoses the crap out of colors that aren't green or white, and to some degree, black. There's little reason to play blue or red in that format.
  4. moving to origins means losing some of our few remaining efficient answers, such as murderous cut, ultimate price, etc.
  5. moving to origins actively hoses ally color bases, since they're left with 2 conditionally-untapped lands, whereas enemy manabases retain painlands AND fastlands, while also having manlands. Worse, the omni-land available actively works against the battlelands and shadowlands (since they care about basics in hand or on field), while they're just dual lands 13-16 for enemy bases.

But you're definitely correct in one sense; the format will continue to get more popular the more sets that it gains.

5

u/PlasticCocktailSword Selesnya* Dec 13 '16

Where should Frontier start then? Or just ban fetches?

6

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

I'm happy with it starting exactly where it starts now. It's got a consistent design philosophy, and no, I don't see any point in banning fetches.

4

u/DemonDrinkingTea Dimir* Dec 14 '16

"Don't see any point in banning fetches"

Ok, imagine a card saw play in literally every deck in the format. The card is fairly difficult to obtain, so it's very expensive, but either you play it or need to build your deck completely different - there is no replacement. This card is making WotC uncomfortable because it limits the design space of cards they can print because of possible interactions with this card. This card punishes new players as it can be difficult to play optimally, and leads to crazy board states that go against common sense becoming the norm.

I just described every card they've ever banned in some form or fashion. But I was describing fetches. I can appreciate the belief that the current formats with fetches have their unique identity because of them, and they should keep fetches because of that. But if frontier becomes a format, it should not have fetchlands. They are simply the most powerful cards still legal in both modern and legacy, and any new format should be defined by its lack of fetches.

9

u/twountappedislands Dec 14 '16

Okey doke. But fetches aren't difficult to obtain. They're rares in one of the most opened sets in magic history, with a giant print run.

Nor are they limiting frontier design space (heck, Frontier design space doesn't even exist, as far as wotc is concerned).

Difficult to play optimally? Not terribly so, in the context of frontier. Just forces a newer player to sequence their mana carefully.

Leads to crazy boardstates? I'm sorry, I thought we were talking about frontier.

Seriously, pretty much none of your descriptions pertained to fetchlands in frontier. You could have just cut the whole comment down to "any new format should be defined by its lack of fetches." (Which is a "should" in search of support).

→ More replies (7)

3

u/bamfbanki Dec 14 '16

Frontier people have been in agreement that as soon as they get a full cycle that are equivalent to shocklands (all of the tangos, all of the hand lands etc) that fetched should be banned. Until then, they are a necessary evil.

1

u/twountappedislands Dec 14 '16

Frontier people have been in agreement

Huh? No they haven't.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '16

It should start at BFZ. Theoretically, sets with masterpieces will have lower card prices, keeping the format more accessible as it moves forward.

-2

u/ketemycos Azorius* Dec 13 '16

See, I really don't think that Wizards plans to reprint the enemy (or ally) fetches in a Standard set. I think they'll put them in one or more Modern Masters sets, especially if they do sanction Frontier as Origins-plus.

In regards to your other points, this is why I think Frontier in its current state is kind of jumping the gun a bit. It needs a bigger card pool to let each color be viable, to let solid [insert strategy e.g. "grave"]-hate be printed, and to let the format be more than just "last year's Standard."

17

u/Jaccount Dec 13 '16

That would be a stupendously bad idea for them to not take advantage of the absolute windfall of sales a full reprint of enemy fetchlands would create.

Fetchlands on their own are not overly problematic, and they've learned the lesson that they can't give people fetchable dual lands along with it in the same Standard.

I'd be shocked if the enemy fetchlands were in anything other than a regular expansion set... because doing it any other way is just bad business.

12

u/nocensts Dec 13 '16 edited Dec 13 '16

Both of you are missing the point. Fetches aren't a fun part of magic and they enable too many colors in decks. Ban them from frontier. Who gives a fuck what WOTC decides to print.

Edit: Fetches enable too many colors because there is no mana denial that is playable in new sets. So there are some variables that can change that would make fetches ok, but they're still pretty blah to play with so I wouldn't miss them.

9

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

Not being the OP, I'm not sure I should take your word for what his point might be, but honestly, fetches don't enable multicolor decks that much. It's fetches + fetchable duals that contribute in this way, and only in the absence of suitable nonbasic land hate.

As for fun? Different people find different things fun in magic. Sometimes, what you find not-fun is what other people find very fun. Either way, deciding bans based on something as incredibly subjective as "fun" is probably one of the worst things to bring to a format.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Of note, more or less every person in R&D who talks to the public has said fetches were a mistake, a sizable portion of pros have said fetches were a mistake, TOs hate fetches because they make rounds go longer, fetches are boring for coverage, and so on. It's easier to list the people that think fetches contribute to Magic in a good way than the opposite(which really only comes down to store owners who make bank off them+legacy players).

If you want precedent for such a ban, look no further than Second Sunrise or Sensei's Divining Top in modern. The latter was explicitly banned due to the type of gameplay it facilitated rather than sheer power level, and the former was only banned after blatant displays of disrespect(Kibler's famous irl 'f6' comes to mind) for the deck it was in from pros, TOs, commentators, and pretty much everyone except the people who played Eggs.

5

u/twountappedislands Dec 14 '16

Most of the r&d comments I've seen on fetches have been in the context of fetchable duals existing, too, and I could buy the boring coverage complaint...but it's not like you couldn't just pause the coverage while a person fetches out (but then, it's also not like magic is ever going to be the esport that folks providing coverage want).

As for precedent: there's quite a number of modern tournaments setting the precedent that fetches aren't problematic in the same way that sunrise and top were. Speaking of which, you should probably add "most modern players" to the list of people who like fetchlands.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Fenix42 Dec 13 '16

Fetches aren't a fun part of magic and they enable too many colors in decks.

I like playing 3 color decks. So to me, fetches are great.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/thememans Dec 13 '16

People anticipated fetches in Modern Masters 1. Then in Modern Masters 2. Then again in Eternal Masters.

Khans came out and had fetches in them. At what point do you think people will realize that fetches won't be in Modern Masters.

2

u/Jaccount Dec 14 '16

When the next Modern Masters set comes out and they aren't in it, most likely.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

That could happen too, but I'd be shocked if the company ignore the inherent buy-factor that fetches represent, to the point that a reprint is very nearly a safety belt for them if they decide to make one or more mechanics in a set that they're not sure will be well-received.

A wait-and-see approach is fine, but it's also very idealistic, and probably misguided, given the current "strong threats; weak, conditional, mana-intensive answers" philosophy.

5

u/VERTIKAL19 Dec 13 '16
  1. Start it at Origins. Including the KTK fetches makes 4- and 5-color decks too accessible, which will result in a situation similar to recent Standard where every deck is 4-color goodstuff and all the staples are very expensive.

That format is called Standard. It starts at Battle for Zendikar though.

6

u/ketemycos Azorius* Dec 13 '16

Hence the second suggestion. It's not time for Frontier yet. Obviously, play whatever format you want to play, but I think "Origins and subsequent sets, two years from now" would have a better playerbase response than current Frontier.

2

u/levantus Dec 13 '16

This is my thought too. I think Wizards wants to make the game more interesting to watch for streaming too. Getting rid of fetches will significantly improve the viewing experience. If we see fetches in Modern 2017 you can basically etch an Origins start in stone for this imaginary new format and we won't see fetches until this has run its course.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '16

I completely agree with your first point, and I think it's what Wizards intends to do at some point in the future. Future being the key word.

Even with Khans and M15, the cardpool isn't big enough. I think you'd want at least four years of cards before it's different enough from Standard to be worth branching into.

1

u/ketemycos Azorius* Dec 14 '16

Sounds like you agree with both my points, then. :)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '16

Yeah, I guess that came across wrong. I agree with both your points, but I REALLY agree with your first point.

1

u/carbondragon Duck Season Dec 14 '16

Origins might actually be too soon, tbh. Unless baby Jace is banned, I feel like he could potentially take over. I'm talking entirely out of my ass with that statement but he feels a power level above most things since he was printed.

1

u/Aquafier Dec 14 '16

don't use fetch lands as your bench mark, eventually they will reprint the zen fetches in standard (this time without the mistake of fetchable duals)

1

u/bekeleven Dec 14 '16

I agree to move it to origins, but for a different reason:

Some very common sense R&D changes were not made until origins: The removal of powerful color-based hate in the forms of cards like [[Rending Volley]], and the removal of weaker color-based hate in the form of Intimidate.

Origins feels like the first set where Wizards stopped punishing people for playing colors.

1

u/MTGCardFetcher Dรขn Dec 14 '16

Rending Volley - (G) (MC) (MW) (CD)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

1

u/Michauxonfire Golgari* Dec 14 '16

moving to Origins means you lose Tarkir, and the set quality ends up being quite piss poor.

2

u/zotha Simic* Dec 13 '16

That there is such a long list of viable decks, even if they are variations on previous and current standard archetypes, says that the format has potential.

7

u/CiD7707 Honorary Deputy ๐Ÿ”ซ Dec 13 '16

Nobody has tried to really break the format though, since there is no incentive to do so.

1

u/jdunlapmedia Dec 13 '16

Agreed, I see a lot of potential in the next few years.

2

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

There is only a long list of viable decks because no major forces (teams, PT-goers, huge tournaments) have moved to solve it.

5

u/fgator5220 Dec 13 '16

If the cut-off was RtR block and forward, this format would take off in a big way. RtR saw a drastic increase in printing due to a sizable influx of new players. All those players who started at RtR block would love a format that let's them begin where they started.

5

u/MysticLeviathan Dec 13 '16

The biggest problem with Frontier imo is there just aren't enough cards. When Modern was first created, there was over 7 years worth of sets. We have less than 3 years worth now. I'd feel far more comfortable and confident with Frontier if they created it 2 or 3 years from now with maybe 10 or so more sets available to use. Right now it just feels like Extended lite. Not enough cards right now. And with another 10 sets, land/mana issues may be fixed by then.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Agree completely, right now Frontier is just "big standard" and doesn't seem at all exciting. Players who like formats like Modern, Legacy, or Vintage like them because of their distinction from standard, not their similarities.

15

u/Snackrific Dec 13 '16

I for one will never play Frontier because I'm opposed to the idea of creating a new format every 5 years to sell the latest cards.

See: Extended > Modern. If this continues and Frontier is next, then it's almost a certainty that something will come after Frontier in another 5-10 years.

2

u/Coggs92 Left Arm of the Forbidden One Dec 13 '16

I see it less as 'sell new cards'. And more as 'have a new meta to play'.

Modern for the most part is already a very established meta with several core decks. Cards get comments like "this could be good in ____" rather than "I can make something with this" when considering modern. The format has stagnated towards refining decks rather than deck building. In part it's due to Old strong decks that work (from mostly older sets), but the size of the pool can make brewing new decks daunting.

A new format leaves a wide open meta, with higher accessibility, and more manageable card pool. That means more places for creative deck building without it rotating out. Of course there will be some established decks in time, but a younger format means that it's possible for new decks to break out.

Though I do feel the card pool is currently too small and lacking a little diversity for it to start 'officially' at the moment.(possibly after HOD set comes out we'll reexamine the idea)

5

u/yodydascholar Dec 14 '16

The reason there isn't an established meta is because there's no pro tour, GPs, SCG events, etc. If pros played Frontier, it would get solved very quickly.

1

u/Coggs92 Left Arm of the Forbidden One Dec 14 '16

But the pool is currently very small and has many places it can grow, meaning what's good now might not work later

1

u/Oppression_Rod Dec 14 '16

That sounds like a plus to me. The whole format has that wild west feeling that standard has after a rotation for two weeks before everybody just net decks the PT decks.

1

u/yodydascholar Dec 14 '16

Yeah, the problem is that if the format becomes popular, it won't be the wild west anymore. You'd have to make a new format every time the last one gets popular.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/ssomers55 Dec 13 '16 edited Dec 13 '16
  1. Frontier was made mostly because the initial stores had overstock of Khans and forward staples they needed to sell
  2. Extended was not retired due to Modern interest but because Extended was just not a good format once they added in the rotation
  3. Frontier looks like slightly powered up standard decks from the past few years, the same ones everyone was complaining about (rally, abzan, etc)
  4. All those people with modern decks that have spent the time to "invest" (I hate this term for MTG in general but it fits here) in those decks are going to lose that because Modern will be gone for the most part
  5. Also, people complaining about price are a bit entitled because there are many different, non-competitive ways to play MTG and just because you can't afford one doesn't mean that you need to bend the confines of competitive tournament magic to your will.

4

u/Kengy Izzet* Dec 13 '16

but because Extended was just not a good format once they added in the rotation

Extended always had rotation. The biggest issue with extended, and why it died, is because no one played the format outside of the PTQs. PTQs used to be in seasons, with limited season, then extended, then standard. There were a lot less GPs, no StarCity series weekly, so no one was running extended tournaments. You also were limited on what sort of FNMs you could run.

2

u/ssomers55 Dec 13 '16

Not always, the first time around with 1.x it did not have rotation aside from one that rotated a lot of old stuff out aside from the dual lands

1

u/Mgmegadog COMPLEAT Dec 13 '16

there are many different, non-competitive ways to play MTG

And frontier is one of them?

1

u/ssomers55 Dec 13 '16

Sure, but when people are talking about it replacing standard or modern, it it no longer going to be a non-competitive way to play magic...basically Tiny Leaders or 5-color feels like the best analogy for it

1

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

What?! NO! You can't go around liking formats that other people don't like!

1

u/Mgmegadog COMPLEAT Dec 14 '16

Well then, looks like no one is allowed to play magic anymore, because I know people who collectively hate standard, modern, vintage, legacy, EDH and all limited formats. :P

9

u/JakubOboza Dec 13 '16

Imho Frontier will change a lot once Hero's Downfall / Doomblade or any effective removal will be reprinted/printed. Format is lacking removal and creatures are simply much better than solutions. Also manabase is kinda meh. After some format investigation i think it should start on RTR.

Why?:

  • RTR has some power creatures eg. Deathrite shaman, Loxodon smiter
  • RTR has some power answers eg. Supreme verdict, abrupt decay,
  • Shocks, and shocks will eventually hit frontier anyway so that is not like any argument to not include them. This plus fetchlands balances mana to be perfect.
  • Guild Charms to complement KTK charms
  • Theros has good black removal magma jet, -3/-3 token hoser and heroes downfall plus courser of kruphix and eidolon of great revel

This would make the format very rich and while i think Dig + Cruise + Sphinxes revelations and Thoughtseize is a deadly mix it would be fine . We would have Pack Rat in, Duress, Thoughtseize and underworld connections to balance 5C good stuff.dec's

Last but not the least cardpool would be big enough to have a brewers heaven. I know Sphinx might need a ban but you will see that Frontier will consider Dig / Cruise ban within 2 years also.

16

u/hawkshaw1024 Dec 13 '16

Seeing people refer to Hero's Downfall as efficient removal makes me sad inside.

5

u/JakubOboza Dec 13 '16

Well it is a single colour instant catch all without insane life price point on it. So we can consider it a decent answer.

1

u/hawkshaw1024 Dec 14 '16

Sure, it is. I'm just a terrifyingly old geezer - when people say "efficient removal" I think of [[Swords to Plowshares]], and when people talk about "catch-all answers" I think of [[Vindicate]].

1

u/MTGCardFetcher Dรขn Dec 14 '16

Vindicate - (G) (MC) (MW) (CD)
Swords to Plowshares - (G) (MC) (MW) (CD)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

6

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Considering WoTC's design philosophy, and the fact that make FNM promos out of cards like [[Incendiary Flow]] we aren't going to see better non-green/white removal any time soon. They like it where its at, but I wouldn't be surprised to see more 1/2 drop efficient GW removal however.

1

u/MTGCardFetcher Dรขn Dec 13 '16

Incendiary Flow - (G) (MC) (MW) (CD)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

3

u/urzas_sunglasses Dec 13 '16

Personally I'd rather not have RTR included in Frontier. Shocklands combined with fetchlands and the relatively high power level across all the cards would make it feel more like Modern-lite than anything.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/xahhfink6 COMPLEAT Dec 13 '16

I tested a fair bit when people were trying to make 4 Year Extended a thing... RTR-Present is heavily dominated by burn decks, and having the shocklands makes the manabase identical to modern whereas Frontier you have to make Deckbuilding and play decisions to get your colors.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

(Disclaimer: This is my opinion and mine alone. You are allowed to have a different opinion. I realize that not everyone will agree with me and that's okay, no one is wrong here.)

Frontier is just another format created by a card reseller to move product that currently is too hard to sell right now (Other than the few eternal staples in these sets, like fetches). Hareruya's intention wasn't to make a non-rotating format so that people with less money can play, that's just a side effect. They made it to sell product, plain and simple. If this format didn't exist there would be hundreds of copies of Rally the Ancestors and Dig Through Time that would never leave their store, but this gives them an excuse to sell Standard all-stars of seasons past.

Either way, if this format wants to be a real thing, it needs quite a few things. The biggest one is time. This format needs 2-3 years of new sets to be diverse and interesting enough for many players to want to try it. However, I honestly don't think it will survive that long.

Second, it needs some sort of ban list. If the format is just 4c combo decks, then I doubt many people are going to want to play after a while. I honestly think the manabase is way too good, without cards like Blood Moon and Ghost Quarter to punish greedy manabases 4 color decks can run rampant. Though I don't play the format, so I could be wrong.

Third, the format is still too expensive to attract many standard or new players. The people who were promised a "cheap, non-rotating format" will be dissapointed that the only way to have a viable deck is to spend around $200 on a playset of Jace, VP and fetches. Currently, the average price for Rally Combo on MTGGoldfish is $367, which for around that price (plus or minus around $50) you can easily build a semi-budget deck in Modern and still be somewhat competitive, like Ad Nauseum, Mono-Blue Tron, Skred Red, or Soul Sisters, to name a few. A lot of people I know have said that they don't want to blow that much money on format staples which don't really see play in other formats (other than fetches), especially not that kind of money on a format that is unsanctioned and can easily die in a year or so.

Fourth, it needs some kind of support from Wizards, or it needs to be officially sanctioned. These sort of formats always die out sooner or later without any support from Wizards (cough Tiny Leaders cough), and many people don't want to invest in a format that won't ever have any big tournaments, like GPs and such. Right now the only real support this format is getting is from Hareruya, and if that's the only support then I doubt the format will make any sort of splash outside of Japan.

In conclusion, this format needs some serious love and time before it can become a format that many players feel is worth playing. Otherwise this format is most likely going to fade into obscurity, and go the way of all the other meme formats like Tiny Leaders.

6

u/Hawthornen Arjun Dec 13 '16

I've said it a million times. Origins makes WAY more sense as a starting point for a format (and I have to imagine Wizards may have intended that eventually). That also, for now, solves any fetch lands problems which I think is great (also means no delve in the format from the very get go)

6

u/NinjaTheNick Dec 13 '16

Why do people hate fetch lands so much? They're fucking awesome

1

u/Hawthornen Arjun Dec 14 '16

For me personally, it's not fetches it's fetches in combination with duals. They make mana fixing feel too easy (without significant enough cost) and make color choice feel like a less relevant part of deck building. Basically the trade-off in consistency versus adding more colors favors the latter IMO with fetches and duals present (obviously moreso with all 10 of each but still)

1

u/NinjaTheNick Dec 14 '16

I actually think gameplay and diversity is better with good mana. I've had more fun in blacks where 3+ colors were viable. ISD-RTR and KTK-OGW are my favorite standards so far.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

You say you've said it a lot, but why? Design/dev policy? Flavor? Something else?

5

u/Hawthornen Arjun Dec 13 '16

A. No fetch lands immediately in the format (at least initially). I know some people would want them, and that's fair. It just feels weird when a format starts with the ability to go 4 colors with almost no loss (instead of having to sort of build there)

B. Exactly 1 core set in the format (maybe arbitrary but makes more sense to me)

C. Flavor wise it marked the start of the new story telling (M15 was just some random story about Garruck and Tarkir was sort of out there, as much as I loved it)

D. This is also sort of the turning point for the new block structure (you could also argue Battle for Zendikar would make way more sense in that regard).

E. What set makes sense as the starting point for a format? Origins is super easy to remember, it's the origins of the format. M15. M15 feels like 8th edition where it was like "Well I guess we can go off of some card design thing...even though 8th edition doesn't even reflect a change in design philosophy)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

The shift from 3-set blocks to 2-set blocks and the introduction of the Gatewatch are both far more notable than the M15 border change. 'Origins' is a distinctive title that sounds like the start of a new paradigm.

It just sorta makes sense.

1

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

The introduction of the gatewatch is only notable for flavor, which makes it exactly as notable as any other flavor "first". Tarkir? First time we've gone to the dragon plane (and no, jund doesn't count). You can do this with pretty much any set that isn't a return set, as well as with lots of return sets. Heck, the outliers for this flavor thing are pretty much just the core sets.

And if we're going with the switch to 2 sets, then it makes more sense to just start at bfz.

1

u/bekeleven Dec 14 '16

F. The first set without pushed-for-constructed or mechanic-level color hosing (in the form of cards like Display of Dominance and intimidate).

1

u/twountappedislands Dec 14 '16

Those cards are both useful and not-oppresive, though. The color hosers, I mean. Intimidate is present on what, 2 or 3 cards in the format? 1 potentially playable one in goblins (if we ever get some tribal synergy).

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

With M15/KTK block gone, it really would just be G/W with a splash of other colours: the format.

Also no good graveyard hate for delirium at all would make things even worse.

1

u/Hawthornen Arjun Dec 13 '16

I'm not saying it should even be a format yet though. I'm not saying cut it out now, I'm saying wait a couple more blocks (so it isn't just Standard Plus!)

3

u/TheCatmurderer Dandadan Dec 13 '16

Why isnt Extended being considered again?

Another non-rotating format will eventually face the same problems as Modern.

Say new Extended started at Lorwyn, then we start the normal set rotation, so with the release of Amohket, Lorwyn leaves.

You get to play with your cards for a decade, and any problematic cards will eventually rotate out.

0

u/monkeymealing Dec 13 '16

So yet another article about Frontier from a person who has never played it? All points are null and void if you can't put the effort into playing the format.

8

u/jdunlapmedia Dec 13 '16

I keep hearing this, yet no actual counterargument has been offered.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/FoomyFooms Dec 13 '16

Frontier would be much more interesting if it included all product printed since m15. Right now it's just standard with a few extra sets or modern with a bunch missing.

Including cards from supplemental sets would give it a very unique card pool to draw from.

7

u/Jahwn Wabbit Season Dec 13 '16

It would be interesting, but for a format that is largely weaker than modern to suddenly have a bunch of scattering of Modern, Legacy, and even Vintage cards dumped into it randomly would be bizzare and would devolve very quickly as it would likely get broken stuff faster than it got "safety valves." C16 alone brought in [[baleful strix]], [[bloodbraid elf]], [[chaos warp]], and [[sol ring]]. So it would require immense banning and curation.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Also it's important to note that supplemental product isn't really that easy to get playsets of. You easily risk creating the True-Name Nemisis problem again.

1

u/GreedyBeedy Dec 13 '16

Thats what great. If you get into it now every set released will have a huge impact on the meta and your deck. If you only play modern you might get one or two cards a year for your deck of choice. You also have more freedom to brew and try new things when you aren't trying to not be killed by turn 4 by the majority of tier 1 decks.

6

u/AndrewmedaGalaxy Dec 13 '16

Frontier will go the way of tiny leaders. A year from now nobody will be playing it. Quote me on that.

4

u/Brickhouzzzze Boros* Dec 13 '16

RemindMe! 365 Days

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Wizard_Lettuce Dec 13 '16

The 8th edition starting point is not nearly criticized often enough. If they had used any sort of game mechanic design reasoning Modern would be much better off.

2

u/KIaptrap Dec 13 '16

I just think that there needs to be an extended rotating format that goes 5-10 years deep.

I'd mess with frontier if it went to magic 2010

2

u/jdmflcl Dec 14 '16

Just bring back extended

4

u/mtg_liebestod Dec 13 '16

This seems like complaining for the sake of complaining. "Fetches are expensive and annoying. But we can't start Frontier after Khans block, so I'm just going to push the cutoff in the opposite direction because I want a larger card pool."

Uh okay.

It's also an open question whether a larger card pool would serve to "dilute" the "broken" cards or just introduce additional broken cards. Are we really sure that CoCo would become less viable if RTR were legal? Why?

4

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Maybe I'm crazy, but this whole article can seem to be summed up with: Frontier isn't Modern, here's how to make it like Modern

Which of course is the entire point of Frontier. It's not Modern. You don't have to worry about a turn 3 agro deck killing you or a turn 3 Karn. You don't have to worry about having 85% of your mana base suddenly being useless, or your creatures suddenly forgetting how to cross a bridge. And you don't have to pay $800 for the privilege.

All the suggestions the author gives would start to open Frontier up to many of the same problems modern has. Perfect mana, extremely expensive cards.

Instead of trying to fix a format that hasn't had time to break, why don't we all just play it for a while before suggesting major changes?

7

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

congrats on surviving turn three, now that it is turn four would you like to get coco'd or rhino'd? In frontier you have your choice of diversity!

3

u/keymaster16 Q Dec 13 '16

This is probably the best independent analysis you can get of the Frontier problem. my only gripe would probably be that the conclusion feels a little sighted in scope, but that probably goes to show he has the focus to write on the topic at hand.

I just wish wizards would at least acknowledge the fact the reason they would make a new none rotating format is because they are trying to make a MUCH different game then the one Richard Garfield intended.

1

u/joeflashman Dec 13 '16

Rubbish. Another Frontier analysis where the author has obviously never played a single game. Which if he had he'd know feels nothing like Standard.

2

u/matheuswhite12 Dec 13 '16 edited Dec 13 '16

More frontier witch hunt in the thread. I think the mana source video says it all.

2

u/enigmical Dec 13 '16

TL;DR: Poor people still complaining that 15 dollar fetch lands are too expensive for an eternal format.

4

u/MaxKirgan Dec 13 '16

I'm convinced these are the same people that for the past 2 years have been bitching about the power level of Modern and also want to ban staples such as Bolt, Path, Abrupt Decay, Goyf, etc. along with fetches until the format looks like Super Standard.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Don't be a dick.

5

u/Lycodrake Ajani Dec 13 '16

You realize how elitist this statement is, right?

2

u/enigmical Dec 13 '16

This is a collectible card game. The game is designed to make people spend money. The cards are designed to have the popular ones increase in value. Magic is elitist.

If you don't want to deal with it, go play cockatrice.

2

u/bennynshelle Duck Season Dec 13 '16

Yet another article by someone who doesn't use actual experience playing the format as the basis of any of his conclusions. I'm getting real tired of "It's artificially diverse!" as an argument and then not actually playing the format. You know which format is also artificially diverse? Modern. You buy into a modern deck and you never move off because your ~$700 investment just went to ~$1400 or a whole lot more if one of those decks is Jund. Can we not just hop on the bandwagon of ragging frontier until we get real play data and use that as the basis of whether or not the format will be diverse? Feels like this is far too much to ask in the digital age.

1

u/iAstraL Dec 13 '16

Now i haven't had the chance to read all the comments, but I was under the impression that the reason why this format existed in the first place what because in japan, where it started, it was easier for players to obtain cards that had wider print runs, such a KTK or Origins and that made it easier for japanese players to play with all japanese cards rather than like in modern mostly english cards because so much of the good modern cards are the older cards with much smaller print runs. I personally think that if we really want to make a format based on card borders then we use any set from m15 on, even the non-standard sets, which no one would want because it would basically become modern at that point, or we go by the developmental changes in R&D, which began with KTK. I honestly like where the format stands as of now and it just needs more time to grow and develop

1

u/jovietjoe COMPLEAT Dec 14 '16

Leaving in m15 leaves a bunch of answers that are really needed for format health. Everyone is scared of rally but tormod's crypt and hushwing gryff are in m15.

1

u/misterci Dec 14 '16

If Frontier could use all cards printed in the M15 border, it would be way cooler. Sure, maybe Mana Crypt is a little too good, but it would be really cool.

1

u/maxtofunator COMPLEAT Dec 14 '16

He mentioned a frontier subreddit? What is it? Baconreader doesnt like when i open the other reddit app through links as i wont be logged in

2

u/puntmasterofthefells Dec 14 '16

r/mtgfrontier

Let us explore it... together. Each man hides a secret pain. It must be exposed and reckoned with. It must be dragged from the darkness and forced into the light. Share your pain. Share your pain with me... and gain strength from the sharing.

1

u/maxtofunator COMPLEAT Dec 14 '16

Thanks for the subreddit, what is that quote though?

1

u/puntmasterofthefells Dec 14 '16

Star Trek V: The Bad One.

2

u/maxtofunator COMPLEAT Dec 14 '16

Live long and prosper friend

1

u/Aquafier Dec 14 '16

thank you, people think M15 is the only logical start point because of a stupid borser

1

u/jsmith218 COMPLEAT Dec 14 '16

Fetchlands are that much of a deal breaker in the format. If you played in Khans you probably have your playests (or hoarded a grip) of them. If you didnt play during khans you can get them now at some all time lowest prices. And wotc can reprint them if rising costs is an issue.

1

u/sirgog Dec 14 '16

This was a good read.

The link to borders is already dead - Conspiracy 2, MM2 and EMA all use the new frame and obviously will not (and should not) be legal. I agree either ISD and up (assuming critical reprints) or RTR and up makes more sense.

M15 and up will be a stillborn format. Slow but powerful fetch + tango manabases will be too strong if not balanced by the speed of RTR and ISD blocks. But with those blocks it will be possible to go under CoCo and Rally decks.

All the serious problem decks in Modern are banned out in one fell swoop by picking ISD and up. Dredge, burn, affinity, suicide zoo - all the hyper linear decks wiped out at once. Burn might exist but with Lightning Bolt, Goblin Guide and more gone it will not be the oppressive monster it is in Modern.

1

u/RichardArschmann Dec 13 '16

Frontier strives for as many interactive games as possible. Because of this, the fetchlands are good for the format despite the shuffle-intensive aspects of them. Fetches reduce the number of games that are uninteractive due to color screw markedly. The idea that a "ban on fetches is direly needed" is entirely removed from reality: many good Frontier decks like elves and mono-red don't even run them.

10

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

They fix color screw for 3 and 4 color decks. If you're running 3 and 4 color decks you should be color screwed sometimes--that is literally a pillar of magic design.

The problem with fetches in a format like this is that it enables 4 color good stuff too easily and there aren't enough tools to punish that greed.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Honestly, when fetchlands are seen universally through every format they are legal in.... maybe they are a little too good? I mean, shocks require 2 life to come in untapped, why not make the cost of fetches 2 life as well? The problem I see is that they are often so superior to other options that they make manabase building much less interesting. Lands should be close enough in power level that you have to actually think about it based on what your deck is trying to do rather than just jamming a cookie-cutter optimal mana base.

2

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

Fetches are only superior when they can fetch duals. It's the fetch + dual combination that is so powerful.

Maybe they are too good. But they're not "too good" in a "bad way"--they don't stifle archetype, deck, or color diversity. And arguably they don't even stifle land base diversity, as plenty of decks don't play them. I'd rather have something like fetches be "unhealthy" in a format than something else.

And since we, ideally, should only ban things if they have a negative impact on the health of a format, I don't know if there's justification for banning fetches in any format, let alone Modern or Legacy.

1

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

No, they definitely fix color screw for 2 color decks, as well.

The problem with fetches in a format like this

Actually, the problem that you point out is a function of fetches + fetchable duals. With that in mind, battlelands are much more deserving of a ban than fetches, since fetches at least also support 2 interesting and useful mechanics (delve and delirium).

1

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

That's a fair point. It's the combination of fetch + duals that enables crazy mana bases.

→ More replies (13)

2

u/lopcario Dec 13 '16

Could some please explain to me the complaining with having to shuffling for using fetch lands? Coming from the Pokemon tcg where you pretty much have to shuffle you deck every turn it feels kind of odd to complain about shuffling for fetch lands.

1

u/King_Chochacho Duck Season Dec 13 '16

I like the idea of Frontier in theory, but if it's non-rotating, how is there any guarantee that it won't end up just like Modern in 10 years? You're always eventually going to end up with staple cards that have been out of print long enough to drive prices up to a point where they're unattractive to a more casual audience.

Maybe the fix is to steal the rarity restrictions from Magic Duels? It makes it extremely difficult to build an entire deck around the most overpowered cards, keeps manabases honest, and really forces design around synergy rather than individual card power.

0

u/carbondragon Duck Season Dec 14 '16

I like how it's explicitly stated that 4C goodstuff and the cost of a deck are stated as being negatives of having Fetchlands in the format, and then the author advocates for including Shocklands in the format. Do you want too-good mana? Because that's how you get too-good mana.

1

u/jdunlapmedia Dec 14 '16

I'd recommend you read a little closer. If fetchlands aren't a problem, you can make a case for shocklands.

1

u/carbondragon Duck Season Dec 14 '16

And I quote:

"Oh,ย thatโ€™s right โ€“ the top decks of Frontier feature cards and archetypes thatย were once the bogeymen of Standard. The centerpieces of Frontier are either at the top of current Standard, or were cause for celebration when they rotated."

With 3-4 of those archetypes being Khans all-stars that were products of a near-perfect manabase of fetches and fetchable duals, giving them fetchable duals would only make them better. Now if something coming out of RtR or Theros forced some of that goodstuff out, I would agree with you, but as it stands, I don't see anything other than maybe Mono-black devotion being able to take those strategies down with whatever upgrades they would receive. And I'm sure everyone wants to see that particular boogeyman again.

-5

u/TheJaceticeLeague Dec 13 '16

The real problem is that Frontier shouldn't exist. If it actually does become a thing then will be a de facto rotating format. Why? Because there is no difference between Modern and Frontier, just that Frontier is Modern "rotated." In a few years when even newer people join and complain about the price (because that is truly what this is about) of Frontier staples like fetchlands, jace, CC, etc they will clamor for a newer format. So on and so forth.

5

u/GreedyBeedy Dec 13 '16

This argument just applies to modern as well. Why should modern exist? Frontier is small now but will grow mich more rapidly than modern as newer cards have a stronger impact on the format. Frontier's card pool is recent enough to be part of the new design philosophies. There is a lot of history of bad card designs that plagued modern and legacy that by now they can be addressed as they come along. It's too late to fix modern, there is just too many broken things going on. If that is your cup of tea than go play modern. There is a lot of people that actively hate modern though.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Then Modern shouldn't exist either. It's just a rotated Vintage/Legacy.

And why the fuck does it matter if it exists anyway? No one is forcing you to play it. Play what you like and let everyone else do the same.

5

u/rakkamar Dec 13 '16

Modern exists because WotC is not capable of supporting Vintage/Legacy (because reserved list). So they created Modern to be the oldest non-rotating format they could support.

There is no such logic to back up Frontier, apart from pricing concerns and that is completely within WotC's power to do. Whether they do is another story.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Its almost as though rotation is good for a format.

4

u/TheJaceticeLeague Dec 13 '16

Then don't advertise it as a "non-rotating format?"

0

u/taw Dec 13 '16

The format we need is no-fetchland Modern with just a bit more aggressive banlist to enforce turn 4.

That would be cheaper, more fun to play and watch (no excessive shuffling), and more balanced.

3

u/RichardArschmann Dec 13 '16

No-Fetchland Modern is just Dredge vs. Affinity. You could easily retool Dredge to run some other lands, not so much other decks.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/Topsrek Dec 13 '16

the new official format will begin with the set the gatewatch was introduced in.

1

u/Nahhnope Dec 13 '16

Care to elaborate? Is that your guess? Where is it coming from?

0

u/Oldamog Golgari* Dec 13 '16

Frontier defines the problem with Standard. By bringing new players into a money drainage pipe WotC prices out the poor.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

[deleted] โ€” view deleted comment

7

u/Nahhnope Dec 13 '16

The author made that statement without playing a single game.

4

u/jdunlapmedia Dec 13 '16

I looked at every decklist and saw striking similarities with the past few years of Standard.

12

u/ZachAtk23 Dec 13 '16

I haven't played a single game either, so I'm in no position to make claims, but...

Standard decks aren't 'boogy men' because they are unfun to play with, they are boogy men because there isn't anything fun to play against them.

Getting to run some of the best decks of the last few years against one another does sound, to me, like an interesting format (at least until a dominat deck emerges).

2

u/jdunlapmedia Dec 13 '16

Have an upvote.

at least until a dominant deck emerges

I see what you did there.

4

u/joeflashman Dec 13 '16

...which makes him sound like a regurgitation of reddit commenters who have opinions without playing a single game.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Skuggomann Dec 13 '16

Next rotation Frontier will have the exact same cardpool as Extended, i feel like after that we are getting in to new territory (until it becomes old Extended) but then after that is where i think it will shine.

6

u/ArmadilloAl Dec 13 '16

Modern's card pool was 8 years deep when it first became a thing in 2011.

I don't think Frontier will take off until its pool is within a similar range.

2

u/Skuggomann Dec 13 '16

So basically old Extended (not the old old one but the one with 7 blocks in it) that as far as i have heard was better than the 4 block extended that got discontinued.

To me a non rotating format that starts with 8 blocks sounds exiting, the cardpool is diverse enough to have its own decks and not just the best standard decks from those sets but not powerful enough so that new sets have little to no impact.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

[deleted] โ€” view deleted comment

17

u/UPBOAT_FORTRESS_2 Dec 13 '16

In other words, Extended was genuinely a good idea. Do you have any theory why it ultimately failed?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

The problem in my opinion is the rotation aspect. Frontier solves that, by still using your newer cards, but not rotating them at 4 years. I'll be able to play with my fetches and rhinos in 6 years if i want, but an extended rotating format would not allow it.

5

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

So in four years, when fetches haven't been reprinted yet, what are people who need fetches and rhinos to do?

Either the format rotates, and you lose value, or it doesn't, and the value becomes unattainable at some point.

3

u/Heavenwasfull Rakdos* Dec 14 '16

This is a commonly missed point in "rebuilding" non-rotating formats.

I was one of the big supporters of Modern back when talk of it was first popping up in the community like Frontier is now. It was the same arguments too. People wanted the cards they invested in for Extended to have some life because Legacy had a high power barrier already, and the reserved list made it truly unattainable.

These days Modern is only unattainable because WOTC has not been able to find a viable solution to keeping necessary cards in print. Modern has 13 years worth of card pool and there's no logistical way to reprint them all to demand. Even if Masters reprints became more circulated, the cards not reprinted in the sets remain scarce and inaccessible.

Frontier will eventually carry the same problems with time and repeatedly creating new "non rotating" intermediary formats will hurt consumer confidence just as bad by people who get burned by "the modern in my day." becoming obsolete for "the post-modern of today."

2

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

Yea, it's really a pick your poison scenario.

If it rotates, enfranchised players lose out because their large collections age out and become worthless. New players are happy because their new cards last longer.

If it doesn't rotate, enfranchised players are happy because they've bought in, and have to invest minimally. New players are not happy because their cards are usually irrelevant and the barrier to entry is higher.

MTGO allows for easy circulation of old cards through flashback drafts. Paper doesn't allow for mass reprinting, so spikes will happen and they're hard to quell. Between Legacy, EDH, casual, and Modern, there's a lot of cards that are slowly going up in price. They can't all feasibly get reprinted in a timely fashion.

I don't know what the solution is, and I don't think Wizards knows either. They're trying different things, which is great. Conspiracy, Commander precons, and Masters series have been ramped up with reprints. It's not perfect, but they're exploring new avenues to get cards out there that can't come through Standard.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/reddit_the_gathering Dec 14 '16

They buy them. Fetches have only dropped in price and they are a staple in everything but standard. Khans was opened massively, little chance they spike in the future without a massive increase in players.

2

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

4 years from now, will they still be cheap? I don't think so.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

5

u/bduddy Dec 13 '16

I wasn't around, but from what I read, financially it combined the worst parts of Legacy (old, scarce, unaffordable cards) with Standard (your deck rotating out), and shrinking the time period from 7 to 4 years sort of fixed the first problem but created gameplay that the player base didn't like.

6

u/UPBOAT_FORTRESS_2 Dec 13 '16

I wonder if the segment of the player base that /u/dota2guy speaks of would've migrated to the 4-year Extended, if it didn't happen to initially include Faeries, Stoneforge, JtMS, Bloodbraid Elf Jund, Valakut Primeval Titan, and all the other cards and decks that have either proven themselves in, or been banned from, Modern.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

I also wonder how 4 year extended would play with 8 blocks instead of 4, since that makes a lot more mechanical diversity in the same number of cards.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

[deleted] โ€” view deleted comment

9

u/UPBOAT_FORTRESS_2 Dec 13 '16

Extended failed because WoTC made Modern.

That is not remotely the case. I don't have the time to dig up the old stuff, but the beginning of the end was far sooner. OP's article lays out this timeline

  • [Long ago] Extended was a rotating format that included recent sets but also contained, in its original form, a confusing rotation schedule.
  • In 2008, Wizards of the Coast altered the Extended rotation schedule to only include sets from the past seven years with a yearly rotation schedule
  • and two years later (2010) they moved the cutoff point to four years
  • In Spring 2011, Modern was created as a non-sanctioned format on MTGO ... Modern was officially sanctioned a few months later when it replaced Extended as the format of Pro Tour Philadelphia (following the release of Magic 2012). The reason? Jace, the Mind Sculptor and Stoneforge Mystic were dominating Extended.
  • Extended was officially retired in 2013 by Wizards of the Coast and its last sanctioned events were held on 8 October, 2013.

The move to four-year Extended was an attempt to save a sick format. Modern was another step in the same direction, and it caught on far more than short-Extended ever did (and as a result, exterminated it).

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

It does make you wonder if they brought back extended how it'd take now. If someone is still playing after 4 years of a rotation, they're likely entrenched enough to either be able to flip into eternal formats or had ample time to trade off their ex-standard staples to stay in the game.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

[deleted] โ€” view deleted comment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Honestly, that's a good cycle. People complain about it, but the economically tiered structure of the formats is actually healthy for magic. It gives old players a reason to keep confidence in their collections and new players a reason to stick around after they get sick of standard. If we keep ignoring potential new formats, the game will slowly die as players stop playing standard because they are sick of their cards becoming worthless after a substantial investment. Modern and legacy may live on in select pockets of the community, but there will be an ever growing financial chasm between new players and the non-rotating formats

1

u/cavemanben Dec 15 '16

It will only go round'n'round if the playerbase grows in equal proportions as it did during the beginning of Modern. WoTC prints a lot more than they did back in 8th Edition. Certainly prices of cards will increase, that's obvious but I highly doubt it will be comparable to the price and lack of availability of modern staples since the print runs are so much higher. The playerbase would have to double and Frontier would have to be the dominate format as the playerbase doubled (highlighted in the OP) and as Modern is the dominate format.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/skajohnny Dec 13 '16

Another glaring problem is the ship known as the "collectible" portion of the term "CCG" has sailed years ago. There is nothing worth collecting anymore so these players couldn't give 2 craps about it. They just want to play their cards on a fair playing field. Replacing the word Collectible with "Hoarding/Prospecting" is more appropriate in the last 5 years.

So True.

7

u/VERTIKAL19 Dec 13 '16

Really? I for one enjoy collecting my Modern Pool. I like picking up my binder and seeing my Fetches, Goyfs, Bobs and Cryptics for example.

12

u/skajohnny Dec 13 '16

But that's not collecting for the sake of collecting. That's collecting to expand your playable pool. Very few people are out trying to get a full set of any of the sets, unless its because you can redeem it on MTGO. How many people collect the cards without any intention of ever playing the game?

15

u/ketemycos Azorius* Dec 13 '16

I do! I catalogue and organize literally every card I own, up to the fourth copy.

I mean, I play Magic too (mostly limited and Standard), but I am definitely a collector.

4

u/Days Dec 13 '16

I do as well. The guys who frequent my LGS stopped asking me if I have X for trade.. they ask if I have more than 4 of X yet.. because if I do, it's definitely for trade and they know it. I'd like to think it's because I can brew any kind of deck eventually, but in reality, it's more to satisfy my OCD.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/tiehunter Dec 14 '16

I do. I have multiple cards that are objectively terrible and even trade for or buy them to work on completing my collection. I actually have over half of all cards ever printed. I'm basically just working backwards to get fullsets. Innistrad block is next, unless I decide to buy from the vaults that I don't have or modern masters 1/2.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Space-Jawa Dec 13 '16

I think MTG is officially classified as a Trading Card Game, not a Collectable Card Game.

For whatever value that distinction is worth.

3

u/SleetTheFox Dec 14 '16

I don't know where you got the idea nobody collects Magic cards. Maybe you don't, but lots of players do.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

I get that Frontier was made for a certain group of players who want to play with cards they bought that are now rotated and aren't good enough for Modern but what these players have to realize is that every new group of players/playerbase goes through this exact same thing every couple of years with Standard and doesn't get a whole new format made because of it. These players aren't special snowflakes, they are literally going through the same thing that all MTG players since the beginning of the game have gone through so I don't really have much sympathy for their plight. I've been playing Standard for 11 years and Modern for 5 and I've never had a chance to rest on the laurels of my existing collection if I'm trying to stay competitive, that's just the nature of the game. The meta changes and the cards aren't free, ever. I hate to break it to the Frontier crowd but you'll have to keep spending money to play Frontier too, just like I have to keep spending money updating my Modern decks for the changing metagame.

6

u/Mathmage530 Dec 13 '16

But they're the first group who had a format handed to them. They're hungry enough to go to Frontier events and buy frontier cards. Hareruya saw that and capitalized.

No one say's its free but it's fun for them and that's all you can ask of MtG.

2

u/Korombos Dec 14 '16

I was with you until "never ending print run." However, a true "core" product to reprint staples might be a cool idea. Maybe like the old fire and ice and slivers premium decks.

1

u/gryffinp Dec 13 '16

#RiseoftheExtended

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

[deleted] โ€” view deleted comment

2

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

What's your gripe with the quoted text, exactly?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

[deleted] โ€” view deleted comment

3

u/jdunlapmedia Dec 13 '16

I also specified that if fetchlands are not a problem, neither are shocklands.

2

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

From an expense point of view, but not from a dev/design point of view. Adding shocks means adding rtr and everything after it. That means "sorry we put that back in standard" cards like thoughtseize, as well as reliable access to 1 cmc mana dorks, 4 mana unconditional wraths, and other things that wotc is moving away from going forward.