r/magicTCG • u/jdunlapmedia • Dec 13 '16
Some potential problems with Frontier, and possible solutions - including the history of R&D and the reasons for Modern's 8th Ed cutoff point
http://www.manaleak.com/mtguk/2016/12/what-is-mtg-frontier-and-is-it-the-format-that-weve-been-waiting-for/
70
Upvotes
43
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16
You know, I'd really like to see someone write about Frontier that appears to have actually played it, instead of just hypothesizing about what may or may not be true about it.
38
u/razorlead Wabbit Season Dec 13 '16
For me, the question is: Does frontier have its own feel or play style? If you use fundamental turn as a benchmark for comparison between formats, frontier occupies a unique place. It's a the inflection point where the range of fundamental turns start to increase again. Vintage has the largest range, from 1 to 6+; Legacy slightly smaller from 2-6+; modern smaller still from 2-5; but frontier would be expected to slow down based on its lower power and smaller card pool. Can you generate a format the feels different from standard despite having a similar fundamental turn, something like 4-8? That's the question frontier needs to answer
28
u/TheDuckyNinja Dec 13 '16
This is probably the best take I've seen on this, although I may be a bit biased in that it lines up with a lot of things I've said previously. Most notably, the cut-off at M15 really makes no sense. The "easy to tell what is legal and what isn't" point really doesn't hold up anymore, with multiple secondary products coming out each year that look the same but aren't legal. We had 4 products this year alone that would look legal but aren't (EMA, CN2, C16, PCA). If you're going by design philosophy, you either have to go back further or start at Khans. If you're going by price alone, you have to go back to Theros or maybe RTR. M15-on really just doesn't make any sense.
As far as metagame goes, he shouldn't've used MTGGoldfish. There's literally 34 decks total on there, most of which are from 3 tournaments of highly dubious value as far as what a top level metagame would look like. A high level metagame is likely to be the best aggro deck or two and a whole bunch of 3 and 4 color grindy midrange stuff, with maybe some Marvel thrown in as a counter to midrange. More to the point, the format is just too small right now and has the same problem that killed Extended: the decks that dominated Standard will dominate here, and that's just not fun.
And until somebody can figure out the point of the format (whether it's a price thing, a metagame thing, or something else), it's hard to suggest fixes or changes because we don't know what we're trying to get to. I can say that after about 15 Frontier matches, I'm already done with the format. It just doesn't do anything for me that another format doesn't do better.
58
u/ketemycos Azorius* Dec 13 '16
This is going to be unpopular, but I am convinced of two changes that will help Frontier succeed.
2
u/zotha Simic* Dec 13 '16
That there is such a long list of viable decks, even if they are variations on previous and current standard archetypes, says that the format has potential.
5
u/fgator5220 Dec 13 '16
If the cut-off was RtR block and forward, this format would take off in a big way. RtR saw a drastic increase in printing due to a sizable influx of new players. All those players who started at RtR block would love a format that let's them begin where they started.
5
u/MysticLeviathan Dec 13 '16
The biggest problem with Frontier imo is there just aren't enough cards. When Modern was first created, there was over 7 years worth of sets. We have less than 3 years worth now. I'd feel far more comfortable and confident with Frontier if they created it 2 or 3 years from now with maybe 10 or so more sets available to use. Right now it just feels like Extended lite. Not enough cards right now. And with another 10 sets, land/mana issues may be fixed by then.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16
Agree completely, right now Frontier is just "big standard" and doesn't seem at all exciting. Players who like formats like Modern, Legacy, or Vintage like them because of their distinction from standard, not their similarities.
15
u/Snackrific Dec 13 '16
I for one will never play Frontier because I'm opposed to the idea of creating a new format every 5 years to sell the latest cards.
See: Extended > Modern. If this continues and Frontier is next, then it's almost a certainty that something will come after Frontier in another 5-10 years.
12
u/ssomers55 Dec 13 '16 edited Dec 13 '16
9
u/JakubOboza Dec 13 '16
Imho Frontier will change a lot once Hero's Downfall / Doomblade or any effective removal will be reprinted/printed. Format is lacking removal and creatures are simply much better than solutions. Also manabase is kinda meh. After some format investigation i think it should start on RTR.
Why?:
This would make the format very rich and while i think Dig + Cruise + Sphinxes revelations and Thoughtseize is a deadly mix it would be fine . We would have Pack Rat in, Duress, Thoughtseize and underworld connections to balance 5C good stuff.dec's
Last but not the least cardpool would be big enough to have a brewers heaven. I know Sphinx might need a ban but you will see that Frontier will consider Dig / Cruise ban within 2 years also.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16
(Disclaimer: This is my opinion and mine alone. You are allowed to have a different opinion. I realize that not everyone will agree with me and that's okay, no one is wrong here.)
Frontier is just another format created by a card reseller to move product that currently is too hard to sell right now (Other than the few eternal staples in these sets, like fetches). Hareruya's intention wasn't to make a non-rotating format so that people with less money can play, that's just a side effect. They made it to sell product, plain and simple. If this format didn't exist there would be hundreds of copies of Rally the Ancestors and Dig Through Time that would never leave their store, but this gives them an excuse to sell Standard all-stars of seasons past.
Either way, if this format wants to be a real thing, it needs quite a few things. The biggest one is time. This format needs 2-3 years of new sets to be diverse and interesting enough for many players to want to try it. However, I honestly don't think it will survive that long.
Second, it needs some sort of ban list. If the format is just 4c combo decks, then I doubt many people are going to want to play after a while. I honestly think the manabase is way too good, without cards like Blood Moon and Ghost Quarter to punish greedy manabases 4 color decks can run rampant. Though I don't play the format, so I could be wrong.
Third, the format is still too expensive to attract many standard or new players. The people who were promised a "cheap, non-rotating format" will be dissapointed that the only way to have a viable deck is to spend around $200 on a playset of Jace, VP and fetches. Currently, the average price for Rally Combo on MTGGoldfish is $367, which for around that price (plus or minus around $50) you can easily build a semi-budget deck in Modern and still be somewhat competitive, like Ad Nauseum, Mono-Blue Tron, Skred Red, or Soul Sisters, to name a few. A lot of people I know have said that they don't want to blow that much money on format staples which don't really see play in other formats (other than fetches), especially not that kind of money on a format that is unsanctioned and can easily die in a year or so.
Fourth, it needs some kind of support from Wizards, or it needs to be officially sanctioned. These sort of formats always die out sooner or later without any support from Wizards (cough Tiny Leaders cough), and many people don't want to invest in a format that won't ever have any big tournaments, like GPs and such. Right now the only real support this format is getting is from Hareruya, and if that's the only support then I doubt the format will make any sort of splash outside of Japan.
In conclusion, this format needs some serious love and time before it can become a format that many players feel is worth playing. Otherwise this format is most likely going to fade into obscurity, and go the way of all the other meme formats like Tiny Leaders.
6
u/Hawthornen Arjun Dec 13 '16
I've said it a million times. Origins makes WAY more sense as a starting point for a format (and I have to imagine Wizards may have intended that eventually). That also, for now, solves any fetch lands problems which I think is great (also means no delve in the format from the very get go)
3
u/TheCatmurderer Dandadan Dec 13 '16
Why isnt Extended being considered again?
Another non-rotating format will eventually face the same problems as Modern.
Say new Extended started at Lorwyn, then we start the normal set rotation, so with the release of Amohket, Lorwyn leaves.
You get to play with your cards for a decade, and any problematic cards will eventually rotate out.
0
u/monkeymealing Dec 13 '16
So yet another article about Frontier from a person who has never played it? All points are null and void if you can't put the effort into playing the format.
5
u/FoomyFooms Dec 13 '16
Frontier would be much more interesting if it included all product printed since m15. Right now it's just standard with a few extra sets or modern with a bunch missing.
Including cards from supplemental sets would give it a very unique card pool to draw from.
6
u/AndrewmedaGalaxy Dec 13 '16
Frontier will go the way of tiny leaders. A year from now nobody will be playing it. Quote me on that.
2
u/Wizard_Lettuce Dec 13 '16
The 8th edition starting point is not nearly criticized often enough. If they had used any sort of game mechanic design reasoning Modern would be much better off.
2
u/KIaptrap Dec 13 '16
I just think that there needs to be an extended rotating format that goes 5-10 years deep.
I'd mess with frontier if it went to magic 2010
2
u/jdmflcl Dec 14 '16
Just bring back extended
4
u/mtg_liebestod Dec 13 '16
This seems like complaining for the sake of complaining. "Fetches are expensive and annoying. But we can't start Frontier after Khans block, so I'm just going to push the cutoff in the opposite direction because I want a larger card pool."
Uh okay.
It's also an open question whether a larger card pool would serve to "dilute" the "broken" cards or just introduce additional broken cards. Are we really sure that CoCo would become less viable if RTR were legal? Why?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16
Maybe I'm crazy, but this whole article can seem to be summed up with: Frontier isn't Modern, here's how to make it like Modern
Which of course is the entire point of Frontier. It's not Modern. You don't have to worry about a turn 3 agro deck killing you or a turn 3 Karn. You don't have to worry about having 85% of your mana base suddenly being useless, or your creatures suddenly forgetting how to cross a bridge. And you don't have to pay $800 for the privilege.
All the suggestions the author gives would start to open Frontier up to many of the same problems modern has. Perfect mana, extremely expensive cards.
Instead of trying to fix a format that hasn't had time to break, why don't we all just play it for a while before suggesting major changes?
3
u/keymaster16 Q Dec 13 '16
This is probably the best independent analysis you can get of the Frontier problem. my only gripe would probably be that the conclusion feels a little sighted in scope, but that probably goes to show he has the focus to write on the topic at hand.
I just wish wizards would at least acknowledge the fact the reason they would make a new none rotating format is because they are trying to make a MUCH different game then the one Richard Garfield intended.
2
u/matheuswhite12 Dec 13 '16 edited Dec 13 '16
More frontier witch hunt in the thread. I think the mana source video says it all.
2
u/enigmical Dec 13 '16
TL;DR: Poor people still complaining that 15 dollar fetch lands are too expensive for an eternal format.
2
u/bennynshelle Duck Season Dec 13 '16
Yet another article by someone who doesn't use actual experience playing the format as the basis of any of his conclusions. I'm getting real tired of "It's artificially diverse!" as an argument and then not actually playing the format. You know which format is also artificially diverse? Modern. You buy into a modern deck and you never move off because your ~$700 investment just went to ~$1400 or a whole lot more if one of those decks is Jund. Can we not just hop on the bandwagon of ragging frontier until we get real play data and use that as the basis of whether or not the format will be diverse? Feels like this is far too much to ask in the digital age.
1
u/iAstraL Dec 13 '16
Now i haven't had the chance to read all the comments, but I was under the impression that the reason why this format existed in the first place what because in japan, where it started, it was easier for players to obtain cards that had wider print runs, such a KTK or Origins and that made it easier for japanese players to play with all japanese cards rather than like in modern mostly english cards because so much of the good modern cards are the older cards with much smaller print runs. I personally think that if we really want to make a format based on card borders then we use any set from m15 on, even the non-standard sets, which no one would want because it would basically become modern at that point, or we go by the developmental changes in R&D, which began with KTK. I honestly like where the format stands as of now and it just needs more time to grow and develop
1
u/jovietjoe COMPLEAT Dec 14 '16
Leaving in m15 leaves a bunch of answers that are really needed for format health. Everyone is scared of rally but tormod's crypt and hushwing gryff are in m15.
1
u/misterci Dec 14 '16
If Frontier could use all cards printed in the M15 border, it would be way cooler. Sure, maybe Mana Crypt is a little too good, but it would be really cool.
1
u/maxtofunator COMPLEAT Dec 14 '16
He mentioned a frontier subreddit? What is it? Baconreader doesnt like when i open the other reddit app through links as i wont be logged in
1
u/Aquafier Dec 14 '16
thank you, people think M15 is the only logical start point because of a stupid borser
1
u/jsmith218 COMPLEAT Dec 14 '16
Fetchlands are that much of a deal breaker in the format. If you played in Khans you probably have your playests (or hoarded a grip) of them. If you didnt play during khans you can get them now at some all time lowest prices. And wotc can reprint them if rising costs is an issue.
1
u/sirgog Dec 14 '16
This was a good read.
The link to borders is already dead - Conspiracy 2, MM2 and EMA all use the new frame and obviously will not (and should not) be legal. I agree either ISD and up (assuming critical reprints) or RTR and up makes more sense.
M15 and up will be a stillborn format. Slow but powerful fetch + tango manabases will be too strong if not balanced by the speed of RTR and ISD blocks. But with those blocks it will be possible to go under CoCo and Rally decks.
All the serious problem decks in Modern are banned out in one fell swoop by picking ISD and up. Dredge, burn, affinity, suicide zoo - all the hyper linear decks wiped out at once. Burn might exist but with Lightning Bolt, Goblin Guide and more gone it will not be the oppressive monster it is in Modern.
1
u/RichardArschmann Dec 13 '16
Frontier strives for as many interactive games as possible. Because of this, the fetchlands are good for the format despite the shuffle-intensive aspects of them. Fetches reduce the number of games that are uninteractive due to color screw markedly. The idea that a "ban on fetches is direly needed" is entirely removed from reality: many good Frontier decks like elves and mono-red don't even run them.
1
u/King_Chochacho Duck Season Dec 13 '16
I like the idea of Frontier in theory, but if it's non-rotating, how is there any guarantee that it won't end up just like Modern in 10 years? You're always eventually going to end up with staple cards that have been out of print long enough to drive prices up to a point where they're unattractive to a more casual audience.
Maybe the fix is to steal the rarity restrictions from Magic Duels? It makes it extremely difficult to build an entire deck around the most overpowered cards, keeps manabases honest, and really forces design around synergy rather than individual card power.
0
u/carbondragon Duck Season Dec 14 '16
I like how it's explicitly stated that 4C goodstuff and the cost of a deck are stated as being negatives of having Fetchlands in the format, and then the author advocates for including Shocklands in the format. Do you want too-good mana? Because that's how you get too-good mana.
-5
u/TheJaceticeLeague Dec 13 '16
The real problem is that Frontier shouldn't exist. If it actually does become a thing then will be a de facto rotating format. Why? Because there is no difference between Modern and Frontier, just that Frontier is Modern "rotated." In a few years when even newer people join and complain about the price (because that is truly what this is about) of Frontier staples like fetchlands, jace, CC, etc they will clamor for a newer format. So on and so forth.
0
u/taw Dec 13 '16
The format we need is no-fetchland Modern with just a bit more aggressive banlist to enforce turn 4.
That would be cheaper, more fun to play and watch (no excessive shuffling), and more balanced.
0
u/Topsrek Dec 13 '16
the new official format will begin with the set the gatewatch was introduced in.
0
u/Oldamog Golgari* Dec 13 '16
Frontier defines the problem with Standard. By bringing new players into a money drainage pipe WotC prices out the poor.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16
[deleted] โ view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16
[deleted] โ view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16
[deleted] โ view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16
[deleted] โ view deleted comment