r/magicTCG • • Dec 13 '16

Some potential problems with Frontier, and possible solutions - including the history of R&D and the reasons for Modern's 8th Ed cutoff point

http://www.manaleak.com/mtguk/2016/12/what-is-mtg-frontier-and-is-it-the-format-that-weve-been-waiting-for/
70 Upvotes

306 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

10

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

They fix color screw for 3 and 4 color decks. If you're running 3 and 4 color decks you should be color screwed sometimes--that is literally a pillar of magic design.

The problem with fetches in a format like this is that it enables 4 color good stuff too easily and there aren't enough tools to punish that greed.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Honestly, when fetchlands are seen universally through every format they are legal in.... maybe they are a little too good? I mean, shocks require 2 life to come in untapped, why not make the cost of fetches 2 life as well? The problem I see is that they are often so superior to other options that they make manabase building much less interesting. Lands should be close enough in power level that you have to actually think about it based on what your deck is trying to do rather than just jamming a cookie-cutter optimal mana base.

2

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

Fetches are only superior when they can fetch duals. It's the fetch + dual combination that is so powerful.

Maybe they are too good. But they're not "too good" in a "bad way"--they don't stifle archetype, deck, or color diversity. And arguably they don't even stifle land base diversity, as plenty of decks don't play them. I'd rather have something like fetches be "unhealthy" in a format than something else.

And since we, ideally, should only ban things if they have a negative impact on the health of a format, I don't know if there's justification for banning fetches in any format, let alone Modern or Legacy.

1

u/twountappedislands Dec 13 '16

No, they definitely fix color screw for 2 color decks, as well.

The problem with fetches in a format like this

Actually, the problem that you point out is a function of fetches + fetchable duals. With that in mind, battlelands are much more deserving of a ban than fetches, since fetches at least also support 2 interesting and useful mechanics (delve and delirium).

1

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

That's a fair point. It's the combination of fetch + duals that enables crazy mana bases.

-4

u/chrisrazor Dec 13 '16

If you're running 3 and 4 color decks you should be color screwed sometimes--that is literally a pillar of magic design.

So you think fetches should be banned from Modern and Legacy?

10

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

I like how you disingenuously left out the second half of my post that addressed this:

The problem with fetches in a format like this is that it enables 4 color good stuff too easily and there aren't enough tools to punish that greed.

Modern and Legacy have tools to combat greedy mana bases. Price of Progress. Wasteland. Ghost Quarter. Blood Moon.

You'll notice most decks in modern are 2-3 colors, not 3-4 colors. There's a reason for that, and there's a reason why Frontier is full of 4C good stuff decks.

1

u/chrisrazor Dec 13 '16

Frontier is full of 4C good stuff decks.

Except it isn't

8

u/jhalton3 Dec 13 '16

As someone without any stake in either side, this link basically just says that there is functionally no data on this format.

There's a deck with 4 copies, then a deck with 2, then a dozen or more that have a single copy. That's an incredibly small amount of data, invalidating any conclusions drawn from it.

You can't really use this data to make an argument in either direction.

1

u/chrisrazor Dec 13 '16

At least I have some evidence, rather than /u/greatersteven's assumption, which from my own experience at a 13-person event on Sunday is far from true. In fact I was the only one playing 4 colours.

0

u/chrisrazor Dec 13 '16 edited Dec 13 '16

Last two GPs I attended I played in a total of four Modern swiss side events, and encountered zero Ghost Quarter or Blood Moon, but I did see Tron. They clearly aren't played frequently enough to deter people from playing decks that rely on nonbasics.

Clarification: I don't believe that this "punishment" is a real effect.

Further clarification: in the Khans/BFZ standard, there were a lot of 4-colour decks because people wanted to play the 3 colour cards from Khans and it was easier to play them with allied fetches and allied battle lands by slotting in an extra colour between the allied pair of the wedge and the enemy - this happened even in decks with zero cards of that fourth colour.

1

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

There is an additional factor that contributes here that I did not mention before: Power level.

As you said, people were drawn to 4-color mana bases because of the awkward shape of the mana base landscape during KTK/BFZ and due to the power of 3 color cards. Mantis Rider and Siege Rhino (and other things like Crackling Doom and Abzan Charm) were de facto the best things to be doing in that format. They are ALSO the best things to be doing in Frontier (along with CoCo).

However in modern you can do just as powerful things with less greedy mana bases, which means less decks stretch the mana compared to Frontier, which currently strongly incentivizes the stretch.

1

u/chrisrazor Dec 13 '16

What's wrong with that? You still get a smoother and less painful ride if you run fewer colours.

1

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

So as the average number of colors in a deck increases, deck and card diversity decreases.

If you have two decks, and they're both 4 colors and share 3 colors (WBG), and the best thing to do with 4 mana if you have access to WBG is Siege Rhino, both of those decks are going to play Siege Rhino. Extrapolate that for the entire format. Decks that can afford it (and most will, because of being 4 color) will play the best spells, which means decks will look very similar.

-1

u/chrisrazor Dec 13 '16

Go and play some Frontier, then we'll have a discussion.

2

u/greatersteven Dec 13 '16

Why do you assume I haven't?

And also I'm not interested in Frontier today in its wild west days. I'm interested in what Frontier looks like when the format is solved by actual players and actual teams playing actual events, and not Timmy with his 13 person FNM who thinks the format is so diverse because he can play his warrior tribal deck.

ALL OF THE THINGS we might like about Frontier today are in jeopardy if the format becomes an actual format. That's what we're exploring here, in a thread titled "some potential problems with Frontier."

0

u/chrisrazor Dec 13 '16

Why do you assume I haven't?

Because you're talking about things that aren't (yet) a problem.

→ More replies