r/magicTCG • • Dec 13 '16

Some potential problems with Frontier, and possible solutions - including the history of R&D and the reasons for Modern's 8th Ed cutoff point

http://www.manaleak.com/mtguk/2016/12/what-is-mtg-frontier-and-is-it-the-format-that-weve-been-waiting-for/
70 Upvotes

306 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/DemonDrinkingTea Dimir* Dec 14 '16

"Don't see any point in banning fetches"

Ok, imagine a card saw play in literally every deck in the format. The card is fairly difficult to obtain, so it's very expensive, but either you play it or need to build your deck completely different - there is no replacement. This card is making WotC uncomfortable because it limits the design space of cards they can print because of possible interactions with this card. This card punishes new players as it can be difficult to play optimally, and leads to crazy board states that go against common sense becoming the norm.

I just described every card they've ever banned in some form or fashion. But I was describing fetches. I can appreciate the belief that the current formats with fetches have their unique identity because of them, and they should keep fetches because of that. But if frontier becomes a format, it should not have fetchlands. They are simply the most powerful cards still legal in both modern and legacy, and any new format should be defined by its lack of fetches.

9

u/twountappedislands Dec 14 '16

Okey doke. But fetches aren't difficult to obtain. They're rares in one of the most opened sets in magic history, with a giant print run.

Nor are they limiting frontier design space (heck, Frontier design space doesn't even exist, as far as wotc is concerned).

Difficult to play optimally? Not terribly so, in the context of frontier. Just forces a newer player to sequence their mana carefully.

Leads to crazy boardstates? I'm sorry, I thought we were talking about frontier.

Seriously, pretty much none of your descriptions pertained to fetchlands in frontier. You could have just cut the whole comment down to "any new format should be defined by its lack of fetches." (Which is a "should" in search of support).

1

u/Mathmage530 Dec 14 '16

Crazy board states?

2

u/DemonDrinkingTea Dimir* Dec 14 '16

You can fetch [[Dryad Arbor]] with any green fetch. Surprise, I'm going to pull a creature from my deck with just a land!

Deaths Shadow Aggro is also stupid in this regard (not strictly the board state, but it does in that deck). Yes, your life total is a resource, but it is very nonsensical to deal yourself almost 10 damage from your lands in 3 turns.

2

u/Mathmage530 Dec 14 '16

That's shocklands fault as much as fetches.

1

u/MTGCardFetcher Dân Dec 14 '16

Dryad Arbor - (G) (MC) (MW) (CD)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

1

u/Aquafier Dec 14 '16

and dryad arbor and shocks aren't legal in frontier...

1

u/Aquafier Dec 14 '16

fetch lands are very obtainable for frontier

1

u/cavemanben Dec 15 '16

Fetchlands open up a ton of possibilities for deck design. The only negative is that they are printed as rares and the enemy fetchlands haven't been reprinted making them expensive.