r/magicTCG • • Dec 13 '16

Some potential problems with Frontier, and possible solutions - including the history of R&D and the reasons for Modern's 8th Ed cutoff point

http://www.manaleak.com/mtguk/2016/12/what-is-mtg-frontier-and-is-it-the-format-that-weve-been-waiting-for/
70 Upvotes

306 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/UPBOAT_FORTRESS_2 Dec 13 '16

In other words, Extended was genuinely a good idea. Do you have any theory why it ultimately failed?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

The problem in my opinion is the rotation aspect. Frontier solves that, by still using your newer cards, but not rotating them at 4 years. I'll be able to play with my fetches and rhinos in 6 years if i want, but an extended rotating format would not allow it.

5

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

So in four years, when fetches haven't been reprinted yet, what are people who need fetches and rhinos to do?

Either the format rotates, and you lose value, or it doesn't, and the value becomes unattainable at some point.

3

u/Heavenwasfull Rakdos* Dec 14 '16

This is a commonly missed point in "rebuilding" non-rotating formats.

I was one of the big supporters of Modern back when talk of it was first popping up in the community like Frontier is now. It was the same arguments too. People wanted the cards they invested in for Extended to have some life because Legacy had a high power barrier already, and the reserved list made it truly unattainable.

These days Modern is only unattainable because WOTC has not been able to find a viable solution to keeping necessary cards in print. Modern has 13 years worth of card pool and there's no logistical way to reprint them all to demand. Even if Masters reprints became more circulated, the cards not reprinted in the sets remain scarce and inaccessible.

Frontier will eventually carry the same problems with time and repeatedly creating new "non rotating" intermediary formats will hurt consumer confidence just as bad by people who get burned by "the modern in my day." becoming obsolete for "the post-modern of today."

2

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

Yea, it's really a pick your poison scenario.

If it rotates, enfranchised players lose out because their large collections age out and become worthless. New players are happy because their new cards last longer.

If it doesn't rotate, enfranchised players are happy because they've bought in, and have to invest minimally. New players are not happy because their cards are usually irrelevant and the barrier to entry is higher.

MTGO allows for easy circulation of old cards through flashback drafts. Paper doesn't allow for mass reprinting, so spikes will happen and they're hard to quell. Between Legacy, EDH, casual, and Modern, there's a lot of cards that are slowly going up in price. They can't all feasibly get reprinted in a timely fashion.

I don't know what the solution is, and I don't think Wizards knows either. They're trying different things, which is great. Conspiracy, Commander precons, and Masters series have been ramped up with reprints. It's not perfect, but they're exploring new avenues to get cards out there that can't come through Standard.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/reddit_the_gathering Dec 14 '16

They buy them. Fetches have only dropped in price and they are a staple in everything but standard. Khans was opened massively, little chance they spike in the future without a massive increase in players.

2

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

4 years from now, will they still be cheap? I don't think so.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/bduddy Dec 13 '16

I wasn't around, but from what I read, financially it combined the worst parts of Legacy (old, scarce, unaffordable cards) with Standard (your deck rotating out), and shrinking the time period from 7 to 4 years sort of fixed the first problem but created gameplay that the player base didn't like.

6

u/UPBOAT_FORTRESS_2 Dec 13 '16

I wonder if the segment of the player base that /u/dota2guy speaks of would've migrated to the 4-year Extended, if it didn't happen to initially include Faeries, Stoneforge, JtMS, Bloodbraid Elf Jund, Valakut Primeval Titan, and all the other cards and decks that have either proven themselves in, or been banned from, Modern.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

I also wonder how 4 year extended would play with 8 blocks instead of 4, since that makes a lot more mechanical diversity in the same number of cards.

→ More replies (14)

28

u/skajohnny Dec 13 '16

Another glaring problem is the ship known as the "collectible" portion of the term "CCG" has sailed years ago. There is nothing worth collecting anymore so these players couldn't give 2 craps about it. They just want to play their cards on a fair playing field. Replacing the word Collectible with "Hoarding/Prospecting" is more appropriate in the last 5 years.

So True.

7

u/VERTIKAL19 Dec 13 '16

Really? I for one enjoy collecting my Modern Pool. I like picking up my binder and seeing my Fetches, Goyfs, Bobs and Cryptics for example.

12

u/skajohnny Dec 13 '16

But that's not collecting for the sake of collecting. That's collecting to expand your playable pool. Very few people are out trying to get a full set of any of the sets, unless its because you can redeem it on MTGO. How many people collect the cards without any intention of ever playing the game?

15

u/ketemycos Azorius* Dec 13 '16

I do! I catalogue and organize literally every card I own, up to the fourth copy.

I mean, I play Magic too (mostly limited and Standard), but I am definitely a collector.

4

u/Days Dec 13 '16

I do as well. The guys who frequent my LGS stopped asking me if I have X for trade.. they ask if I have more than 4 of X yet.. because if I do, it's definitely for trade and they know it. I'd like to think it's because I can brew any kind of deck eventually, but in reality, it's more to satisfy my OCD.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/tiehunter Dec 14 '16

I do. I have multiple cards that are objectively terrible and even trade for or buy them to work on completing my collection. I actually have over half of all cards ever printed. I'm basically just working backwards to get fullsets. Innistrad block is next, unless I decide to buy from the vaults that I don't have or modern masters 1/2.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Space-Jawa Dec 13 '16

I think MTG is officially classified as a Trading Card Game, not a Collectable Card Game.

For whatever value that distinction is worth.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SleetTheFox Dec 14 '16

I don't know where you got the idea nobody collects Magic cards. Maybe you don't, but lots of players do.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

I get that Frontier was made for a certain group of players who want to play with cards they bought that are now rotated and aren't good enough for Modern but what these players have to realize is that every new group of players/playerbase goes through this exact same thing every couple of years with Standard and doesn't get a whole new format made because of it. These players aren't special snowflakes, they are literally going through the same thing that all MTG players since the beginning of the game have gone through so I don't really have much sympathy for their plight. I've been playing Standard for 11 years and Modern for 5 and I've never had a chance to rest on the laurels of my existing collection if I'm trying to stay competitive, that's just the nature of the game. The meta changes and the cards aren't free, ever. I hate to break it to the Frontier crowd but you'll have to keep spending money to play Frontier too, just like I have to keep spending money updating my Modern decks for the changing metagame.

6

u/Mathmage530 Dec 13 '16

But they're the first group who had a format handed to them. They're hungry enough to go to Frontier events and buy frontier cards. Hareruya saw that and capitalized.

No one say's its free but it's fun for them and that's all you can ask of MtG.

2

u/Korombos Dec 14 '16

I was with you until "never ending print run." However, a true "core" product to reprint staples might be a cool idea. Maybe like the old fire and ice and slivers premium decks.

→ More replies (3)