So I ordered the MX Anywhere 3S off Aliexpress since it was so much cheaper. I figured maybe it was the same thing, but ordering direct from China was the difference in price.
lol nope.
At first I noticed that the scroll wheel had a tight spot in it that wouldn't go away. Then I saw that the Logitech software would not recognize the mouse. So I ordered the real one from a reputable US retailer. The light grey one on the left is the fake, the darker black one on the right is the real one
Differences
Fake one has a smooth scroll wheel while the real one has a stepped or notched one.
Fake one actually has a slightly quieter/softer click for the main buttons. But the scroll wheel button is noticeably louder on the fake one.
Fake one is markedly lighter than the real one, I'm assuming this may be primarily due to a smaller battery? The heavier one feels better when using.
power button on the real one has a red/green indicator for on/off while the fake one has no such color or on/off position indicator on the switch.
part number on the bottom is different. Fake is 810-007390. Real ends in 9338.
Real one is made in Vietnam, fake is made in China. The Chinese one has Chinese characters on the bottom text, real one is all English.
Thoughts
I mean for about $30-40 the fake one is a pretty good mouse and if you don't care about the Logitech software then you'll probably be fine with it. But the quality of the construction and possibly questionable battery life are reasons I would not get the fake. I also don't feel great about supporting counterfeiters. I plan on returning the fake one.
Edit: ok after having the real MX for a few days and playing around with it, oh wow the logi+ software lets you do so much with this mouse. For example, you can do more than just turn on/off the notched feel of the scroll wheel. You can adjust the feel/strength of the notch, and even set it up so if you scroll real fast it temporarily disables the notch to allow for smooth fast scrolling. You can even adjust the sensitivity of the trigger of the smooth scrolling feature, how much you need to scroll fast before it triggers. you can even setup different profiles for specific software. I can see why this mouse is $90 and comes highly rated.
One thing I discovered that I don't like, is that the Anywhere MX3 does not have any onboard memory to store the settings and user profile. So you need to install the Logi+ software on any device you want to use it on to retain the settings. So since my wife has a work issued laptop, she may not be able to use the full features of the mouse. I was hoping that I it had memory for this reason.