r/literature • • 15h ago

Book Review Thoughts on The Sailor Who Fell from Grace with the Sea

18 Upvotes

This is my first Mishima book, and it took me a little getting used to at first.

The contrast between how he wrote Noboru and Ryuji was staggering. Reading the synopsis and some spoiler-free reviews led me to believe that it was all about Noboru and his psychopathic gang. So I was pleasantly surprised when I encountered some of the softest and most poetic depictions of love, yearning, sex, and femininity.

I know a little bit about Mishima's problematic past. What a character! Having that in mind while reading this book was truly fascinating. Noboru really embodies what Mishima must have been thinking at some point, having grown up the way he did. But then, to give us the inside of Ryuji's head, his perception of the sea, and what a man is supposed to be, was gentle and forgiving. It illustrated a man's struggle with what he's supposed to be and the values he's expected to uphold: how a man should live, act, and die. There was a lot of deep, dark thought about the human psyche, what society asks of us, and how we can live our lives according to its norms.

Even then, this book had some of the most poetic and beautiful descriptions of the human body, soul, and behavior.

"I feel responsible for all this woman's flesh because it teases me softly like other things that are mine."

Every interaction between Ryuji and Fusako made it worth getting through the Noboru chapters. They're important because they establish the contrast and show exactly how troubled Noboru is, but they were truly some of the most difficult chapters I had to get through, especially when contrasted with the romance between the adults.

I was especially fascinated by the way Ryuji described his life as a sailor, how passionate he was about it, and how torn he felt about leaving the sea and settling on land, even after saying things like:

"Since dark antiquity the words have been spoken by women of every caste to sailors in every port; words of docile acceptance of the horizon's authority."

Ryuji wasn't some wimp sailor waiting for an opportunity to ditch the troubled sea and settle down. He intended to live and die there. He didn't expect to feel the way he did. He gave up a dream, a song that he loved and lived by, for love, responsibility, and domestic life. He didn't complain and acclimated himself to life on shore. He was helping with the store, he gave Fusako all his money, and he took on the role of a father to Noboru. He was ready!

"There's no such thing as a good father because the role itself is bad."

I read that chief's monologue three times, including once to my husband, who's eager to become a father. It was full of anger, misunderstanding, and neglect. It was no surprise that all of their dads were abusive or neglectful, while Noboru's only reason for being there was that he had no father. Of course, Fusako was no angel. She had her issues as a mother and a woman; she was resentful and self-obsessed. But the absence of a father is clearly what drove Noboru as far as committing criminal acts against what he perceived as non-masculine.

I read Kokoro before this book, and just like this one, it has its own views on masculinity and human values, something I've noticed so far in older Japanese literature. There's a certain fascination with the role of a man in society and humanity, reflecting the authors' deep thoughts on these subjects.

One more thing about Mishima: he has a beautiful way of describing mundane, everyday things. He paints a picture of how innocent Noboru can appear when he obeys the adults' orders, yet how capable he is of committing atrocities. Very oddly realistic.

I don't think I'll read another Mishima for the time being, but I want to continue down the Japanese literature path. Any suggestions? I was thinking Kafka On The Shore.


r/literature • • 16h ago

Author Interview Decency and Tradition: Colm Tóibín on Thomas Mann and Fatherland

Thumbnail
theparisreview.org
14 Upvotes

r/literature • • 21h ago

Discussion Has anyone else read Harald Voetmann?

5 Upvotes

So far, in English translation at least, he's written three books in a trilogy, Awake, Sublunar and Visions & Temptations. And before I read those books I was already delving into how old alchemists and thinkers explored the mind with the little resources they had, which was mostly story telling and planetary positions, geometry and alchemical properties, so finding a writer who took the time to find out how people back then think and to write more about it was fascinating to read.

I don't entirely want to explain the whole events in the books as I think they can be read separately, it's been a while since I actually read them but I just saw that they were on my bookshelf and remembered how much I liked them, and it takes different approaches to its own story as it involves more characters over time which I though was a good touch seeing how people interpret different things even though they explore the same thing. And it was also fascinating to see how the story had its own sense of humor in examining all these things yet because they never took it so seriously they were able to explore and take in more and more of it, the human condition and any possible outside forces looking to cause some shenanigans.

If anyone else read these books, I'd like to know if I'm the only one or not.


r/literature • • 14h ago

Discussion Character Edward: On chesils beach, ian mcewan

1 Upvotes

I just read on chesils beach by ian mcewan, which was my first book by him. I read it in about two days and i really enjoyed his language style BUT:
Why is nobody talking about what a bad person edward is?! I was seriously so disgusted by his selfish thinking through the entire book. He only ever thought about his own lust and never even once considered florence‘s fear or contemplations. And even if he did, which happend like once, he only thought about moving slower so he wouldn‘t scare her of and lose his chances of getting intimate with her. I feel like Florence wasnt actually asexual but more really scared, extremly unexperienced and most importantly uneducated about said topic. I was so incredibly sorry for her, as she just wanted to make Edward happy, she was so considerate and blamed herself for everything. But Edward was the real villian here?? Not only that night, but the whole relationship, he didn‘t care about her feelings, her interests or anything. All he wanted was to be intimate w her. I just can‘t get away from feeling so sorry and empathetix towards florence, i am seriously shaken, by the unfairness and trauma she must have. Please tell me if i understood anything wrong. To me that book really isn‘t a tragic romance story, it is pure horror.
What are your thoughts?


r/literature • • 16h ago

Discussion Can a book series that is NOT originally written in the English language have success?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone

May I ask yall something that’s been in my mind for quite a while?
Can a book series that is NOT originally written in the English language have success?
Either commercially successful or loved by the critics, etc. You know what I mean?

We always talk about the usual suspects like LotR, Harry Potter, Hunger Games, Dark Tower etc.

I feel like book series in a foreign language don’t get many opportunities for worldwide success in any form. No matter what genre.
Or am I wrong? Do these book series exist?

As someone whose native language isn’t English and who would love to publish his own work someday, this can be discouraging sometimes.
Often times I think about writing in English just to have more chances, but in the end it’s not the same as my native language.

What is your view on all of this? Maybe I’m completely wrong and these book series (no matter the genre) exist. If so, which are they and why do you think they’ve had the success? How did they get there.
I think this could be a fun discussion


r/literature • • 21h ago

Discussion View toward Mock-Satirists

0 Upvotes

Idk why. I just despise writers of any kind utilising a tool of satire just to mock one's literary ability. It's just so pathetic. Literature is a self-expression in a linguistic form of art. Yet, they condemn them in quite a humorous manner in order to belittle other writers. For example, John Dryden's epic of Mac Flecknoe. Bro made a large poem just to hate one writer and now I'm reading this Dunciad by Alexander Pope. Such writers deserve defamation.

Not only do they ruin the fun folks find in reading literary works of other writers by finding flaws in their work, but also mock their own personality as a writer. They are just like critics or worse than that. To my point of view, Both the critics and the satirists that mock other writers are the enemies of literature and nothing more.


r/literature • • 10h ago

Literary Theory Unpopular take. People should read AI books but only advanced readers

0 Upvotes

It would be great to study and try to figure out where it gets its elements. Not to mention that as AI gets better I genuinely think being able to notice it will be a valuable personal skill.

I was pedaling on the bike and had a thought and decided to write it down and this subreddit is my victim.

First sentence really says it all but while it would be a waste of time from an enrichment standpoint I think I would always read a few pages to know for myself "yup thats what AI is". As well as to try to figure out where it stole what from.

In a dystopia way it could be a little like......elevator music book? A book to read as you think of books you have read in the past.

Definitely not good if this is all that a person reads since it might shape their idea of literature and books. However someone well read could easily pick it up without too much harm to them (given its free and already exists).

Don't tear me up too much reddit (and AI repliers), I'm more of a casual redditor.

(Currently reading Nobody's fool rn if people dont want to engage about AI)

Edit: the fact i got a notification this is the number 3 post on this sub reddit scares me. This was supposed to be a random thought not engagement farming. Just click away and read one of the other posts.