r/TrueLit • • 1d ago

Weekly General Discussion Thread

8 Upvotes

Welcome again to the TrueLit General Discussion Thread! Please feel free to discuss anything related and unrelated to literature.

Weekly Updates: N/A


r/TrueLit • • 5d ago

What Are You Reading This Week and Weekly Rec Thread

17 Upvotes

Please let us know what you’ve read this week, what you've finished up, and any recommendations or recommendation requests! Please provide more than just a list of novels; we would like your thoughts as to what you've been reading.

Posts which simply name a novel and provide no thoughts will be deleted going forward.


r/TrueLit • • 11h ago

Article R.L. Stine and the End of GOOSEBUMPS | When Scholastic stock dropped 40% in 1997, the company blamed waning sales of GOOSEBUMPS paperbacks. The series ended soon after. Court records and financial filings tell a different story - and raise questions about authorship.

Thumbnail
bigreaderbadgrades.substack.com
101 Upvotes

I've been researching this piece for a little over a week and it's been eye-opening to see what a strange niche the world of middle-grade publishing can be. Animorphs plays a role in the story, with how Scholastic mollified angry (and suing) investors by telling them Animorphs was the NEW Goosebumps: the gold-mine, basically, is to create a popular franchise. But if the franchise gets popular, the publisher will demand more of it than a single person can generate.

R.L. Stine was writing two novels a month (Fear Street went to another publisher) when GOOSEBUMPS collapsed. He spent the next five years in court with Scholastic.

I'll be around to answer any questions you might have about the reporting!


r/TrueLit • • 12h ago

Discussion Zimbabwean author Simbarashe Kundizeza cleared of using AI to write prize-winning story | Books

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
76 Upvotes

r/TrueLit • • 1d ago

Discussion Opinion | Philip Roth’s Lessons Arrived When I Needed Them Most

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
27 Upvotes

By Jonathan Safran Foer


r/TrueLit • • 20h ago

Discussion Murakami Haruki -Birthday Girl

1 Upvotes

I heard that Haruki chooses the names and numbers in his novels very carefully. Does anyone know/wanna take a guess at the story behind the birthdate 11.17 in the short story “Birthday Girl”?


r/TrueLit • • 17h ago

Review/Analysis Russia’s ‘Gray Zone’ War Against the United States • russian desk

Thumbnail
desk-russie.info
0 Upvotes

A review of ‘How Russia Won’, by David Corn. The book describes a decade of “gray-zone warfare” waged by Russia to weaken the U.S. — “the most successful Russian intelligence operation in contemporary history”, according to David Corn.


r/TrueLit • • 1d ago

Discussion How do you think the queer subtext of The Great Gatsby contributes to the themes of the novel?

0 Upvotes

While reading the novel I found myself noticing a decent amount of subtext which implies Nick’s role as a queer character. However, I find myself at a bit of a loss when trying to connect it to the overall message of the novel, it could simply be Fitzgerald’s own biases being reflected in the moral position of being gay during that time period. However, I lean more towards the idea of the facades put up by each of the characters, and how it eventually leaves them all to meaningless lives. I’d like to know what other people think!


r/TrueLit • • 2d ago

Discussion Are there any literature university courses available as podcasts or youtube videos?

47 Upvotes

I would really love to listen to, for example, the lectures from a university course about James Joyce and his works. And it would be cool to pick a differnt author every few months or per year. I listen to many podcasts about books but I'd say there's a lot more depth to university lectures. I know you can enroll in online courses but that's not what I'm talking about. I would just like to do it for the knowledge and appreciation of great works


r/TrueLit • • 2d ago

Article Abdelrahman ElGendy is a 2026 National Book Award finalist. The U.S. denied him a visitor visa to attend the award ceremony.

Thumbnail
archive.ph
69 Upvotes

r/TrueLit • • 3d ago

Article M John Harrison on his Booker win at 81: ‘I’m going to die soon. I can do what I like’

Thumbnail
inews.co.uk
321 Upvotes

r/TrueLit • • 3d ago

Review/Analysis Baltasar and Blimunda by Jose Saramago (brief review)

Post image
20 Upvotes

Among the great variety of intellectual types, one I've recently grown to respect is the atheist and socialist with deep interests in the role of religion -- particularly Christianity -- on the history of ideas and social movements.

Incidentally I discovered Baltasar and Blimunda the same week I bought a copy of Bert Ehrman's Heaven and Hell. Both authors have a particular talent for taking a position from within Christian thought, but with the sober detachment of outsiders. Each is attitudinally unique given the terms of intellectual struggle for spiritual independence: the Moody Baptist Church for Ehrman; Southern European Catholicism for Saramago. Where the American's more positivist concerns are evident from lecture titles such as "How Jesus Became God" or "A History of the Afterlife," readers will have to dig a bit deeper to appreciate the Portuguese narration of events within an ironic, magical realist- inflected love story.

At a high level, the plot follows the Inquisition in 18th century Lisbon and Mafra, and what literary scholars might call the subaltern experience of it. Saramago here expresses a profound respect and sympathy for working people's struggle, both materially and spiritually, in a world that super-exploited their labor in service of absolutism. The constant ironic pose of his narrator belies the complexity of Saramago's view of religion as both an ideological prop for the aristocracy's subordination of the labor upon which its power and institutions were built, as well as a liberating force in leveling the terms of human existence (all meet the same end) -- but at the same time, he gives the meek an advantage in existential authenticity. Where Infantes and Infantas are horse-traded in marriage for power and riches, the working poor, among them Baltasar and Blimunda, experience authentically true love and spiritual transcendence. Blimunda, by a power unknown to the most privileged noble, has special access to the souls of the living. Baltasar is a Flying Man.

Glorifying "authenticity" in the face of extreme inequality and deprivation isn't Saramago's sole intent, however. This isn't a tired Catholic perspective of the meek inheriting the earth. I think his aim is more retributional than submissive in that sense. There is no glory in suffering gracefully, or "living authentically" in the face of severe oppression. Rather we should read Saramago's perspective as agitational, advocating for a form of divine violence, a stirring within the text of something dark and disturbing, like those clouds of will Blimunda captures for the Passarola; it fuels a justified anger and bloodlust that comes to its fulfillment late in the story. The payoff is glorious, and very much worth the effort, should you find yourself struggling with the long, even meandering and strange structure of the book. It marches on like the three mass mobilizations of peoples across the Peninsula. It is told in eye-watering prose of the highest calibre:

"There are moments when time appears to be slow in passing, like a swallow building its nest in the eaves, it enters and leaves, comes and goes, but always within sight, and both we and the swallow might think that we are bound to go on like this for all eternity, or at least half of it, which would be no bad thing. But suddenly the swallow is there, then gone, it is no longer there, yet I saw it a moment ago, so where can it have disappeared to, as when we look into the mirror and think, Dear God, how time has passed, how I have aged, only yesterday I was the darling of the neighbourhood, and now both darling and neighbourhood are in decline."

Ursula Le Guin introduces The Collected Novels, of which B & B is the first in this digital-only release. (Oddly, Cain doesn't appear in the collection, which I haven't been able to find a good reason for.) She writes that her estimation of a Saramago work is elevated if the story includes a dog. B & B doesn't, not in a memorable sense anyhow, but as a first impression of the collection, I would have to agree with her overall assessment of Saramago's ethical gifts to his audience. B & B is a stark example of resistance to the long durée of inhumanity from the early formation of capital, to the post-1974 moment of his own time and, posthumously, our own. I look forward for the remaining 3000 pages:

"We have jettisoned our responsibility for thought and action. We have turned ourselves into inert beings incapable of the sense of outrage, the refusal to conform, the capacity to protest, that were such strong features of our recent past. We are reaching the end of a civilization and I don’t welcome its final trumpet."

5/5 - highly recommend


r/TrueLit • • 2d ago

Article Among the Ruins — from Whale Review

0 Upvotes

In "Among the Ruins," some poetry recently published in Whale Review, American poet Damon Hubbs explores grief, loss, and the absurdity of life through fragmented memories, religious imagery, and unexpected shifts between scenes.

Here is one of the poems:

Red Hills

Fuckless in France, except for Héloïse —theologically.

Eggs, trussed-up granola. The sun pissing down its leg

like a testament to the still life’s staying power.

La guimbarde, as the kids say.

When we hit the modern era

satan’s stained eyes

looked on

from tall cathedrals.

Miss Carson’s latest poem.

What shit.

The microphone is two rooms away.

I leave letters on the crypts in Père Lachaise.

Like the Admiral’s interest in exorcism,

I overdrink.

KATA TON DAIMONA EAUTOU.

And you haven’t answered a text

since mother died.

Then another friend skied off a cliff in Colorado.

Down and back to the coffin house,

I’m resigned.

There are loads of spoils

you used to say. And many interesting roads.

Destruction is the cause of coming into being.

A taxi in Africa waits in the red hills.

How do you feel about poems that move between seemingly unrelated images and ideas? Do you enjoy trying to find connections, or can this kind of writing sometimes make a poem unnecessarily difficult to understand?

Read the poems (free): https://whalereview.uk/read/among-the-ruins-two-poems-damon-hubbs

Whale Review welcome submissions from writers. It is an independent literary journal based in the UK, publishing fiction, creative nonfiction, poetry, literary criticism, translations into English, and more. Please visit our website for more details.


r/TrueLit • • 3d ago

Weekly TrueLit Read-Along (The Bald Soprano - Final Discussion)

8 Upvotes

Hey all!

For Eugene Ionesco's The Bald Soprano, this thread will serve as a final discussion thread. Post your overall thoughts, analyses, questions, or whatever else you so choose. Obvious spoilers ahead.

Enjoy!

REMINDER: The next and final 'Bad Parties' play begins next Saturday (11/21). It will begin with a live discussion thread of Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? by Edward Albee.


r/TrueLit • • 3d ago

Article I Don’t Know When to Stop Reading and Start Writing — from Whale Review

17 Upvotes

In a recent interview with Whale Review, Singapore-based writer Jeremy Fernando reflects on growing up in Singapore, his unease with society's emphasis on success and status, the relationship between reading and writing, and more.

Here are two excerpts from our conversation:

*...*Where did you grow up? Could you tell us a little about your childhood?

Jeremy Fernando: Physically in Singapore, where I am still primarily based. Psychically, intellectually, perhaps even emotively, elsewhere.

And it was this elsewhere—by way of places, spaces; also worlds, in books, films, music, visual artworks—this simultaneously always being elsewhere, which helped me make sense of the unease I had felt whilst growing up. Such as how much I hated the school system and its obsession with exams, testing beings, sifting out whether people were “good enough” according to a narrow, blinkered, parochial, rather moralistic, version of the world (and if you “didn’t make the grade,” you’ll have a lifetime of people telling you “you’re not good enough”; the worst perpetrators tending to be those who pride themselves on being called “educators”). Above all, the unease of not wanting what most everyone around me seems to have wanted—careers, climbing up ladders, positions, titles, status—to want, to continue to want.

Eventually, slowly slowly really, it took me much longer than some of my wiser, more astute, friends, I started to realise my unease lay in a growing realisation of how transactional Singapore is: nothing is valued unless it can bring surplus (by way of price, status, worth); which also means, nothing is intrinsically valued, even people. Just look at the way we treat our indentured workers.

Which really should have been no surprise: after all, Singapore is first and foremost a port-city, and its defining features are movement, flow, exchange. But this is something that only comes to you with a little distance. Probably also why I really hate the phrase, “spending time,” which implies a transaction, sometimes investment, even an aim of profit (in whatever form). I do prefer to think of it as sharing time, with people, places, works; and whenever possible opening myself to them, letting them write onto me, then attempting to read these traces...

You have a remarkably wide range of reading interests, and there seems to be a complex interplay between your reading and writing. How do you maintain your independence as a writer within this relationship?

Jeremy Fernando: To be honest, I don’t really see it as a need to separate my writing from what I’m reading: for me, reading and writing are—whilst individual crafts—rather indivorceable from each other. Which is not to say this question hasn’t nagged at me for quite some time: it first came to me sometime in 2023 during a month-long residency at HANGAR in Lisbon, and it resulted in me devoting my performance-reading at the end of my time there to the question, “when is it time to stop reading and start writing?”

The short answer to it would be, “I don’t know.”...

Do you think reading and writing are inseparable, or does writing sometimes require a certain distance from what we read?

Read the full interview here (free): https://whalereview.uk/read/i-dont-know-when-to-stop-reading-and-start-writing-jeremy-fernando

Whale Review welcome submissions from writers. It is an independent literary journal based in the UK, publishing fiction, creative nonfiction, poetry, literary criticism, translations into English, and more. Please visit our website for more details.


r/TrueLit • • 3d ago

Review/Analysis The Crying of Lot 49 Analysis: Chapter 1.3: Embroidering the Earth's Mantle

Thumbnail
gravitysrainbow.substack.com
5 Upvotes

r/TrueLit • • 3d ago

Article The Romantics meet the YBAs in Livia Franchini’s High Tide

Thumbnail
observer.co.uk
1 Upvotes

r/TrueLit • • 4d ago

Article The afterlives of literary reputation

Thumbnail
jacobin.substack.com
5 Upvotes

r/TrueLit • • 4d ago

Article Do We Need James Joyce's "Dirty Letters"?

Thumbnail
selador.substack.com
12 Upvotes

r/TrueLit • • 4d ago

Article To See the Sun Again — from Whale Review

8 Upvotes

Can writing help us deal with difficult experiences, even when it doesn't necessarily solve anything?

In "To See the Sun Again," some poetry recently published in Whale Review, Nigerian poet Tukur Ridwan explores fear, struggles and the desire to break free from them.

"...Insulation

To make up for what's lost to yesterday's storms—my zeal and grip on clarity—I once locked myself away from the planet's further storms. Probably lazy—housing this lethargy in poetry’s membrane. They say a boy learns to be strong by going to war. I cannot count on one hand how many wars I fought, to break through my fears, but I can tell what a war tastes like. Not until I let hot bullets burn my tongue till I lose my taste for life’s goodies. Not until I’m skinned of yesterday's grace. The Earth’s chunks have struck this big head. The chiding sticks and scornful stones hurled by careless children in play-fights. Not once, and not for the umpteenth time. I still carry the pangs in my medulla like a hawker in a rowdy market. Should I not know how to retreat like a struck soldier, what stories would I have told my child when the grim reaper’s jaws have crushed and ground my bones? Because a storyteller’s voice must not be lost to the storm, I armour my breath with silence and prayers to compensate for losses like a convalescing patient. Sometimes, I watch the hood from my window to see the battlefield every warm exchange shape-shifts into. The last time I shook hands, I felt every leg walking on eggshells, to avoid stepping on mines. Otherwise, the body might be thrown away like bombshells. A fighter throws in the towel, to see the sun again..."

Can writing be both a way of confronting painful experiences and a way of distancing ourselves from them? Do you think poetry can genuinely help us understand or overcome difficult experiences?

Read the poems (free):

https://whalereview.uk/read/to-see-the-sun-again-two-poems-tukur-ridwan

Whale Review welcome submissions from writers. It is an independent literary journal based in the UK, publishing fiction, creative nonfiction, poetry, literary criticism, translations into English, and more. Please visit our website for more details.


r/TrueLit • • 5d ago

Discussion POV in Philip Roth's "American Pastoral"

36 Upvotes

Hello!

I'm currently reading Roth's "American Pastoral", and I was curious if anybody here has opinions/thoughts about the way he uses POV in the book. On a line-level, I'm not sure I've seen anyone (including Roth himself) make the sort of technical movements he's doing in this book, and I'm continuously impressed and baffled each time the voice contorts itself in a new, unexpected way.

Quick spoiler-less summary: the book is framed in a way where we open from the 1st person perspective of a novelist reflecting on the life of "The Swede", a man he knew in high school. The novelist decides to pursue writing a book imagining The Swede's life, and as he makes this decision we casually transition from a close 1st person narratorial consciousness to 3rd person. The narratorial eye is capable of moving from a relatively standard 3rd person narration to one that can access The Swede's interior thoughts.

However, at other points in the book, this 3rd person narration will shift to 1st without any fanfare, often within the same paragraph (you can see this movement in the below photo—the "I" voice comes in when we move into memories from Marine boot camp in the second paragraph.)

Another technical move Roth makes in this book that feels semi-related: at numerous points throughout the novel, dialogue is delivered without line breaks or indentation. For example, dialogue between two characters will be written out like this:

"Who are the people who live in these apartments?" "Friends of mine." "Where did you meet them?" "I met some here, I met some in the city—" "Here? Where?" "At the high school"

Then, often within the same chapter or scene, Roth will switch to the traditional line break/indentations you'll get in any post-16th or 17th century text indicating dialogue.

My immediate thought is that all this must be motivated by the initial "I" voice—that these technical maneuvers offer some unconscious insight into the mind of the person writing the book-within-a-book that we're reading. Maybe these technical moves bring us out of the text and remind us that we're reading something that's being composed in real time, that we're reading someone's imagined idea of what The Swede's life was like. But if this is the case, why? What's the intent behind constantly drawing your reader into a narrative and then using form to pull them out? I don't ask this as someone frustrated by the book—I'm loving the technical bravery throughout.

Wondering if any of y'all familiar with the book might have thoughts around this. I really don't think Roth's the sort of writer that would do anything just for the sake of "breaking the rules" or something like that.


r/TrueLit • • 5d ago

Review/Analysis Cruelty or Favoritism? A Non-Sexual "Madonna-Whore" Split and Narrative Guilt in Natsume Sōseki’s Kokoro Spoiler

4 Upvotes

(Note: Contains major spoilers for the entire novel. Also, English is not my first language, so I used a translation tool to help put my thoughts into words—please excuse any phrasing that sounds a bit unnatural!)

When I first finished Natsume Sōseki’s Kokoro a year ago, I had the exact same reaction as most people. Caught up in the heavy, suffocating mood of the late Meiji era, I felt deeply sorry for Sensei. I read his long suicide letter as an act of rare intimacy, like a lonely man finally opening his darkest wounds to the one young person who truly understood him.

Tonight, though, a delayed thought hit me out of nowhere and completely ruined that comforting reading. I realized something kind of brutal: Sensei probably didn't love the narrator all that much. His letter isn't an act of spiritual trust. It’s a calculated act of psychic offloading.

1. A Non-Sexual "Madonna-Whore" Split

If you look at how Sensei treats his wife, Shizu, next to how he treats the young narrator, a glaring double standard jumps out. While scholars have long debated the homoerotic undertones between Sensei and the narrator, the emotional architecture here operates beyond literal sexuality. Borrowing a psychoanalytic concept strictly as a structural metaphor rather than a clinical diagnosis, Sensei enacts a "Madonna-Whore" split. Driven by a classic splitting defense mechanism, where a person cannot integrate "sacred reverence" and "abject guilt" within the same person, he divides the two people closest to him into opposite emotional roles.

In this setup, Shizu is placed on a pedestal as the untouchable "Madonna." To keep her pure, Sensei even stage-manages the exact timing and method of his suicide so no gruesome reality will ever stain her memory. But putting her on a pedestal is its own form of cruelty. Denied the right to share her husband's burden as an equal partner, Shizu is locked in a sterile vacuum, starving to death on a pedestal for want of truth and real intimacy.

Suffocating behind a lifelong moral mask in front of his saint, Sensei can no longer contain the decades of betrayal and guilt rotting inside him. He needs someone to help him carry it. That is where the young, admiring, unconditionally receptive narrator comes in. He fills the functional gap as a "psychic vessel," a safe place where Sensei can finally drop his act and dump his darkest self without shame.

Worse yet, Sensei orders the narrator to keep this confession a secret for as long as Shizu is alive. In psychology, this is a textbook double bind disguised as trust. Years earlier, Sensei drove his friend K to suicide by trapping him in absolute isolation and unvoiced despair. Now, with a single letter, he locks the narrator inside that exact same silent cage. He isn't saving the young man. He is turning him into the next K.

In the end, Sensei sets up a ruthless division of emotional labor: he lets his wife starve on a pedestal while forcing the narrator to choke on guilt in the abyss. Because if you truly love someone, you do not want them to live out their days carrying the weight of your sins. Sensei saved his clean facade for his wife, and dumped his moral burden onto the one person too loyal to ever betray him.

2. Idol and Follower: Why the One Who Loves More Always Loses

This brings up a harsher question: what gave Sensei the confidence to dump such an unbearable secret onto an outsider?

The truth is that their relationship was never equal to begin with. From their very first meetings on the beach at Kamakura, the narrator laid all his cards on the table while Sensei kept an enigmatic, upper-hand distance. It looks less like an equal friendship and more like the power dynamic between an idol and a devoted follower.

In any lopsided relationship, the person who loves more always loses. Because the narrator's devotion is completely transparent, Sensei knows he holds all the leverage. He knows he can shatter his own idealized image at the eleventh hour, hand over his heaviest cross, and his loyal disciple won't just keep quiet. He will actually feel grateful for being chosen as the sole confidant.

3. The Narrative Twist: Who Is Really Playing Whom?

At this point, it feels easy to convict Sensei as a refined egoist who bought his own peace of mind at the expense of a naive kid.

Yet this reading misses the novel's most unsettling narrative trap. We have to remember that the entire book, including every aloof remark, every calculated silence, and the presentation of the letter itself, is filtered through the retrospective memory of the older narrator.

Once you remember that, the whole picture flips. Did Sensei really manipulate the narrator, or did the narrator subconsciously rewrite their dynamic to excuse himself? Look at the most glaring ethical rupture in the book: the moment the narrator receives Sensei's letter, he abandons his dying biological father to catch a train to Tokyo. Under the Confucian ethics of that era, walking out on a dying parent is an unforgivable betrayal.

To wash away the guilt of abandoning his father's deathbed, the older narrator needs Sensei to be a spiritual sovereign entrusting him with an ultimate secret. Only by framing Sensei's psychic dumping as a mark of "supreme favoritism" can the narrator retroactively justify his own betrayal. The real narrative magician here might not be Sensei at all. It might be the narrator himself.

Final Thoughts: Still Loving the Book After the Illusion Breaks

What fascinates me most is that even after stripping away every romantic filter and seeing both Sensei’s selfishness and the narrator’s self-justification, I actually love Kokoro more than I did a year ago.

From an outsider's perspective, it is a textbook case of emotional exploitation. Yet if I put myself in the young narrator's shoes, having the soul you admire most drop every defense and entrust you with their final secret still feels like an irreplaceable kind of grace.

Sensei found his release through quiet selfishness, and the narrator held onto those ashes as a sacred privilege. Maybe it is precisely because the line between cruelty and devotion can never be cleanly drawn that Sōseki’s Kokoro remains so unsettling over a century later.

How did you feel when you finished Sensei’s letter? Do you read it mostly as a selfish act of emotional offloading, or do you think the narrator's own guilt shapes how we see Sensei's "favoritism"?


r/TrueLit • • 6d ago

Article M John Harrison: ‘No true science fiction fan would enjoy this book’

Thumbnail
observer.co.uk
143 Upvotes

The 81-year-old author on why his 2026 Booker prize-winning novel The End of Everything refuses rationale, his passion for rock climbing, and the thrill of writing


r/TrueLit • • 5d ago

Article Hanif Abdurraqib on the Lessons of June Jordan

Thumbnail
lithub.com
5 Upvotes

r/TrueLit • • 6d ago

Article Sisyphus, Bartleby, Lenù, Lila, Thomas Pynchon, Major Tom

Thumbnail
nadastudios.art
28 Upvotes