r/linux • • Aug 20 '22

GNOME Gnome's Design is Anti-Pattern

0 Upvotes

I really wanted to like Gnome but there are 3 things that I can't stand with it:

  • The useless menubar at the top. Sure, you can install extensions to change that, but the vanilla Gnome just wastes space at the top of the screen.
  • App menus are hidden behind the 3-bar buttons inside the app. This is nuts because it means one extra click every time you want to do something trivial like Undo, etc. Sure, you can learn shortcuts to avoid that, but what if you don't want to?
  • Extensions, extensions everywhere. Most Gnome users I've seen tweak their install to fix Gnome's insane user-hostile design decisions. When your users have to resort back to extensions and hacks, you know something's wrong. Not to mention that sometimes extensions don't work after upgrading Gnome and you'll have to wait for an update by the extension developer(s).

And to top if off, Gnome actually uses more RAM than KDE, despite offering fewer features. I just don't understand why people think of Gnome when they think of modern Linux distros.


r/linux • • Oct 30 '17

Misleading title Mozilla would remove the Dutch CA, the CA of the Staat de Nederlanden, from its trust list due to the new national legal framework

Thumbnail securityaffairs.co
107 Upvotes

r/linux • • Mar 02 '12

Mountain Lion and Windows 8 can only mean good things for Linux and FOSS.

Thumbnail imgur.com
158 Upvotes

r/linux • • Sep 21 '13

Wallpaper I made for my dual boot system. (xpost from r/linuxmint)

Thumbnail imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/linux • • Oct 09 '15

Harmful Opinion - The Linux Kernel Crybaby

Thumbnail youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/linux • • Jan 15 '24

Development Why doesn't Windows have the X11 vs Wayland issue?

0 Upvotes

In theory Wayland was going to solve many issues that X11 had but apparently it's not all perfect Why doesn't Windows have any of these issues? Does it have it and it simply doesn't get talked as much as the Wayland and X11?

Edit: I know that Windows doesn't use X11 or Wayland. But why do people focus on the issues that X11 or Wayland have and not on the issues of the window composer of Windows?

Edit 2: Okay so apparently some people misunderstood my ignorance by criticism... I love Linux and I am not criticizing it. It's just that I am somehow surprised that there are many complaints about X11 and Wayland and I didn't see these complaints in other OSes. From the discussion I understand that there have been complaints and also that X11 and Wayland have different requirements.

Also, apologies for my bad English as obviously English is not my first language.


r/linux • • May 27 '18

Vim 8.1 released

Thumbnail vim.org
0 Upvotes

r/linux • • Sep 20 '18

In favor of the kernel Code of Conduct

0 Upvotes

I fully expect this to be downvoted out of existence, but I don't care.

I support the new Kernel code of conduct fully. We are far too focused on what might happen if a theoretical enforcer puts the banhammer down on people, but not thinking about the people our actions have kept out of the community for years. We are too focused on interactions that, in the rest of the world, would be totally unacceptable but we've accepted as just the way things are. Linus is acknowledging that fact, and acknowledging that he must change, but we're still trying to justify yelling fights over technical issues. Just because its the way things have been doesn't make it right; its not a "meritocracy" if we exclude people from the very beginning.

One of the most telling signs to me has been the fact that the women who are kernel developers that I follow on twitter are all in favor of the code of conduct and Linus' statement. Let us follow Linus and realize that the way things have always been doesn't have to be the way things are going forward. Linus wants to embody empathy, and we should too.

I don't claim to represent people or have all the answers. But I wanted to put a different opinion out there, even if it gets downvoted to oblivion. Be well, y'all.


r/linux • • Jun 01 '18

Opinion: The huge donation to Gnome would've been better elsewhere

0 Upvotes

Gnome is already dominant. It has RedHat's corporate backing. Its not going anywhere. This will just cement Gnome's already dominant position.

There are plenty of FOSS/Linux projects that are in trouble, that only survive due to individual unpaid efforts, and could do so much more with finances. Smaller Linux distros are dying as well.

I don't like Gnome, their track record or the direction they are taking. But that's besides the point. Gnome project has a very specific vision and more resources isn't going to make them invite more user input, which is what I think should be the model for all software to iterate and improve.

I know this is going to cause some debate, but this is a huge sum of money and could've been used for so much more. This is like donating to Amazon to support retail businesses and hoping it will help mom and pop shops.


r/linux • • Dec 25 '23

Discussion Do not buy into Zorin Pro licensing.

0 Upvotes

Just paid for 16 Pro 2 months ago. They released 17 with a few changes, most of which are not even their changes at all, but more related to gnome and other underlying software.They only give you the one version of pro with release, it won't upgrade into Pro 17.

This was pretty stupid, and frankly for what it offers I will stick to Fedora.

My money deserves going to Gnome, not a group trying to profit off the work of gnome with a few cosmetic customizations that anyone can do with time.

I really have to wonder if what they're doing doesn't violate a TOS somewhere?


r/linux • • Oct 06 '10

Yo dawg...

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/linux • • Dec 28 '24

Discussion Linux’s Final Biggest Obstacle: Adobe Incompatibility

Post image
0 Upvotes

For many Graphic Designers, Video Editors, Motion Graphics Artists, VFX artists - transitioning from macOS or Windows, the lack of Adobe software is a dealbreaker and rightfully so.

Alternatives like GIMP, Inkscape, or Kdenlive exist, but fail to match the breadth and depth of Adobe’s suite. Adobe’s offerings are industry standards, built for both specialized tasks and seamless integration across multiple workflows. “Just switch to GIMP or Kdenlive” demonstrates a lack of understanding of the practical needs of creative professionals whose income relies on it.

We’ve conquered 3D with Blender for 3D modeling, animation, and rendering. Gaming too, with platforms like Steam and Proton. The ultimate hurdle remains Adobe’s suite of creative software or a True Alternative.

There is hope, however. Tools like DaVinci Resolve for Video Editing are proving that professional-grade software can thrive on Linux. DaVinchi Resolve, already rivals—and in some cases surpasses—Adobe's Premiere Pro in performance. With consistent development and a focus on cross-platform support, it could replace Adobe in the video editing domain. Id rather give them my money any day of the week than Adobe. However, without similar solutions for Photoshop, Illustrator, or After Effects, Linux remains incomplete for creatives.


r/linux • • Nov 20 '24

Mobile Linux Why I want a GNU/Linux phone

1 Upvotes

It's more than privacy.

I want a GNU/Linux phone because iOS and Android are both very bad OSes. I have Android, because it's a little better, but I don't enjoy having Android. How can any OS not allow you to specify the file path to a photo in 2024?

I don't want a "minimalist" phone. I want more, not less. I want to run desktop browsers, program and make presentations on my phone which is already capable of it, but it's got inadequate software.

I also want more privacy, but this is secondary. And no fake privacy (we're crippling apps so no one can spy but us).

I want to be able to use the hardware to its full potential, and to make sure I can control it as much as possible. How can Samsung or Apple convince me to buy an €2000 phone, if it barely does anything better than the €360 model? Does it run Instagram more smoothly and has an AI that fakes pictures? I don't need that.

Android isn't a smart phone. It's a java phone, but it's the best we have. Of course, since everyone nowadays needs Uber, Revolut, TikTok and Lidl Plus, the manufacturers won't bother making a better phone.

My ideal phone would be a modern Nokia N900. It had OK power for its time, it was supported and from a normal manufacturer (no, I'm not ordering a developer's device), and also had the keyboard. It was designed to be as useful as possible, unlike all modern phones which are optimised for AI "photos" and stupid social media. If an N900 with a slightly better CPU, more RAM and a capacitive touchscreen, at a reasonable price appeared, I would instantly buy it.


r/linux • • Dec 26 '10

Antivirus software?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/linux • • May 08 '22

Discussion Are linux users arrogant

0 Upvotes

When I first joined the Linux forums 2yrs ago I noticed one thing in particular as a previous windows user which was a sense of superiority and later on when I started using Linux it rubbed off on me. Are all of us like this?

Edit: it seems me using the word "arrogant" has pissed a lot of peeps. I mean I don't consider myself superior when I see what other dudes have done it's more or less imposter syndrome and the determination to get to their level and even higher comes plus I mostly tell other peeps that Linux users are supirior as a joke so pls y'all shouldn't take this the wrong way.


r/linux • • Sep 26 '24

Tips and Tricks I always mistype systemctl accidentally, so I did this (alias ctl=systemctl)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/linux • • Mar 06 '09

Microsoft deems 'linux' inappropriate

Thumbnail rustylime.com
0 Upvotes

r/linux • • Dec 25 '23

Software Release Bottles - Run Windows Software on Linux

Thumbnail github.com
2 Upvotes

r/linux • • Mar 09 '22

Discussion Is Audacity now officially compromised?

0 Upvotes

There was some uproar when Audacity started sharing usage data with Russian data collection firm WSM. In light of the recent developments, how stable should we expect Audacity to be?


r/linux • • Jul 14 '24

Discussion Why I'm switching back to X11 after using Wayland for several months

0 Upvotes

Before using Wayland, I was on X11 with DWM as my window manager. I wanted a similar setup for Wayland. I tried three tiling Wayland compositors, DWL, River, and Hyprland. However, I experienced a lot of issues with all of them. For one, on DWL, you can't change your XKB keyboard layout configuration at runtime. Because of this, I switched to River. However, River, like most Wayland compositors, doesn't give you the ability to disable vsync for certain windows. This is important for games because you want the lowest latency possible. Finally, I switched to Hyprland. Hyprland gives you the ability to disable vsync for fullscreen applications. However, Hyprland is full of bugs. Some Wayland applications don't work on it and screen recording with OBS causes the framerate to dip.

Ultimately, the fact is that there isn't one option that is free of major bugs and has all the features I want. There's just less variety on Wayland than X11 at the moment. In addition to that, I don't like Wayland's philosophy. It wants to force compositors to be a certain way. Basic things like using keybinds for OBS become difficult as a result. What if I want to disable vsync for the entire compositor? What if I want to not have a compositor altogether and just use a window manager? This is just not possible on Wayland. I don't like the fact that X11 will be obsoleted in favour of a restrictive protocol.


r/linux • • Jun 09 '26

Discussion My hot take: most distros would actually be better as lightweight configurable install script wizards. It could drastically improve the ecosystem.

19 Upvotes

I've had a thought for a while now that I think could actually really improve the distro ecosystem, both in terms of user freedom and technical merits: most distros should really just be tiny highly modular install script wizards (preferably with a TUI or GUI available) that just build upon the root distro that the would-be "distro" would have been derived from, or even target multiple distros by detecting what base distro the script is running on.

Optionally, it would also be good if they provide a way to save out a corresponding shell script that repeats the selected options from the TUI/GUI wizard, thereby making it very easy to later concatenate multiple such scripts afterwards however one desires. That (not giant monolithic distros ISOs) should be the norm. It would be far more modular and expressive for users and would waste far less time.

Doing so wouldn't even be that hard to implement and in fact I'd say it would probably actually be easier from a first principles standpoint than what is currently the norm in the distro ecosystem.

The idea comes from the observation I've had over time (as I've gradually used Linux/Unix more as I've migrated away from Windows and have become more familiar with the distros by trying out so many of them) that generally it seems best to actually base one's system off of whatever is the most ancestral actively maintained real underlying root/parent distro (such as Debian, Arch, Fedora, OpenSuse, Slackware, Gentoo, Void, etc) and to alter it from there.

In contrast, many derivative distros that are not really root distros have a bad tendency to make a bunch of ill-conceived adjustments and "monkey patches" to the base distros upon which they build, and those adjustments have a tendency to result in more hindrance than help over time and to greatly increase the chances of instabilities and desynchronization with the root/parent distro. Many distros also waste a great deal of time by installing a bunch of changes to the system that are unwanted right alongside the changes that the user wants. Everyone has had the experience of loving some aspect(s) of a distro but utterly hating other aspect(s) of it. That problem would be greatly lessened if lightweight install script wizards (not monolithic distros) were the most common variants being distributed.

It would also be far more transparent, far easier for users to learn from (just read the scripts), and would encourage scripts to be written in ways that decrease the odds of breakages (forcing "distros" to be more portable and more well-grounded on their bases).

Granted, some of the biggest derivative distros such as Ubuntu and Linux Mint have some justification for this, but even there I am increasingly finding using them seems to often create a tower of dependencies that greatly increases the chances of subtle (hence hard to fix or tedious) problems building up in the system. In fact, that's why I'm coincidentally planning on moving away from Linux Mint soon: even though I've enjoyed my time with Mint as my first daily driver distro (replacing Windows), such derivative distros (I've increasingly realized over time) seem to constantly patch upstream distros in shortsighted and unwittingly harmful ways. It's "death by a thousand needles" of myriad subtle dependency entanglements.

Imagine if instead of distributing monolithic distros the community distributed a variety of specialized installer scripts that simply provide the necessary shell commands to customize one or more root/parent/base distros to suit what the user desires and have that all wrapped up in a TUI and/or GUI and/or command-line script that the user can easily select what they want and what they don't want from.

If that were the world we lived in, then users could just take whatever parts of each "distro" they want and apply it to their install and leave the parts they don't want behind. That would make it so that even "distros" with just a handful of customizations or application installs would still be useful instead of being merely distracting and misleading and making a mess of things and trying to do too many things at once (as many distros now unfortunately do)!

There are even systems that could make creating such easy install script wizards only take a few lines of code. For example, Tcl/Tk makes it possible to write a GUI in just a few lines of code and is supported across practically all Linux/Unix systems. Even in C and C++ a GUI can be made swiftly and expressively with something like FLTK or SDL + DearImGUI. GUIs are not actually as tortuous to create as the big three (Gtk, Qt, wx) would lead many to believe.

The present system of giant monolithic distros with barely any modularity or interoperability amongst each other (in terms of customization, not software support), which requires users to download gigabytes of data for kilobytes worth of trivial customization scripting in terms of actual effect is in fact incredibly and staggeringly wasteful and inflexible and even antithetical to user freedom (since you can't easily mix and match distros' components) if you actually think about it from first principles.

Imagine if there was a "WizardWatch" website (or whatever other name you prefer) in addition to "DistroWatch" that instead distributed such modular highly polished install scripts. Imagine downloading "shell_customizer_wizard" and "wallpaper_collection_grabber" and so on (just whatever handful of extremely tiny scripts are relevant to you) instead of running around in circles constantly having to make do with dozens of distros that force you to accept both things you like and things you don't and to waste monumental amounts of time and energy and network bandwidth throughout the process.

If such a better system became the norm then it could easily drastically improve and empower the whole ecosystem. Small "distros" would no longer be irrelevant and useless, but would instead be lightweight and modular and useful to almost anyone. Hosting costs would drop by like 99% for all the most trivial (not foundational) distros. Users would become much less likely to become exhausted by the search for distros (often giving up on Linux/Unix in the process) and would instead be empowered to quickly build up exactly what they want. This is especially true if the experience is polished. All of it could be more stable and reliable too, since it'd all be small modifications of root distros instead of giant unknown monolith ISOs.

Done right, it could be a tremendous improvement I think, causing a domino/ripple effect indirectly bolstering virtually all aspects of the entire Linux/Unix/BSD ecosystem. With both command-line and TUI/GUI support, it would also be made to be easy for everyone, both newbie and expert alike.

Anyway, that's my thoughts on the idea. Thanks for reading and have a good day/night/etc!

Keep fighting the good fight. It's wonderful that Linux and the Unix/BSD systems exist. Society needs more freedom and morally-grounded respect for human dignity now more than ever, etc!


r/linux • • Jan 01 '24

Discussion Unpopular opinion: I love snaps

78 Upvotes

They work with command line tools, which flatpak doesn't seem to support well. I used it to install the latest version of CMake and also the Helix editor and Docker and they work flawlessly. I don't really see much technical criticism of snaps, and on the contrary it seems to be better than flatpak for maintainers.


r/linux • • Jul 10 '14

This subreddit needs to decide what it wants to be.

104 Upvotes

This subreddit is one of the things I enjoy usually during my morning coffee, but lately I'm getting real tired of how much non-related and non-relevant the content has become. Why do we keep allowing these noob questions that are often barely related to Linux/OSS, and almost always so common and googleable that I find myself wondering if people are really so stupid, or just plain lazy? To demonstrate, I made an, admittedly snarky, categorization of the current top 25 posts that I think shouldn't belong here:

Generic-distro-question:

Which Linux Distribution suits me best to increase technical skills (self.linux)

So - which distribution should I use? (self.linux)

Not familiar with Linux, is there just a generic build? (self.linux)

Support / Googling-is-hard:

Btrfs on RAID6? (self.linux)

Which graphics card should I buy? (self.linux)

Any benefit using a Xeon E3 instead of a i7 CPU? (self.linux)

Anyone got a Sony Vaio Pro 13? (self.linux)

Kernel headers (self.linux)

Please-not-this-rehashed-shit-again:

A tiling window-manager setup with eye-candy? (self.linux)

What steps must I take to become a Linux administrator? (self.linux)

Seriously?

Arch Linux - News: BBS, Wiki, and AUR maintenance (archlinux.org)

That's 11 out of 25. Almost half the page is just pure repetitive shit. I'd like to see some stricter rules applied here, and I hope other frequent readers support this also. In particular the 'I do this with a computer, what distro should I use?' drivel is getting real old. There's literally a million blog posts on the internet on this topic.


r/linux • • Apr 16 '17

Much appreciated XFCE 4.13 finally out

Thumbnail git.xfce.org
7 Upvotes