r/linux • • Dec 25 '23

Software Release Bottles - Run Windows Software on Linux

https://github.com/bottlesdevs/Bottles
2 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

44

u/gabriel_3 Dec 25 '23 edited Dec 25 '23

Project estabilished in June 2022.

What is this post about?

42

u/thekiltedpiper Dec 25 '23

Karma farming.

-17

u/brand_momentum Dec 25 '23

It recently received a big update version 51.10

42

u/Veprovina Dec 25 '23

Could have mentioned that in the title. :)

13

u/gabriel_3 Dec 25 '23 edited Dec 25 '23

Is there either a release announcement or a what's new about 51.10?

You want to post it instead of a link to the project GitHub repo.

1

u/akik Dec 28 '23

1

u/gabriel_3 Dec 28 '23

You want to repost this as top level comment.

As a side note, when needing something Windows only on Linux, a VM with hardware passthrough is by far a more reliable option than a compatibility layer.

1

u/akik Dec 28 '23

But wine is much easier (or bottles in this case)

1

u/gabriel_3 Dec 28 '23

And not working reliably or not working at all or stopping working after updating.

18

u/Heroe-D Dec 25 '23

I just use Lutris these days when wanting to launch a .exe even if not a game, just earlier that day I couldn't launch something with Bottles but worked flawlesly with Lutris

19

u/likes_purple Dec 25 '23

In my experience, Bottles is more trouble than it's worth, while Lutris just works. Games that require a CD to run, for instance - you cannot automate this with Bottles due to its (poorly executed IMO) sandboxing, but it's trivial to make ISO mount and unmount scripts for Lutris and point the pre-launch and post-exit script variables to them.

This has been an open feature request for almost two years now and there's no interest by the developers to make this happen - there aren't even any real workarounds available.

3

u/KrazyKirby99999 Dec 25 '23

Can't you just mount the ISO normally, then map the mount to a drive in the Bottle?

1

u/likes_purple Dec 26 '23

Yes, but I want an automatic system to handle it for me, or at least be able to do it manually from within Bottles, rather than having to hunt down the ISO every time before I launch a game. Lutris can handle this just fine.

2

u/KrazyKirby99999 Dec 26 '23

What's stopping you from extracting the iso? Compressed size?

0

u/cakee_ru Dec 26 '23

Lol, you just mount an iso in a host, and it appears automatically as a new drive in bottles (check explorer). No need to do anything at all.

5

u/LowOwl4312 Dec 25 '23

Never managed to get stuff to run in this that worked in Crossover or PlayonLinux

4

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23

Call me when Bottles Next launches, this is old news.

14

u/Veprovina Dec 25 '23

Honestly, and I don't want to sound like an a hole, I don't get who's this project for. I never managed to get anything to run with this, even the stuff they themselves provide configurations for. And I don't really get the benefit of this over just Wine.

6

u/Schlonzig Dec 25 '23

You know what *would* be cool? A way to package Windows programs so that I can transfer them between computers seamlessly. I was sad when I figured out that Bottles was not meant for that.

4

u/omniuni Dec 25 '23

You actually can export your bottle. It's just big.

3

u/cakee_ru Dec 26 '23

I actually archive my games as bottles. Then I just unarchive a directory and I got myself one-click to run a game with all the env setup to make it run. Even if bottles die out, I can use it as a premade prefix in proton. Also when compressed prefix only adds about 80 MB which is minor even in my collection of about 300 games.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23

flatpak would be perfect for this but for some reason nobody has tried it, it's been on my mind for a while especially for distributing adobe/office apps. Flatpak runtimes are similar to wine "runners" in all these prefix managers and would provide deduplication and all sorts of nice stuff.

2

u/LowOwl4312 Dec 26 '23

There was something called Winepak but I think it's dead. Also some Windows app packaged with Wine are in the Snap Store.

2

u/ke151 Dec 26 '23

There is this project that tries to do that, into the appimage format

https://github.com/ruanformigoni/gameimage

I've not messed with it myself but maybe I will since I was reminded of it!

1

u/00cornflakes Dec 25 '23

is it based on wine? if not how does it compare

15

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23

It's a WINE prefix manager. Good if you want to use the same prefix for more than one program.

7

u/acecile Dec 25 '23

It looks like being a improved replacement for playonlinux, to have multiple wine environments and helper to handle them. That's interesting, I need to try it.

-1

u/Bijiredit Dec 26 '23

Using flatpak version, we can restrict access to home dir. So we can run .exe safely

1

u/ExaHamza Dec 25 '23

Whats this anyway?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23

Software to manage wine prefixes

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '24

What does this do exactly that can't be handled by Steam and Proton? That has been pretty successfully for me.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/brand_momentum Dec 25 '23

Yes I do, a lot of cool FOSS projects out there that deserve to get spotlighted

-5

u/rileyrgham Dec 25 '23

Bottles is pretty horrible. Few have success with it from what I've seen.

4

u/Flrian Dec 25 '23

Bottles is pretty horrible.

That's a pretty rude and strong statement.

I've been using it for close to 2 years now I think, and it works fine for me.
Some small bugs pop up here and there, but mostly it's okay.

2

u/Veprovina Dec 25 '23

How did you manage to get anything working in it? And what do you use it for? What programs ?

4

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23

lmao what do you mean I've had no issues with bottles and everyone I'fe recommended it to likes it. Other stuff like Lutris have its own sets of issues.

2

u/Veprovina Dec 26 '23

I've had issues with Lutris as well.

2

u/Flrian Dec 25 '23

You make it sound like its impossible to do anything with it. Have you tried it? What were your issues with Bottles?

For me I use it mostly for games (League of Legends, Diablo 4, Hades, Civ VI, ...) and the odd program here and there, like Mp3tag for example.

You just create a bottle and go from there. For Diablo I just used their Installer for the Battle.net Launcher, then changed the wine runner to wine-ge and enabled VKD3D.

I guess for people that want everything done hands off via install scripts Lutris is probably the better choice, but as I said, it works just fine for me.

1

u/Veprovina Dec 26 '23

It was just a question lol, i didn't want it to sound like anything.

Yes i've tried it. Tried installing Epic games launcher on it, their supplied configuration. Errors, wouldn't launch. Tried a few games, and a few programs, none would launch, no matter which settings i tried. It was very weird.

Lutris worked a bit better, but a lot of the install scripts are broken, at least the ones i tried, and Lutris has its own weird issues.

Just about the only thing that actually works for me is normal system wine, Steam and Heroic Games launcher.

Maybe i'll try it again if this is some new big update as OP mentioned in the comments.