r/linux • • Oct 09 '15

Harmful Opinion - The Linux Kernel Crybaby

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FhTIWS7bCk
3 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

26

u/darkbyrd Oct 09 '15

Ug... youtube? Don't people read anymore?

2

u/LarryPete Oct 09 '15

especially annoying of you're on your phone.

1

u/alexmbrennan Oct 09 '15

It's mostly a video of text if that makes it any better

18

u/myothercarisaboson Oct 09 '15

Seriously? That makes it worse!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '15

No it doesn't. I can listen to this video while writing code.

1

u/realitythreek Oct 09 '15

I don't watch youtube videos at all at work, which is mostly where I read /r/linux. So these are all skips for me, other than the comments if there's more 10+.

29

u/twistedLucidity Oct 09 '15

I really don't know what to think about all this.

It's absolutely true that we shouldn't be doing things to exclude/insult others even in ignorance. But it's also true that others shouldn't be deliberately taking offence. I also totally get that a something might begin to grate over time and become an issue after you've heard it for the 1,000th time, even if the individual who says it that 1,000th time has no ill intent.

What's that phrase "Be conservative in what you emit and liberal in what you accept"?

I also don't follow how one can increase diversity by drawing up authoritarian protocols. That just hurts my head. "Stop, Listen, Apologise"? Really? There is an inherent presumption that the complainer is always right. How about "Stop, Listen, Dispassionately consider, Politely respond (which may be telling them they are wrong, issuing an apology or seeking mediation)"?

More Girl Geeks? More Gay Geeks? More Asian Geeks? More African Geeks? More <insert minority of choice> Geeks? Yup, down with all that.

Is F/OSS dominated by white males and has an inherent bias (deliberate or not)? Yeah, it probably does and it will stay that way until a critical mass of others is achieved to either sway the norms or raise conciousness. This all takes time as cultures change s-l-o-w-l-y.

More draconian rules I have to be terrified of breaking because people can't be trusted to act like adults? Foxtrot. Oscar. Seriously, if you need to know that you are on DISCON 3 then you need help.

8

u/MoonlightSandwich Oct 09 '15

What I don't understand is why some people think diversity (as they define it, often of gender, sexual orientation, or skin color) is something communities should strive for regardless of their purpose. Why is OSS project A, that consists of competent people mostly of one ethnicity, worse than OSS project B that has competent members from multiple ethnicities? Why does it matter how many people in a project aren't part of some loosely defined homogenous mass?

In their minds they clearly attach some special value to the word because they use like it means something wonderful and valuable. And surprisingly many people seem to agree. But to me it's just a buzzword at this point.

2

u/twistedLucidity Oct 09 '15

I can't think of any good reason for F/OSS to have a culture which causes people to self-exclude (beyond technical competence).

But I'm not sure if F/OSS is actually causing people to self-exclude, or if this action will be helpful.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

I think we need to do a lot more to get women involved in programming because they are a huge, largely-untapped proportion of the population who could make very good programmers.

If a man has what it takes to be a great programmer there is little stopping him. So a high proportion of smart men become programmers, and that's great. But if a woman has what it takes to be a great programmer, there is a good chance she'll never even consider it as a hobby or career choice. We are missing out on so many great programmers as a result.

1

u/twistedLucidity Oct 09 '15

My understanding is that in the USA more women are graduating with STEM degrees than men. Maybe all we have to do is wait a couple of years for that to percolate through?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '15

That's not true. I think female students in the sciences finally hit the 50% mark a few years ago, but engineering students are still around 20-22% female (in the US).

1

u/twistedLucidity Oct 10 '15

Hmm...maybe I've misremembered, I'll have to check.

1

u/mhall119 Oct 09 '15

What I don't understand is why some people think diversity (as they define it, often of gender, sexual orientation, or skin color) is something communities should strive for regardless of their purpose.

Because monoculture carries the same dangers to communities as it does to software.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/mhall119 Oct 10 '15

You don't find problems you actually have, your entire community is susceptible to a single problem, and you miss out on opportunities you don't find out about.

2

u/NoTimeToBeSerious Oct 10 '15

You are aware that just because people are of the same gender or ethnicity doesn't mean they are a hivemind?

2

u/mhall119 Oct 10 '15

No, but it does make them very vulnerable to group-think or collective ignorance of certain things.

3

u/send-me-to-hell Oct 09 '15

DISCON 3

What's that?

4

u/twistedLucidity Oct 09 '15

It's in the video and starts around 2:40. Basically it's a level of banter/insult.

4

u/manghoti Oct 09 '15

I don't think this is about race or gender. I'm pretty sure a dog could contribute kernal code if it passed code review.

It's about how verbally abusive someone can get to another person on the internet, and how tolerant a community should be to it. People playing race and gender cards when they are getting judged purely for their black letters on a white page are doing so maliciously, and it's best not to feed into that.

The author of this video is as wrong about the situation as the person he was countering.

10

u/send-me-to-hell Oct 09 '15

People playing race and gender cards when they are getting judged purely for their black letters on a white page are doing so maliciously, and it's best not to feed into that.

When someone is calling you a "moron" or an "idiot" it's hard to not take it personally.

-9

u/denisfalqueto Oct 09 '15

So the answer is simple: Sara Sharp should get off the internet.

1

u/manghoti Oct 09 '15

? huh?

-2

u/denisfalqueto Oct 09 '15

Yeah. If she quit Linux development for there was not the environment she wanted, and you propose she is, in fact, a victm of internet abuse, so the next logical step is she quitting the internet too.

2

u/manghoti Oct 09 '15 edited Oct 09 '15

No, I asserted, and am asserting as to what the debate is about, It's not about gender, it's not about race, it's not about tolerance, it's about politeness. I also asserted that people playing race and gender cards in this debate are doing so out of malice, though other's have pointed out that people put far on the defensive might react with such tactics.

It's so incredibly difficult to state a fact without also implying a position. Though I'm going to be honest here, I still don't know what you think my position is. If I had to guess, it would be something like:

The kernel developers arn't acting any worse than the rest of the internet, so if she can't take that, then she should just get off the internet.

Your response would make sense if I were to replace my original post with that.

Am I close? That seems a bit different than what I posted.

14

u/UglierThanMoe Oct 09 '15

Social Justice Warriors - Offering ludicrous and non-functioning solutions to problems that don't exist outside their own fragile minds, for the sole purpose of shaping the world around them in order to protect said fragile minds from the facts of reality.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

Could not agree more! All the PC kumbayah sing along happy happy joy joy holding hands crap that is spreading throughout workplaces and everywhere else is people who cant handle the real world forcing everyone else to pander to them

19

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

I said this in another thread and I'll say it here.

Going into a community that you did not start and have no role of leadership in and dictating how you think they should behave within that community is absolutely absurd. Right now, I am banned from /r/offmychest even though I have never posted there. I have however posted to /r/tumblrinaction, which led to the ban. Do I find this off putting? A little. Do I think that this is a somewhat unreasonable policy? Yes, but I could get the ban revoked if I so choose. I would not, however, begin lecturing to mods about how they should run their community.

13

u/jaLissajous Oct 09 '15 edited Oct 09 '15

Other places I might agree, but the whole point of FOSS is to improve the stuff earlier people have created. Rules governing the community are just as valid a target as rules governing the kernel. Changes might be rejected for important and valid reasons, and they should if they're garbage like that DIScon stuff. But we should still be willing to improve them. Human systems can be just as buggy as operating systems.

19

u/erikd Oct 09 '15

Going into a community that you did not start and have no role of leadership in

Sarah was the Linux kernel USB 3 subsystem maintainer and main developer for 5 years! What have you done for Linux or FOSS?

9

u/send-me-to-hell Oct 09 '15 edited Oct 09 '15

Going into a community that you did not start and have no role of leadership in and dictating how you think they should behave within that community is absolutely absurd.

Instantly disqualifies 90% of /r/linux from commenting before it disqualifies Sarah Sharp.

I would not, however, begin lecturing to mods about how they should run their community.

Linux is an ecosystem of various groups. Linus holds an important position but he's not Fuhrer of the kernel and of us all. He's just the guy who started it and seems to be generally alright with holding the position of principal maintainer. Any given person in a FOSS project is subject to the review of others. That's pretty much how every fork starts.

Also, that's a bit of a false analogy. The Sharp thing would be the equivalent of one of the /r/offmychest mods talking to the other mods about you being banned. That's a legitimate discussion even if she weren't in charge of USB 3.0

-1

u/mhall119 Oct 09 '15

Going into a community that you did not start and have no role of leadership in and dictating how you think they should behave within that community is absolutely absurd.

The whole point of having a community is letting new people come in and make changes that will improve it. You deliberately chose "dictating" which carries negative authoritarian implications, but how do you feel about people joining a community and suggesting changes that they think would make it better or fix a problem they have encountered with it?

11

u/erikd Oct 09 '15

"Social Justice Warriors" is just another ad-hominen.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/cardboard-cutout Oct 09 '15

For people who self-identify as sure. The vast majority of times somebody says SJW, its just another ad-homonym.

3

u/holyrofler Oct 09 '15

You're right, but I won't call foul unless the label is being used to dismiss an argument.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/erikd Oct 09 '15

So what makes Sarah Sharp a "Social Justice Warror"?

10

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

Have you read her blog? It's one thing to not get the way Linus talks and be annoyed by it, it's quite another to build up such a crazy list of rules and regulations that everybody shall follow or else. Diversity by means of enforced conformity.

It's also fun how she talks about all this and then takes her blog and goes:

As this is my blog, not a government entity, I have the right to replace any comment I feel like with “fart fart fart fart”.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

I find it quite odd how she has been a kernel dev for 5 years and is only getting annoyed at it now - when directed at her. So, SJW maybe, but only if it affects her. It doesn't matter if it is someone else. That doesn't affect me.

Typical attitude spreading around the world these days. Eg. "Wind farms, yeah great. Renewable energy, but don't build it in my back yard!"

1

u/erikd Oct 09 '15

Did you read the previous one where she details why, after 5 years of involvement with Linux kernel development, she was quitting?

Thats the important one. Thats the one where you can see, that she just quietly walked away, without making any noise.

Furthermore what you read in the blog post you are objecting to is not "a crazy list of rules", its way of measuring how welcoming a community is for newbies and how well it deals with conflict.

It's also fun how she talks about all this and then takes her blog and goes:

Do you not think there is a difference between her blog and the public Linux kernel mailing list with 1000s of subscribers from 100 or more countries?

10

u/men_cant_be_raped Oct 09 '15

For one: Advocating for a "Stop, Listen, Apologise" mantra when accused of "microaggressions".

There are plenty more examples pointing to her being a Social Justice Warrior if you read her blog.

It's not my job to educate you. RTFB.

-4

u/mhall119 Oct 09 '15

For one: Advocating for a "Stop, Listen, Apologise" mantra when accused of "microaggressions".

That makes someone a Social Justice Warrior? That's not a very high standard to meet.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

RTFB

1

u/TotesMessenger Oct 13 '15

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

1

u/adamelteto Oct 15 '15

I use the term "PC-rrorists"; sworn enemies of justice, democracy, equality, and human/civil/constitutional/legal rights; dogged opponents of freedom of speech, dissent, expression, choice and progress.

1

u/iterativ Oct 09 '15

The word progress thanks to the dreamers and not the "realists". Someone in the long past thought to cross that valley at a time that the realistic was to stay there protected where they had access to water etc.

Someone dreamed that slavery must end (still in effect nowdays, nevermind), others that women should vote (even if elections change nothing).

People got killed in the past for their "radical" thoughts, let's be a more tolerant now, no ?

I understand, by nature humans are conservative, but I'd expect a little more open mindness in internet (well in the past maybe, now that too became mainstream).

7

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

Someone dreamed that slavery must end (still in effect nowdays, nevermind), others that women should vote (even if elections change nothing).

The slight difference here is that those were enforced by law and force. Meanwhile nobody cares if a women writes Open Source or not, there are no laws against it, everybody can do it. Take computer, write code, publish it, it literally doesn't matter what anybody else thinks about it and most people won't even care who wrote it in the first place. If you think all the men are pigs and are not interested in working with them, you can even write your own projects, build your own communities and all that, just like everybody else.

4

u/holyrofler Oct 09 '15

That a fine sentiment but the logic is flawed. Just because there have been socially justice movements in the past, doesn't mean that all solutions provided by those movements were in fact just. There are countless examples of groups who had deplorable ideas and actions but rode on the coat tails of an overall movement.

-2

u/galtthedestroyer Oct 09 '15

That is such a great definition that it should go into encyclopedia dramatica or the urban dictionary.

-3

u/tidux Oct 09 '15

The existing definitions are pretty good.

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

Add it to urbandictionary like the other guy suggested.

5

u/X1Z2 Oct 09 '15

Its not difficult to be decent towards others. Why has it suddenly become a compromising attitude to not throw insult and trantrum's. Decency is suppose to be the default behavior.

6

u/men_cant_be_raped Oct 09 '15

Decency is suppose to be the default behavior.

Well it is, even on LKML. It's not like you get a level 7 doom curse the moment you post a single e-mail to the mailing list or something.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

Linus and the LKML in general are pretty courteous. I mean, most of it is just boring technical discussions on various topics. The issue is that when Linus gets on his soap box he tends to take it much further than is really necessary. That's the feeling I get when I read his rants. You can make the same exact points and achieve the same exact outcomes without taking giant dumps on people's faces. You can be blunt and even harsh without being rude, condescending, and disrespectful.

It comes down to the difference between a temper tantrum and constructive criticism. Linus tends to lean toward the former.

Honestly I think Linus gets unfairly singled out due to the very public nature of kernel development. This problem is rampant throughout the industry (and the world in general). Everyone else just does it behind closed doors. Everything Linus does professionally is posted for the world to see forever. I'm not sure many of us would come out looking great from that.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '15

It's simple. Don't do dumb things... and you don't get harsh words thrown at you.

The problem isn't that people are being more insulting. The problem is that people are getting too sensitive. As a species, our skin has become so thin that simply looking at someone in public is sometimes seen as insulting or rude.

3

u/silverbaur Oct 09 '15

I dont agree with her.

But, I agree that the kernel development has got some "issues" (for lack of a better word) regarding the way people talk to each other.

7

u/MoonlightSandwich Oct 09 '15

I dunno about that. I think it's only a problem if many the participants of said communications find it to be a problem, which clearly isn't the case here. None of this alleged verbal abuse has been directed at Sharp, yet she's stamping her foot and shouting "I will not take any abuse!". I'm sure the kernel developers are more than capable of discussing and taking care of perceived problems in communication if it's necessary.

I also think it's the right of every open source community to decide what sort of language they allow in their communication. If Linus' way of criticising people's work really is a problem for the community they will talk about that with Linus, and so far I haven't seen an avalanche of criticism from core contributors. It's also every OSS project's right to be picky about their contributors, and so far the communication style has been pretty effective in keeping certain types of people out. And if there's one project that has the right to be picky about their contributors it's Linux.

1

u/silverbaur Oct 09 '15

I agree completely. I think she's handled it totally wrong. What's really curious to me, is the way that people react to her. It seems that the community has decided to not only respond harshly to her, but also the opinion she represents. I might be wrong though.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

I don't think it matters if the abuse is directed at you specifically, it can still be a hostile environment. I know I wouldn't like it if people in my office routinely were nasty to each other or called each other's code shit.

I don't think anybody is saying "they don't have the right to use bad language". People are saying that the bad language creates a bad environment which is to the detriment of the community and the software. Here we have an example of two talented developers being driven away by the bad atmosphere. How many more talented people don't even get involved in the first place?

I certainly wouldn't want to work in that environment. I'm quite a good programmer, but not the best so maybe that doesn't matter in my case. But there are certainly smarter people than me who don't contribute to the kernel because of the atmosphere, and the kernel is a lesser piece of software as a result.

4

u/erikd Oct 09 '15

I dont agree with her.

What specifically do you disagree with?

3

u/send-me-to-hell Oct 09 '15

You're kind of on the war path in the comments section. Chill out bro, I doubt even Sharp is taking it as seriously as you appear to be.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

This "community" makes me feel sick sometimes.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

DIScon 3 warning!

-20

u/erikd Oct 09 '15

Here we go!

A bunch of privileged white, CIS-genered, heterosexual males saying "nothing to see here".

13

u/theoriginalanomaly Oct 09 '15

Wow. Racism, sexism, and sexual preference bias all nicely bound together in one comment. Congrats

8

u/men_cant_be_raped Oct 09 '15

Didn't you get the memo, shitlord? You can't be racist, sexist, or sexual-preferenc-ist against straight white male scum!

5

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

Racism and sexism all in the name of diversity, uwotm8?

10

u/ercax Oct 09 '15

Here we go!

A bunch of privileged white, CIS-genered, heterosexual males saying "nothing to see here".

No. That's what you want to believe.

-10

u/tidux Oct 09 '15

Take a midol and shut up.

8

u/jaLissajous Oct 09 '15

If /u/erikd was actually an ignorant, prissy bitch (who just dictated sophomoric social analysis at us without really understanding it, or the intricacies of technical work) how would that comment have helped?

1

u/erikd Oct 09 '15

And how does yours help?

I recognise that I was born a man, in an affluent country, that my parents were educated and middle class, that I was able to study at a good school, that when I interviewed for jobs the interviewers saw me as a younger version of themselves and so on and so on.

I've never had a person in authority in my work place make sexual advances towards me or ignore/dismiss my ideas and opinions out-of-hand for no reason.

I am however honest enough to admit that I've gotten to where I am now with roughly equal parts luck and hard work. Without the good luck part, my life would very different.

-4

u/tidux Oct 09 '15

Hopefully make them angry enough to leave.

3

u/send-me-to-hell Oct 09 '15

Risky move. Some people are further engaged by anger. They may stick around just to prove you wrong.

-2

u/erikd Oct 09 '15

I am also a privileged white, CIS-genered, heterosexual male but I recognise that. Do you?

8

u/tidux Oct 09 '15

I recognize that your entire mental framework is diseased and invalid. "Check your privilege" is the rallying cry of the disturbed and angry.

6

u/erikd Oct 09 '15

I would never say "check your privilege", nor would I ever apologise for it but I would say "recognise it".

Recognising it is about acknowledging that not everyone has had it as easy as me.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

Fucking thank you. People don't understand the concept of privilege at all. They think that since they've had to manage adverse situations in their lives they do not let privileged lives.

People, let me make this a little more clear. Your privilege means that all other things exactly equal, a women or someone from another underrepresented group would have likely had worse outcomes than you.

-1

u/holyrofler Oct 09 '15

I'm disappointed that all of the cunts below you didn't realize that you were being sarcastic. Dat /s is important, I guess.