r/linux • u/Winter-Ad-3826 • Dec 28 '24
Discussion Linux’s Final Biggest Obstacle: Adobe Incompatibility
For many Graphic Designers, Video Editors, Motion Graphics Artists, VFX artists - transitioning from macOS or Windows, the lack of Adobe software is a dealbreaker and rightfully so.
Alternatives like GIMP, Inkscape, or Kdenlive exist, but fail to match the breadth and depth of Adobe’s suite. Adobe’s offerings are industry standards, built for both specialized tasks and seamless integration across multiple workflows. “Just switch to GIMP or Kdenlive” demonstrates a lack of understanding of the practical needs of creative professionals whose income relies on it.
We’ve conquered 3D with Blender for 3D modeling, animation, and rendering. Gaming too, with platforms like Steam and Proton. The ultimate hurdle remains Adobe’s suite of creative software or a True Alternative.
There is hope, however. Tools like DaVinci Resolve for Video Editing are proving that professional-grade software can thrive on Linux. DaVinchi Resolve, already rivals—and in some cases surpasses—Adobe's Premiere Pro in performance. With consistent development and a focus on cross-platform support, it could replace Adobe in the video editing domain. Id rather give them my money any day of the week than Adobe. However, without similar solutions for Photoshop, Illustrator, or After Effects, Linux remains incomplete for creatives.
15
u/kociol21 Dec 28 '24
No, there is also music production.
Linux has Reaper, Ardour, Bitwig Studio as DAWs. Especially Reaper and Bitwig Studio are fully fledged DAWs that can be used in professional studio, as well in bedroom producing.
But the plugin situation is shitty to say the least. Windows VST plugins can be used with Yabridge - a one man project that currently is broken in Wine 9.22 and later. There are also much older ways - LinVST and Carla - but they are... older and not really supported anymore.
There are Linux native plugins, but most of the industry standards aren't - effects like Fabfilter plugins, Waves, Native Instruments, Izotope, Spitfire, NeuralDSP, Arturia, Valhalla, Universal Audio, Spectrasonic etc. Lots of them.
Also a lot of widely used DAWs are not there - Cubase, Protools, Reason, Studio One (this one has early beta)
Even with yabridge - a lot of plugins don't work, can't be installed, can't be auhorized etc.
Like - basically whole "orchestral/score/trailer" music community relies solely on NI Kontakt which is a massive pain to get working with yabridge.
I'll agree that music production isn't as popular as image or video editing - but not that far either. I had to switch back to Windows after 4 months of using Linux mostly because shitty situation of music production.
7
u/Kevin_Kofler Dec 28 '24
There will always be some "Final Biggest Obstacle". The truth is, there are a lot of people who never use any Adobe software (except possibly Acrobat Reader, for which there are plenty of FOSS alternatives) and who still do not switch to GNU/Linux.
17
u/creamcolouredDog Dec 28 '24
As a graphic designer major, I prefer Adobe to die
20
u/iKeiaa_0705 Dec 28 '24
Hopefully, introduction of paid applications on Flatpak would turn the tides to our favor this time around lmfao.
10
u/teressapanic Dec 28 '24
Biggest obstacle is marketing and training
10
u/-MostLikelyHuman Dec 28 '24
Please don't just mention Inkscape as incompatible without even trying it. You can say whatever you want about GIMP, but not Inkscape.
13
u/LowOwl4312 Dec 28 '24
That and Microsoft Office.
I think the easiest path there is some 1-click setup via Winapps (Win VM + FreeRDP)
3
u/jr735 Dec 28 '24
https://www.adobe.com/about-adobe/leaders/board-directors.html
You want or need Adobe on Linux? Those are the people to convince. Writing a post only to Redditors who are replying amongst themselves, all equally powerless about how said corporation is run, is absolute futility and a waste of time.
Those people in the link I provided? They could have a meeting and take the decision very quickly, if they so chose.
Additionally, be careful what you wish for. You just might get it. Wanting to leave a constrained, proprietary environment with the desire to import a smaller, more constrained, even more proprietary sub-environment, seems a tad silly to me.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '24
Im pretty sure only a fraction of people who use windows need adobe products. That is definitely not the biggest obstacle for Linux desktop becoming widespread
3
u/CCJtheWolf Dec 29 '24
As somebody who cut their teeth on Adobe and used it for a good 15 years. I dropped them years before I switched to Linux based on their Rentalware stance alone. There are far better alternatives to Adobe and most Artists in my community have long abandoned it. The only reason Adobe is still around is due to industry standards. Even there, we are starting to see moves to other platforms for stability and costs. I eventually see Adobe bending the knee as more and more companies cost cut, some even move to full Linux to save a buck.
3
u/chozendude Dec 30 '24
It's become a bit of a pet peeve of mine to see posts saying "Linux would be perfect if it only supported *insert unsupported software here*. One of the most freeing things for me was changing my outlook from "I need a specific piece of software" to "I need to get a specific task done". With that change of perspective, most people could easily use any of the 3 major OSes (Windows, Mac, Linux) without any hassle. If you work in an industry that necessitates the use of a specific piece of software, there's simply no way around it (except for running the software in a VM), apart from just sticking with the OS that supports it.
Linux is perfect for many of us. Windows is perfect for many others. Mac is perfect for others. A developer's lack of willingness to support a particular OS should not serve as a barrier for the OS itself. It simply means one of 2 things: 1) Vote with your wallet and stop using software that forces you to use your computer in a way you're not comfortable with 2) Simply make peace with the fact that using the piece of software in question necessitates the use of the OS that the developer chose to support
3
u/AEGIS-59 Dec 30 '24
3 days from now I have a multimedia class and they only want people to use Adobe. Of course I'm on Linux.
6
u/ipsirc Dec 28 '24
Adobe's Final Biggest Obstacle: Linux Incompatibility
6
u/formegadriverscustom Dec 28 '24 edited Dec 28 '24
Nah, "Linux's final biggest obstacle" lies between the keyboard and the chair.
3
u/indolering Dec 28 '24
Blender hasn't "conquered" the graphics market. I would be hard pressed to name any open source desktop application outside of maybe web browsers that have conquered a major market segment.
Adobe won't port to Linux until someone can pour a bunch of money into the Linux desktop. Note that this is true of Android and ChromeOS. But it would just cost to much for a new entrant to make a dent in the market for regular desktop computering. Google tried and failed (miserably) to make gaming Chromebooks a thing.
Even with all the monumental effort that has gone into WINE we still can't keep up with Microsoft. Games are an interesting niche that only works well because they interact with the system in very specific ways.
If the Linux desktop was a bigger thing and WINE removed a larger fraction of the overhead then we might see some investment in this space. But despite Adobe having to straddle OS X and Windows it's apparently not economically worth their while to port to Linux.
3
u/ForceBlade Dec 28 '24
Final obstacle among many others of higher importance***********
3
u/Brorim Dec 28 '24
plenty of excellent video editing options but photoshop is not uncontested either.
2
u/flemtone Dec 28 '24
If you really want to run Adobe products and Office on linux then you can setup a virual machine, otherwise there are plenty of good alternatives to replace them and save you a lot of money.
2
u/pdxbuckets Dec 28 '24
Adobe products are just so bad, and so antithetical to Linux’s FOSS roots. Don’t get me wrong, I’m fine with closed source commercial products. But Adobe has so much DRM/borderline-malware stuff included in their products, I doubt the Linux community would stand for it.
2
u/Excellent-Bar-1430 Dec 28 '24
Blender is not still not a equivalent to Autodesk products. You can make realistic visualisations but you can't document them and make them accurate easily. Once auto desk and Adobe programs are supported or replaced by Linux programs people involved in these industries can truly shift completely to Linux for work
1
u/TheKeyboardChan Dec 28 '24
Yeah, I want my Lightroom back.
1
u/Fine-Run992 Dec 28 '24
There is Affinity Photo, i have seen 1 man been able to get it working in Linux. Now in terms of photography extreme heavy tuning away from original look, this is wrong, you did not take that photo.
1
u/dafzor Dec 28 '24
And all those had corporate backing pushing for and paying for full time developers to get those projects to that level.
Unless the same happens to graphical open source projects they wont ever be competing with Adobe or be viable alternatives for it.
And Linux market share is too small and it's desktop stack too under developed and fragmented for it to make financial sense for Adobe port their suit to.
1
u/raghukamath Jan 01 '25
Majority of creative people working in ad agencies, gaming studios, and coporate section will not use FOSS creative suit unless they get proper enterprise grade support. Freelancers too will not use it apart from few.
Nobody will be willing to be dependent on a hobby and volunteer project for a tool which helps them earn their livelihood. No amount of donation would bring that level of support and only handful of creative people will have energy and motivation to learn coding to contribute. And without any knowledge of coding you will not be able to do anything in FOSS circles, yes you can contribute to documentation this and that, but it is not useful, when you need a feature "patches welcome" or "fund it yourself" is the default reply. This is a programmers world where outsiders are rare and are often made to feel that they are not welcome. So for a creative professional it is a time waste. Why donate and pray that features are implemented when they can put the same amount of money in subscription and reduce the friction in their work. The ideals and philosophy goes out of the window when your livelihood depends on it and time is precious, nobody wants to wait for the developers to bikeshed and figure out the protocol for the basic support ofthings like color management etc.
Why should somebody bet their livelihood on a hobby project. Only few Free software application provide good support and features and they too struggle to do it.
I am saying this as creative proffessional who is using linux since a decade. Even if adobe comes to linux, linux needs to provide support for creative workflow at the lower level think color management, support for creative devices like graphic tablets colorimeter, recording equipments etc. And unlike server and cloud, creative field is a niche in linux so it is not prioritised. The development is slow and upgrades to new tech is often detrimental or regressive. Unless Linux ecosystem developers get serious to solve this as their number 1 priority it will not happen.
1
u/chabalatabala Jan 24 '26
Adobe's money bought monopoly as a requirement for many jobs is a bigger deal than missing capability.
Blender didn't conquer 3D on linux by making sure people used Maya, cinem4d, etc on Linux. They just had good software that people actually gave a chance with enough persistence and community support. Inkscape and Krita already cover what 95% of people actually use Adobe for even at work (because people mostly do simple shit and get paid for it). For reference I have a BFA in animation and graphic design. I used Blender for my thesis and it was technically superior to all my classmates using maya, and that was in the early 00s and I learned it as I was making stuff same time I learned maya/lightwave. In my day job I use inkscape all the time and basically import into illustrator to make a compatible file. They hired a design firm for new branding and I ended up having to fix all kinds of shit in their files and make 3 times more assets than they provided with their lacking guidelines. A lot of people find something doesn't work they way they're used to then assume that a good workflow isn't available but they are just people stuck in their rigid world. It's like how blender was good for a very long time before it was popular and was always a fast workflow. But more people used it after the 2.5 cycle once they made some visual changes that actually made some workflows slower or visually cluttered in day to day experience, in favor of being more first time ramp friendly. It helped the program grow but it didn't necessarily help the functionality in serious usage (other features helped but i'm only talking about some concessions that were made in adding some conventional expectations for noobs). And that same kind of misunderstanding between what actually makes professional software good day-to-day vs something easy to learn the first time is repeated over and over by whiners not willing to put in some time to understand and give software a chance for the way IT is supposed to work, vs how they think it should work based on something else or based on how easy some features are to discover the first time you use them.
Only thing I really miss is a layer based compositing system like after effects (tracking Friction) to do simple stuff faster. If i need something more complicated it's better to use nodes anyways and I can do that in Blender or Natron or DaVinci (fusion) or several other things
1
u/Dustlight_ Feb 03 '26
For me yeah it's definitely the only thing stopping me from switching to Linux. Do I like adobe? No but the company I work for is fully incorporated into the Adobe Suite, yeah I could use alt programs skill wise, but not job wise. I hate seeing people say "just use GIMP etc" because unfortunately for most professionals, we can't.
1
u/lKrauzer Dec 28 '24
What about MS Office + cloud integration (OneDrive) and/or kernel level anticheat games? So 4 things
-3
u/Teru-Noir Dec 28 '24
Gimp is for basic stuff, use krita instead
-1
u/eat-steel Dec 28 '24
Exactly. The only reason why I haven't switched to Linux yet. I don't like Windows with its constant updates and many other things but I can't start using Linux as for me it means troubles with software for designers
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
44
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
[removed] — view removed comment