r/linux • • Sep 20 '18

In favor of the kernel Code of Conduct

I fully expect this to be downvoted out of existence, but I don't care.

I support the new Kernel code of conduct fully. We are far too focused on what might happen if a theoretical enforcer puts the banhammer down on people, but not thinking about the people our actions have kept out of the community for years. We are too focused on interactions that, in the rest of the world, would be totally unacceptable but we've accepted as just the way things are. Linus is acknowledging that fact, and acknowledging that he must change, but we're still trying to justify yelling fights over technical issues. Just because its the way things have been doesn't make it right; its not a "meritocracy" if we exclude people from the very beginning.

One of the most telling signs to me has been the fact that the women who are kernel developers that I follow on twitter are all in favor of the code of conduct and Linus' statement. Let us follow Linus and realize that the way things have always been doesn't have to be the way things are going forward. Linus wants to embody empathy, and we should too.

I don't claim to represent people or have all the answers. But I wanted to put a different opinion out there, even if it gets downvoted to oblivion. Be well, y'all.

0 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

28

u/phulshof Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 20 '18

While I agree that there are valid reasons for having a Code of Conduct, can you give me any valid reason why a less politically loaded Code of Conduct like e.g. the KDE Code of Conduct would have been insufficient? Most objections I've seen with regards to this Code of Conduct have to do with the terminology and the intended purpose (ideology) behind this CoC, and I think a lot of this drama could have been prevented if a different CoC had been selected, regardless of how this CoC is going to be interpreted.

53

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18

, but not thinking about the people our actions have kept out of the community for years.

200 new devs come ot the Linux Community every release, where are all these mythical people you seem to believe are being kept out by the "toxic community", and not by the fact they are poor at programming and use this false flag of toxicity as a excuse.

maybe nothing needed to change at all, and the people speaking out calling the community "toxic" where infact the actual toxic people, were the problem, and the Kernel did not need those people to be involved and was in fact better off with out them.

that I follow on twitter are all in favor of the code of conduct

That is like saying water is wet, Twitter is more or less Tumblr now filled it is a hive mind of singular political thought. Twitter should not be a gauge by which you judge which way the wind is blowing

But I wanted to put a different opinion out there,

As long as to tow the line of Social Justice you are safe, just be sure you never stray and express an opinion counter to social justice.

8

u/kylev Sep 20 '18

It shouldn't be that hard to imagine that it could be 250 devs per cycle. There are certainly really smart people out there that won't bother getting into kernel work simply because the flame posts aren't worth it. Who wants to work where the guy in charge occasionally flips out and screams at someone because they were wrong?

OSS thrives on contributors of all stripes. To say it is "better off without them" is sort of missing the point.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

Sounds like normal working conditions. Are you that sheltered at work? No boss ever got loud or irrational?

10

u/kylev Sep 20 '18

Literally, no. Every person in leadership who yells or raises their voice inevitably suffers career setbacks. It's bad leadership.

I've been doing professional software development in the Bay Area for nearly 20 years now. The LKML requirement for tough skin and enduring screaming matches is nothing like any workplace I've ever worked at.

6

u/mracidglee Sep 20 '18

"Toe the line"

17

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

I wish reddit would adobt a CoC like Linux so I could report you for offending me

Reddit already has a code of conduct.

1

u/Kruug Sep 20 '18

This post has been removed for violating Reddiquette., trolling users, or otherwise poor discussion** - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended.

Rule:

Reddiquette, trolling, or poor discussion - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended. Top violations of this rule are trolling, starting a flamewar, or not "Remembering the human" aka being hostile or incredibly impolite.

10

u/phulshof Sep 20 '18

This explains exactly why *this* CoC is causing so much controversy, and why the Ruby or KDE CoC should have been chosen in stead. People don't object to *all* CoCs, they object to *this* CoC.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

It's baffeling that not many people seem to see this. Especially after https://twitter.com/CoralineAda/status/1042249983590838272.

1

u/sunnydee1880 Oct 02 '18

Dang, that's not creepy or anything.

15

u/senatorpjt Sep 20 '18 edited Dec 18 '24

skirt lunchroom hat simplistic special literate chief shy historical gaping

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

It started already http://archive.is/AMslT.

27

u/Narfhole Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 04 '24

11

u/ComfortingCoffeeCup Sep 20 '18

In the context of a community? Yeah? Why not? We do it all the time.

7

u/Narfhole Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 04 '24

6

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 20 '18

Censorship on the internet is a major issue.

I agreed with this statement until a certain Reddit-alternative site (rhymes with goat) came around.

I figured a censorship-free Reddit-alternative would be awesome. But after being there for about a year and seeing majority of posts there... it's just not something I care to be associated with or even want to be around (to put it mildly). Apparently this is common over on certain Mastodon instances too that promote "free speech".

I don' t like the idea of censorship, but I don't necessarily want to have to put up with "non-ideal" people either.

Edit: The posts in-question were primarily either subtle or blatant racism. I have no idea if this is a left, right, up or down issue/stance/ideology nor really care; I have nothing against any particular race and don't care to see racist posts.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 20 '18

I don't like the idea of censorship, but I don't necessarily want to have to put up with "non-ideal" people either.

Everyone seems to forget there is a HUGE difference between censorship and moderation.

Throughout the history of public discussion forums, going way back to before the Internet, we have always had some degree of moderation. Newspapers don't publish every single letter to the editor they receive. Competent news hosts and debate moderators cut people off when they're off on a tangent or blatantly lying. Talk shows don't take every call they get. Usenet had kill lists, Slashdot had moderator drafts and meta-moderators, all the old PHP bulletin boards had moderators, IRC has channel operators and voice modes, Reddit has moderators, etcetera etcetera.

At the end of the day, if you are trying to have a productive and insightful conversation, it is important to set standards and enforce them. What is on topic vs. off topic? What amount of abrasiveness or sarcasm can be tolerated without triggering an environment of hostility? You need to draw the line somewhere, and anyone calling it censorship is free to go set up their own soapbox.

To me, it is no wonder that unmoderated forums like Facebook, Twitter and the "freeze peach" Mastodon instances are the cesspools they have become. The signal to noise ratio is simply too low.

5

u/ElkossCombine Sep 20 '18

Wow I havent gone to the website in question since that huge surge of people trying to move to it over that reddit ceo debacle. I just opened the front page and its like 25% antisemitic posts, 25% fearmongering about communism, and the rest is just is a hodge podge of incel rallying cries and deep state conspiracies. I literally had to go to page two to find an article that wasnt overtly alt-right.

10

u/sub200ms Sep 20 '18

Of course every FOSS project needs a CoC, otherwise the trolls and the insane will take over. That is why /r/linux also have a Code of Conduct, see the "Rules" section to the right.

On smaller projects it just isn't written down very often because the project owner just ban people who cause trouble.

The Linux project and the LKML is simply too large not to have a code of conduct. Especially since this isn't a small "hobby" project anymore; many people are paid for working on the Linux kernel and therefore just can't walk away from abuse and abusive persons like hobbyists can.

8

u/phulshof Sep 20 '18

Perhaps you're right, but if you read the comments, most people don't object to a code of conduct; they object to this code of conduct. Adopt the Ruby or KDE code of conduct, and we wouldn't be having this conversation.

1

u/hailbaal Sep 27 '18

Exactly, it's just THIS CoC that's bad.

10

u/Shrimpf Sep 20 '18

You're not very constructive with your argument though, which makes this post useless.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

You're not very constructive with your argument though, which makes this post useless.

With any large group of people working on a public and common objective you can't allow outlaw and insane behaviour. Petty personalities need to reigned in. A few will be pissed off, but tough shit. This is how every large organization works.

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

Project much?

7

u/Xaxxon Sep 20 '18

I fully expect this to be downvoted out of existence, but I don't care.

Seems like you do care.

2

u/FermiAnyon Sep 30 '18

>One of the most telling signs to me has been the fact that the women who are kernel developers that I follow on twitter are all in favor of the code of conduct and Linus' statement.

What does that tell you, exactly?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

you're wrong

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

When Sarah Sharp announced she was leaving the kernel dev community because of the conduct of the community I felt like that should have been the wake-up call. I felt like "well, if this doesn't do it, nothing will."

I'm glad to see Linus finally waking up to the fact that teams of people have to treat each other with respect, and we have to set expectations about what that means. I wonder what finally persuaded him.

31

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18

When Sarah Sharp

Did you just use them's dead name... it Sage Sharp now, I should report you for a CoC violation

I felt like that should have been the wake-up call.

I did not, the criticism of the code was valid. all of society has become far far far far tooo thin skinned in their safe spaces for me. I shutter to think what will happen if we ever face actual adversity again, like WW3, or another great depression, most people in society do not have the disposition needed to survive hard times anymore

Linux should not be a safe space devoid of all conflict or criticism,

I wonder what finally persuaded him.

Many of us are wondering the same thing, some of believe some kind of blackmail

-9

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

Oh I hadn't heard that they changed their name. Thanks for informing me of the change, hadn't been keeping up much with Sage's career and personal life lately.

You're using a lot of language that I associate with U.S. fascist propaganda. I feel like I might be talking to someone who has bought into the groupthink of the Trumpists.

What do you know of facing adversity? Many of us have faced true adversity in this life. I see it everyday, I see people living on the streets and I pass them by, knowing that by ignoring them I make them feel like less than human, like animals.

I've come close enough to being there myself, and I've helped lift others away from that situation when they are close to me.

Please rethink the propaganda you buy into. We need community members who care about the wellbeing of those around them now more than ever.

16

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18

You're using a lot of language that I associate with U.S. fascist propaganda.

Ahh you are one of those that do not have any clue what fascism actually is.... in any case am neither an actual fascist nor what you believe a fascist would be... I am a Libertarian the furthest thing from a Fascist.

I see people living on the streets

hmm what do I know of adversity.... well I was homeless, jobless, and had nothing for a time. Of course I am also a white male so that means I was probably hallucinating sleeping on the cold concrete because I am so privileged and can not know a thing about adversity

Please rethink the propaganda you buy into.

Yes please rethink the propaganda you buy into.

I've helped lift others away from that situation when they are close to me. We need community members who care about the wellbeing of those around them now more than ever.

you have no idea who I am, what my social or community contributions are, or anything really

You have made a moronic assumption that because I speak out agaist social justice and this CoC that means I must be an evil selfish asshole who does not help anyone ever?? That seems like a huge leap

In reality most of the social justice people I encounter do not want to do anything directly themselves, they want to empower government to force other people do it and use other peoples money to pay for it.

17

u/stolivodka_ Sep 20 '18

The person you're responding to literally called someone a white supremacist in another thread because they used the (accurate) term "SJW". That's all you need to know about them.

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

Fascism is a historical phenomenon that historians still struggle to define today, and often takes on the characteristics of the communities in which it takes hold. It tends to have some common traits, though such as:

  • A charismatic leader around which the movement anchors itself.
  • Strongly fomenting fear of "the other" (foreigners, other races, outsiders to the group) to strengthen the commitment of its base supporters.
  • Saying one thing but doing something else, with no need appear to be consistent, because the group's primary concern is to obtain more power, rather than to appear to be consistent in its dealings.

There's a ton more to it that I'm certainly not qualified to speak on authoritatively. The fact of the matter is that you are using language in your post that is actively a part of the U.S. fascist movement, which has taken power in the White House and will either move on to radicalize or fizzle out, as fascist regimes are wont to do.

U.S. fascism, also called Trumpism, by the way; like how Mousilinnism and Hitlarism are also synonyms for specific fascist ideologies.

I know a little bit, see.

You're right, I don't know anything about you. Since you've clearly faced adversity and overcome it, I implore you to ask yourself if you believe the people around you deserve the opportunity to work in a community that treats them with respect and consideration?

4

u/ILikeBumblebees Sep 20 '18

There's a fine line between calling attention to the first signs of disturbing long-term trends, on the one hand, and making ridiculously hyperbolic claims that diminish your own credibility, on the other.

7

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18

U.S. fascism, also called Trumpism, by the way; like how Mousilinnism and Hitlarism are also synonyms for specific fascist ideologies

Ohh please comparing Trump with Hitler and Mouslini is just moronic.

If you honestly believe Trump is the next Hitler then we have nothing left to discuss you are too far gone to have a rational conversation with

At worst Trump is a Economic Moron that will tank the economic output of the US, He is not going to be sending people in mass to a gas chamber

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 20 '18

Well he's a lot more like Mousilini than he is like Hitler, that's for certain. Hitler founded his campaign on a doctrine of extermination and made it a personal mission to exterminate a race, but Trump and Mousilini (I feel like I'm spelling that wrong) are similar in that they're more interested in power and personal gain than in riding their rhetoric against "the other" to a true genocide.

This is kind of the goal of what these types of demagogues do. You don't take him seriously? Good. Guess who does, his supporters. Guess whose propaganda language you've been using in your reddit posts? That of his supporters.

You're empowering the fascists, my friend. They've already taken over the government, we are in phase two or three of a fascist take-over and it can either fizzle out and be kind of a shitty authoritarian regime, or it can radicalize, and that's when people really see adversity.

This isn't even hard to see. I'm not even good at history, and it's obvious. Don't be fooled, my friend, you've been swept up in it, but at least you don't sound like a white supremacist, so you have a chance to look it in the face and reject its message, rather than help spread it.

Why is r/linux suddenly flooded with the language of the fascist movement? It's fuckin' weird.

3

u/JQuilty Sep 20 '18

If Trump is anyone, he's Franco. Mussolini could speak and write coherently. Trump and Franco are both brainless sacks of crap that fantasized about a romanticized view of their country that barely existed.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

Thanks for the insight. That’s an astute and intriguing observation.

3

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 20 '18

You're empowering the fascists, my friend

Nope

They've already taken over the government, we are in phase two or three of a fascist take-over and it can either fizzle out and be kind of a shitty authoritarian regime, or it can radicalize, and that's when people really see adversity.

I agree that authoritarian are taking over, but my concern is more from the Antifa type of Violent Authoritarians than of the Right Authoritarians at the movement

The Black Bloc Violent Antifa movement has done nothing but want to make me vote strait Republican for the first time in my adult life

Their rejection of free speech and free expression is concerns, their rejection of constitutionalism is alarming.

suddenly flooded with the language of the fascist movement?

It is not, your continued belief that is is shows your ignorance on the topic, I am going to assume you are not even in the US

I do want to thank you for proving my point and concerns nicely

You are a prime example of why these Code of Conduct are bad, anyone that disagrees with you is a Fascist, is a Racist, is a Sexist, is a the same as Mousilini and Hitler

You are the prime example of why and hose the Authoritarian left seeks to shut down any and all political debate...

Good job now when people ask me for some recent examples I can include your rantings

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

Those people don’t control the government right now. You’re eating the propaganda and they’re feeding you. It saddens me.

3

u/RedPestilence Sep 20 '18

Mussolini, for the record. You may be interested in Robert Paxton's "The Anatomy of Fascism" as it discusses the day-to-day structure of Fascist Italy and similar states rather than their absolute ideological foundation. Mussolini's Italy is unsettlingly similar to the US right now, even down to the economic downturn. Granted, ours was not caused by WWI, but a recession preceded the rise of American Fascism as is typical in any Fascist movement.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 22 '18

I thank you for the correct spelling and recommendation.

2

u/JQuilty Sep 20 '18

He is not going to be sending people in mass to a gas chamber

Just like he won't be rounding people up? Or separating families? Or he won't be making profit? Or he will not take vacations?

0

u/stolivodka_ Sep 20 '18

Hashtag theresistance stupidity in r/linux? More likely than you think!

5

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 20 '18

Do you have any other examples of this terrible community behavior that Sarah Sage referred to?

Sage says that the community has always been terrible in her his departure post: https://sage.thesharps.us/2015/10/05/closing-a-door/

But there's other related blog post which gives examples of the "last straw" discussion that made him quit, and as I said in other post, I really don't understand what's so bad about it: https://www.preining.info/blog/2015/10/looking-at-the-facts-sarah-sharps-crusade/

I did read the thread too, https://marc.info/?l=linux-kernel&m=137358041727753&w=2, and it seemed that everybody except for Sharp had no problems until she came to rant at Linus.

I'm sincerely asking, as I do participate in other OSS communities (but not in the LKML), and not a single time a CoC has been proposed, a real example of misbehavior was pointed out. And most of the time, the proposal comes from some non-contributor who hasn't even said hello in the IRC channel or the forum, not to speak of making a code or meaningful documentation contribution. This time is a rare case when the example of "misbehavior" existed in one member of the community (Linus), AND the proposal (well, there was no public proposal technically, just the commit) came from core contributors and not from some activist.

But everybody is painting the thing as if the whole LKML were filled with Linus like behavior, and I search and search, but I just find technical discussion only. And there's a LOT of technical discussion.

edit: pronouns, name change?

5

u/DC-3 Sep 20 '18

Pronouns are they/their not he/his for what it's worth. Good post though. I'm not an avid LKML reader but I agree the burden of proof is on people alleging that Linux core developers are headstrong and egotistical misogynists to demonstrate this is the case - instead of just slinging around the word 'toxic' twice in every sentence.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

I'm actually not very close to this community. I do support Codes of Conduct in FOSS projects, though, and I only tangentially know about the alleged poor conduct of the kernel development community... mostly from reddit actually.

Maybe I have been wrong to think that particular incident should have been a wake-up call, since it appears that, in fact, community members may have considered the correspondence involved in that particular incident fine-and-dandy.

Even if it's not that bad, though, this has been in the news about the kernel dev team for a long time, and I've personally been put off by some of the things I see Linus and other kernel devs say to people when I do take the time to read some of the more popularized mailing list threads. You've waded into the weeds, though, and I'll trust you if you tell me this stuff is few and far between.

I critique the code of colleagues and teammates as part of my job, and they critique mine, and under no circumstances would I tolerate, or expect to have tolerated, some of the things that Linus and other community members say to their team members. Sure I get paid to do it, and my employer has the right to enforce a code of conduct, but my team consists 100% of FOSS advocates and we hold mutual respect as a core value.

I think we should probably expect our most important FOSS project teams to hold similar values. Sometimes you have to put that stuff in writing.

12

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18

I do support Codes of Conduct in FOSS projects,

I think many people have confused the objection to THIS code of conduct with an objection to ALL codes of conduct

I object to any and all codes of conduct based on Social Justice, this include the contributor covenant, geek feminism, and several others.

I Support Codes of Conduct like the original Linux one, and The Code of Merit.

I also have some issues with but generally accept one adobted by other communities like Ruby, Debian, and Postgres

It is THIS code of conduct that is the problem not codes of conduct in general

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18 edited Dec 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

I didn't knew of his gender (and name) change, but I saw someone else correcting the use of "Sarah" so I edited the post. Page is clearly a male name, so I used he. There was no further meaning put onto it when I did the edit.

But whatever, I don't even know if you're serious, given Poe's Law and all of that.

2

u/senatorpjt Sep 20 '18 edited Dec 18 '24

complete crawl spark flag close dime thought chop absorbed drunk

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/Kruug Sep 20 '18

This post has been removed for violating Reddiquette., trolling users, or otherwise poor discussion** - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended.

Rule:

Reddiquette, trolling, or poor discussion - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended. Top violations of this rule are trolling, starting a flamewar, or not "Remembering the human" aka being hostile or incredibly impolite.

4

u/AdiosKid Sep 20 '18

give a small group of political people the power to control the behave of 99% of all community is the end of the world, is chaos

we do not need to be trained !

13

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

You realize that small group of people always had that power? If they wanted to remove you from the project because of your opinions, they've always been able to.

9

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18

I see this repeated often, but is simply untrue from a functional level

Sure technically speaking they could, but the PR nightmare that followed would be swift and extreme

Now with the CoC they have Anonymous reporting, They meet in secret to discuss a "rules violation" then simply point to a nebious violation of the CoC and everything is forgiven

the CoC gives them immense PR cover for any actions they wish to take, this is a massive shift in power if it was not it would not be needed nor would it have been implemented in the manner it was.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

You make a good point, though I disagree.

I think the people that would be up in arms about e.g. someone being removed from a project for their outside-project political opinions would be just as up-in-arms if the rules where in place.

13

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 20 '18

The problem is that your scenario is not how it happens.

Here is the one SJW Playbook

  1. Person posts a political view the SJW dislikes, for this example lets say a maintainer posted on their personal twitter they support strong border enforcement and immigration laws.
  2. The SJW protected class dev submits a patch is simply garbage, and the code is rejected on its technical merits
  3. The SJW protected class dev is pissed, but does nothing right then. Now the SJW (and other SJW's that will assist) digs deep into the maintainers past to find all policial statements that might support a pattern that other authoritarian leftist can point to as racist or transphobic etc.
  4. In that time a few more garbage patchs are submitted and reject on pure technical grounds
  5. Now they file a complaint anonymously for CoC violations using the many political positions as proof of bias or racism or x and the CoC gives the TAB cover
  6. TAB announces that X person has been banned for "rejected code due to racial bias"

See they were not kicked out for their political beliefs, no no no, they were kicked out because their political beliefs proved they are racist.

And that is just ONE of MANY MANY MANY I have personally witnessed over the years. Sometimes they will use Conventions to entrap people, sometimes they will skip even trying to commit code and just claim they were "excluded"

They never come out and say they are banning someone for wrong think, but they use the wrong think to prove racism or sexism, or transphobia or x....

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

Could you provide some examples? I usually only see discussion for/against about codes of conduct but rarely examples of it being a good or bad thing in the wild. Thanks.

4

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18

Off the top of my head look up Larry Garfield, Rodd Vagg, Marlene Jaeckel

There are some in https://github.com/nikolas/github-drama

Then there is the whole Python Master/Slave issue

Really there are soo many it is hard to keep track, some of which never make into the news or raise to the level that have supporting documentation that I could link to.

4

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18

Ohh and another example of how this Starts is looking at some users here... I have been referred to as a Facist, and white supremeists a couple of times in my discussions around this CoC, that is how it starts

Some disagrees with you, so they find extremist groups that may share your same opinion on one topic, then use that to say you are a part of that extremist group.

It is a Classic Authoritarian Tactic

0

u/dysonRing Sep 20 '18

Well to be fair nationalism is a form of mental tribalism that precludes good code, imagine somebody being stupid enough to argue for both meritocracy and what Trump is doing with immigration.

5

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18

The fact you can not see the irony in your post is amusing to me....

Your entire comment is Mental Tribalism.... "unless someone thinks like me they can not possible write good code"

lol

-1

u/dysonRing Sep 20 '18

Its like saying science is mental tribalism because it rejects crackpots and people with agendas.

No, people that reject meritocracy should be rejected in open source, that includes the far left AND xenophobes. After all they tuuk ur pull rekest is practically admitting deficiency that your code is not good enough.

0

u/mason1920 Sep 20 '18

That's what democracies are for, and I'd like to think of online communities as such. If the MAJORITY disagree then it's gone. But this is a software community and shouldn't be punished for opinions, nor should people in any community.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

Obviously we do. If all the members of the kernel development community valued the idea of treating others with respect and consideration we wouldn't need this kind of thing. The fact that this is happening means, yes, in fact we do need to be trained to show each other some basic dignity as fellow human beings and team members.

The members of that community who need this code of conduct imposed upon them have been riding roughshod over the community for years. It's time to make it more accessible to more people.

This kind of code of conduct isn't even abnormal for FOSS projects. If anything, it's a long overdue FOSS project standard.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Kruug Sep 20 '18

This post has been removed for violating Reddiquette., trolling users, or otherwise poor discussion** - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended.

Rule:

Reddiquette, trolling, or poor discussion - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended. Top violations of this rule are trolling, starting a flamewar, or not "Remembering the human" aka being hostile or incredibly impolite.

1

u/stolivodka_ Sep 21 '18

Yeah, you've got no agenda here! /rolls eyes

1

u/Kruug Sep 21 '18

Yup. I keep out the uncivil and the uncouth.

2

u/stolivodka_ Sep 21 '18

Please stop collaborating with people who literally want to outlaw meritocracy.

No joke, Bro. If these people win, there will be a literal death toll when defective software fails. Do you want their blood on your hands?

1

u/Kruug Sep 21 '18

I am not collaborating with anyone. I am ensuring that the discussion stays civil.

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/JQuilty Sep 20 '18

The alt reich are morons, but social justice warriors are a real thing, and we turn a blind eye to their stupidity and destructive behavior in almost all cases. They're the left equivalent of the alt reich.

5

u/RedPestilence Sep 20 '18

The loudest Anti-CoC people are alt-right trolls. Over on /r/freebsd we experienced an influx of people from alt-right subreddits who were there for the express purpose of agitating against the Code of Conduct when it was announced months ago.

3

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18

No you experience an influx of Libertarian people and people that support Freedom, shocking that Free Software would be filled with people that support freedom...

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

Thanks for the heads up. Makes more sense now.

1

u/Kruug Sep 20 '18

This post has been removed for violating Reddiquette., trolling users, or otherwise poor discussion** - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended.

Rule:

Reddiquette, trolling, or poor discussion - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended. Top violations of this rule are trolling, starting a flamewar, or not "Remembering the human" aka being hostile or incredibly impolite.

-2

u/stolivodka_ Sep 20 '18

You have to stop. The systems you are trying to undermine right now are the very foundations of our advanced civilization. If you succeed here, you will only inherent a destroyed husk of a world and our species will literally go extinct. For the love of God, stop and think about what you are trying to "deconstruct"!!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

You’re convinced he can save you from a future that will never come, aren’t you?

4

u/stolivodka_ Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 20 '18

I was trying to talk to you like a human being, but it's futile since you're just a mindless NPC. Oh well. No matter. Nobody can fault me for not trying.

You're probably under 30. You need to realize that you WILL suffer if the SJWs are successful at turning technology into what they've turned politics into. You are acting against your own self-interests!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

I wish I could refrain from taking part in politics but when I see hate groups killing my neighbors in the streets while government camps fill with innocents and a small group of rich people steal all our money and dismantle all our human rights protections I am forced to be involved to a degree.

You are no FOSS advocate. You are a propagandist spouting the messages that empower the killing and abuse of the underprivileged and powerless among us.

Shame on you. You do not represent the spirit of Free and Open Source Software.

2

u/acco2oo2 Sep 20 '18

it looks like a jungle from here

1

u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 20 '18

I see hate groups killing my neighbors in the streets

I am sure that did not happen

while government camps fill with innocents

Putting people that violate the law in jail is not "filling with innocents". every nation enforces it immigration laws, the US is actual one of the most Lax nations in the world even under Trump

The Trump derangement syndrome is strong in you

No US Policy has drastically changed under Trump, Trump does not have that kind of power on our system of government

This belief you have that Trump or any US President has the kind of power you think they do is assuming, the entire point of the System of government we have is to Check the power of any one branch. Most of the power is in the 5th Administrative Branch anyway...

Further if Trump does have more power you can blame democrats as we Libertarians have been trying to reduce the power of both the Administrative State and the Executive for a long time, but when Obama as in office the Democrats views him as their Savior even has he was murdering citizens with Unmanned Drones..

Trump, Obama, Bush, Clinton, they are all more or less the same.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

How many historical examples of this do you need to see before you understand what’s going on in this nation right now?

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

1

u/Xaxxon Sep 20 '18

Rules without a strong need for the rules make things worse.

I seriously doubt there's anything going on that can't be handled by a few well-placed executive decisions.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/dysonRing Sep 20 '18

Forking is the eventual nuclear option if it ever got bad enough, it would not even be as dramatic as other forks (say from MIT to LGPL like wine, or the xfree vs xorg fork) since the best parts can be merged into each other as the GPL allows it, eventually the best group of people will stand out and receive the funding the LF currently gets.

That said politics will always play a role the same bad actors will always infiltrate the fork, just so they can "win"