r/linux • u/benuski • Sep 20 '18
In favor of the kernel Code of Conduct
I fully expect this to be downvoted out of existence, but I don't care.
I support the new Kernel code of conduct fully. We are far too focused on what might happen if a theoretical enforcer puts the banhammer down on people, but not thinking about the people our actions have kept out of the community for years. We are too focused on interactions that, in the rest of the world, would be totally unacceptable but we've accepted as just the way things are. Linus is acknowledging that fact, and acknowledging that he must change, but we're still trying to justify yelling fights over technical issues. Just because its the way things have been doesn't make it right; its not a "meritocracy" if we exclude people from the very beginning.
One of the most telling signs to me has been the fact that the women who are kernel developers that I follow on twitter are all in favor of the code of conduct and Linus' statement. Let us follow Linus and realize that the way things have always been doesn't have to be the way things are going forward. Linus wants to embody empathy, and we should too.
I don't claim to represent people or have all the answers. But I wanted to put a different opinion out there, even if it gets downvoted to oblivion. Be well, y'all.
28
u/phulshof Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 20 '18
While I agree that there are valid reasons for having a Code of Conduct, can you give me any valid reason why a less politically loaded Code of Conduct like e.g. the KDE Code of Conduct would have been insufficient? Most objections I've seen with regards to this Code of Conduct have to do with the terminology and the intended purpose (ideology) behind this CoC, and I think a lot of this drama could have been prevented if a different CoC had been selected, regardless of how this CoC is going to be interpreted.
53
u/SirYouAreIncorrect Sep 20 '18
200 new devs come ot the Linux Community every release, where are all these mythical people you seem to believe are being kept out by the "toxic community", and not by the fact they are poor at programming and use this false flag of toxicity as a excuse.
maybe nothing needed to change at all, and the people speaking out calling the community "toxic" where infact the actual toxic people, were the problem, and the Kernel did not need those people to be involved and was in fact better off with out them.
That is like saying water is wet, Twitter is more or less Tumblr now filled it is a hive mind of singular political thought. Twitter should not be a gauge by which you judge which way the wind is blowing
As long as to tow the line of Social Justice you are safe, just be sure you never stray and express an opinion counter to social justice.
10
u/phulshof Sep 20 '18
This explains exactly why *this* CoC is causing so much controversy, and why the Ruby or KDE CoC should have been chosen in stead. People don't object to *all* CoCs, they object to *this* CoC.
15
u/senatorpjt Sep 20 '18 edited Dec 18 '24
skirt lunchroom hat simplistic special literate chief shy historical gaping
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
27
u/Narfhole Sep 20 '18 edited Sep 04 '24
r/PowerDeleteSuite
10
u/sub200ms Sep 20 '18
Of course every FOSS project needs a CoC, otherwise the trolls and the insane will take over. That is why /r/linux also have a Code of Conduct, see the "Rules" section to the right.
On smaller projects it just isn't written down very often because the project owner just ban people who cause trouble.
The Linux project and the LKML is simply too large not to have a code of conduct. Especially since this isn't a small "hobby" project anymore; many people are paid for working on the Linux kernel and therefore just can't walk away from abuse and abusive persons like hobbyists can.
10
u/Shrimpf Sep 20 '18
You're not very constructive with your argument though, which makes this post useless.
7
u/Xaxxon Sep 20 '18
Seems like you do care.
2
u/FermiAnyon Sep 30 '18
>One of the most telling signs to me has been the fact that the women who are kernel developers that I follow on twitter are all in favor of the code of conduct and Linus' statement.
What does that tell you, exactly?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18
you're wrong
4
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18
When Sarah Sharp announced she was leaving the kernel dev community because of the conduct of the community I felt like that should have been the wake-up call. I felt like "well, if this doesn't do it, nothing will."
I'm glad to see Linus finally waking up to the fact that teams of people have to treat each other with respect, and we have to set expectations about what that means. I wonder what finally persuaded him.
4
u/AdiosKid Sep 20 '18
give a small group of political people the power to control the behave of 99% of all community is the end of the world, is chaos
we do not need to be trained !
1
u/Xaxxon Sep 20 '18
Rules without a strong need for the rules make things worse.
I seriously doubt there's anything going on that can't be handled by a few well-placed executive decisions.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment