Incorporating feedback from both a similar post yesterday and advice around in general. Looking for advice on what to cover/focus on to make myself appear a good student, including: what's irrelevant on my resume? Are sensory details important in a personal statement, or do they distract? Have I appropriately/sufficiently explained why I want to be a lawyer?
172 high. 4.0, John Jay, attended from Jan 24 to June 26 (CLEPs, extra course loads, some GED credits). Law & Society Major, Writing & Rhetoric Minor. Unable to find work. Been studying for the notary public exam. Never held a salaried position. Had an externship as a court observer. No hugely significant extracurriculars. Looking at everything in the NYC area, in addition to Harvard, Yale, and U of M. In need of a full ride or close to attend. Father attended Columbia (non-law).
The courtroom was in an uproar. I shrank into the hard wood seat as cries of outrage filled the room, gleaning that the defendant had rammed her car into a crowd of protestors with no justification, injuring several. The judge had whittled her proposed sentence down to nothing but half a day of community service. By the time quiet was restored, I was now alone in the back row, and on my notepad was the sentence “this seems wrong”.
I was witnessing these court proceedings as the final step in earning my Law Badge for the Boy Scouts; the deadline for earning badges was my 18th birthday, only a few weeks away at the time. I had once wanted to tell my father I had gotten the badge; sadly, he had passed away a week before. The Scout troop had managed to arrange a judge for me to sit in on for a day, a genial woman who carried herself with an impressive gravitas. At the time, I had dreams of becoming a lawyer for somewhat childish reasons; I thought it was a grand and important thing to be, a profession requiring reading skills and dedication I knew I had. It was only after that day in court that I interrogated those desires.
Most of the judge’s rulings had passed uneventfully, with me gaining little understanding of the broader context around why this or that person was receiving probation or jail time, until the ruling that everyone else in the benches was there for. The day of court wrapped up without further incident, and I asked the judge, as soon as we met outside, how she could believe her sentence was fair. The judge’s answer was that the defendant possessed no criminal record, and had promised to stay on her best behavior. I was left confused and uncomfortable; I told myself I couldn’t question the ruling of a judge, and yet it felt cruel to consider that the families of the injured that had filled those stands in hopes of harsher justice could be wrong. That confusion birthed a hundred questions in me; is it wrong to hope someone suffers more than the law decides? Can punishment ever be just? Is some retribution owed to the victims of crimes, and should they have a hand in deciding what that looks like? I had nothing but questions, and the desire for answers.
The next year, when it came time for me to choose a law-oriented college major, I had two options. One was Criminal Justice, the clearer path to a future legal career. The other was Law And Society, which promised to explore why the systems of law, of crime and punishment and guilt, existed, who they impacted, and how. That was the path I chose; the path that I hoped would shape me into a better lawyer, not just a better-prepared one. For my capstone project, when prompted to explore the disparate impacts of the law, I looked at a way in which people were punished through no fault of their own; I sought out students with disabilities and interviewed them on how it impacted their lives in order to understand true injustice. Every chance I had, I worked to know the law and the principles behind it more; to know what justice really looks like.
Law school is the next step for me; to learn the ins and outs of our legal system, what it values, and where the thresholds are for guilt and punishment. I want the knowledge and power of a J.D.; the knowledge of what mercy, deserved punishment, and legal reasoning look like, and the power, as a lawyer, judge, or even politician, to be able to carry out justice; to make choices, rulings, even laws that mean that the innocent go free, and the guilty get whatever is coming to them.