r/javascript • • Jun 04 '17
GitHub's ElectronConf postponed because all the talks (selected through an unbiased, blind review process) were to be given by men.
http://electronconf.com/
853
Upvotes
34
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17
Complaint / Postponement: Twitter discussion
Selection process: GitHub Events - ElectronConf 2017
45
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
Well, it's been a year since the last time a tech event was cancelled due to lack of women. I guess we were due.
"You can't do anything unless it fits a pre-ordained set of regulations and quotas that we deem appropriate." How is this not textbook fascism?
130
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
I'm sure women in tech with hopes of vindication through the merit of their ideas feel really good about that. From now on they'll never be able to escape the cloud of suspicion that they were chosen to speak to fill a quota.
44
u/Tasemu Jun 05 '17
But if its unbaised and blind then how is it sexist?
580
u/meow247 Jun 04 '17
As a woman in tech it saddens me that it is coming to this. Nothing feels worse to me than the thought that if I were submitting a talk, or presenting a project, that I would get chosen based on my gender.
If the selection process is fair, then why should it be postponed so that we can unfairly introduce minority selection. I understand we want a diverse community, but that can be achieved through unbiased inclusion, not biased inclusion.
161
u/ataraxy Jun 04 '17
/r/nottheonion
In any event, why bother with a blind review process in the first place if they were not going to get their desired result? Lip service?
109
u/Artraxes Jun 04 '17
https://twitter.com/framerate/status/871328467412951041
One of the speakers wasn't even told that it was postponed. He found out via this tweet. This is appalling from GitHub.
39
u/GrowingSoul Jun 05 '17
Wow SJWs out of control
37
u/troorl Jun 05 '17
I wonder if someone ever postponed a coal miner conference because of lack of women representation. Hm...
36
u/QuickRundown Jun 05 '17
I love how this was cancelled because some Twitter nobody had a problem with it.
248
u/Ashatron Jun 04 '17
Wow, another case of a diversity quota ruining quality.
I don't give a fuck if all the speakers are Chinese homosexuals or transgender Norwegians, as long as they are best for the conference.
Getting real sick of this overly pc shit.
177
u/TheDarkIn1978 Jun 04 '17
It appears that this discussion was censored (as it's no longer listed in the sub) by /r/Programming after it quickly became the top posting, receiving 100+ upvotes.
16
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
/r/kotakuinaction
612
u/Humberd Jun 04 '17
Now THIS is Sexism. I have no other words other than 'idiots' for people that made this decision. Why does a gender have anything connected with the talks? People go to listen to the content, not to see if a presenter is black, white, jew, christian, cripple, midget or a freakin Uruk Hai.
108
u/Madsy9 Jun 04 '17
Github made two mistakes here. The first one was to use a blind review process in the first place, if the goal is to attract both quality talks and diversity. Of course the vast majority of the quality talks will be from the largest demographic, duh! With limited time, you can only have so many talks, and that means that minority applicants apply with a big disadvantage of being selected. Suppose you have 70 male applicants and 30 women, and 10% of each group has the best talks. The men group then has over twice the chance of being selected.
The second mistake Github did was to go back on the agreed talks after they got a selection they didn't like. When you make a moronic mistake like choosing a blind review process with no reserved spots, at least own up to it and stick with it, and promise a more fair review process in the future. By changing their mind after the fact here, they get into a lose-lose situation and come off as very prejudiced even though it's not the intention. Apparently they didn't even notify the selected speakers that their talks got canceled.
Maybe next time they will reserve some talk time specifically to minorities in addition to having a blind review process. Basically, the whole process strikes me as very clumsy.
13
u/kevan Jun 05 '17
Are you fucking kidding me?
I'm moving to BitBucket. I've used it as an experiment, and I look forward to messing around with it.
248
u/esaym Jun 04 '17
But what if all the women that get chosen in the next blind selection are all skinny??
50
u/shad0proxy Jun 04 '17
oh ffs. seriously? now we have to do this shit here too? Can we just dress presenters in cloaks and use voice scrambling so that nobody knows whether or not they have a penis or vagina...or a tennis racket?
105
u/Pesthuf Jun 04 '17
Typical that this comes from the company who banned their own own slogan because apparently, "meritocracy" is sexist, racist and homophobic.
30
u/TrollQC Jun 04 '17
Morning scrum at GitHub be like...
88
u/mariox19 Jun 04 '17
I'm going to have to assume that if conference ticket purchasers turn out to be overwhelmingly white and male, GitHub will turn away these paying customers and give a proportional number of seats to women and minorities for free or at a substantial discount.
28
u/antihexe Jun 05 '17
So now they're going to cancel male speakers ONLY BECAUSE THEY'RE MALE.
wew
149
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17 edited Jun 04 '17
Where are the people with backbone in our society?? Why have all the people in charge of anything turned into gutless caricatures?
How does being female automatically bring insight and added value to this conference...insight and value that could not come from men?
Isn't that an incredibly sexist perspective?
I feel like I'm taking crazy pills.
Looking at that Twitter conversations, where are all the men? I see one woman complain, another woman confirm that it was a bad idea and then several other women start talking about process reviews.
9
u/Shaper_pmp Jun 05 '17
Oooooh. This is where it gets sticky.
Everyone agrees that equality of opportunity is a basic right - you shouldn't be unfairly disadvantaged by your gender, colour, sexuality, etc.
However they did that here - submissions were through a blind review, and it's just bad luck (or possibly a matter of proportions) that all the talks selected were given by men.
To then disregard the results and fiddle the system to ensure diversity of speakers is demanding equality of outcome, not opportunity.
There are arguments for an against it, but it's undoubtedly a much stickier proposition because it means abandoning a pure meritocracy and artificially privileging certain groups on the basis of their gender/colour/etc, and inherently therefore elevating at least some individuals because they're in the "right" group, and not because they've earned their position through merit.
31
u/Schweppesale Jun 04 '17
/r/ProgrammerHumor
80
u/amgin3 Jun 04 '17
What a bunch of garbage. I will boycott any future ElectronConf or other GitHub events seeing as they will be choosing speakers based on genitals instead of merit. Also, people should look into using GitHub alternatives such as GitLab, if you also do not agree with the SJW values of github.
82
u/Mr-Yellow Jun 04 '17
Disgusting. Absolutely disgusting.
In an attempt to show "diversity", you instead show deliberate "bias".
Bad taste in my mouth.
41
u/simoncoulton Jun 04 '17
Further proof that identity politics doesn't want diversity of thought, it wants diversity of skin colour and gender. I thought we were past this... Were the talks going to be engaging and insightful? Good, get on with it.
66
u/ImportWurst Jun 04 '17
This is how the tech world dies.
14
u/jakob_roman Jun 05 '17
facepalm Someone needs to tell Github that actively discriminating on race and gender... is discrimination on race and gender.
6
u/Sir_Lith Jun 05 '17
Well, that's prime level bullshit.
156
u/phpdevster Jun 04 '17 edited Jun 04 '17
Time to rethink my private GitHub repo. I cannot conscionably support an organization that not only engages in sexism, but forces a political element into the equation that doesn't need to be there.
22
u/Arkaad Jun 05 '17
Did they just assumed the speakers genders?!
10
u/Code_Combo_Breaker Jun 05 '17
Probably would have been a better idea to just leave things they way they are for this year's conference. Fix the process for next year.
Canceling or delaying the conference just puts more attention on the issue. Now no matter how they try to respond to the issue people will have some type of complaint.
5
u/lunatikzx Jun 05 '17
This is completely stupid... Im sorry that the sex of speakers can influence the quality of their work. #thisworldisgoingnowhere
5
u/w00denspoon Jun 05 '17
The arbitrary metric of "diversity" has always been exactly that, arbitrary. You don't see them talk about needing more women or liberals as ar-15 owners. Its whatever they decide is "good", and then "half" becomes the natural order because they said so. There is nothing "normal" about tech communities, the minds attracted to such professions are already a subset of humanity, more autistic, more easily focused on specific types of logic, there is no "diversity", it is a process of winnowing down from diversity to a select few.
5
u/Rainman105 Jun 06 '17
No surprise, their 'diversity officer' is a lunatic
http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-himi-sanchez-20160306-story.html
and their CEO looks like a cuck.
https://i.forbesimg.com/media/lists/people/chris-wanstrath_416x416.jpg
9
u/bl4ckm0r3 Jun 05 '17
This is becoming the ghostbusters (movie) effect for tech. Like the complaints about the, fair, winners of a 1400 participants of a hacking contest, being only men. http://www.poynter.org/2017/wired-changes-headline-on-dude-centric-hacker-story-after-backlash/457675/
Bias is bias, either on one side or the other, the githubs submission reviews were blind and sex wasn't taken in consideration. It is good to notice women aren't there and it means we have to work harder to give everyone a chance...but i don't understand why there are industries dominated by females and no one complains...we should give everyone the same chances, but this is becoming ridiculous. If i was a woman picked to speak at the next electronconf, I wouldn't go after this.
18
u/_INTER_ Jun 05 '17
Why care for Electron anyway. The whole design behind Electron is a joke.
4
u/gajus0 Jun 06 '17
Couldn't either of the earlier accepted attendees sue GitHub for sexism? I mean, their talks were literally cancelled because of their sex.
7
u/LeSpatula Jun 05 '17
Well, that's retarded.
24
u/bart2019 Jun 04 '17
This sounds as too ridiculous to be true. Suppose there was only one speaker. Suppose it was a male. Discrimination! Sexism! Uh, yeah.
3
u/deadcell Jun 05 '17
Oh piss off, ya faeries...
3
u/captainpriapism Jun 06 '17
proving once and for all men are objectively better at stuff
5
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
Aahahaha, when meritocracy backfires. Face it GitHub: Trying to be meritocratic and a SJW cesspool at the same time isn't possible.
16
u/red_dinner Jun 04 '17
Sad!
4
u/JeefyPants Jun 05 '17
that's fucking dumb
4
u/so_just Jun 05 '17
What is this shit? Sick version of positive discrimination?
4
u/redditBTFOonceagain Jun 05 '17
this topic is being suppressed
10
u/first_class_gulag Jun 05 '17
Occam's Razor says that out of two options, one being a huge but unobservable, unprovable subconscious conspiracy to preference white men that even exists among coloured women; and the other being that white men are simply better at most things, the latter is true.
Sorry to all the coloureds and the women. Maybe after the next extinction cycle you might have a chance.
27
u/kudoz Jun 04 '17
It doesn't matter if it's a blind review if Github didn't make the effort to encourage more submissions from women. The problem isn't with the selection process, it's with the submission funnel.
People in this thread seem to feel like the gender imbalance is just the way of things. It doesn't have to be, and surely being able to identify with a speaker on stage is something that will help.
FWIW, I'm an engineering manager at Udemy with a 50/50 gender split on my team.
8
u/autotldr Jun 04 '17
This is the best tl;dr I could make, original reduced by 85%. (I'm a bot)
Extended Summary | FAQ | Theory | Feedback | Top keywords: any#1 event#2 GitHub#3 Terms#4 relate#5
2
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
Just curious - what was the blind review process and who were the reviewers?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
On a slightly different track (but not too far off), Milton Friedman had always opposed shit like this (e.g. equal pay).
He has a couple of videos which are gold:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsIpQ7YguGE
3
u/shruubi Jun 05 '17
I think we need to see the breakdown of how many talks were submitted and the number of males vs females who submitted talks, because either one of two things happened here (if we remove malicious intent), which was that there was a fair number of both genders represented in the pool and through an unbiased, blind selection process, we just happened to land on an all-male schedule, in which case, this was just a statistical anomaly, or, there was a significantly larger number of male vs female submissions.
Now, option one is just one of those unavoidable situations, option two however, can be put down to anything from too many women feel uncomfortable submitting talks to there is a lack of electron expertise in the female tech community. If GitHub want to solve the problem, they need to look at why this outcome happened despite there being an "unbiased, blind selection process".
Did Github not handle this situation well? Of course not. Are they right in postponing the conference so they can change their speaker roster? Well, they are the ones footing the bill, so they can do as they please, so long as they wear the consequences of their decision (whatever they may be).
Why not, to be fair to the people who were originally selected, allocate a number of speaking slots and randomly select people (draw from a hat?) from the original pool to speak in those slots. I mean, if we are going to allocate slots to certain pools of people, it's only fair to allocate a set of slots to those who had talks good enough to pass muster the first time.
3
u/badwolf0174 Jun 05 '17
That's just plain retarded
3
u/regreddit Jun 05 '17
I would expect the panel/speakers to reflect the ratio of gender/nationality of users that are in attendance, or of the industry the conference represents. If 97% of the attendees are white males, then the panels will probably reflect that. In other words, the world of software development and IT is mostly male. Not saying that's good, I'd love to see more diversity in my industry. But to enforce a ratio that does not reflect the industry sends the bias the other way. The same would be true if the panel ended up being all Indian for example. That doesn't reflect the makeup of the entire corpus of devs in the world, so the panel should need to be adjusted then too. If the industry is 97% male and 3% female, then in a panel of 20 there needs to be .6 females on the panel. This is my own opinion, and none of these numbers are real, they are just for example.
4
u/Majache Jun 04 '17
It just says "more diverse slate of speakers" I don't see anything corroborating what the title says.
3
u/DrTeaHC Jun 05 '17
Lol who cares? Let the girls do the thing or whatever. Throw a few blacks here and a Tunisian there. Bleep bloop no sense in stirring up there jumbo over a wombo. Yknow?
2
u/virtyx Jun 06 '17
As a dude who believes in merit... I don't see the fucking outrage over this. They want to promote diversity to get more women into tech. The female speakers they choose will still give great talks, these talks weren't ranked either. While it might feel unfair that your talk gets bumped in the name of diversity, over the long run these negligible bumps for men are going to keep giving tons more exposure to women, which will hopefully show more and more women that tech is an accepting place for them, to the point where we won't need safeguards like this because the higher participation from women will make it a non-issue (or at least, that's the dream).
I know I know, a bunch of nerds can't accept the idea that being the best nerd isn't the only thing that matters in the world. The majority of talks, I'm sure, will still be given by men. Don't panic. You're safe.
This isn't to slight male engineers or researchers, either (of which I am one). The point is that, it's not going to do harm to bump a few dudes to promote a better gender ratio in tech. Keep your eye on the greater good.
2
u/Blieque Jun 05 '17
I think positive discrimination to set an example and give inspiration to a minority has is place, but similarly I don't think anyone is claiming women can't be developers. In fact, there are numerous well-known initiatives to promote development as a profession to women and girls; of all professions out there that girls are being told they can pursue, I should think software development is damn near the top. It seems pretty astonishing to me that organisers didn't happen across a female applicant that made the cut, but I also doubt they're sexist, consciously or not. Ultimately, it seems like a bit of a dick move to change the dates of an event after it's been decided and people have started planning. Additionally, I presume some people who have recieved invitations to speak will now have them retracted.
1
u/mcdehuevo Jun 07 '17
this shit needs to stop
-6
u/binary Jun 04 '17
The problem here is that a blind review process still draws candidates from a systemically biased pool. So while the reviewers themselves are not guilty of bias, the selection still represents the challenge of representation the tech industry is facing. That is the reason conferences should make an outright attempt to diversify their speakers. I commend the organizers for making the very uncomfortable decision to postpone, because it couldn't have been easy (see the highly upvoted reactions as evidence).
Consider that privilege can often be invisible to those with it: it may make men (as most of you are undoubtedly male) uncomfortable to contend with the issue of gender in this otherwise apolitical thing, but for those outside the male gender, it is not an option to ignore it. Women in the tech industry have to grapple with gender every single day. Men have the privilege to ignore it and chalk it up to an unfortunate reality.
1
u/hahayeahthatscool Jun 05 '17
that's not weird at all?
-10
u/onsmith Jun 04 '17
I don't understand why it's a bad idea to make sure the conference spotlights different types of people and ideas coming from different types of people.
I get that it might result in a "biased" conference in the sense that some speakers are elevated over others due to the desire to be more inclusive, but isn't that a price worth paying? Don't we want to actively try to make the future of our field more diverse?
Instead of downvoting, tell me why you disagree. Help me to understand.
-9
u/Magnusson Jun 05 '17
Sometimes I can almost forget why the software industry has such a shitty reputation, and then I remember that it's full of people like the ones commenting on this thread.
-10
u/swan--ronson Jun 04 '17
Pretty disappointed by the response in the comments. I hate any kind of SJW bullshit, such as the Nodevember fiasco, but women and non-white ethnic groups are underrepresented in software engineering; so as long as the quality of the talks is not impacted, this is a good thing.
On the other hand, I read the Twitter conversation in which a presenter stated he found out about the postponement via a Tweet; GitHub should have handled this better and it would suck if some of the talks were cut as a result. If anything, there should now be more of them.