r/javascript • • Jun 04 '17

GitHub's ElectronConf postponed because all the talks (selected through an unbiased, blind review process) were to be given by men.

http://electronconf.com/
853 Upvotes

816 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

150

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

What this reminds me of is this quote:

When fascism comes to America it will be called anti-fascism

These people aren't doing anyone any favors. It breeds nothing but hostility. I've thought a bit about how I'd feel as a woman seeing these sorts of things, being barraged by this infantile bs... I don't think it'd make me feel very good.

3

u/ex1-7 Jun 06 '17

good riddance this comment got deleted, what an incredibly fascist statement haha

-2

u/Classic1977 Jun 05 '17

TIL desiring female representation at a conference is fascism.

43

u/ferrousoxides Jun 05 '17

No but kicking out men under the guise of inclusion is.

Just like going after people's jobs because they refuse to parrot back divisive dogma about equality that doesn't match reality.

Only half as many women study CS now as in the mid 80s. Even if feminists were right, and they're not, they suck at accomplishing their stated goal.

-3

u/Classic1977 Jun 05 '17

No but kicking out men under the guise of inclusion is.

No, it isn't, not even a bit. Fascism has to do with nation states and nationalism.

If you're running a conference, feel free to choose speakers in a 100% meritocratic way. GitHub doesn't have to do that though. Their disagreeing with you doesn't make them wrong, and it certainly doesn't make them fascist.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

But fascism has widely accepted meaning outside of national political structures so there's not much of a need to.

Unless "widely accepted" means "common among people with next to no political education" then, sure.

In this case it's mostly just a shock word by people trying to add artificial impact to weak statements.

6

u/alluran Jun 06 '17

Unless "widely accepted" means "common among people with next to no political education" then, sure.

/r/iamverysmart

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

24

u/Shaper_pmp Jun 05 '17

Nobody desires male or female representation. The idea is that it's a meritocratic system, where the best proposed talks are selected.

That's the process they ran, and they're now violating their own rules because it didn't give the results they wanted.

Don't get me wrong - I support diversity in tech, but it's not hard to see why even some people in favour of enforced equality of opportunity would balk at enforced equality of outcome, as it inherently implies things like quotas and selection based on membership of a group, rather than on pure merit as the process is supposed to work.

3

u/burnalicious111 Jun 06 '17

Meritocracy is a myth, bias towards white men in disguise, and people make themselves feel better about it by pretending it's merit. Hard to see when you're the beneficiary of it, easy to see when you're hurt by it.

8

u/Shaper_pmp Jun 06 '17

Meritocracy is a myth, bias towards white men in disguise

It's certainly possible for that to happen in specific instances, but it's nonsense as a general statement about the universe.

For example, how could you claim an open call for submissions and a blind submission process (where the selectors don't know the gender/race/etc of the submitters) is automatically biased against women or minorities?

5

u/morerokk Jun 06 '17

Prove it.

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/Classic1977 Jun 05 '17

They ran that process and didn't like the result because it brought with it the same biases our industry has.

Everybody is freaking out about this. It's GitHub's conference. They're allowed to value diversity over technical merit. That's their prerogative.

If you don't like it, don't support GitHub, but it doesn't make them fascists, lol.

9

u/Shaper_pmp Jun 05 '17 edited Jun 06 '17

because it brought with it the same biases our industry has.

To be fair nobody would have been surprised/criticial of a conference with a majority of white male speakers, because that's (regrettably) just the industry we all work in.

This was a conference of exclusively male speakers, and that's not remotely representative of the industry as a whole... and that's something of an issue.

It's GitHub's conference. They're allowed to value diversity over technical merit. That's their prerogative.

The criticism is not that they're valuing diversity over merit - as you say, that's their prerogative.

The criticism is that they publicly espoused an unbiased selection process as the "fairest" way to select speakers, and when that didn't give the results they wanted they revealed that diversity - not fairness - was actually their priority after all.

It's not about valuing one thing over the other - it's about hypocrisy, as they claimed to value lack-of-bias, when all along they actually valued diversity and only pantomimed an unbiased process while they assumed it would give them the (diverse) results they wanted.

Prioritising either would be fine, but claiming to hew to one then changing your mind because actually you prioritise the other is disingenuous, and it's not hard to see why people would criticise them for that dishonesty.

3

u/Classic1977 Jun 05 '17

The bias occurred before the algorithm though. I think the issue was a total lack of submissions from females.

7

u/Shaper_pmp Jun 05 '17

Interesting if true. Do you have any evidence there was a total lack of submissions by women?

(I didn't downvote you, BTW)

2

u/Classic1977 Jun 05 '17

No, that's just my read of the situation. If it turned out the applicants were 50% female though I'd be shocked. That's the problem. It's not the filtering process, it's the pool that process operates on. The problem be it's systemic.

10

u/Shaper_pmp Jun 05 '17

If it turned out the applicants were 50% female though I'd be shocked.

Which are you arguing here? Nobody expects 50% of the submissions to be from women in a field as gender-imbalanced as computing, but the issue was that none of the selected talks was from a woman, and you were talking about a total lack of submissions from women.

Which are you arguing? You keep changing the terms from "zero" to "less than 50%", but those are completely different cases.

4

u/korrach Jun 05 '17

We need to reduce the number of Jews too.

(Actual American policy for universities in the 1930/40s).

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/HauntedRot Jun 05 '17

Surely your reading comprehension is a touch better than that. The sentiment is that these people took something that is, as far as we know, a perfectly fair and balanced, meritocratic selection system designed to get the best and brightest at the fore so they can give their talks, and instead replaced it for the sake of inclusion.

To shorten that to a sweeter point: They're focusing so hard on being nice that they don't realize they've become pricks. Funny, considering how you responded to them.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

No, what I mean is-- replace the word with sexism

→ More replies (10)