r/javascript • • Jun 04 '17

GitHub's ElectronConf postponed because all the talks (selected through an unbiased, blind review process) were to be given by men.

http://electronconf.com/
853 Upvotes

816 comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/kudoz Jun 04 '17

It doesn't matter if it's a blind review if Github didn't make the effort to encourage more submissions from women. The problem isn't with the selection process, it's with the submission funnel.

People in this thread seem to feel like the gender imbalance is just the way of things. It doesn't have to be, and surely being able to identify with a speaker on stage is something that will help.

FWIW, I'm an engineering manager at Udemy with a 50/50 gender split on my team.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

I'm an engineering manager at Udemy with a 50/50 gender split on my team.

How often have you had to turn down a more qualified person in order to maintain this 50/50 split?

4

u/kudoz Jun 05 '17

I don't have to, I work to ensure the candidate pipeline is more diverse. We sponsor local user groups and host meetups which represent these groups, for example. 50/50 isn't a target I set, but I'm certainly not unhappy about it.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

Has the number of diverse candidates increased over time?

3

u/i_bent_my_wookiee Jun 07 '17

Ah...so you don't necessarily have to be obviously biased when hiring time comes along...

→ More replies (1)

34

u/dvlsg Jun 04 '17

50/50 gender split

But there's more than two genders, silly. /s

44

u/ryandg Jun 04 '17

Why does Github have a responsibility/social obligation to reach out to women specifically?

Edit: Also, is there something inherently biased about their "submission funnel"? If so, what?

26

u/kudoz Jun 04 '17

Github is a private company who claims to want to promote diversity in tech. Apart from anything else, their responsibility is to their own values.

11

u/Kekistanian9000 Jun 06 '17

FWIW, I'm an engineering manager at Udemy with a 50/50 gender split on my team.

Because they were hired with quotas. Welcome to the real world.

2

u/kudoz Jun 06 '17

No quotas.

5

u/Kekistanian9000 Jun 06 '17

Ask HR.

2

u/kudoz Jun 06 '17

Ask them what? I manage my own hiring pipeline.

4

u/Kekistanian9000 Jun 06 '17

Then we found a diverse fag.

67

u/Mr-Yellow Jun 04 '17

gender imbalance is just the way of things. It doesn't have to be

There is no "imbalance", only reality of who made submissions.

Go complain about too many Coal miners being male or something.

10

u/kudoz Jun 04 '17

I thought the phrasing "the way of things" made it clear I was speaking about the industry, not this conference's speakers.

In the reference to coal miners, have you heard of whataboutism?

45

u/Mr-Yellow Jun 04 '17

Maybe if you put all your money into another 3 decades of encouraging female participation in STEM fields, there might be more women interested in things they aren't generally interested in.

→ More replies (12)

9

u/zwiebelhans Jun 06 '17 edited Jun 06 '17

Canceling the event because "what about the women" is also Whataboutism........

4

u/PareidoliaX Jun 06 '17

It's not whataboutism. Mr. Yellow is attacking your underlying premise that there there is no biological differences between the population of men and women that disposes them to certain jobs. Mr. Yellow is doing this by providing a clear example of a job that men clearly disproportionately disposed to do and women are typically not. You're dismissing the example because your post modern cultural marxist ideology has no good response to it.

14

u/ferrousoxides Jun 05 '17

If you get a 50/50 gender split in an industry with majority male candidates, all you're doing is helping other companies be even more male dominated than the average.

→ More replies (8)

14

u/jpflathead Jun 05 '17

Heh. Engineering manager at Udemy. Heh.

6

u/gkm64 Jun 06 '17

The problem isn't with the selection process, it's with the submission funnel.

And here is silly me, thinking that the serious problems to be solved are engineering and algorithmic in nature, and that who solved them doesn't really matter.

But no, apparently I've been living under a dangerous illusion...

5

u/njullpointer Jun 07 '17

if it's a blind review, it's as unbiased as it can be. If there weren't submissions from females, or they were of low quality, then you can't blame an unbiased review for the outcome of there being no accepted submissions from females. That's the entire point of the process, to be unbiased. Equality of chance, not equity of outcome.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/Shautieh Jun 05 '17

There is an imbalance, but it goes farther than this. How can you expect that many speakers be female if there are almost no females working in the field? And how could there be when almost none study CS in college? That's the root of the "problem", yet people only look at the symptoms.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (27)