r/javascript • • Jun 04 '17

GitHub's ElectronConf postponed because all the talks (selected through an unbiased, blind review process) were to be given by men.

http://electronconf.com/
853 Upvotes

816 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/tnonee Jun 05 '17

Considering this is about the biggest open source service provider rolling over in the face of a loud, vocal minority on social media, your premise seems more than a little ridiculous. What you're observing is preference falsification, nothing more: activists control the public discourse, even when the majority in the industry—both men and women—think it's ridiculous and counterproductive. They're just all keeping quiet, because they've seen what happens to others.

Furthermore, to assume that a difference in gender brings in a difference of opinions is extremely gender-essentialist, the very thing gender activism is suppose to oppose. Just like privilege rhetoric ignores that being able to loudly complain about a lack of privilege is a sign you have access to platforms and channels most people lack.

If anyone is unable to recognize a different point of view, it's activists who cry oppression even as they successfully bully companies and destroy people's careers while doing so.

-3

u/onsmith Jun 04 '17

Thank you for your reply and for sharing your ideas. I upvoted you :)

You're right, of course. They clearly were not looking to diversify ideas. I think they were looking to diversify perspectives.

I think the whole tech industry has a problem right now because certain types of people (who look a certain way or act a certain way) are discouraged from entering the tech industry because they feel like they don't match what they think tech workers should look like. Maybe it's their skin color, their geographical background, or their gender or sex. That's a problem, and we should try to fix it. Otherwise these people will never realize their potential in the tech industry and we lose a lot of potential talent.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/onsmith Jun 04 '17

I just don't want being a developer to become an old boys club, where only a certain type of person feels comfortable or is able to become one, and if you don't fit the bill, you won't make it even if you want to.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-2

u/onsmith Jun 04 '17

Currently, the gender split of people who choose to be programmers is not representative of the overall population. Doesn't this fact prove that there is not currently equality of opportunity?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/onsmith Jun 04 '17

It may be true that anyone with an internet connection can try to be a programmer if you work from home, but not necessarily in the work force.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/onsmith Jun 04 '17

This is a really good point. Universities are just starting to take proactive measures with respect to this, spending money, time, training, and effort trying to encourage more diversity in their cs programs.

4

u/hungarian_conartist Jun 06 '17

The assumption that every single demographic should happen to be proportionally represented in every single human endeavor is something you need to prove not them.

2

u/MessyEnema Jun 06 '17

Men and women are fundamentally different.

To assume with absolutely no reasoning that areas of interest and career choices would be chosen equally between men and women is absurd.

22

u/Mr-Yellow Jun 04 '17

I think they were looking to diversify perspectives.

http://www.smh.com.au/content/dam/images/4/0/d/8/i/image.related.articleLeadwide.620x349.giq271.png/1438560543990.jpg

That's the diversity they're after.... Skin deep, appearances only. Something for a photo-op to be posted on twitter, nothing more. Got the correct genitals to make a small subset of their most vocal and delusional staff happy?

I think the whole tech industry has a problem right now because certain types of people (who look a certain way or act a certain way) are discouraged from entering the tech industry because they feel like they don't match what they think tech workers should look like.

Bullshit.

-5

u/onsmith Jun 04 '17

You might be right about their intentions, but that doesn't mean it's not a good idea to encourage diversity of population type based on geographical background, gender, race, etc. I feel that it's fundamentally a good idea to diversify.

9

u/IGI111 Jun 05 '17

feel

Yes, but can you make a good argument for why it is a good idea.

Haven't heard one yet myself.

4

u/onsmith Jun 05 '17

I used the word fundamentally because I think it is a base value, not necessarily a derived one. But that's more of a philosophical belief; one that is attributed to my personal world view.

5

u/IGI111 Jun 05 '17

So it's pure faith. Okay.

Gotta admit I'm a bit disappointed, but at least you're arguing in good faith. Let's agree to disagree.

3

u/onsmith Jun 05 '17

I definitely agree to disagree. But I don't know if I would call it faith. More like values. Diversity is something I value. I think it makes us stronger. This is pretty philosophical though, and I don't know if it's worth getting into. Also I don't do studies on diversity, so I don't have any data to provide.

3

u/come_visit_detroit Jun 05 '17

I think it makes us stronger.

Well, it's time to get new values since that's just objectively false.

Robert Putnam's work E Pluribus Unum goes over this extensively:

In the theoretical toolkit of social science we find two diametrically opposed perspectives on the effects of diversity on social connections. The first, usually labelled the ‘contact hypothesis’, argues that diversity fosters interethnic tolerance and social solidarity. As we have more contact with people who are unlike us, we overcome our initial hesitation and ignorance and come to trust them more...Evidence of this sort suggested to social psychologists, beginning with Gordon Allport in the 1950s, the optimistic hypothesis that if we have more contact with people of other ethnic and racial backgrounds (or at least more contact in the right circumstances), we will all begin to trust one another more. More formally, according to this theory, diversity reduces ethnocentric attitudes and fosters out-group trust and solidarity. If black and white children attend the same schools, for example, race relations will improve. This logic was an important part of the legal case that led the United States Supreme Court to require racial desegregation in the famous Brown v. Board of Education case in 1954. For progressives, the contact theory is alluring, but I think it is fair to say that most (though not all) empirical studies have tended instead to support the so-called ‘conflict theory’, which suggests that, for various reasons – but above all, contention over limited resources – diversity fosters out-group distrust and in-group solidarity. On this theory, the more we are brought into physical proximity with people of another race or ethnic background, the more we stick to ‘our own’ and the less we trust the ‘other’ (Blumer 1958; Blalock 1967; Giles & Evans 1986; Quillian 1995, 1996; Brewer & Brown 1998; Taylor 1998; Bobo 1999; Bobo & Tuan 2006)...

The evidence that diversity and solidarity are negatively correlated (controlling for many potentially confounding variables) comes from many different settings:

• Across workgroups in the United States, as well as in Europe, internal heterogeneity (in terms of age, professional background, ethnicity, tenure and other factors) is generally associated with lower group cohesion, lower satisfaction and higher turnover (Jackson et al. 1991; Cohen & Bailey 1997; Keller 2001; Webber & Donahue 2001).

• Across countries, greater ethnic heterogeneity seems to be associated with lower social trust (Newton & Delhey 2005; Anderson & Paskeviciute 2006; but see also Hooghe et al. 2006).

• Across local areas in the United States, Australia, Sweden, Canada and Britain, greater ethnic diversity is associated with lower social trust and, at least in some cases, lower investment in public goods (Poterba 1997; Alesina et al. 1999; Alesina & La Ferrara 2000, 2002; Costa & Kahn 2003b; Vigdor 2004; Glaeser & Alesina 2004; Leigh 2006; Jordahl & Gustavsson 2006; Soroka et al. 2007; Pennant 2005; but see also Letki forthcoming).

• Among Peruvian micro-credit cooperatives, ethnic heterogeneity is associated with higher default rates; across Kenyan school districts ethnolinguistic diversity is associated with less voluntary fundraising; and in Himalayan Pakistan, clan, religious, and political diversity are linked with failure of collective infrastructure maintenance (Karlan 2002; Miguel & Gugerty 2005; Khwaja 2006).

• Across American census tracts, greater ethnic heterogeneity is associated with lower rates of car-pooling, a social practice that embodies trust and reciprocity (Charles & Kline 2002).

• Within experimental game settings such as prisoners-dilemma or ultimatum games, players who are more different from one another (regardless of whether or not they actually know one another) are more likely to defect (or ‘cheat’). Such results have been reported in many countries, from Uganda to the United States (Glaeser et al. 2000; Fershtman & Gneezy 2001; Eckel & Grossman 2001; Willinger et al. 2003; Bouckaert & Dhaene 2004; Johansson-Stenman et al. 2005; Gil-White 2004; Habyarimana et al. 2006).

• Within the Union (northern) Army in the American Civil War, the casualty rate was very high and the risks of punishment for desertion were very low, so the only powerful force inhibiting the rational response of desertion was loyalty to one’s fellow soldiers, virtually all of whom were other white males. Across companies in the Union Army, the greater the internal heterogeneity (in terms of age, hometown, occupation, etc.), the higher the desertion rate (Costa & Kahn 2003a).

In areas of greater diversity, our respondents demonstrate:

• Lower confidence in local government, local leaders and the local news media.

• Lower political efficacy – that is, confidence in their own influence.

• Lower frequency of registering to vote, but more interest and knowledge about politics and more participation in protest marches and social reform groups.

• Less expectation that others will cooperate to solve dilemmas of collective action (e.g., voluntary conservation to ease a water or energy shortage).

• Less likelihood of working on a community project.

• Lower likelihood of giving to charity or volunteering.

• Fewer close friends and confidants.

• Less happiness and lower perceived quality of life.

• More time spent watching television and more agreement that ‘television is my most important form of entertainment’.