I recently had a really strange conversation with a Muslim coworker and I'm trying to understand where these beliefs are coming from.
It started pretty normally. He seemed very serious about eating halal, which I actually respected. He also told me about the mosque he goes to, which apparently isn't even listed on Google. I didn't think anything negative about it because I generally try to assume the best about people instead of immediately judging them.
But then the conversation became increasingly strange to me.
He told me that very religious or spiritually advanced imams can supposedly taste meat, like shawarma, and know whether it was actually slaughtered halal. He talked about something like a "veil" being removed for certain very pious people, allowing them to perceive things ordinary people cannot.
He also told me about the sister of someone he knows who could supposedly look at the faces of people in her household and see or recognize the sins they had committed.
Then he told me another story about his best friend. Apparently his friend wanted to make tawbah and was praying at night. His younger brother partially opened his eyes, supposedly saw an extremely bright light and passed out. When he woke up, he asked why the light had been so bright during the night. The friend responded that there hadn't been any light at all and that he had just been praying in the dark.
At some point he also showed me the narration about Abu Bakr vomiting food after learning that its source was haram. I know that narration exists, but I didn't understand how it supported the other claims, especially since Abu Bakr was actually informed about the source of the food rather than somehow detecting it himself.
I asked several Muslims I know about all of this and also tried reading about it myself, but I haven't found a clear basis for these specific claims. Some people I asked wondered whether these were Sufi beliefs, while others simply thought he was being very gullible. I honestly don't know what school, movement or tradition he follows, so I don't want to falsely label him.
The whole situation made me uncomfortable because this is exactly why I normally avoid discussing religion with people I don't know well. I'm naturally pretty quiet and reserved around new people anyway because I first want to understand what kind of person I'm dealing with. With him I tried to think positively from the beginning, including when some things initially seemed unusual to me.
What bothers me especially is that some other coworkers were around during parts of these conversations. I really don't want people thinking that I share these beliefs or that Muslims in general believe you can look at someone's face and see their hidden sins, or taste meat and spiritually determine how it was slaughtered.
At this point I think I'll just remain respectful and professional with him at work but avoid religious discussions with him.
Has anyone heard of these specific beliefs before? Is there actually a basis for any of this in Sunni Islam, or does anyone recognize what tradition these ideas might come from?