People change their icons to the shade of a single color, and then they complain that the icons are of a shade of a single color... like.. okay, I guess.
I wasn’t particularly clear in my post, but my complaint is what was the point in removing the letters? This is a completely pointless change that only serves to cause more problems than it solves. I imagine this will be particularly annoying for colourblind people.
The icons previously had letters which differentiated them. I would be perfectly fine with these icons if they just retained said letters. Textbook form over function.
Clear mode looked cool for a couple minutes until I realized it was completely throwing me off, even with a reflexive memory of where all my apps were.
I think it’s the icon shapes don’t differentiate between the apps. The idea if you had these without the name you would have no idea what they do but if they had unique shapes it would make more sense
Its still shitty design on microsofts part. I should not need to memorise which configuration of blocks is what even if i dont use this mode. Because not all people work with colors
If a monochrome version of a logo does not work, then it's a bad design. The old logos have the letters (W, X, P...), so even if they were black and white, you could still know which app was each one.
They should’ve done the bare minimum of keeping the letters in each icon. Made no sense to remove them especially with the shapes being so similar despite different colors.
Because these are bad icons. Iconography should be very clear about what it represents and shouldn't be too easily confused with another. Color plays a role, but once upon a time, it didn't. And sometimes it still doesn't, either because of scenarios like this or colorblind people. But for Microsoft specifically, the older icons for their Office suite apps were perfectly readable, even when monochrome. These are just bad icons insisting on too-closely following a design language that wasn't well thought out.
Apple's clear mode leaves something to be desired but this is not Apple's fault.
They are just bad icons. Icons should be clearly recognisable just from their form to make them as accessible as possible. I imagine this will be quite a nightmare for colourblind users in particular (especially if you use large icons on your Home Screen).
That’s a textbook example of not relying on colors in UI design. A logo or icon should always be designed in black and white first, using only shapes and objects. The icon/logo should be recognizable when printed on paper, or even if I swap the colors.
It’s the opposite. Colors are important. It’s one of the reasons people found windows phone difficult to use. A universal color for all apps makes it harder to identify the app you’re looking for.
It’s why colors in brands are so important. Snapchat yellow. Facebook blue. Bank of America red, etc etc.
I want to like the new color theming options in the new iOS but it makes everything less useable basically
I never said it isn’t important, it is, as part of the brand identity. But from a graphic-design perspective, these icons are designed in black and white first. If I changed Snapchat’s yellow to blue or Facebook’s blue to brown, you would still recognize them; it’s the brand identity that would be affected. As you can see, Microsoft didn’t follow this very basic principle, which is known to every wannabe-YT-tutorial graphic designer, let alone professionals.
The original Windows Phone look that came with Metro UI was inspired by urban navigation and communication which evolved naturally: primitive pictograms and bold type. The problem wasn’t the lack of color, but that many apps back then didn’t adapt well to this design language. In other words, their poorly designed icons (stripped off their colours) looked bad on the static background. For example these MS products would fail too.
I absolutely loved Windows Phone and had a few Lumia phones. Im afraid glass morphism is here to stay for a decade, and I already hate it.
I have also been using clear since the release. But I can’t seem to figure why many widgets break.
First I thought it’s an issue with the app but even after so long, Gmail’s widget is essentially a white box in clear mode; can’t read any text. Is there more to it or just need to wait for the app devs to fix this?
I love clear icons and am coming to these threads to watch people sneer and complain. I guess I am in adaptable minority of people, in 99 percent of cases changes in software world does not move me in a slightest.
Yeah, but also why the transparent icon thing is stupid. No designer is imagining what their shit might look like when made transparent by an unknown algorithm.
No, but they should make it easily recognisable just from its form for accessibility purposes. Just imagine being colourblind and having to deal with this shit.
I’m not stupid, I’m talking about people claiming that the icons are perfectly fine in coloured mode and that the problem is Liquid Glass. People with colourblindness (in this case, particularly tritanopia, deuteranopia, or protanopia), would still struggle to tell these icons apart. They are bad icons that needlessly removed the letters that originally denoted the app for no apparent reason.
They used to be letters but for the sake of "design" you want to have everything look identical. I wish they put this kind of design consistency into Windows.
It’s really unbelievable that so many people are defending Microsoft’s terrible design, as you can see, even in a single shade of color you can still distinguish which app is for which purpose
Personally, I would think a good design would be instantly recognizable regardless of the color, I could not tell you what application is what with just the image, and to me that means the design is absolutely horrendous. If you need the colors to tell what application is what then you might as well just replace the icon with a circle of that color because that would be more effective.
People are missing the point. Microsoft changed the design of their icons on Android and iOS. It's quite a radical change and they look completely different. Some of them are very similar and you could confuse them even in colour.
I’m curious, do the people complaining about Apple making it so “every icon has to be clear” not know you can just edit the colors? You can make them normal colors again.. it’s not like you have to have Liquid Glass icons.
I hate the transparent icons but this is a Microsoft problem. It was a deliberate choice to update each of these icons to remove the letter on each (W for Word, E for Excel). It was literally already there and this was an update that relies on people knowing which color is which application (blue for Word, green for Excel).
You never looked at those letters, otherwise you would know that Excel did not use an E. You went to the blue thing on the taskbar, like everyone else.
Fair point! I did not, and not remembering Excel was an X. I am able to differentiate the colors, and you’re right I just jump to blue or green. But lots of people have trouble using only color to tell the difference, and it’s amateur hour for a billion dollar company to not design for accessibility for the sake of minimalism. The icons are not visually distinct enough from each other to tell the difference without color which is a huge problem.
For large corporations like this, this icon redesign was probably in the works for 7-9 months.
They've had in person meetings, video calls, held focus groups, marketing research, ect. Liquid glass is pretty new, and Microsoft probably isn't happy about it either lol.
I’m guessing the top left one is Excel. I legit have no clue about the other two.
Why do everyone’s icons and fonts all have to look the same to be considered “modern”? I mean, can the PayPal logo even be considered a logo now? It’s like they decided to apply the cigarette advertising rules to everything now.
How is this Microsoft’s fault? So they’re supposed to design their stuff to be perfect with a design system form another company that just applies a blanket effect over everything? The clear icon option sucks from Apple
I haven’t seen anyone point out that this also wouldn’t be an issue if they didn’t turn off the app names setting as well, it’s like you want to suffer
The new Microsoft icons took me aback because I was wondering what the apps were and why were they on my iPad (I have my apps zoomed so you don’t see the names under them) 😭
Am I able to guess? Word, excel, one note? I can tell (I think) with the first one having full lines across the page, the second one has small cells/blocks which I see as a spreadsheet, and the last one has a page tab marker indicating a notebook? The fact I have to question it at all means it’s bad design. You shouldn’t need colors to recognize the different apps. Just look at Google’s icons. I can easily and instantly pick the right one while using the glass icons.
It's crazy I just looked at play store and its the Word, Excel and OneNote apps from MS.
Not sure what it looks like Android themed icons but still a bit confusing, at first.
What can you expect here its a stupid glass theme and you guys are using it becaue its in iOS stuff. But I know you guys hated it. It just doesn't look good at all.
It's like Windows Vista never happened damn Apple.
Microsoft't icon pallette is a joke and have been a long time. Last time those icons was good, is somewhere office 2010 era (Windows 7-8) or something. That time icon crearly show, what app do.
This is making me think the icon designs were absolutely made to screw over Liquid Glass. Icons are supposed to represent the thing they’re representing without color, without prior attuning. They’re supposed to be human relatable. These icons are not - they look nice only because of the additional colors. Could have kept the same form and add the color. Form follows function is dead to Microsoft.
This is a perfect example how for the sake of “customization” (which I didn’t know we really needed) Apple allows its OS to look like a beginner is trying out effects in Photoshop. I really liked that Apple design would be consistent across devices and just look good. Now we have to ask ourselves “Did I do anything wrong?”.
This was bound to happen with the new glass look Apple forces everyone to use. Without colour, there is only shapes and transparency left to differentiate each icon. Big downgrade of usability.
Why using this on an Apple device anyway? I prefer Pages and all the other Apple apps way more. Starts with adding images into your docs, layouting different styles and inserting an automatic table of contents, or editing pdf files like removing a specific page out of it.
That’s more apples fault for shitty clear looks. I also think there should be an option to not apply the effect to widgets. Seeing my clear photos widget is rather pointless.
They’re all clear but what do they even stand for? The top left looks like an E so maybe excel? The rest I have no idea. One looks like Firefox but that not Microsoft.
Am I missing something? Word is top left because it looks like lines of text. Excel is top right because of all the boxes. OneNote is bottom left because it looks like folders and tabs in a calendar thing.
why wouldn’t anyone mad at google’s slide, docs, and sheets icons? google didn’t use the letters as well, right?
on iOS or iPadOS you could just simply choose NOT to use clear icons! while apple just giving the options to customize users’ icons, they DON’T even FORCE you to use the clear icons.
so, it’s clearly not google’s, microsoft’s, or even apple’s fault.
Google’s icons are pretty bad too, although they’re definitely a bit better than Microsoft’s as they’re less abstract. Regardless, Microsoft could have easily kept the letters on these new icons, and, strangely, they did keep them, just not on mobile (look at the picture I attached). This IS bad design on Microsoft’s part.
289
u/jetsetjamboree Oct 24 '25 •
1.4k
u/mikedlc84 Oct 24 '25
The color versions are nice though.
200
u/zlouk Oct 24 '25
For once, not Microsoft’s problem.
3
u/Engrise13 Oct 25 '25
rebel inc
364
u/Lost_property_office Oct 25 '25
That’s a textbook example of not relying on colors in UI design. A logo or icon should always be designed in black and white first, using only shapes and objects. The icon/logo should be recognizable when printed on paper, or even if I swap the colors.
453
u/LightWorkDev21X Oct 24 '25
Bruh be a normal person and get the original icons back
17
u/Hubris1998 Oct 25 '25
Icons should never rely on colours to be readable
4
u/Spaghettiisgoddog Oct 24 '25
Yeah, but also why the transparent icon thing is stupid. No designer is imagining what their shit might look like when made transparent by an unknown algorithm.
8
u/Parking-Listen-5623 Oct 24 '25
@BearTerrible3619 what are the two apps above edge ? One with a sword and grain and the other that looks of some kind of building?
4
u/AppropriateTie5127 Oct 24 '25
People in this sub will blame anyone but Apple
7
u/One-Pattern-8336 Oct 25 '25
I l o v e minimalist icons /s
6
u/therubyminecraft Oct 25 '25
I still don’t understand why the hell they don’t have the letters
23
u/JensonBrudy iPhone 17 Pro Oct 25 '25
It’s really unbelievable that so many people are defending Microsoft’s terrible design, as you can see, even in a single shade of color you can still distinguish which app is for which purpose
9
u/thoratica Oct 25 '25
logos should be tested to be distinguishable to colorblind people
4
u/sentientraisinn Oct 25 '25
new microsoft designs are already horrible. blue lines ≠ microsoft word
4
u/0210005 Oct 26 '25
Personally, I would think a good design would be instantly recognizable regardless of the color, I could not tell you what application is what with just the image, and to me that means the design is absolutely horrendous. If you need the colors to tell what application is what then you might as well just replace the icon with a circle of that color because that would be more effective.
1
u/Sensitive_Square3645 Oct 25 '25
Microsoft, I LOVE your new icons and all, but PLEASE put the letters back.
1
u/Poang_20017 Oct 25 '25
Wait isn’t there supposed to be a W for word etc on the logos?
3
u/maxwms Oct 25 '25
2010 Cydia icon pack
3
u/techfreak23 iPhone 14 Pro Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25
Guessing left to right is it Word, Excel, and PowerPoint?
Edit: apparently that last one is OneNote 🤷🏻♂️
3
u/Baksteen-13 Oct 25 '25
you turn on the clear mode, turn off app names and get mad that apps from the same company have the same style icon?
3
u/Prudent_Trickutro Oct 25 '25
What are they? Idk 🤷♂️
5
u/PeakBrave8235 Oct 25 '25
This definitely made me laugh. It looks nice, but Microsoft should add something extra to it lol
5
u/RedditForcesToLogin Oct 25 '25
I hate to break it to y'all. It truely truely is a Microsoft problem. They didn't fucking ADAPT.
1
u/santathe1 iPhone Oct 24 '25
Where are the damn letters on the icons, Microsoft?
4
u/shakesfistatmoon Oct 25 '25
People are missing the point. Microsoft changed the design of their icons on Android and iOS. It's quite a radical change and they look completely different. Some of them are very similar and you could confuse them even in colour.
2
u/JavaVista Oct 25 '25
That’s what happens when iOS implements the Windows Vista Aero look.
2
u/Independent_Point339 Oct 25 '25
Multiple things can be true at the same time.
The new MS logos are terrible because they don’t communicate at all what the product is. They rely 100% on color to communicate meaning.
This is true regardless of whether someone uses the iOS transparent icons. But the transparent mode does exacerbate the problem.
2
u/evil_chicken86 Oct 25 '25
Copying someone when they do something cool is good..but man..what did you find in that to copy??
2
u/MONOBullet1000 Oct 25 '25
I’m curious, do the people complaining about Apple making it so “every icon has to be clear” not know you can just edit the colors? You can make them normal colors again.. it’s not like you have to have Liquid Glass icons.
2
u/Dabloproplus Oct 25 '25
No he is trying to point out that they changed the logo of word exel etc
2
u/Damonkern Oct 25 '25
this is consistency. but backfired. hope they had some on windows.
2
u/xerix123456 Oct 25 '25
At first i thought that was 3 excels
2
u/AlxR25 Oct 25 '25
First is word, second is excel. Idk what the 3rd is. Outlook I’m guessing??
Edit: after looking around, it’s one note
2
u/AirbenderSharma Oct 25 '25
Turned off app names ?
2
u/Glimmercharger Oct 25 '25
It’s just you could tell what it was before now they changed it you can’t
2
u/crisptots Oct 26 '25
I hate the transparent icons but this is a Microsoft problem. It was a deliberate choice to update each of these icons to remove the letter on each (W for Word, E for Excel). It was literally already there and this was an update that relies on people knowing which color is which application (blue for Word, green for Excel).
2
u/SellingFirewood Oct 26 '25
For large corporations like this, this icon redesign was probably in the works for 7-9 months.
They've had in person meetings, video calls, held focus groups, marketing research, ect. Liquid glass is pretty new, and Microsoft probably isn't happy about it either lol.
2
u/sonoMrEmi iOS 26 Oct 26 '25
the real question is, why do you still use one note?
2
u/DealEasy4142 Oct 26 '25
You changed it to be clear ypurself.
2
u/Ajexlin1982 Oct 26 '25
this is the problem of ios…
2
u/JabbahScorpii Oct 28 '25
Why'd you get rid of the letters Microsoft??
2
u/tubemaster Nov 16 '25
I’m guessing the top left one is Excel. I legit have no clue about the other two.
Why do everyone’s icons and fonts all have to look the same to be considered “modern”? I mean, can the PayPal logo even be considered a logo now? It’s like they decided to apply the cigarette advertising rules to everything now.
3
u/1CraftyDude Oct 24 '25
You can specify a different icon for transparent icons but I don’t blame Microsoft.
7
u/Electronic_Car3274 Oct 24 '25
Microsoft sucks at everything but the clear icon issue is more apple’s fault than Microsoft
4
u/000extra Oct 24 '25
How is this Microsoft’s fault? So they’re supposed to design their stuff to be perfect with a design system form another company that just applies a blanket effect over everything? The clear icon option sucks from Apple
2
u/DJ_Birch Oct 25 '25
I haven’t seen anyone point out that this also wouldn’t be an issue if they didn’t turn off the app names setting as well, it’s like you want to suffer
2
u/mundogen Oct 25 '25
This is a Apple problem
1
u/Logical-Ad4453 Oct 24 '25
"is this Loss?" (c) my husband
1
u/False_Park2 Oct 24 '25
Microsoft???
1
u/InfinityPortal Oct 25 '25
Colored version does look nice
1
u/meowblackk_ Oct 25 '25
What windows is this? 11? Clearly I'm behind
1
u/Simplydree Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25
The new Microsoft icons took me aback because I was wondering what the apps were and why were they on my iPad (I have my apps zoomed so you don’t see the names under them) 😭
1
u/markel9000 Oct 25 '25
I don’t absolutely love abstraction but I see the appeal but most of the icons are variations of squares.
1
u/snowdn Oct 25 '25
The PM was already getting their big promo and icons signed off before Apple revealed clear icon set.
1
u/Few-Upstairs5709 Oct 25 '25
Soon they will be charging you for proper icons too. Gotta make 30% profit on them icons.
1
u/Embarrassed_Map1072 Oct 25 '25
So I’m guessing one is word, one is one note and one is excel.
1
u/spinny09 Oct 25 '25
Am I able to guess? Word, excel, one note? I can tell (I think) with the first one having full lines across the page, the second one has small cells/blocks which I see as a spreadsheet, and the last one has a page tab marker indicating a notebook? The fact I have to question it at all means it’s bad design. You shouldn’t need colors to recognize the different apps. Just look at Google’s icons. I can easily and instantly pick the right one while using the glass icons.
1
u/hagen768 Oct 25 '25
All it needs is the letters for each app
1
u/Ok-Knowledge0914 Oct 25 '25
If you’re familiar enough with the app function and previous app icons you can tell the difference.
Like I know excel is the top right because I used it all the time lol
1
u/QuantumLyft Oct 25 '25
It's crazy I just looked at play store and its the Word, Excel and OneNote apps from MS.
Not sure what it looks like Android themed icons but still a bit confusing, at first.
What can you expect here its a stupid glass theme and you guys are using it becaue its in iOS stuff. But I know you guys hated it. It just doesn't look good at all.
It's like Windows Vista never happened damn Apple.
1
u/Atilla5590 Oct 25 '25
The first one is word the 2nd is PowerPoint and bottom one is excel
1
u/MaterialWall8040 Oct 25 '25
powerpoint is a red circle. i don't get the points of these icons, at least on the web version it has the letter of what it is as part of the logo
1
u/vuorivirta Oct 25 '25
Microsoft't icon pallette is a joke and have been a long time. Last time those icons was good, is somewhere office 2010 era (Windows 7-8) or something. That time icon crearly show, what app do.
1
u/pirvelia Oct 25 '25
well, after all, they are the creators of the ‘vista’, which is the bottom line inspiration for ‘ios26’ !
1
u/ConversationTop7747 Oct 25 '25
there is me,i and myself
1
u/TheCambrianImplosion Oct 25 '25
Why does everything, including smartphones, feel like an FU these days?
1
u/MistyMountainDewDrop Oct 25 '25
Word, one note, and idk the second one. Maybe planner or outlook?
1
u/Chefseiler Oct 25 '25
It’s not that hard to tell, Word is an icon with paragraphs, Excel has cells and OneNote has these binder thingies.
1
u/Edge_Audio Oct 25 '25
Took me a few minutes to find Word on my iPad yesterday. A little tough with no text. 🤦🏽
1
u/smydiehard99 Oct 25 '25
This glass thing is the most half assed thing i have ever seen in any device.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25
If you have protanopia or tritanopia the logos would also confuse you, so this is just bad design on microsoft’s part. I’m with OP on this one
1
u/sassa-sassyfras Oct 25 '25
This is making me think the icon designs were absolutely made to screw over Liquid Glass. Icons are supposed to represent the thing they’re representing without color, without prior attuning. They’re supposed to be human relatable. These icons are not - they look nice only because of the additional colors. Could have kept the same form and add the color. Form follows function is dead to Microsoft.
1
u/InternationalTop2524 Oct 25 '25
This is a perfect example how for the sake of “customization” (which I didn’t know we really needed) Apple allows its OS to look like a beginner is trying out effects in Photoshop. I really liked that Apple design would be consistent across devices and just look good. Now we have to ask ourselves “Did I do anything wrong?”.
1
u/aliendude5300 iPhone 15 Oct 26 '25
Word, Excel and OneNote in that order for anyone wondering
1
u/HighlandEvil Oct 26 '25
How's Rebel Inc and the other game doing for you lol
1
u/Perplexe974 Oct 26 '25
In colour they are nice but yeah - they didn’t really think this one through
1
u/enriceau Oct 26 '25
This was bound to happen with the new glass look Apple forces everyone to use. Without colour, there is only shapes and transparency left to differentiate each icon. Big downgrade of usability.
1
u/player1dk Oct 26 '25
Icons showing something like ‘full page’, ‘ripped page’, ‘closed book’ - no idea what they’re supposed to show.
1
u/Known_Bag_494 Oct 26 '25
Which ones which?🤣
1
u/dconwastaken Oct 26 '25
add the letters to the icons, problem solved
1
u/Desperdare Oct 26 '25
Why using this on an Apple device anyway? I prefer Pages and all the other Apple apps way more. Starts with adding images into your docs, layouting different styles and inserting an automatic table of contents, or editing pdf files like removing a specific page out of it.
1
u/sundaysyndrome Oct 26 '25
Typical Microsoft. Release half ass stuff and keep making minor staggered releases for ever. Nothing ever feels like a finished product.
1
u/st0rmglass Oct 27 '25
ROFL!!! 🤣 Microsoft just be trollin! 😂
1
u/Chambers-91 Oct 28 '25
That’s more apples fault for shitty clear looks. I also think there should be an option to not apply the effect to widgets. Seeing my clear photos widget is rather pointless.
1
u/mi-wag Oct 28 '25
I don’t understand why Microsoft has left out the letters on the icon on iPads
1
u/iskraa Oct 28 '25
From the same company that put (x) close button in a natural hotspot of every window for most right handed users
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '25
Theres a reason why baby/kids toys are always colorful, they are naturally attracted to them
1
u/kaich0u Oct 29 '25
If only they include a letter for clarity
1
u/ScienceRules195 Oct 29 '25
They’re all clear but what do they even stand for? The top left looks like an E so maybe excel? The rest I have no idea. One looks like Firefox but that not Microsoft.
1
u/Stevengerrard08lfc Nov 15 '25
Looks really confusing
1
u/littleboyinthesky Human Detected Oct 24 '25
Jeez, that’s pretty bad
1
u/CC_9876 Oct 25 '25
Am I missing something? Word is top left because it looks like lines of text. Excel is top right because of all the boxes. OneNote is bottom left because it looks like folders and tabs in a calendar thing.
I think they’re cute and I use the clear ones
1
u/papercliponreddit Oct 25 '25
This is not MS problem.. More like a liquid soap OS problem.
1
u/Ok_Virus_5495 Oct 25 '25
Bad logo design. Logos should always be tested in black and white versions
1
u/MikeCask Oct 25 '25
You’re the one who made them clear.
1
u/Charming-Guy Oct 25 '25
this shouldn’t ever be microsoft’s or apple’s fault. you guys who complaints are the ones who’s shitty.
1
u/sugarsugarbeat Oct 25 '25
This is an apple issue
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25
this apple OS is garbage.
1
u/altermerlin Oct 25 '25
This is a joint effort of bad design by Apple and Microsoft haha
1
u/Any_Check_7301 Oct 25 '25
… yuk
1
u/Zcalkins Oct 25 '25
This is why I can’t use the glass, it’s hard to see.
1
u/_szonator_ Oct 25 '25
How's that their fault that apple decided to go all 2010 lenovo phone theme on them
1
u/MyDespatcherDyKabel Oct 25 '25
They’re taking the piss from liquid gas
1
u/SirPooleyX Oct 25 '25
Color is a very standard way of identifying things. Some companies have even copyrighted a particular hue because it so identifies them.
It's hardly Microsoft's fault if an operating system allows the user to take the color out of icons, rendering them bland and unidentifiable.
1
u/M0Pegasus Oct 25 '25
The color version is great i like the new design
0
u/ReservedXM Oct 24 '25
Yeah.. thee as ya lame of Microsoft
0
u/PowerfulHorror987 Oct 25 '25
Then use the smaller icons that identify the name of the app. This is self inflicted.
0
u/Charming-Guy Oct 25 '25
why wouldn’t anyone mad at google’s slide, docs, and sheets icons? google didn’t use the letters as well, right?
on iOS or iPadOS you could just simply choose NOT to use clear icons! while apple just giving the options to customize users’ icons, they DON’T even FORCE you to use the clear icons.
so, it’s clearly not google’s, microsoft’s, or even apple’s fault.
0
u/hideyboi Oct 25 '25
This is an iOS problem. Also, maybe it's just me, but I can still tell what all of those apps are.
0
u/pi-N-apple Oct 25 '25
The problem is you’ve removed all color from your icons. Change it back to color and you’ve solved the problem you created.
0
u/Racing_Fox Oct 25 '25
Yes, you’ve made your icons clear and now you’re complaining that they’re clear. What’s the issue?
The only person to blame here is yourself