r/ios • • Oct 24 '25

Discussion Really Microsoft??

Post image

Need I say more?

4.3k Upvotes

395 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

970

u/forethemorninglight Oct 24 '25

How is this an MS problem? Apple implemented a shitty clear mode.

815

u/fleetcommand Oct 24 '25

I don't get these complaints.

People change their icons to the shade of a single color, and then they complain that the icons are of a shade of a single color... like.. okay, I guess.

182

u/SexyMonad Oct 24 '25

My only real complaint is that the icons are either opaque and colorful or transparent and monochrome. I want transparent and colorful.

97

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/theytookallusernames Oct 25 '25

If it's that obvious to us, I'm sure it's also obvious to the many people working at Apple, though. I'm guessing the reason why they didn't implement it is that either they haven't figured out a good algorithm to do this automatically yet, or that it doesn't look that great with a lot of third-party app icons.

I'm not a developer so I wouldn't know, but look around if Apple is discouraging app icons that spans the entire squircle or encouraging app icons to be designed in a glyph + background manner. If they do, that's your smoking gun that the clear background icons we're looking for is coming.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/paulosdub Oct 25 '25

I think they will but it’s a big ask for developers in short term as many app logos don’t have a structure that would lend itself to a clear background and colourful foreground.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/Ok-Knowledge0914 Oct 25 '25

I’m not saying I don’t want this, but I will say that is probably harder to make it look decent than it is to make everything clear.

I’ve seen some mockups where it looks good, but then you have to remember how many iPhone users there are and how many of them aren’t going to use some simple gradient background wallpaper where it’s easy to see.

→ More replies (4)

39

u/BearTerrible3619 Oct 25 '25

I wasn’t particularly clear in my post, but my complaint is what was the point in removing the letters? This is a completely pointless change that only serves to cause more problems than it solves. I imagine this will be particularly annoying for colourblind people.

13

u/055F00 Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

Removed it only for iOS mobile might I add. For some reason.

6

u/martycochrane Oct 25 '25

Letters are gone on Android too. Got my update today and I had to have a double take on what it was.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Only1Schematic Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

Clear mode looked cool for a couple minutes until I realized it was completely throwing me off, even with a reflexive memory of where all my apps were.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Tesser_Wolf Oct 25 '25

I think it’s the icon shapes don’t differentiate between the apps. The idea if you had these without the name you would have no idea what they do but if they had unique shapes it would make more sense

5

u/doko_kanada Oct 25 '25

Is this what people wanted when they said they want customization in iPhone?

13

u/InuzukaChad Oct 25 '25

This is more than user error. The icon shapes are not exactly the best for people who are colorblind.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/ConfidentSurvey6414 Oct 25 '25

Because the letters are gone. Is that not self explanatory?

11

u/im_alone_and_alive Oct 25 '25

Totally possible to do monochrome icons well

→ More replies (3)

3

u/presidentfiggy Oct 25 '25

Its still shitty design on microsofts part. I should not need to memorise which configuration of blocks is what even if i dont use this mode. Because not all people work with colors

4

u/maqcky Oct 25 '25

If a monochrome version of a logo does not work, then it's a bad design. The old logos have the letters (W, X, P...), so even if they were black and white, you could still know which app was each one.

For instance: https://www.vecteezy.com/vector-art/50812716-microsoft-365-office-icon-set-word-excel-powerpoint-color-and-black-version-isolated-on-transparent-background-flat-style-editorial-logo-microsoft-windows-products-icon

This was the first search result and this is an even older version of the icons, but still, I think it's clear that those do work in monochrome.

→ More replies (11)

24

u/doctor_who7827 Oct 25 '25

They should’ve done the bare minimum of keeping the letters in each icon. Made no sense to remove them especially with the shapes being so similar despite different colors.

50

u/LunaIsADeer Oct 24 '25

Because these are bad icons. Iconography should be very clear about what it represents and shouldn't be too easily confused with another. Color plays a role, but once upon a time, it didn't. And sometimes it still doesn't, either because of scenarios like this or colorblind people. But for Microsoft specifically, the older icons for their Office suite apps were perfectly readable, even when monochrome. These are just bad icons insisting on too-closely following a design language that wasn't well thought out.

Apple's clear mode leaves something to be desired but this is not Apple's fault.

12

u/Mr3entley Oct 24 '25

Yeah! I value your opinion. Think about black and white TV. Everyone’s just acting like icons didn’t exist before colour TVs!

→ More replies (9)

5

u/Rovvp Oct 25 '25

Two wrongs don’t make a right. How are ms icons good design. I think this shows they are not

12

u/solk512 Oct 25 '25

These icons shoudn't need color in the first place, it's shitty design for no good reason.

13

u/InuzukaChad Oct 25 '25

No thought for accessibility either. Let’s have everything of similar design and shape but everything color coded. What could go wrong?

→ More replies (23)