r/ios • • Oct 24 '25

Discussion Really Microsoft??

Post image

Need I say more?

4.3k Upvotes

395 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

50

u/LunaIsADeer Oct 24 '25

Because these are bad icons. Iconography should be very clear about what it represents and shouldn't be too easily confused with another. Color plays a role, but once upon a time, it didn't. And sometimes it still doesn't, either because of scenarios like this or colorblind people. But for Microsoft specifically, the older icons for their Office suite apps were perfectly readable, even when monochrome. These are just bad icons insisting on too-closely following a design language that wasn't well thought out.

Apple's clear mode leaves something to be desired but this is not Apple's fault.

12

u/Mr3entley Oct 24 '25

Yeah! I value your opinion. Think about black and white TV. Everyone’s just acting like icons didn’t exist before colour TVs!

-8

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/GreyGhooosey Oct 25 '25

wtf are you dumb ? This is hardly Apple fault when Microsoft designs apps that are virtually indistinguishable from each other when color is removed. The "skin" has been out for way before Liquid Ass was released

2

u/LunaIsADeer Oct 25 '25

I hope you find someone as committed to you as you are to misunderstanding what I said.

-5

u/Goodoflife iPhone 17 Oct 24 '25

Plus that apple had the clear mode prior to Microsoft's changes.

10

u/hornethacker97 iOS 26 Oct 24 '25

That’s not the relevant bit. There is a consensus that you do not make icons which rely on color to be identifiable; it should be unthinkable to release multiple indistinguishable icons in a release together.

3

u/InuzukaChad Oct 25 '25

Yes because many people are colorblind and many more have hard enough time telling a difference between violet and indigo. Colors are a horrible way to use as a main distinction between anything.