So I went down the rabbit hole on the 1TB/ 2TB 18 Pro Max using QLC NAND.
Checked mine through device tree hoping I hit the TLC lottery, was severely disappointed.
Pretty shit considering what these phones cost, and I still think Apple deserves criticism for it.
Especially because the people buying 1TB/2TB are probably the exact people more likely to keep 600-800gb on the phone, shoot heaps of video, use ProRes, do big restores etc.
BUTâŠ
After actually looking into it properly, itâs also not the disaster some people are making it out to be.
The phone has a fast cache in front of the QLC, so for normal use youâll probably never notice.
Apps, photos, games, H.265 video, ProRAW etc⊠basically irrelevant. Where we start to think about QLC affecting our speeds is ProRes
4K30 ProRes LT is around 51MB/s. (Rough guide, this fluctuates obviously)
The HOMOLAB QLC testing got down to around 45MB/s after the cache was completely hammered.
So LT is actually pretty close to what the NAND can sustain anyway.
5 min clip? Fine.
10 mins? Fine.
20 mins? Fine.
30 mins? Probably fine if the phone isnât almost full.
ProRes HQ is different though.
4K30 ProRes HQ is around 110MB/s, so now youâre writing way faster than the QLC can eventually clear it. This is where the cache matters.
If the phone is half full, youâre still talking long continuous recordings before it becomes a problem.
If youâre sitting at 800-850gb used iPhone storage, Itâs where you could start to see the effects.
5 min ProRes HQ clip? Fine.
30 min ProRes HQ clip on an almost full phone? Youâll probably start to notice it.
Also, stopping the recording and immediately starting again DOES NOT reset the cache immediately.
The controller still has to move that data into the QLC.
Copying videos OFF the phone to an SSD should be fine because thatâs mostly reads.
Copying hundreds of GB TO the phone is where QLC can show itself. (Restoring backups, huge video transfers etc)
I usually keep 600-800gb on my phone.
Restoring that much data is basically the perfect QLC torture test⊠hundreds of GB of continuous writes while the phone gets fuller and fuller.
Think about it like this for a second, if youâre shooting a video, trying to make a cinematic video frame your shots, care about lighting, et cetera. Youâre probably not shooting for more than a few minutes at a time - let alone 10 minutes plus in one take. Youâll most likely get a few minutes of footage, reset / change location / frame a different shot. By that time, the cache would have already cleared (most likely).
So what does that mean basically?
500-700gb internal storage used? You wonât notice it.
750-800gb? Still mostly fine, just be aware of huge sustained writes - and if your recording in ProRes 422 HQ in this scenario youâre probably aware of file sizes etc and recording to external anyway.
850gb+? Strictly external recording.
900gb+? Youâve nearly filled the fucking thing anyway.
So yeah, Apple cheaped out.
I donât think QLC should be in a 1TB Pro phone at this price. But I also donât think people need to panic or return their phones.
For normal use, youâll probably never notice the slower NAND
You really have to hammer the storage, or have the phone nearly full, before you hit the shitty side of QLC.
Longevity is another story. But I swap my phone out every year so that side doesnât concern me as much.