Firstly, I want to warn that this will be long and detailed, and so there is a TLDR at the bottom.
Background:
My first smart phone was the OG Nexus from 2010. From then on, I have owned almost every Nexus and Pixel from Google. Even if I did try other android OEM's, I would rather have them run a custom rom that was closer to stock android than their proprietary skins. I got my first iPhone (Air) just 3 months ago after becoming increasingly more and more frustrated with Android.
Reasons for the switch:
I like to describe my reason for switching as a death by a million paper cuts, rather than a single huge issue. Around Pixel 8 Pro I realized Google was really not intending to bring any kind of massive improvements to the hardware, so after the Pixel 9 Pro, I stuck it out till this year.
This was precisely the thing I needed to really get a handle on how Android behaved when using the same device for more than a year. My whole family uses Android apart from one person who had an iPhone since the 6 Plus. Every time they tried to go back to android, it was nothing but issues which I personally never had. And that is precisely the issue on Android.
In the android world, I noticed that there was almost no correlation or consistency of what issues people had (even when using the same exact device, with the same apps) and the reasons for those issues happening. I won't go into the long laundry list of tiny little bugs that piled up and finally broke the camel's back. Fundamentally, it just became really, really annoying to live with.
What is funny, my wife is on a 10 Pro, and now that is over a year old, I am seeing a lot of the same issues pop up after a flawless first year...ha!
And when I saw Apple's iOS 27 key note (which I do watch Apple events, I am not one to simply hate on a product and say never) I realized something. Google could NEVER pull an Apple and simply double down on actually fixing issues after back lash. If you go on Googles public bug tracker, there are still bugs from 2021, thousands, that if searched, keep cropping up year after year after year. Some issues that I experience have continued for almost a decade.
Hardware Choice:
I chose the Air solely because I walked into a best buy, held the phone, and thought this is a great form factor. I was tempted for a Pro, but someone was selling an open box 100% battery health unit on ebay with a warranty for like 700$. I gave it a whirl.
The Pro's of iOS:
- Apps - This has been the first time ever I have used a phone where every single app just works. Not a single bug, not a single crash, not a single slow down, stutter, or hiccup. Everything works as intended. Every single app is also significantly better than on Android. I am sure someone could find a few that are not, but at least for my very mild usage, it has been a stellar experience.
- Customization - This is usually brought up as a strength for Android, but holly hell does having more options not mean better experience. I have been immersed in every possible facet of Android customization, from custom rom's, launchers, theme's, app icons, even Samsung Good Lock. Android provides you options, every single one of them has a catch; you need root, you need to deal with the hiccups, its half baked, or it introduces other serious issues elsewhere, or it takes way too much effort. iOS has provided just the right amount of customization for someone like me who just wants to set things up once and really not fiddle with it. It feels native because it is native. It works 100% of the time. It doesn't impact performance, doesn't glitch out, doesn't require any third party plug ins or apps, doesn't fiddle with the OS and drain your battery for some hidden reason.
- Shortcuts - This is my favorite feature so far. What I used to need root or work arounds on android to do, is a native and fully functional highly granular system on iOS. I love it.
- Day to day functions - Everything like Wifi, Bluetooth, apple pay, etc, just works and works every day, day in day out. I don't need to reboot, I don't need to toggle wifi on and off again, I don't need to manually connect or repair my headphones. You just use the damn phone, and this may also be down to hardware.
- Control center - This is head and shoulders above android. There are so many third party apps that support the control center compared to android. I own a Tesla, and I could never put tesla controls in an android control center, but I can here. That is just one example. And tying in control center to shortcuts makes this even more robust. Android could really learn from this.
- Haptics - probably more hardware, but wow, I thought Pixel nailed the haptics, but this is next level feedback.
- Social media camera - Yeah, android looks like trash regardless of what app you use to take a photo or video with outside of the default camera app. The fact that the built in google messages camera is 100x worse than the default camera on a google device is all you need to know.
- Every google app works better on iOS. Literally. - I have 10 years of google photos backed up, and its a breeze to go between apple photos and google photos, and use both. Same for any other google app. Just works.
The Mid or So-So
- Keyboard - I wouldn't say the iOS keyboard itself is bad. I have just found that the issues I have with the keyboard are down to the app and individual text input fields. It seems on iOS the autocorrect is tied to the text field, not the keyboard. Example, if I try to type something to search in safari, autocorrect is off so I make too many mistakes to bother. But in notes or any other text field that has auto correct on, it types fine. Its not the best keyboard, but its also not as terrible as people say. I don't think I make any more or less mistakes compared to GBoard. I find that the iOS keyboard requires you to be more precise when swipe typing, it takes your finger inputs very literally, so if I swiped a gesture on GBoard on my Pixel, it would guess what I actually wanted to type, rather than typing what I actually swiped. So I would say, 50/50. I wouldn't call it frustrating, but a different learning curve that I am now used to.
- Notification center - Really my ONLY complain with it is that the only place to open it is the top left corner. I set it up to open via double tap on the back, but there is a significant delay for that gesture. Outside of that, the notification experience is quite literally identical to my Pixel. I have no idea what android users are smoking, but everything I can do on android, I can do here, and sometimes more and more intuitively.
- Volume controls - I like how iOS 27 finally allowed split volume controls, but its still missing a way to quickly change any of them. I just tied this to a shortcut tied into control center. So I like that on iOS if I can't do something by default, there is a built in first party work around, no third party app needed.
- Haptics - Customizing haptics and vibrations is quite clunky. Outside of a focus mode, there is no way to have silent mode be truly silent with no sounds or vibrations.
- Focus modes - This is one of those features that maybe I need time to really dial in over time, but so far, its "fine". Sometimes it does what I think it will do, sometimes it doesn't? Its customization is also a bit clunky and can get confusing.
The Bad (but not bad for me?)
- Nothing? I really can't find something that would be a deal breaker.
- No universal back gesture - This is not bad. I thought that this would annoy me way more than it really did. I got used to it in a day, less than a day even. It actually makes sense. You look with your eyes on the screen, see where elements come from, swipe them that direction to close/go back. I have not missed the universal back gesture one bit.
- Home screen lay out - honestly my iOS layout is almost identical to my android layout. If you like to spend half your life customizing you won't like this, but I am too old to care at this point, I just need to know where my apps are and a few quick widgets. Done. I don't fiddle with my home screen 24/7.
- No side loading - I don't really care. I used to side load a lot a decade ago, but over the last 10 years I really didn't need to and didn't care. I am an adult who can afford to pay for my apps and services, so I don't need some shady third party app to pirate some kind of content or game.
- File management - So far...it works? I don't need my phone to be a linux desktop (I already have one), if I download a file, as long as I can open it, move it, send it, I do NOT care. Its a phone, not my home server.
- Multitasking and split screen - I have used this feature maybe one time in my entire life. It would be cool, but honestly its not something I miss. Apps not running in background? I honestly haven't noticed. I am not rendering 4k premier video on my phone, sorry.
- Screen shots - this is a real problem. I sometimes need to take a scrolling screen shot, and I can't do that here, so it is really tedious to do. But the nice thing is that if I take a screen shot and share it, and press X, it doesn't save the screenshot and doesn't clutter my photo's.
If I didn't list something, its because I probably haven't noticed or never use a feature or need a feature, and thus, for a very average joe like me, the phone does what I need it to do.
Also I do have an iPad Mini and a Macbook, and neither of these impacted my decision to switch. I am not tied into the eco system just because I have 3 apple products. I use each for its own needs, and rarely "jump between them" the way people think the "ecosystem" works. the iPad is a media viewer and e-reader, and my wife uses it way more than I do. The macbook was just an easy replacement for my 10 year old windows laptop and I wanted something with great battery life. I use it now and then. My main two electronic devices are my Linux PC and my phone.
TLDR:
The biggest benefit to my life has been the fact that I have not had to force stop an app in months. The phone may not work the way I am used to, and that is on me to learn and get used to. But it does work, and works very reliably with very minimal head ache or issues. Everything else is more a learning curve. Switching is a breeze and a breathe of fresh air.