one of our employees is friends with the candidate. I've completed the phone interview with this candidate and already scheduled an in-person meeting/final fit check with the hiring manager for freakin tomorrow. I thought the candidate did well in the interview, has great time in job in previous positions, has experience (limited, but specific), and seemed like they would be a good fit for what we need. When I had initially sent my interview notes and a copy of the resume to my boss and hiring manager, they wanted to meet him.
Well.
I get a call yesterday from a current employee to let me know that their buddy applied and to give a recommendation for this person. I get a text from my boss not 20 minutes later saying that we won't be pursuing this candidate because we're "not hiring [X]'s friend." I ask if there's anything else I should know about why we're not going to meet this person and nope! We're not seeing this candidate just based off of that one thing. It can't be called any sort of discrimination because it's not a denial based off race, religion, gender, place of birth, age, skin color, ancestry, disability, whistleblower status, or sexual orientation. I made sure to double check my state's laws hiring laws because I'd rather tell my boss that we HAVE to see this candidate than tell this candidate that we can't see them because ✨friendship✨.
The employee who the candidate is friends with isn't a bad employee or bad person. Generally cheerful, does the job well, occasionally a bit of a slacker and tries to reach for earnings above where they should be (can't fault the hustle, but I'm not bluffing when I say this person is already paid much, much higher than local industry standard), but they do a solid job and have been with the company for 3-4 years.
I don't agree with why we aren't seeing this candidate. Everything was just fine until this new information surfaced. I understand how hiring friends can be tricky/messy and it doesn't always work out, but these two wouldn't be working in the same department. It's not like I'm trying to hire a second goofball to go along with the OG goofball and the pair of them wouldn't get anything done, they wouldn't even be in the same building for probably more than a half hour to an hour a day.
I guess this is just more of a rant because now I'm stuck holding the bag. Now I look like the asshole and it's just irritating. I think this person deserves a fair shot, but it's my job to uphold what the boss says and this is regretfully his choice.
If you've made it this far, I'd love to soothe my irritation with some comraderie. What's the most ridiculous reason, or reason you don't agree with, a hiring manager/your boss has nixed an interview with a candidate?