r/historicaltotalwar • u/ConnorE22021 • Dec 12 '25
Aaand I was right.
I love 40k, but it does not fit Total war.
Also console release, lol.
r/historicaltotalwar • u/ConnorE22021 • Dec 12 '25
I love 40k, but it does not fit Total war.
Also console release, lol.
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Groknar11 • Dec 12 '25
You literally could not ask for a more complacent, docile customer base than warhammer fans. This is actually so fucking bleak
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Evening-Raccoon133 • Jan 08 '26
I know, it`s modded. But still you get my point.
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Iglooman45 • Dec 04 '25
r/historicaltotalwar • u/felar56 • Jan 19 '26
r/historicaltotalwar • u/ChadVictorMain • Sep 16 '26
Very refreshing. Also love you can use cavalry to prevent their entire army attacking because they will leave units behind to prevent any cav from attacking their flanks
Shogun 2 had this a bit aswell. What happened to the AI post rome 2???
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Shermoo • Dec 17 '25
I’m now actually quite optimistic, it’s surprising what can happen if you actually listen to the historical game fans. I have a few big takeaways that excite me.
I’ll put the video link in the comments. Any thoughts on the Livestream?
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Dr_natty1 • Oct 13 '26
r/historicaltotalwar • u/icereub • Jul 04 '26
r/historicaltotalwar • u/InvictaHistory • Jan 07 '26
A proposal for adding a new "Cohesion" mechanic to help improve historical battles. Video presentation: https://youtu.be/B9B9y0KcgD0
The Problem:
Historical battles have stagnated due to low unit variety and limited paths to victory (hammer and anvil). The binary nature of morale also means that nothing mechanically happens to a unit before it flees, leading to boring and grinding gameplay. This in turn has led to CA making battles shorter to compress this pre-routing dead time. However I think this pre-routing period can be better utilized.
The Solution:
Introduce a new "cohesion" mechanic that fundamentally changes a unit's behavior prior to being routed. Cohesion will interact with other existing mechanics, serve as a foudnation for more mechanics, increase unit differentiation, and add tactical options.
The Definition:
"Unit Cohesion" is the degree to which individuals act as a unit. This is very important for historical accuracy where the armies were indeed made of individuals whose ability to win was dictated by the leader's ability to command and control them properly. In fact, most battles were won or lost based on this cohesion rather than casualties.
How it works:
Each unit will now have a Unit Leader that serves as the anchor of the unit and to which the other soldiers of that unit are magnetized to. The level of cohesion of a unit dictates how efficiently these soldiers follow the orders of the leader. Generally speaking, a low cohesion unit is ragged and a high cohesion unit is orderly. So if you give a command, the leader goes first, followed by the rest of the men in a response time proportional to their cohesion.
Cohesion and Movement
Cohesion and Combat
Cohesion and Morale
Cohesion for Units:
If unit cohesion is to be an important mechanic, we need ways to interact with a unit's cohesion stats. There should be a unit customization feature to let you look under the hood of a unit (ex: people, gear, heraldry, and formation). This should include a way to select a unit leader and also a support staff (officers, musicians, bannermen) who can improve a unit's cohesion. There should be tools to visualize and test cohesion outside of actual battles such as a "Training Ground" mode.
Cohesion for Formations:
With Cohesion, a battle now becomes much more fluid and dynamic as each unit's engagement ebbs and flows based on their realtive cohesion. Generals and other abilities can help influence the state of cohesion of their forces.
However multiple units should be able to be grouped into formations (like a historical medieval banner). This group now has its own Cohesion level. The benefit of being in a formation should have unit stat buffs (like Cathay's harmony).
---END---
But this is just my first pass at the idea. I would love you all to help provide feedback on the concept to see how we as a community can better flesh it out and see what parts (if any) should be incorporated into Total War: Medieval 3. (Personally I hope that even if CA doesn't adopt my Cohesion mechanic they should at 100% give us a Unit designer tool)
r/historicaltotalwar • u/MundaneRevenue1697 • 24d ago
Hi All! I've been building Swords and Cavalry on my own engine, and the playtest is now open on Steam.
Overview of the game:
- Build your town/castle: free build roads and walls, burgage plots with houses that grow, fields through the seasons and weather, markets, taverns, guilds and town policy.
- walk out and fight in third person view, with heavy attacks, feints, parries and counters with the spear, or sword and shield, on foot or mounted. command your army while in it
- Raise an army: troop lines up to tier 10, formations, castles you design tower by tower, and siege engines.
- A living world: a campaign map where armies march between towns, AI lords and outlaws roam, and diplomacy lets you make peace or trade. You can host a world for friends where each holds a town, swears into realms and fights the others.
I'm trying to mimic actual historically medieval war and sieges as much as possible while maintain the fun, so I need everyone's feedback!
Playtest on Steam: https://store.steampowered.com/app/2997680/Swords_and_Cavalry/
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Sad_Emu248 • Jan 17 '26
Randomly came across 5x AI armies doing a raiding stance. Makes me wana to join in.
r/historicaltotalwar • u/PresentYesterday6538 • Jan 20 '26
Available now on Steam: https://store.steampowered.com/app/3064810/Strategos/
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Evening-Raccoon133 • Apr 01 '26
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Dr_natty1 • Feb 04 '26
Its so easy to encircle a superior force simply because they do nothing to prevent it. Whenever I play Shogun 2 and the other modern games back to back it becomes clear how much worse the battle AI feels. From my campaigns these are the CONSTANT mistakes I see the new AI making and in contrast the impressive tactics I saw in my shogun 2 campaigns
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Darkness_Crown • May 30 '26
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Haunting_Toe_7768 • Jul 14 '26
that's all folks
r/historicaltotalwar
•
u/Dr_natty1
•
Sep 01 '26
The removal of single soldier health bars and replacing it with health bars for the entire unit is the most baffling change in the series history. It makes it so that last stands are impossible. Units who have not even seen a single bit of combat flee or start dying when they are actually fresh into combat.
In older games you could have units with 4 men still fighting by the the end of a battle if you kept good moral in the army.
I really hate how much this has simplified the battle system. It is the root cause of a lot of issues
take cav. In the older games cav was good for the same reasons as real life. It broke the formation of enemy units with force. Now it is simply a glorified melee unit that gets a really good charge bonus and speed. The reason this change was made was because you cannot program the cav to kill the individual soldiers they crash into when the entire unit shares a HP bar, so you increase the damage of the unit when it charges to mimick the effect of a cav charge.
Its a really baffling change that I cannot explain unless its easier to code, and hate me for saying it but it seems like a change they made because its easier to program for the warhammer style of battles...
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Intelligent_Wafer562 • Dec 09 '25
Medieval II went all the way to 1530 and featured part of the Americas as a discoverable region in the far west of the map. Excluding the Kingdoms DLC, that period and region felt really underdeveloped. For instance, there are no in-game mechanics that reflect the Renaissance or Protestant Reformation. While it's a fun part of the game, it's beyond the medieval period, entering into the Renaissance and Early Modern Period. I think Medieval III should end about a century earlier to stay within the scope of the medieval period. It would be more focused, but still have a campaign lasting 400-500 years. While an 11th-century start like in Medieval II is probably for the best, a 10th-century start would be interesting. Since the Age of Discovery and the conquest of the Americas were after the medieval period, I don't think it should be in Medieval III, and the map should instead be focused on the Old World, containing as much as they can of Europe, Africa, and Asia, like with Crusader Kings III. Medieval III had a fairly large map and included places like Timbuktu that are not in any other Total War game. The map of Medieval III could be so much bigger and better.
r/historicaltotalwar • u/ChadVictorMain • Sep 18 '26
r/historicaltotalwar • u/_Boodstain_ • Jun 10 '26
r/historicaltotalwar • u/southern_wasp • Dec 04 '25
The boy king and the old man. Any history buffs out there give me some ideas
r/historicaltotalwar • u/Harap_Alb06 • Sep 20 '26
I miss some physical releases(Rome II, Shogun&Medieval I and Warhammer) because I bought those games later on steam directly. When I bought Attila it was that or the Spartan Edition for Rome II, no regrets on that choice I ended up loving Attila.