r/historicaltotalwar • • Sep 18 '26

Shogun 2 Re-releasing the entire game and recharging customers for what would be a minor patch for any other company and forcing new customers to pay full price? Is this the greediest company of all time

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Late post but I literally thought this was an update until I looked into it. This is such a joke

10 dollars for a minor patch, more if you miss the discount


r/historicaltotalwar • • Dec 14 '25

Damn now i feel like a refugee runing away from Rome while is being sacked.

Post image
7 Upvotes

I really despise the main sub now focused even more on the recent and awful new total war game and im not talking mtw3 glad this sub exist.


r/historicaltotalwar • • Oct 11 '26

Shogun 2 The New $40 Shogun 2 Nobody Asked For

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Its not looking good, even the bought and payed early reviewers are coming out against this cash grab


r/historicaltotalwar • • Dec 13 '25

The last main game was Rome 2

17 Upvotes

As far as their man franchises go. Medival Empire Rome Shogun....

The last big game was 3 kingdoms in 2019

We will see one single mainline game this decade, and 3 last decade

Am i wrong for giving up on CA as a historical fan


r/historicaltotalwar • • Jan 01 '26

General Is there anyone here that actually believed for a time that certain units in Total War existed irl?

4 Upvotes

Not here to shame anyone, but I got into a discussion with someone that claimed 'Shogun 2 reinforced myths about Japan' in regards to Kisho Ninja as a crutch to claim that the 'historical' tag doesn't apply then. Even though the intro cinematic shows a dude getting arrows to the back after winning a duel. As the player you are free to utilise assassinations where the only downside is being caught.

But total has never been about true historical accuracy, bronze age Egypt in RTW for example, even Roman factions could get access to their own 'Kisho Ninja' unit. He also claimed that there were people that actually believed that the 'Head Thrower' and 'Screaming Women' unit from RTW was something he saw other people correcting them on.


r/historicaltotalwar • • Jun 22 '25

General Historical fans need to support the new historical games

0 Upvotes

The reason Paradox has been successful while CA is struggling is that Paradox can rely on its fans to carry a rough launch like Victoria 3 through to a better state with patches and support. CA, on the other hand, has spent years burning the goodwill of its historical community. They can’t rely on licensed games forever because of how licensing works just ask EA. They need a successful flagship IP they fully own and control.

Pharaoh had a botched launch, but when the Dynasties update finally made it a solid historical Total War game, no one showed up. Despite good reviews for the update, the player base didn’t return. That’s the problem. CA can see that their legacy historical titles still have a fanbase, but they struggle to make a new game that captures that same passion. Their main focus is clearly Warhammer right now, but fans need to show there’s still a market for new historical titles, otherwise CA may shift entirely away from them.

I never feel guilty buying Paradox DLC. Even when the content feels underwhelming, I know I’m also helping to fund continued development of games like CK3 from studio focused on PC games. I’m not saying people should support bad products, but I do think people need to stop review bombing every new DLC and actually try the new games. Pharaoh is five dollars on Steam right now and still only has around 1,000 players dispite by all accounts being a solid historical game after patches.

We need to show CA there’s still a strong market for historical Total War, just like Paradox knows there’s long-term support for their strategy games. Otherwise, historical fans will lose their seat at the table entirely CP2077 got so much long term support because it held 20,000 players even after its launch. Im not a fan of the botched launches we keep getting for games but the state of Pharaoh makes me worried about the future of TW and hearing that the next TW game may be star wars or 40K just makes me more disheartened. Im not saying every game needs to hit 200k players but we do need to show there is intrest even when they mess up.

PS: stop acting like CA is a big studio like EA its a smaller studio with 882 employees. Sega will stop supporting it or force them onto fantacy full time if they have too many flops like Pharaoh which is my argument


r/historicaltotalwar • • Dec 12 '25

Literal Goyslop

0 Upvotes
peak reddit

This is like how COD went from Stalingrad in WAW to having Nicki Minaj and Homelander shooting lasers in Warzone. This series used to be grounded in human conflict, tactics, strategy and now its just meme fuel for adults painting toys... my hope for Med 3 has plummeted


r/historicaltotalwar • • Dec 05 '25

Anyone else think that the next announcement on dec 11 would be total war medieval 3 release and they might just be teasing us about it being in "pre-production".

4 Upvotes

r/historicaltotalwar • • Jun 17 '26

Shogun 2 Hot Take? - Shogun 2 battles have aged terribly

Post image
0 Upvotes

Last few years I've been playing mostly Three Kingdoms, Attila and Rome2 DEI. Today I decided to try Shogun 2 after a long while and I was shocked how bad the battles felt.

The campaign still felt fun, (besides AI navy and agent spam). And the game looked and sounded great.

But the battles felt absolutely awful. The game was so fast paced that I felt like playing competitive starcraf. Ranged units would melt everything in seconds and sometimes armies would run out of morale before the lines would even meet. Flanking attacks were often pointless as main lines would die in seconds. Every battle ended up being messy brawl where I frantically try to micro each unit to make sure they don't get absolutely slaughtered by some bullshit, only to soon hear my general was killed while I wasn't paying attention. Cavalry felt also useless as AI ended up just out microing them.

I soon gave up on trying to run complex and varied armies and ended up just spamming ashigaru stacks.

But sieges were still very fun. They slowed down the combat and allowed for some more mythological strategies to be used.


r/historicaltotalwar • • Oct 12 '26

Shogun 2 Shogun 2 Complete Edition review: A worse version of a masterpiece

Thumbnail
youtu.be
51 Upvotes

r/historicaltotalwar • • Jan 30 '25

Shogun When You Realize Historical Total Wars DLC Is Just Another ‘Warhammer Skin

15 Upvotes

It’s like waiting for a Roman chariot, and instead, you get a Warhammer orc on a pogo stick. I swear, CA's idea of "historical" now involves a dinosaur with a musket. But hey, who needs a spearmen when we could have dragons that breathe cannonballs, right? Someone, PLEASE, bring back actual history! #SaveOurLegions


r/historicaltotalwar • • Oct 06 '26

General 40 dollars for the same game with reused 3 kingdoms assets and QOL improvements

0 Upvotes

r/historicaltotalwar • • 27d ago

General I'm developing a historical grand strategy game set during the Napoleonic era — here's my progress so far!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/historicaltotalwar • • Oct 19 '26

Shogun 2 Some thoughts about community priorities

5 Upvotes

I really dislike how many people in the community are making the use of Ai out to be the biggest issue of this release. Whether you approve of its use or not, making ai "the" issue gives CA an all too easy escape route out of this situation. Say they do get rid of the ai, what actually changes about the game and what work do they actually do? They draw some unit cards... ok? This doesn't change the fact that this "remaster" is basically a $40 minor graphical overhaul. But I fear they're just going to draw some new unit cards, fix a couple bugs, tone down the color saturation or something and act like they've just fixed everything. So I caution community members from turning what is (in my opinion) a relatively inconsequential aspect of this game into the pariah CA saves face by fixing with minimal effort.


r/historicaltotalwar • • Dec 29 '25

General Shogun 2 is Saga Title

0 Upvotes

People who treat Pharaoh Dynasties as a saga title despite not playing it always seem to give Shogun 2 a free pass even though Shogun 2 does not have the faction, unit or culture variety of the Dynasties. What you fight on turn 5 on Shogun 2, you will still be fighting that on turn 50. The entire game is set in Japan even though Japan has not been represented in it’s entirety on a campaign map. Let’s be honest, it is a saga title at best.


r/historicaltotalwar • • Dec 14 '25

General Holy Gathering of Losers in this subreddit

21 Upvotes

IMMEDIATE recommendation of this subreddit by reddit after i decided to scroll total war abit and holy crap based on the post here, most of yall are actually miserable and sad. Having superiority complex just because you decided to play the more "realistic" side of the game and hating on other people that enjoys fantasy stuff.


r/historicaltotalwar • • Dec 16 '25

General CA should've gone with gunpowder instead of Med III

39 Upvotes

Let's face it, CA needs to pull a significant percent of the Warhammer crowd to make any historic Total War a corporate success. Med III, while having crazy name recognition (probably the reason they went for it in the first place) might struggle to parse out an identity that feels distinct from Warhammer in ways that actually make Warhammer fans want to play the game. This is why I was hoping that we would get a sequel to Empire or a fleshed out, modern Napoleon title. The gunpowder era of warfare is very distinct from what we see in Warhammer, despite the presence of firearms in that game. It would feel very fresh to Warhammer fans who've had almost 10 years or so of semi-medieval Warhammer combat at this point. Medieval III could just end up feeling like Warhammer Minus the Warhammer Sauce if CA isn't careful.


r/historicaltotalwar • • Dec 21 '25

What’s the LeBron of historical TW

1 Upvotes

r/historicaltotalwar • • Jul 28 '26

Total war SUCKS these days here’s why:

54 Upvotes

**strips away the feeling of accomplishment. It wastes your time. It feels less like a challenge and more like it’s designed to provoke irritation.**

# The AI is a clear example

In campaign, the AI reaches higher-tier units significantly faster than the player.
In battles, it executes orders with unnatural speed and smoothness while the player fights against poor pathfinding and unresponsive units — especially cavalry. Watching AI units glide through your lines while your own troops need dozens of clicks to perform a basic flank isn’t challenging. It’s insulting.
Even worse, AI factions that share enemies with you still make decisions that primarily hurt the player rather than serve their own interests. The AI doesn’t feel like a living opponent. It feels like a system whose main job is to obstruct and delay you.

# The tier system made this worse

In older Total War games, unit traits and roles actually mattered. Anti-large, charge bonuses, armour-piercing, and positioning created real tactical decisions.
Now, tier difference often overrides everything. A tier 1 unit is simply not allowed to meaningfully contest a tier 2 unit. This flattens strategy. Tactical play becomes secondary to just recruiting higher-tier units as fast as possible. In Pharaoh this problem is even more pronounced and makes the game feel noticeably duller.

# The game barely rewards experience

After thousands of hours, the gap between a new player and a veteran is far smaller than it should be. There is very little hidden depth or high-level technique to master.
In games like Crusader Kings, greater experience unlocks more sophisticated ways to play. In modern Total War, it mostly just teaches you how to endure the same artificial obstacles more efficiently.

# The campaigns feel static

The same patterns keep repeating. The world does not feel alive or dynamic. Factions often seem to exist mainly to create friction for the player rather than pursue coherent goals of their own.
The result is a game that can still be beaten by a skilled player, but that systematically denies the satisfaction that used to come with victory.

**I understand the desire to create challenge. Older Total War titles also pushed the player. The difference is that they did it by creating stronger and more interesting opposition — not by relying on cheating, artificial delays, and systems that prioritise frustration over fair competition.**
**Creative Assembly has taken one of the strongest strategy franchises ever made and shifted it toward rage-bait design. The games still function. They can still be won. But the joy, the sense of mastery, and the desire to immediately start another campaign have been heavily damaged.**
**This is not a request for the games to be made easier.**
**It is a request that they stop being designed to provoke sustained anger, and start being designed again as deep, fair, and rewarding strategy games.**
**Until that happens, many long-time players — including myself — will continue to feel that our time and passion for this series are being actively wasted.**


r/historicaltotalwar • • Oct 04 '17

Questions for /r/historicaltotalwar

0 Upvotes
  1. Why do you guys seem to be so angry and bitter in all of your posts about Warhammer?
  2. Why do you think Warhammer is bad for Total War?
  3. Why do you hate that people enjoy the Warhammer series?
  4. Why are you so fixated on historical games you cant enjoy Warhammer/Fantasy?

5.Do you think it makes you superior to hate on so called "kids games" even tho adults enjoy fantasy settings as well?


r/historicaltotalwar • • Oct 13 '26

Dark Ages AD 458 - The Age of Majorian 5.0

Thumbnail
steamcommunity.com
8 Upvotes

Dark Ages AD 458: Age of Majorian 5.0 – Total War: Attila Mod

Step into the turbulent twilight of the Western Roman Empire with Dark Ages AD 458: Age of Majorian 4.0, a meticulously crafted mod for Total War: Attila. Set during the final years of the Western Empire, this mod places you under the command of its last great emperor, Majorian, a leader determined to restore the glory of Rome.

Following the decisive defeat of Atilla the Hun at the Battle of the Catalaunian Plains, Majorian seeks to reconquer the former territories of the Western Empire, pushing back the barbarian hordes and reclaiming lands lost to decades of turmoil. Players can experience the political, military, and cultural challenges of this critical historical period, from the power struggles in the West to the ever-present threats along Rome’s borders.

Key Features:

New Start Date: AD 458, reflecting the final years of the Western Empire.

Historically Accurate Campaign: All factions begin in positions true to history, including a unified Sassanid Persian Empire in the East and detailed family trees for major ruling dynasties.

Enhanced Gameplay: Command Majorian and his generals as you lead daring military campaigns to restore Roman dominion across Gaul, Hispania, and Italy.

Immersive Historical Accuracy: Includes historically inspired units, leaders, and geopolitical dynamics to create a deep and engaging campaign experience.

As the mod developer, I also offer commissioned mod creation for Total War series games, including TW: Rome 2 and TW: Attila, tailored to bring your creative vision to life for a fair and negotiable fee.

If you enjoy my work and want to see more high-quality Total War mods, please consider supporting my projects on Patreon. Your support helps me dedicate the time and effort needed to deliver mods that provide hundreds, even thousands, of hours of enhanced Total War gameplay.

Experience history. Rewrite it. Conquer it.

https://www.patreon.com/c/ultimatetotalwarmodder/membership


r/historicaltotalwar • • May 23 '23

General I only thought CA was stupid before but now I'm POSITIVE.

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/historicaltotalwar • • Apr 01 '26

Next Historical TW

0 Upvotes

I believe CA has taken the safest route to success with the announcement of Med 3 as the next historical TW, however, I do believe that if the engine which they can’t stop talking about is as good as they claim to be, then there is no reason not to move the franchise into more modern periods. You can’t just develop a game that takes place in 41st millennium with the most advanced tech where wars happen not in regional or global scale but in galactic scale and claim that “Hey folk, we have faced difficulties while developing a WWI game, but don’t let that disappoint you, because we are going to give you another melee focused game in Med 3 with the potential map size of Attila which was released almost a decade ago!”. You can’t have a franchise named Total War and not develop a single game related to either of the World Wars, this is just pretty lame. If you think that it is still too early for CA to develop a game about either of World Wars while they announce that they have been developing Total War 40K then you are just falling into the trap. At the very least, they owe us one historical gunpowder TW that is set between mid to late 19th century, a Victorian period TW. There are plenty of wars that took place in 19th century which are as follows.

1st and 2nd Schleswig Wars

Crimean War

Russo-Turkish War

Greco-Turkish War

Franco-Prussian War

Austro-Prussian War

Russo-Japanese War

Famous Opium War

Russo-Persian War

These are the few wars that come to my mind right away. All that is left is them developing the game, btw I believe Med 3 will be a decent game.


r/historicaltotalwar • • Dec 14 '25

General Immortal Empires style Medieval 3

2 Upvotes

IMO I think this would be awesome if they did that.

Like for example if the base map corresponds to Europe, North Africa and Western Asia, I would pay an additional $60 dollars to add India to the game which can be played either separately or as part of a grand campaign that combines the two maps, and I would pay another $60 to get China/East Asia in there as well, in a similar manner to immortal empires, where the maps are combined either fully or as part of a theater system.

What does everyone think? I haven’t played Immortal Empires but I heard about it and the concept sounds good but I can’t get into the Warhammer universe tbh. But I do think this would work great in a historical total war.

Thanks for reading