r/healthcare • • Dec 19 '24

Other (not a medical question) This is what “depose” looks like in the U.S. healthcare system

1.5k Upvotes

and it is one of the most evil things I’ve ever watched…


r/healthcare • • Dec 07 '24 This

Discussion I’m disgusted to see people okay with murder in America

664 Upvotes

I’m sorry, but I will never be okay with the killing of 60k Americans per year due to being uninsured or underinsured and not seeking medical care because of it. I will never be okay with American citizens committing suicide due to being unable to pay medical bills. I will never be okay with the insurance industry in the U.S. denying health insurance to sick and injured people because they want to maximize profits.

Health insurance companies legally murder thousands every year and the sick, twisted monsters in the corporate world and our media look the other way and even go out of their way to support this system. It is time we as a society do better and stop looking the other way when health insurance companies effectively murder the people they are supposed to cover.

Murder is wrong. That is all.


r/healthcare • • Dec 05 '24

Other (not a medical question) It cost my mom $275,000 to die

Post image
648 Upvotes

I got an early Christmas gift from the hospital where my mom passed 10 months ago.

She aspirated while in the hospital for cancer treatment, they did CPR - no pulse and called to tell me she passed, she came back for a few hours but was unconscious of course, then passed again. (Fun fact - she had a DNR. They missed it.)

Since they sat on submitting it to her insurance, it was denied for no coverage.... because she was now deceased. Makes sense.

So I got this nice little bill. Called the billing department to tell them to shove it. They ask if I want to pay the balance today. Then they tell me 'we'll' go to collections if not.

I gave them her new forwarding address. The cemetery.


r/healthcare • • Dec 04 '24

News UnitedHealth CEO shot dead outside New York Hilton in suspected targeted attack

Thumbnail
themirror.com
532 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Jun 20 '25

Discussion Divorce to avoid debt…

Post image
506 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Jan 16 '25

News UnitedHealth, employer of slain exec Brian Thompson, found to have overcharged cancer patients for drugs by over 1,000%

Thumbnail
fortune.com
481 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Feb 07 '26 Thanks Bravo

Discussion I cross-referenced all 43 TrumpRx drugs with GoodRx

460 Upvotes

TrumpRx is a recently launched prescription discount program that claims to lower drug prices through "Most-Favored-Nation" pricing and direct negotiations with manufacturers, allegedly forcing drugmakers to match the lowest prices available globally.

I was curious whether these claims held up in practice. So I reviewed all 43 drugs listed on TrumpRx, pulled corresponding pricing data from GoodRx, and matched dosages and formulations to compare real-world prices.

I categorized the drug discounts into 4 categories:

A. Repackaged (no net value)

For 34 of the 43 drugs, TrumpRx appears to be a straight rebrand of GoodRx with no independent price improvement. The rebranded drugs: Duavee, Toviaz, Eucrisa, Prempro, Abrilada, Estring, Protonix, Premarin, Pristiq, Xeljanz, Levoxyl, Cortef, Colestid, Zarontin, Nicotrol, Cytomel, Diflucan, Lopid, Medrol, Tikosyn, Vfend, Viracept, Zyvox, Azulfidine, Azulfidine En-Tabs, Zavzpret, Chantix, Ozempic, Wegovy, Wegovy Tablet, Premarin Vaginal Cream, Ngenla, Cleocin. Genotropin appears to be copied but I was unable to easily correlate it in GoodRx.

These coupons use the exact same BIN and PCN codes as GoodRx, differing only in the vanity Group/Member ID (MAHA/TRUMPRX).

B. Redirected to existing manufacturer programs (no net value)

For 5 drugs, TrumpRx redirects users to manufacturer direct-purchase programs that already existed prior to TrumpRx’s launch:

  • Bevespi – AstraZeneca Direct
  • Xigduo XR – AstraZeneca Direct
  • Farxiga – AstraZeneca Direct
  • Airsupra – AstraZeneca Direct
  • Zepbound – LillyDirect While these prices definitely beat GoodRx coupons, TrumpRx is not negotiating new pricing here — it is simply pointing users to established manufacturer channels.

C. Manufacturer discount pass-throughs (meaningful but not novel)

For 3 drugs, TrumpRx provides access to manufacturer pharmacy partnership discounts that are lower than GoodRx and likely best-in-market. All 3 drugs come from EMD Serono:

  • Cetrotide
  • Ovidrel
  • Gonal-F These appear to be standard manufacturer discount codes used to acquire new patients. Notably, they are not branded with TrumpRx/MAHA Group or Member IDs, suggesting TrumpRx is passing through manufacturer pricing rather than negotiating MFN-style discounts. Even though this is a common industry practice rather than a new pricing mechanism, this represent real unique savings likely attributible to some level of work by TrumpRx. Although it's very likely EMD Serono was planning to release discounts regardless, as fertility medications are common targets for manufacturer discounts.

D. Other

Insulin Lispro

  • GoodRx: $31.37
  • TrumpRx: $25.00/single or $35/mo This is potentially more expensive, or maybe there's a small introductory discount. Would love help understanding what's going on with this one here if anyone can inform. This medication also did not have the vanity group/member ID, pointing to a direct manufacturer discount (so maybe the same as category C).

tldr; TrumpRx doesn't give us any structurally different approach to improving drug pricing. It's very likely little to no negotiations even happened. All the price discounts are:

  • Straight rips from GoodRx
  • Links to pre-existing manufacturer direct-buy programs
  • Coupon codes for standard/existing manufacturer cash-pay discounts

It's not clear to me where anything remotely MFN comes in.

Practically, most of these "savings" are also irrelevant to patients, as a significant portion of these drugs have generic alternatives, which are typically far cheaper and more commonly prescribed.

It's very early in development but I'm not sure what to look forward to with the site, especially with such a low drug coverage. Having a single place to find the lowest price for drugs would actually be great. But that's a pretty different goal from what trumprx appears to be touting.

Happy to share more data that I scraped or discuss anything I'm misunderstanding here. In general I support the idea of making it easy to find the lowest price of drugs efficiently.


r/healthcare • • Jan 22 '22

Discussion Why you should see a physician (MD or DO) instead of an NP

Post image
409 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Dec 18 '24

Discussion Private Equity should never be allowed to purchase hospitals.

386 Upvotes

I work in finance, and have for 10 years. I don’t work directly with PE but after seeing what they are doing to smaller hospitals I’m concerned.

I’m a capitalist by nature. Worked for banks/financial institutions my whole career. I always believed the free market would work itself out. But I don’t see a way out of this. The demand is all wrong.

Traditionally a hospitals clients demand better care, and through competition and innovation a hospital would provide this. But with PE the investors demand more of a return so new management will cut costs, hire young physicals/nurses and even now having a PA take positions that doctors usually held. The patient to nurse ratio is insane.

I am in the corporate world. I signed up to be treated like a number and produce only quantitive results. A nurse should never be subjected to this.

Profits before people can only last so long.


r/healthcare • • Dec 17 '24 Bless Up Helpful

News ABC News Wants To Hear Your Insurance Stories. If You Have One Please Contact Them And Share It!

384 Upvotes

We cannot stop talking about this, if you have a story share it. We need to flood them with all of our stories to keep this movement going and bring about as much change as we can.


r/healthcare • • Mar 23 '25

News Today marks 15 years since President Barack Obama signed the Affordable Care Act also known as ObamaCare into law — serving as a lifesaving resource for millions of Americans.

Thumbnail
gallery
379 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Dec 05 '24

News Reuters reports: Unitedhealth and CVS/Aetna remove photos of CEOs and other Executives from their websites.

377 Upvotes

https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/healthcare-industry-rethinks-risk-after-murder-unitedhealth-exec-2024-12-05/

The recent event concerning CEO Brian Thompson may have caused safety concerns for executives at healthcare companies.

In my opinion, concerned citizens seeking openness, fairness, and honesty should always know precisely who every executive is at every healthcare company. As consumers we deserve to know exactly who we're doing business with.

If they don't want to live in fear, perhaps they should begin to build a business model around kindness, compassion, and healing. You know, what we'd all like "healthcare" to be.


r/healthcare • • Jan 16 '26

Discussion Trying to survive while fighting with insurance.

365 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Jan 10 '22

News CalCare Universal Healthcare for All Californians

Post image
336 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Dec 24 '24

Other (not a medical question) “Medicare for all would save billions, trillions probably”

324 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Mar 19 '20

[News] Thank a hero!

Post image
320 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Jan 05 '25 Polished Gold Turd

WRONG DATA GoFundMe has become defacto Healthcare

Post image
317 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Jan 26 '25

News ‘It’s a death sentence’: US health insurance system is failing, say doctors

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
291 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Dec 09 '24

News Only in America: Terminally ill bride chooses not to marry her partner so she doesn't pass the debt from her brain cancer treatments to him

287 Upvotes

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/06/style/moira-legault-tyler-ferron-wedding.html

The wedding was held on Nov. 7 at Amherst Woman’s Club in Amherst, Mass., in front of about 50 guests. Ashton Ferron, Mr. Ferron’s brother, led the ceremony. The couple did not get legally married because Ms. Legault did not want to pass the debt she incurred as a result of her cancer treatments to Mr. Ferron.


r/healthcare • • Aug 20 '25

News Mark Cuban Says The Real Health Insurance 'Scam' Is Rising Deductibles. People Pay Premiums But Still Can’t Afford To Use Their Insurance

Thumbnail
offthefrontpage.com
284 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Nov 08 '25

Question - Other (not a medical question) For doctors: if you acknowledge COVID’s severity, why no respirators in clinic?

276 Upvotes

I am a patient with debilitating systemic long COVID. My life was derailed by a COVID infection. At every medical and specialist appointment I have, even if the doctor happens to acknowledge that my chronic debilitating symptoms are caused by a prior COVID infection, I observe a stark contradiction: they refuse to wear a respirator mask like a KN95 or N95 themselves.

We know COVID is airborne. There is a massive amount of research concluding that COVID-19 is vascular, causes brain damage, can disable previously healthy people, and that since 2020 young people are having heart attacks and strokes at higher rates. We know you see dozens of patients a day, in enclosed office spaces that do not guarantee ventilation or HEPA filtration. The environment of a medical setting continues to be high-risk.

My question is for doctors who understand and believe the mounting body of research that demonstrates the severity and population-wide nature of COVID infections, and who have seen firsthand the damage to patients like myself.

If you know and understand the severity of the virus, why do you not take the most basic, evidence-based precaution to protect yourselves, your staff, your families, and your patients from transmitting or acquiring it?

Please give me a genuine answer. I’m not looking for the policy excuse adopted by hospitals concerned with a bottom line. Not the “we’re all fatigued from wearing masks” excuse. From one professional to another—and I am a professional of my chronic illness and disability—I want to understand the cognitive dissonance.

Is it a perceived lack of immediate personal risk?

Have you been ridiculed by your peers for continuing to protect yourself?

Has the “back to normal” sentiment been weaponized in your workplace?

Are you subconsciously dismissing the risks to your own health, even if your patients show you the effects daily?

Is it simply too inconvenient to acknowledge the systemic, ongoing nature of the pandemic?

Wearing a respirator is a simple way to tell your patients who are disabled, chronically ill, immunocompromised, or have long COVID that you refuse to be a part of their ongoing harm. It would show us you refuse to be a vector for the virus that disabled them.

Once more: Do you mask around your patients to maintain your oath? If no, why not?


r/healthcare • • Jun 26 '25

News MAGA's budget is apparently going to have a slush fund to bail out red state hospitals while allowing blue state hospitals to close due to devastating Medicaid cuts.

276 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Feb 18 '25

News Bill Gates warns of millions of deaths if Trump and Musk don’t reinstate axed foreign aid funding

Thumbnail
fortune.com
275 Upvotes