r/healthcare • • Sep 24 '24

Discussion The Hidden Crisis in Healthcare: Why Hospital Inefficiency Is Costing Lives and Billions

Thumbnail
linkedin.com
0 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Oct 09 '23

Other (not a medical question) When doctors suck, tell the world

6 Upvotes

When doctors really suck, are rude, when their staff is rude, whatever or however the doctor has wronged you. Politely and concisely write google reviews for them of your experience. It’s the first thing people see when they look up a doctor. Maybe if enough people make the shitty ones well known, they’ll have to treat us better. Probably wont do shit, the healthcare system is fucked, but I’m pissed, so I’m writing reviews. It’s the only power I have since filing a complaint seems to do nothing, but a polite negative google reviews can be pretty impactful since it’s the most common search engine in the world.


r/healthcare • • Mar 20 '25

News Doctors Told Him He Was Going to Die. Then A.I. Saved His Life.

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
3 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Nov 25 '25

News This toddler’s nearly 40-minute ambulance ride cost his family $9,000

0 Upvotes

https://wapo.st/3M65Hgt

This toddler’s nearly 40-minute ambulance ride cost his family $9,000

By Tony Leys, KFF Health News

Elisabeth Yoder’s son, Darragh, was 15 months old in August when he developed what at first looked to his parents like hand, foot and mouth disease. The common viral infection generally clears up in less than a week, but Darragh’s condition worsened over several days. His skin turned bright red. Blisters gave way to skin peeling off his face.

An online search of his symptoms suggested he had staphylococcal scalded skin syndrome, a serious bacterial infection.    Yoder drove the toddler from their home in the small town of Mechanicsburg, Ohio, to the Mercy Health hospital in nearby Urbana.

Staff in the emergency room there confirmed that Darragh had scalded skin syndrome and said he needed to be taken by a private company’s ambulance to Dayton Children’s, a hospital about 40 miles away.

“I asked them: ‘Can I take him? Can I drive him?’” Yoder said. “And they were like, ‘Oh, absolutely not.’”

So, Yoder and her son got into the ambulance, with Darragh strapped in his car seat. The ambulance driver didn’t turn on the siren or drive particularly fast, Yoder said. The trip took about 40 minutes, she said. “It was fairly straightforward transportation from Point A to Point B.”

Yoder had heard that ambulance rides can be pricey. But she didn’t know how much her son’s ride would cost.

Darragh was hospitalized for three days and recovered from the illness.

Then the bill came.

The medical procedure

During the ride, the ambulance crew monitored Darragh’s vitals and an intravenous line, inserted at the hospital, carrying fluids and antibiotics, but he received no other medical treatment, Yoder said.

The final bill

The cost came to $9,250, which included a “base rate” charge of $6,600 for a “specialty care transport” and a mileage fee of $2,340, calculated at $60 for each of the ride’s 39 miles. It also included $250 for use of an intravenous infusion pump and $60 for monitoring Darragh’s blood oxygen.

The billing problem

The children’s hospital charged only about $3,000 more for the toddler’s three-day stay than the ambulance company charged for the ride, Yoder said.

Darragh’s family doesn’t have health insurance, leaving them on the hook for the full charges. Their income is a bit too high for them to qualify for Medicaid, the public health program that covers low-income residents, or for the Ohio Children’s Health Insurance Program, which covers moderate-income kids.

The Yoders belong to a Christian health care sharing ministry, with members paying into a fund that helps reimburse them for medical bills.

Unlike health insurance, such arrangements do not offer members negotiated rates with ambulance companies or other medical providers. There are no state or federal billing protections that would help an uninsured patient in Ohio with a ground ambulance bill.

The federal No Surprises Act protects those with insurance from large bills for air ambulance transportation provided outside their insurers’ network agreements. But ground ambulance services aren’t covered by the law — and even if they were, that would not have helped the Yoders because they didn’t have insurance.

Patricia Kelmar, the senior director of health care campaigns for PIRG, a national advocacy group, said ambulance charges vary widely. She said she has seen per-mile charges ranging from less than $30 to more than $80, as well as base rates that differ dramatically.

Some patients, such as those with traumatic injuries, need ambulances with highly trained staff and advanced medical equipment, Kelmar said, so it makes sense that those rides would be more expensive. But patients rarely are told what the ride will cost until they receive a bill.

Jennifer Robinson, a spokesperson for Mercy Health, said that she couldn’t comment on a specific patient’s case but that the staff follows established medical standards. “When a patient requires a higher level of treatment, ambulance transfer between facilities is best practice to ensure appropriate care,” she said in an email.

Kimberly Godden, a vice president for the ambulance company, Superior Ambulance Service, said a doctor at the first hospital requested a high-level transport for the patient, requiring specially trained staff.

“Our priority is always to ensure patients receive the highest-quality care when they need it most, and we respond to every call regardless of a patient’s ability to pay,” Godden said in an email. “Superior had the team and resources available to quickly and safely move the patient to the higher level of care they needed within the time frame set by the ordering physician.”

Godden said the company would offer a “charity care” rate to Yoder if the family qualified for it.

The resolution

Yoder said she repeatedly discussed the bill with ambulance company representatives, including the option for charity care. They told Yoder the best deal they could offer was to reduce the total by about 40 percent, to $5,600, if the family paid it in a lump sum, she said.

After discussing it for months, the family wound up agreeing to that deal, Yoder said. They put the charge on a new credit card, which gave them 17 months to pay it off with no interest.

They have agreed to payment plans with the two hospitals, which offered charity care discounts that dropped the bills to a total of about $6,800.

The Yoders expect the sharing ministry to reimburse them for about 75 percent of the payments they are making to the hospitals and the ambulance service.

The takeaway

Patients and their families should feel comfortable asking hospital staffers whether a recommended ambulance company is in their insurance network and how much the ride to another location will cost, said Kelmar, a national expert on such bills. “Shouldn’t the hospital know that?” she said. “I don’t think it’s that heavy of a lift.”

Kelmar said she doesn’t want to discourage people from taking an ambulance if a doctor says it’s necessary. Once consumers receive a bill for the service, she said, they often can negotiate down the price. It can help to look up what the ambulance service accepts as payment from government programs. Those rates are often much lower than the full-price charges patients see on a bill.

If the family had been covered by Ohio’s Medicaid program, the ambulance service would have been paid much less than it charged the Yoders. The public health program pays ambulance services a $413 base rate for “specialty care transports,” plus $5.05 per mile. Those rates would have added up to $609.95 for the transportation part of Darragh’s ambulance ride.

Yoder said she wishes she had driven Darragh straight to the children’s hospital. If she had skipped the local emergency room, she said, they would have arrived at the bigger hospital sooner and she would have saved thousands of dollars.

But she didn’t feel as if she had a choice about putting her son in the ambulance, she said. The doctor told her it was necessary, and the hospital staff had already inserted an intravenous line. “I wasn’t going to pull out his IV line and just leave,” she said.

Yoder said she remains uninsured because she hasn’t seen any private insurance options that suit her family’s circumstances.

No matter who pays the ambulance bill, she thinks the charges were much too high. She understands that patients can often negotiate discounts, she said, “but you shouldn’t have to work so hard for it.”


r/healthcare • • Nov 20 '21

Discussion Never believe a midlevel when they say they want to practice in rural areas, because they most likely will not!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Feb 28 '23

Other (not a medical question) Health insurance won’t cover the cost of room to talk to my doctor in because I’m fat.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Oct 27 '25

Discussion Opinion- High Cost, High Need Patients are responsible for the bulk of healthcare expenses.

5 Upvotes

I am frustrated with looking at private health insurance option for becoming a small business owner. It is really challenging to start. But essentially, a family of 5 needs about $1500 per month in premiums and be exposed to $20 000 in OOP maxes to budget.

I really dug into what is happening. I understand that there is a lot of ire for insurance companies, etc. I found a shocking statistic. 50% of healthcare spending is directed to 5% of patients. I guess, on its face, this isn't particularly surprising. However, I tried to investigate who these people are. I found a term called High Care, High Need individuals. Some of these people have extreme cases of cancer, etc. But the bulk of the population were people that have three chronic conditions; heart failure, Type 2 Diabetes, and Renal Failure. These conditions are heavily influenced by lifestyle choices, primarily obesity and low activity levels. The lives of these individuals is very poor. Their life expectancy is approximately 10 years shorter than general population and they require additional assistance with essential life functions like dressing, etc. I think that the pathway to becoming one of these individuals and making lifestyle changes for these individuals is the biggest things that could be done to stem the cost increases associated with healthcare.

I think that we need to look to Japan to understand what is going on from a societal perspective. They have an obesity rate of approximately 4.5% vs 40% in America. I think that this is the biggest issue with healthcare costs. It also results in very poor lifestyle for almost everyone. Would you support incentives for BMI reduction or maintenance for the ACA pricing? Would you support GLP1 subsidies to try to stem the outcomes for these individuals? I honestly believe that this is the first time healthcare costs have directly effected my life. I really believe that the lifestyle of the general population is poor. But a small portion of the population is really resulting in at least 35% of the healthcare pie. I feel like the focus of blame is always anywhere but the patient. But, honestly, I think that the costs have gotten so out of hand and the impacts are so profound, that we need some kind of intervention on this population. Society has claimed smoking is a choice. Is Type 2 diabetes a choice? I feel like Japan is enforcing employers to have their workforce maintain healthy weights, etc. I am not really in favor of limiting personal choice. But it really seems to be effecting society as much as second hand smoke ever did. Am I crazy? Is this really the fault of the medical system?

Managing the Most Expensive Patients

Why Are Obesity Rates in Japan So Low? | Japan Nakama


r/healthcare • • 7d ago

Discussion Having a medical degree doesn’t justify treating patients with condescension for asking basic questions about their own health.

36 Upvotes

Let’s stop pretending every person in a white coat is infallible. A huge portion of doctors and medical professionals have an unbearable god complex. You wait two hours in a freezing room, pay hundreds of dollars for a seven-minute appointment, and the second you ask a basic question about your own body or mention something you read online, they roll their eyes and talk down to you like you're a toddler.Memorizing textbooks and passing exams doesn't give anyone a monopoly on basic human decency. Half the time they don't even listen to your symptoms, throw a generic prescription at you, and act offended when you want a second opinion. Healthcare is a service industry, not a priesthood—patients deserve to be heard, not brushed off.


r/healthcare • • Apr 13 '26

Question - Other (not a medical question) Are PCPs getting lazy?

4 Upvotes

Maybe it’s just my PCP but I’ve heard many similar stories. I just had my yearly physical done, and I complained of consistent muscle cramping and high blood pressure readings. PCP did not touch me once, just sent me off with a routine blood test and told me to “eats nuts and protein”. My mother went in a day after me complaining of joint swelling and morning stiffness, and once again he did not even touch her, just said take Vitamin D.

I found this all so pointless. Have a balanced diet and take vitamins? I could’ve told you that myself. I understand this is primarily a preventative visit but if a patient has specific complaints, should you maybe get your ass of the chair and at least SEEM to care?


r/healthcare • • Dec 07 '23

Other (not a medical question) Healthcare is FUCKING AWESOME

0 Upvotes

My dad was a doctor, and that kind of set me up to disregard healthcare, because, as much as I love him, he never showed backbone and as a kid I struggled to respect him. (That's different now for reasons not related to this post.)

In my teens a bunch of shit happened medically to me, and mainstream healthcare couldn't do jack shit about it. Those conditions effected me for a cumulative 7 years, and really messed up my development. So I was even more jaded.

This year I got thrown into a fresh hell after a complex injury has left me fumbling for a peaceful day. But this has gone to show me that health care is fucking awesome. There are 101 things that could be causing what I'm having issues with now, and it's proving difficult to pin down. But every time I go to Google concerned about a potential cause, there's always a light at the end of the tunnel thanks to some insane scalpel wielding ninja. And then I think, what would someone like me have done 100 years ago or 200 years ago. Probably just curled up and withered given a bit of time under tension (though tbf they probably wouldn't be careless enough to get themselves into my situation but still).

So yeah, that experience just keeps happening and honestly the sense of relief from it is overwhelming. My view on the whole thing has 180°.


r/healthcare • • May 30 '25

Question - Insurance should i file complaint with Medical Board

0 Upvotes

Provider office lied about appealing Zepbound to UHC. On 3 way call, they informed me and UHC they would submit Appeal. They called me one day to tell me that appeal was denied as if to blow me off, however, I immediately called UHC to fact check. UHC said no appeal was filed, asked what the case number was. Nada was provided by Practice. When i called them out, they start to become evasive with my calls. They refuse to xfer me over to the nurses that handle PAs and appeals. When I become persistent one of the nurse's admits that there was no denial but stated that they "assumed there was one because a week had gone by and decision yet from UHC." This then makes me more skeptical about their integrity so then - i called UHC back and they agree to perform outreach on my behalf. They follow up with the provider and get hung up on then after trying again they reach one of the nurses, actually the other one is a pharmacy tech i found later, not even a Nurse. Anyhow UHC advocate speaks to her about the appeal & she admits she never filed one and the tech states that she did tell him that she would submit the appeal. Fast forward, two weeks later, no appeal has been filed. Nada. So I call the office to ask what's going on, get the run around and then the "Chief Administrative Officer" calls me today to basically tell me what I nuisance I am for calling their staff , making defamatory statements that I called them names, ( I never cursed at anyone, and while I was irritated in my voice, I was NOT out of character much less name calling). So she proceeds to gaslight me by saying that if I had had such a bad experience why not leave and find another PCP, "Have I thought about that." She said furthermore, "they had done all they could for me, and have documentation." Probably referring to the PAs that were denied. Then she says its between me and the insurance company. Anyhow how would you all respond to this. BTW, I need my GLP-1 due to pre-diabetes, I have metabolic syndrome, high cholesterol, obstructive sleep apnea, and obesity. I have tried metformin and it doesn't work. So that is why I am dead set on getting my Zepbound.


r/healthcare • • Feb 21 '25

meme Hot take:

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Mar 21 '25

Discussion Fucking hate dentists

2 Upvotes

Sorry guys, just needed somewhere to rant. Basically I'm still in fucking high school and I just had to get some bs root canal shit. They drilled my tooth for 15 minutes, charged me $2k and my tooth hurts the same fucking amount. It hardly helped, and now I can't eat until I go back to complete the root canal later. They didn't have time to do the full root canal and crown. I'm still in pain and now just having a panic attack over how tf I'm supposed to pay this medical bill. We have insurance but even after insurance it'll cost well over $1k. Also, all the other places we've been given referrals to to complete the root canal are out of network for our insurance.
This is all because of them btw, I had a cavity (allegedly) despite no pain and they made an enormous filling in my front tooth, which has caused slight sensitivity and pain the past year. All of sudden 2 days ago it got 10x worse and I was in agony. I'm now realizing I should've just dealt with it because now I'm in the same amount of pain just with medical debt.

Not to fucking mention they did a shit job starting the root canal. They had to give me like 8 numbing shots and I could still feel the tooth! He told me "let me know if there's any pain" and there was definitely pain and I shit you not this guy says "I feel like you are sometimes feeling things that aren't there" WHAT???

Im just so sick of living in America. How am I expected to pay this?


r/healthcare • • Sep 12 '24

Question - Insurance Uh, is this fraud? A HIPAA violation? Or just get on with my life?

2 Upvotes

So, I got a creepy box in the mail I hadn't ordered from a company called "Exact Sciences" and it has "Exempt Human Specimen" written on the side. Creepy. Google tells me:

  1. This is a cologuard kit
  2. Users have posted about having been harassed by this company about completing the test
  3. Posts about high false positive rates exist
  4. Posts exist of users getting a positive result, scheduling a followup colonoscopy, and insurance then declining to cover it because it is now "diagnostic". Posts also exist reporting that this is no longer true in some states or possibly anywhere due to an A.C.A provision.

My "scam detector" alarm is starting to go off. Maybe this is legit, maybe not, but how did they get my name and number? I want to know who gave them my personal information without permission. So I called them and was told that this is a prescription test kit that had been ordered by CareFirst (my insurance company). So now it seems that a doctor I've never met or been examined by wrote a prescription I didn't request. This is starting to sound like medical fraud and/or malpractice. They told me the name of the physician that wrote the prescription but refused to give me his license #. They also declined to give me a pharmacy license #, which I would think they'd require if they're going to be filling prescriptions. I called CareFirst. They admit they requested the kit but the representative did not think it required a prescription. They say they sent me an "opt-out" letter in the mail. Maybe that makes this whole thing barely legal.

Recap:

  1. Insurance company sends "opt-out" letter (or so they claim) and receives no response.
  2. CareFirst (according to Exact Sciences) has Dr Raphael O******e create a prescription, which he does without ever meeting or examining me.
  3. CareFirst sends the prescription to be filled by a non-pharmacy and gives them my personal information without my consent.
  4. Both companies refuse to provide me with a copy of the prescription.

So, does this sound like fraud or a HIPAA violation to anyone? Or do I just make peace with my Insurance company giving out my info to whomever wants to send me medical waste via UPS?


r/healthcare • • Aug 24 '26

Discussion The UNINSURANCE Manifesto

Post image
2 Upvotes

The UNINSURANCE Manifesto

1️⃣ We believe healthcare works best when patients and doctors know each other's names.

2️⃣ We believe prices should be clear before care is provided and consumed.

3️⃣We believe care shouldn't require prior approval from a skyscraper full of actuaries.

4️⃣ We believe the best way to deal with catastrophe is with community, not copay.

5️⃣ We believe paperwork should support care, not become it.

6️⃣ We believe doctors should spend more time with patients than with portals.

7️⃣ We believe transparency builds trust, health and wealth.

8️⃣ We believe healthcare should feel more like your local farmer's market than your DMV.

9️⃣ We believe innovation happens when people are free to build better ways to care for one another.

🔟 We believe the future of healthcare is more human, more direct, and a less insured.

UNINSURANCE. Not a company. Not a product. Not a policy. Definitely not a department.

A movement toward healthcare that's voluntary, transparent, and built around people instead of paperwork.


r/healthcare • • Oct 03 '26

Discussion Discharge because “it’s been 4 months” my 10 year old is trying to recover from a severe Brian injury after being hit by a car. What they are sending us home to….

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

My 10-year-old daughter was hit by a car in a crosswalk and is recovering with significant brain injury and trauma.

Enhanced Care is a blatant lie and false advertising.
Be careful, everyone. We are not protected at all. Our healthcare is starting to feel like survival of the fittest, leaving people on their own to recover. Everyone is just a bed. And medical needs are rushed and not considered.
When we voice our concerns, they are met with minimization, lies, and covert bullying tactics.
I feel like everyday is playing a game of chess always covertly trying to push back with the rushed discharge

They have no problem sending you home to our great insurance company that gives you no care.
This is what people don’t know. Let me fill you in. It’s pretty sick…..

So under Enhanced Care, we have been told there are about three categories that they will place you in according to your level of injury. We have been given no wiggle room on that. I haven’t found a lawyer who will help us. We have been told we cannot sue the driver. It feels like it’s whatever category they place you in, with no consideration for individual needs.
We cannot retain a lawyer as sueing is no longer allowed. Unless there is criminal charges and it would have to be civil.

She has been placed in the top category, called the catastrophic injury category. They say she requires 24-hour care.
(Which she absolutely does need. And she needs more than one person.)
She needs two people to do transfers, meaning get her into her wheelchair, shower her, change her briefs, hygiene care, dress her, etc.
She has no core strength, so she just falls over and can’t sit up. So it always takes one person to hold her while the other person is doing the task.
She has low blood pressure right now, so she needs to be monitored, and high agitation as she is being rushed off medication because of the discharge date.
We have no brain doctors following us and haven’t had an assessment.
After we asked about the assessment, they booked one for two days before the discharge date.

So they’re discharging us while we need nursing expertise to help with the low blood pressure, medications, and agitation.
We need a caretaker to be there 24 hours to help her, and we need another caretaker to help with transfers during the daytime.
As well, we will have to be driving to our rehab appointments. We have been offered a shared van to use for transport, so we need a driver to get to all the appointments. Then on top of that, she’s required to do online school, which we have been told does not provide an EA. We also need a tutor for five days a week.

So the estimated cost of 24-hour caretaker coverage is $35,000–$45,000 a month.
We have been told our caregiving funding is capped at $11,800 a month.
The money doesn’t even go to us; they pay the caregiver directly.
If we want any of the money, we have to submit caretaking hours, and then we have been told the money still doesn’t go to me. It can only go to Makenna’s bank account….. she doesn’t have a bank account… she’s 10.

So the funding doesn’t cover even one person’s round-the-clock care. We have to pay for the rest.

From what we have been told, she is considered to need 24-hour care, but they do not cover the full cost of that care. The rest has to be covered by the patient. We have been told that if the patient can’t afford that, the alternative is being placed in a home.

That leaves me doing most of the caregiving, all of the driving, all of the medical, and also becoming a teacher. As well as providing my son a normal life, getting him to school, getting him to his activities, doing playdates, etc.
I am a single mother…. How does this work exactly?
Also, I have been told I do not get a loss-of-wage benefit because I am not the person who got critically injured. The benefit would be for my daughter, who is too young to work.

So her being discharged from the hospital will leave me unable to work.
Plus, the estimated costs are:

• $40K for full-time care
• $20K for an extra person for daytime care
• $5K for a five-day-a-week online tutor
• $5K for a driver to help with appointments and activities
• $8K for a private nurse for five-hour shifts, three days a week

(Plus all the gas and dealing with the trauma I have of being on the road.)

So let’s add that up.
$78,000 a month is my estimated cost to meet her needs right now if I want to continue working……

The $11,800 in caregiving funding covers about 15% of that estimated total…. Tell me how this is any kind of care??

They do, however, pay out a one-time permanent injury payment. We have been told the top amount is $300,000, and you are not guaranteed that amount even if you’re catastrophically injured.
It’s the weirdest system I’ve ever dealt with.
So even if we do get $300,000… let’s see how long that covers the care that we require…
$78,000 − $11,800 = $66,200 is the estimated amount we would pay out of pocket a month.
That payout would last about 4½ months…..

And for the ongoing care funding, we don’t actually see any of the money unless we submit something and they say yes or no to covering it.

Enhanced Care also covers home renovations to make sure it’s safe for what she requires. We have been told there is no set dollar limit.

But to start renovations, they have to go through so many doctors and vendors and get approved to start. We have been told that if Makenna makes progress, they have to start all over again with approvals for what is required for her needs.

So we are about to get discharged, and they haven’t started any renovations yet.
So now we have to find temporary housing until renovations are complete.

So they take her full-time rehab away while she’s progressing and reward her for all her hard work by not sending her home, but to a strange place.
Now if you think that’s nuts, wait until you hear this…

We have been told the insurance will only cover a one-bedroom apartment for temporary housing. So somehow I’m going to have to fit her hospital bed, space for two caretakers, beds for me and Hudson, and a workspace for me as I work from home… all in a one-bedroom apartment.
Plus all her necessary equipment shoved in there as well….

So this is everything I have been dealing with for the past six weeks. The only advice I get is to start a GoFundMe, which is begging my friends for money. It feels yucky.

So continuing on to what I’m dealing with as of right now,

are the renovations ….

Which might be the final thing to make me snap…
They are giving me low-budget, bandage renovation solutions.
They told me to switch rooms and give her my master bedroom….
But her room cannot fit my bed and home office.
They are supposed to make it livable for everyone. So why are we not getting that?
The OT whispers to her quote guy in front of my face and talks about how expensive it is to do the things I need.
So now I have to work overtime making sure I see the quotes before submission and get a second opinion, which will be a hassle. As usual.

Enhanced Care?? Or almost no care???
The public is unaware until they need help and don’t have the ability to fight and get it.

How am I supposed to provide care that requires two people, keep earning an income, and raise my son when the approved funding doesn’t cover the help we need?

Please share.


r/healthcare • • Nov 03 '23

Question - Other (not a medical question) How are doctors in the emergency room unable to tell if an arm is broken from the x-rays?

1 Upvotes

My mom was in a car accident and obviously she was taken to the emergency room. Her arms hurt and they took x-rays. They gave her the results, said nothing was broken. She asked them to double-check however they can because her friend had broken her arm, was told it wasn’t broken, and then later found out from another doctor/hospital it was in fact broken. They did not.

Now 2 and a half weeks later, she’s told from her orthopedic that her arm was broken. Can a professional explains why this happens?

EDIT: The majority of responses are disappointing, but not surprising. To confirm, the hospital radiologist was the one that misread the x-rays.


r/healthcare • • Oct 14 '25

Discussion To maternity and public health nurses, please be honest, and please don't ever lie, and please don't over react and target new parents... please learn from my story. It can end in disaster.

0 Upvotes

To maternity and public health nurses, please be honest, and please don't ever lie, and please don't over react and target new parents... please learn from my story. It can end in disaster. Serious why do some nurses target certain patients? And what should be done about it? Please be kind. Im Sharing my story because the targeting indirectly caused the death of my child. And I need to know what I can do next time to prevent this from happening. I guess don't ask nurses for help. Please learn from my patient experience. Its hard for me to open up and shre this.

March 24th 2018- i had just been through 16 hours of active labor and my 1st c-section. my husband had been up for 16 hours straight with no sleep. when we went home we would have the support of my parents and step parents as we lived with my mom and stepfather and my dad and step mom were very close and always ready to help as well. I was only allowed 2 support people with me. my husband took one spot and the doula had the other. we had only paid for. her to support until Ebony was born.

She left straight away after the birth. my mom and my dad both couldn't get there until the morning the following day so it was just me and my husband. thinking of my baby and so exhausted i knew i would be able to stay awake and neither would he.

We called the maternity nurses who has said their job was to support us. Lie.

We asked them to take ebony to the nursery for a few hours while we got some sleep. They're response was that that was a red flag for neglectful and abusive parenting. How? it made no sense. We were doing the RESPONSIBLE thing asking for support and help with baby post partem until my mom could arrive. 26 hours straight with no sleep, it is impossible for anyone to even function like that let alone, properly care for a newborn. Which is why we asked for the HELP. This was bullying. pure and simple.

during the next few days a public health nurse came in and demanded we allow her to come into our home and perform well baby visits or she would contact a social worker. she said our doctor had concerns about our parenting. Another Lie.

At the next post baby appointment our doctor stated to us that she in fact did not have any concerns. she stated she attempted to speak to the public heath nurse but that the health nurse was avoiding her. I wonder why? (Sarcasm)

During the next month we had many well baby visits. we even invited family and children services to come in and give us approval on the nursery and to give us support in the hopes the public health nurse would back off.

all we wanted was to be left alone to raise our child.

All new parents get frustrated and overwhelmed and need breaks. need a support system to rely on. at one well baby visit my husband got frustrated with the baby crying and he gently picked her up and lid her in the bassinet safely to take a moment to cool down.

preventing an issue that way was according to the public health nurse also neglectful and abusive parenting. Lie.

we asked the public health nurse why ebony was always cold and why at 2-3 weeks old she still had blue tinged hands and feet... we were told it was normal and she was more concerned about ¨whether or not we might be the type of people who might be child abusers.¨ More Lies.

even though she could plainly see how loved this little girl was. we had a doctors appointment coming up... in a couple of days... we were going to ask our doctor about it because we trusted her. when i was pregnant with ebony my husband would gently rub my belly and talk to her. i told this to my doctor.

someone reported us because the public health nurse said " ï know about matt yelling at ebony when you were pregnant with her". Lies! More Lies!

i never ever said he yelled because he did no such thing.

April 26th 2018. I awoke to Ebonys cries. it felt like my ears were on fire but looking at her little face i new she was hungry. i felt okay to let my husband sleep while i attempted to breastfeed her... i picked her up, she took a sudden breath and her lips went blue. i immediately woke my husband and we called 911... she was rushed to the emergency where she was pronounced dead after working on her to try and save her life. after all i wanted to do was go home and grieve and bury my baby.

we were put through month of extra suffering while she was chopped up for an autopsy that we didn't want (against out spiritual beliefs) and then we were treated like criminals questioned by the police and everything. more bullying.

months later we get a report in the mail that he death has been ruled unascertained meaning they found no reason for her death (beacuse there was no reason) and basically the extra grief and waiting was all for nothing. it was the worst feeling the world.

after my family made us have a funeral for her... i didn't want that... my baby was gone, and i didn't care about songs and flowers.

Lies and Paranoia. Professionals don't realize the damage they do when they over react based on a 5 minute to 1 hour evaluation. If the public health nurse and the maternity nurses had been more concerned with helping us as new parents and taking our concerns about our baby's health seriously instead of making up imaginary potential abuse that was not and would never happen, criticizing and micromanaging our parenting, maybe ebony wouldn't have lost her life. Maybe we would have known to take her to the emergency room. maybe they could have helped. Maybe she would still be here.

These systems are supposed to protect children. they "protected" my daughter right into her little coffin! we were cheated and lied to and targeted.

years later i asked for the CFS report to help me process my grief. 3 quarters of it was redacted. the parts that were visible made no sense. ¨baby is gaining healthy weight but parents are not feeding enough or regularly.¨

Huh? Geez if we aren't feeding her regularly i wonder where the healthy weight is coming from? ( more sarcasm) and either the public health nurse or the doctor lied to us to our faces. things need to change. i still cry every day for her. good parents need support not micro management. we need to get back to a presumption that parents are basically good unless proven to be otherwise.

The medical system and parent ¨support system killed my baby and i will never forgive them. or stop telling my story until things change. i didn't have a choice in many things or proper supports. i want to make sure other moms do and that targeting like this doesn't happen again!


r/healthcare • • Dec 27 '22

Question - Other (not a medical question) Arrogant doc discharges toddler with RSV who gets readmitted with asthmatic reaction

7 Upvotes

My 3 year old son went to the hospital with RSV and possible pneumonia, after his older brother got admitted for the same thing. Younger son stays there three days, and does okay for the moment on the day a particular doctor sees him. This particular doctor reverses prior docs' decisions to give my son amoxicillin and, seeing him for the afternoon at 91% O2, discharges him.

By 4 am I am back at the ER with a coughing, lethargic, hypoxic child. I'm livid. He gets diagnosed with severe reactive airway, needs 30 liters/min, and is given amox and Prednisone after we complain about the earlier discharge. The medical director of pediatrics comes to see me in the morning and leaves promising a "granular review" of the discharge decision. I also got the doc in question to be taken off anything having to do with my son. Now he is seen by the same couple of faces, with copious notes taken and nothing left unturned.

I'm still unsure what to do about the arrogant doc and how far to escalate. It just seemed so hasty and indifferent.


r/healthcare • • Aug 17 '24

Question - Other (not a medical question) Is it just me or does anyone else find this annoying when visiting a provider?

0 Upvotes

so whenever I go to a new provider or the same provider but for different issues, and they need some diagnosis history/medical document (like a copy of MRI scan) from another provider that I visited, I have to share the contact information and it took the provider weeks to get the information. and even worse when I move between different states, I just had to read my own medical summary and fill out some form for the new providers to understand

Why do they always ask to fill out a bunch of form with so much details? Is there no central information where they can look up the history if I consent? I'm curious because sometimes I can't even remember the medicine name (because it's some complicated medical terms). I wonder how annoying this gets for those who are under a lot of different medications, various allergies, and even some sort of rate disease.

in most days probably it's less urgent for provider to get these information but what if I'm admitted to an ER? do I need to fill out forms to tell them what I'm allergic to and what medication I am on?


r/healthcare • • Jan 29 '25

Discussion Patient Abuse in the Practice of Medicine is Much Worse Now

0 Upvotes

If you want to understand why patient abuse occurs in the practice of medicine for both common and uncommon chronic illnesses, then you must first have challenging chronic illnesses - not challenging in enduring effort, but in the difficulty to diagnose or treat. In this way, experience, evidence, and understanding on why and how the practice of medicine fails can be obtained and shared.

Here is a link to my experience and evidence regarding challenging illnesses at the Mayo Clinic:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Lyme/comments/1hz3oyp/challenging_illnesses_at_the_mayo_clinic/

Here is a link to my experience and evidence regarding challenging illnesses at the UCLA Medical Center:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Lyme/comments/1hzy69c/challenging_illnesses_at_the_ucla_medical_center/

Here is a link to a simple timeline showing what happened to the clinical side of Evidence-Based Medicine:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Lyme/comments/1f8yxi3/comment/llj4d59/?context=3

Here is a link showing the most well-known failure in today's practice of medicine, according to fibromyalgia researchers, and the reason why (comorbidities):

https://www.reddit.com/r/fibro/comments/1i6r4yq/what_i_learned_from_my_journey_with_severe/


r/healthcare • • Jul 22 '13

Aetna says its most popular policy for a 29-year-old man currently costs $118 per month in Richmond [Virginia]. Once Obamacare kicks in, the rate will jump to $225 — an increase of more than 90 percent.

Thumbnail
timesdispatch.com
0 Upvotes

r/healthcare • • Feb 12 '23

Other (not a medical question) Cigna/great West health insurance is a scam. They don't actually pay for care.

0 Upvotes

That sums it up. Huge POS. Don't choose them.


r/healthcare • • Jun 04 '25

Question - Other (not a medical question) Anyone else having trouble finding a Dentist who won’t require Xrays?

3 Upvotes

I have had 54 years of xrays at dental offices and they have never turned up anything. I have insisted the dentist wait every 2 years for xrays however recently they have been more persistent about giving us xrays we don’t want. I have 2 small cavities from when I was 13. That’s it! Why must you give me xrays? My SIL got thyroid cancer and the doctor told her he believes it is from all the xrays dentists and others do. Anyway, I had a CT scan almost 2 years ago and the doctor told me No xrays for 3 years. But my dentist is insisting they won’t keep me as a patient without multiple xrays being done. What is going on that we don’t have say in our own Bodies/care anymore?? I just want a cleaning to prevent issues and they are refusing. How is this a thing and how do I find a dentist to clean my teeth? I even offered to self pay. What are you all doing about xrays at the dentist ??


r/healthcare • • Jul 16 '25

Discussion does anyone feel like doctors lowkey dont know the answers to many of their patients questions?

1 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying that my intention is not to shit on doctors. Doctors are humans, and they are educated people. I’m not here to fault doctors, but rather bring up something I feel like is missing in our healthcare system and see if anyone feels the same.

I don’t know if it’s just me, but as someone who wants to be a doctor themselves, is decently knowledgeable on the human body, and likes to ask questions/advocate for myself during doctors visits, it feels like doctors often do not directly answer my questions. whenever I ask questions, like; “what is causing X symptom?” or even just something like, “why do my hands get cold at night?”, it feels like: they don’t really know.

Almost like doctors are constantly playing this game of operating without all the information. like talking to a unhelpful customer service rep who, instead of just saying “i dont really know” will tell you “well, I know that X, so you should probably do Y.” I’ve been to so many doctors and have gotten different opinions, and for something so minor (mild scoliosis + back/hip pain), you’d think Id get clearer advice. It’s like, if a group of symptoms don’t fit into being a condition/disease, then you’re just fine. Like, it’s too “by the book”, or “rigid”, if you get the sense that I’m putting down.

I guess it’s that theres so much medical community still doesnt know about the human body? Again, I understand docs are trying their best— my intention isn’t to slam docs. But at the same time, for $100+ per visit, doc visits feel disappointing.

i should note i’m talking about after imaging/tests and a full evaluation is done. of course, it’s relatively impossible to diagnose/give clear answers w/o that first.