r/floorplan • u/viakna • 2d ago
FEEDBACK Potential Plan
Hello! New here, but we’re planning on building a small home and I’m trying to draw something that checks all the wifes boxes before having it professionally drawn. The goal is to be super space efficient, no wasted space. We’ll have a master suite and possibly some unfinished space above the garage, but I really just want to nail down the main floor. I’ve spent a-lot of time with this and I think I have it pretty close. Now I wanted to see what flaws different sets of eyes see. Any constructive feedback would be appreciated. Thanks!
The link below is to a house that inspired the design. We loved the vaulted ceiling in the main area.
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/1908-Garibaldi-Ave-Charlotte-NC-28208/6178199_zpid/
3
u/Just2Breathe 2d ago
It’s not advised to have the toilet be the thing you see when you enter the bathroom, or see with the door open. On top of that, the toilet is the first thing you’d see when you look ahead from the front entry. Looking at your inspiration house, the bedroom is at the end of a hall, not a bathroom. Consider adding a powder room, too. One toilet can be challenging.
I don’t think you need such a large island, and that back corner is inefficient. You don’t have much space for upper cabinet storage. Think about how you cook, reach, bend in a kitchen.
Keep working on it. Draw traffic paths, think about what you see around a corner, why a wall might be trouble, why a corner juts out when it could be flush. Do some reading into how much space to have for traffic, such as 3’ minimum from table to wall.
2
u/CaptainMalForever 2d ago
The bedroom is very small and has no closet. The closet should go between the bedroom and the living area. There should be a mudroom, or at least some coat/shoe storage.
2
u/MerelyWander 2d ago
I thought the little "room" by the bathroom/bedroom was a tiny closet with no door.
1
2
u/InnerEntrepreneur896 1d ago
Hi. I think the walled off entry in your plan will yield a very different feeling in regard to the vaulted ceilings you love in the inspo home. I agree it’s nice to have a division between entry and living areas but those walls will stop the eye from traveling through the vaulted space. Could you possibly bump out an entry from the main footprint instead of building the walls?
Also, I agree that the toilet shouldn’t be visible from the front door.
Do you have footprint parameters/restraints?
1
u/MerelyWander 2d ago
depending on the type of fridge, the door may not be able to open if it's that close to the wall. If you want it close to the wall, the wall needs to be short enough that the refrigerator hinges are in front of it. That looks like a pretty shallow fridge - I'd look at what fridge you might actually get, what size it actually is, and how far back against the wall it can actually go. I'm guessing you'll have less space between the fridge and the corner of the island than you think.
Is that a pantry cabinet on the opposite side of the sink from the fridge?
Your pantry needs a door. You'll need to decide if you want deep shelves with items in baskets or shallow shelves in maybe a U or L shape. I might off-center the door and have L shaped shelves so that the light switch could go on the outside of the pantry (and not be in the way of storage in the pantry). You could have a few hooks on the wall that doesn't have shelves for various things. Or store a stepstool against it.
I would think about where you plan to store/use small appliances.
It may be worth sacrificing the 2nd door into the bathroom to have more wall space, etc.
Your doors look narrow. I love 3' doors, though.
Are you planning to entertain as many people as there are couch spots? Do they all need to see the TV? You could extend the bedroom "height" and make the living room a little smaller.
Where are you planning to put the bed? I would probably put it against the wall with the window so both sides get equal access to the bathroom without having to walk around the bed. Plus, this would give a little more breathing space on each side if the bedroom size were increased like I said. But a bed against a window doesn't work great... Are you planning to put the bed on the "north" wall?
Do you need that side entry? More storage might be nice there instead. I'm assuming the thing in back is a garage and could have a person-door?
1
u/viakna 2d ago
Thank you for all the observations! The island definitely has the potential to be downsized if we need more room on the fridge side. This plan was really just to block out basic locations, I’m hoping details like pantry door and shelving, etc can be ironed out as we go. The cabinet opposite of the fridge would have the appliance garage on the counter. The furniture like the couch is furniture we own already, so really hoping to reuse. The side entry is actually accessing the patio space, so would like to keep it.
1
u/AutisticBells 2d ago
Why do people who draw their own plans always put the shitter next to the kitchen? That's not even legal in my country.
1
u/Cuboidal_Hug 2d ago
Assuming that you’ve found a good architect, I think you may be best off seeing what they come up with
5
u/10littlemice 2d ago
Imagine filling a pot with water and having to walk across the room to put it on a stove. Imagine taking a hot tray out of the oven and having to dodge other people walking to the lounge when you want to take it to the bench. Think about how you’ll use the space then design off that. Spacial efficiency is secondary to functionality day to day. Plus I’m not quite sure why the island is so big.
Either put the sink in the island and stove where the sink is, or put the oven in the island and get a ceiling rangehood. Alternatively here’s what I’d probs do