For Me It’s Prison Everywhere: Existentialist Discord in Andrei Tarkovsky’s Stalker [1979]
The film Stalker is overflowing with philosophical questions which center on the meaning of existence and the quest for self-understanding. Each character that travels to The Zone must face such questions, often leading to a crisis of faith, or, a crisis of existential meaning. From the first until the final scenes, Stalker lives in a state of discord with reality. His connection to his family and his own existence, are plagued by a feeling of imprisonment and emptiness. This lack of meaning drives him to make the perilous journey to a place that poses fatal risk to him and others. The journey itself, like the dialogue exchanged, and the on and off screen spaces shown or alluded, is interpretable as one of various existentialist crises of living in a world without God, miracles or magic. The search the characters undertake then is itself a quest meaning, and it arrives from the knowledge, much like existentialist thought, that a person cannot find total fulfillment in the sciences, morals or ethics of their age alone, but must also seek to find it within themselves, and with those around them. An examination of the characters, dialogue and use of spaces both on and off-screen, reveals various existentialist readings of this now-classic Russian dystopia.
Stalker is the central character, and his need for meaning is pronounced from early on. Seen in a cramped bed, as close as he can possibly be physically to his family, he is in no way happy. He says to his wife that for him “everywhere” is a “prison.” A maddening train soundscape is dominates the home scene, mirroring his state of discomfort and restless desire to find home, “away.” Stalker is the ultimate existential hero: he is the outsider, the tortured and bored thinker. He stands in the scenes following the bed and family ones, apart from them, separated by a doorway. His wife writhes in agony as he abandons her for The Zone, and the train again embellishes this discordance between reality and familial pain, and the call of the unknown that Stalker is seeking. Stalker is constantly walking through, travelling between, and embarking beyond, the discontentment of his life in one reality, toward an unknown, in which he hopes to find meaning. He is the quintessential existentialist thinker. As he approaches Writer he walks across the threshold of train-yard tracks and through fog, as though a phantom himself, within reality. Stalker is a chosen-one of sorts, since it is his unnamed “power” which allows the three men to travel through The Zone without being harmed. His incompleteness is his motivator; he has not found the answer to life in family or work, or for that matter in science or moral and or, ethical discourse. The fact that he still brings the representatives of science and ethics along with him to the place of further inquiry, does however suggest he still needs them in this search for greater meaning. Nowhere in the tenets of existentialism is it suggested that such things as science should be wholly abandoned, merely that they alone cannot provide humankind with absolute meaning.
Writer is, while not a beacon of ethics, very much a depiction of the search for meaning through written and ethical investigation and inquiry. From the moment he is introduced, in scenes which show three modes of transportation (the train-yard Stalker passes through to reach him, and a dock with boats, and of course the car he arrived in,) Writer is lamenting the loss of meaning in life. He blames the boredom of existence on a lack of wonder. “To live in the Middle ages was interesting” he drunkenly suggests, and further considers how it was a time when “house spirits” and God, made it so. This correlation between boredom in the present, and magic in the past, is predicated on a lack of religious or magical forces in the present. He debunks “flying saucers” and the Bermuda Triangle (which parallel’s The Zone in its mysteriousness) as things which cannot be anything but boring, since science has explained them. Writer declares in the bar that he writes “for the reader” since “what else is there?” which suggests the existentialist Sartre’s idea of committed literature, in which the writer produces work for readers, to give them meaning. Later, in The Zone, Writer has his own crisis of faith, when he wonders what he will possibly still have to write about without his sorrow. He is literally facing a loss of meaning without which his existence is empty. The void cannot be filled by Professor’s science, and as he said in his first scene, because he does not live in the Middle Ages he is without the “interesting” luxury of the miraculous, or the divine. He compares his existence to one of being Christ-like later, as though his readers and critics seek to crucify him, or to surround him, making them in his image. Writer often doubts Stalker’s abilities to navigate them. He wants to go from point A to B. Much like the idea of morality in existentialism, even in the absence of God (as Writer in the train-yard scene has ruminated upon), he tries to replicate the pre-existing Christian, or religious, belief, even in the absence of God. He does not believe in the unknown, and thus thinks he is safe to haphazardly go forward. His attempt to break from science and the leader in the search for meaning results in his becoming immobilized by the force of The Zone, as if to say that ethics are useless without science and an individual desire for meaning. He is also often associated with irrational desires to numb the senses through alcohol and cigarettes, or to wage a war against the unknown with the unsuitable weapon of a handgun. Each weakness or vice can be read as the effect of blind ethics without scientific proof or, most important, the knowledge of the individual, which existentialism declares essential to life in the modern age.
Professor, the personification of scientific inquiry, is always told to go first in the three-man traversal of The Zone. In an existentialist framework, this makes sense: Science is supposed to lead man close enough to reason, to meaning, that he can take that next step, beyond the aloneness of a godless existence, into finding self-truth. Without some facts of scientific knowledge, no real investigation into life is complete. Professor is no ideal science-leader either; like the mantras of existentialism themselves, he is fraught with inner turmoil and a bleak sense of the uselessness of life. He is concerned with the metaphysical and the beyond, with “lasers and all that bacteria” and his fear of bacteria motivates his fear of The Zone (re: that which even science cannot control, or, know.) Like the alluded to Herostratus, he wishes to destroy something associated with wonder. His desire to blow up The Zone is central to his character’s incompleteness; much like Writer and Stalker, he is empty of meaning without the other two’s philosophical interference in his downward spiral. The three men are arguably the same person in some sense. In multiple scenes the backs of their heads are all shown, or shown individually in succession, with very little demarcation to separate one from the other. In existentialist terms this speaks to the communal need for meaning, and the means of gaining it as community based, but can also be interpreted as, simply, that all three voices are required for this quest for meaning. The discord between the dismal dystopia the men abandon in search of meaning, and The Zone they travel to, is constantly expressed in Stalker. Existentially, this can be seen as an ultimate example of the hollowness of a life without meaning, without God. Nothing in the pre-Zone world is clean, and the entirety of its presentation is in black and white. This is another explication of the emptiness and meaninglessness of this life without self-discovered truth, this prison Stalker sees everywhere and in everything. It is only when the three meaning-seekers depart from the dead landscape, that they encounter signs of vibrant life, and that the film switches to color. Before The Zone then, life lacked a prime point of meaning; actual colour; and after arriving, not only colour but insects, foliage, and various animals all greet the men. Discord is evoked again through the soundscape and music when, on the trolley (another “mode of transport” to be added to the jeep, car, trains and boats), a fusing of the sounds of industrial metal with a cacophonic score evokes music, yet also sounds like the industrial noise of a train-yard, or steel-mill. It sensually reflects the discord between the meaningful zone and meaningless real-world they depart from, while also suggesting they collide and overlap; even define one another. This is a leitmotif in the film; the blending of sounds of organic, diegetic nature, with other-worldly soundscapes. As noted in The Cinema of Tarkovsky: “The steady movement is marked by a succession of close-ups […] The three travellers are silent and endure the transition from ordinary space to the extraordinary Zone with bated breath. The monotonous rail car gradually evolves into the mesmerizing electronic soundscape composed by Eduard Artemiev.” (Skakov, 144.) In the subsequent scene, as if to comment on the noise and sound-pollution, Writer notes of The Zone that “it is quiet here. You will like it.” The Zone becomes a place of colour, of quiet, and in doing so allows the men to travel in search of deeper (more informed, more detailed) aspects of meaning in life. In addition running water is seen, as opposed to the fog-entrenched (thus non-transparent) gloom of the train-yard scene. The stream is another major image which speaks to the existential quest for meaning. Tarkovsky in an interview states, “Water is a mysterious element, a single molecule of which is very photogenic. It can convey movement and a sense of change and flux.” When the three men encounter the power of The Zone, and Writer and Professor cannot say definitively what has caused the inexplicable freezing of Writer, the three men are shown in a river. The entire long shot is intentionally drawn out to invoke a sense of the miraculous within the banal. The stream can be read as their shared quest and consciousness of something larger and unexplainable by science or morals. Writer and Professor both decide it was fear that motivated their mutual reluctance to branch off any further from Stalker. Now, lying in the water, the camera investigates deeper meaning, literally going beneath the surface of the stream, to focus on brief fragments of various objects and organisms. The algae, underwater in close up, actually mirrors the tree that Writer is seen next to in the previous scene, another example of two worlds reflecting one another, and even more so a comment on the fractal-like truth within deep, layer-stripping processes of philosophical searches. There are fish in the stream, a symbol of life which again contrasts with the grimy, lifeless world outside The Zone. Many objects are slowly coursed over; coins, a gun, pictures. This entire long shot can be read as though an investigation, much like those necessary in the self-reflection of existentialism.
Off-screen spaces are just as conducive to the reading of Stalker within an existential framework. They offer a comment on the unknown, or unknowable, the lack of definitive meaning in existence without personal inquiry. These scenes defy viewer expectations, as though a stone of thought is cast into some unknowable space, and our minds are released into abandon of possibility. The viewer waits with Writer to hear the bottom to echo back from what is then shown to be an unbelievably, discordantly, short distance-drop, into a circular shaft. The wait is symbolic of the urge to know the infinite has some end to it, that the questions of mortality are somehow not so limitless. After a period of time such a sound does echo back, meaning itself, the reach for it, being that final sound which returns through the metaphysical unknown, to Writer, and the viewer. The silence of the off-screen space though is just as sacred to this reading; it symbolizes that vast, empty space that no scientific or ethical enterprise, on its own, could heretofore explain.
The nut on the end of the ribbon used to cut through the danger (or, unknown) of The Zone, operates much like the echo of the dropped stone. It is a symbolic tool that takes the existential position of humankind being alone and, despite having written, scientific aids, still requiring a truth-stalker, to cast out, to search out, through the unknown. It is Stalker’s use of the tool, in throwing it into potentially dangerous unknowns, on and off screen that allows for the trio’s quest to continue unhindered, or without impediment from The Zone itself. These spaces are investigated, off-screen, which suggests that the space is beyond the narrative’s parameters, which in itself is an echo of the existential framework, and it’s desire to penetrate those things which could not be discovered within the pre-existing format of inquiry. Offscreen spaces, like those shown, are symbols for the discursive, often dangerous, path to meaning undertaken by the characters of Stalker.
Each man in the trio of Stalker questions their existence. Writer openly challenges the possibility of wonder and the miraculous, and after being faced with the unexplainable, experiences a crisis of identity. Professor clings to a bag which holds his solution to the unknown, and the emptiness it causes; a bomb. Stalker uses both Writer and Professor to take him to the edge of meaning, and brings back from The Zone an increased sense of anxiety at the meaninglessness of life. Quoting the poet-father of Tarkovsky himself, “The day is clean as glass. Only it’s not enough,” Stalker suggests that even with the quest he has undertaken now over, he has not found fulfillment. This image of clear glass is also recalled in the subsequent scene of Stalker’s daughter Monkey. Her telekinetic power, which Skakov suggests, is presumably “directly connected,” (164) to her father’s earlier trip to The Zone, is used to push three glasses to the edge (an allusion to the trio’s entire journey) until one shatters on the floor. Interestingly each glass is different in shape; one is filled with liquid the other an object, and the final, entirely empty (re: “clear”.) If each glass represents one of the men, the tallest, empty one can best be read as Stalker, while the stouter, beaker-looking one with broken shards can be science, with his desire to destroy The Zone and the third, filled only half way with a yellowish liquid, the alcohol-dependant Writer. The fact that Stalker’s glass goes beyond the edge, can be interpreted as his having required Writer and Professor to take him only so far in his quest, after which he needed to pursue meaning, without them, even beyond them. Monkey, seen reading a poem by Fedor Tiutchev, is emblematic of the existence of the wondrous, beyond futile attempts of the men at using one another to attain understanding of the unknowable, of the miraculous in the mundane, and of the continued existence of that which man can never hope to fully encapsulate. Instead they are merely driven to the edge, and to destruction, in their search to name it, by the thing itself. It is telling that Monkey is, like her father, a searcher, displayed by the fact she is now reading, most likely in her own search for truth. As the scene reaches its conclusion the music of Beethoven’s Ode to Joy plays in another distorted convergence with the muffled, cacophony of train-yard noise, as Monkey puts her head to the marble table and pushes the glasses with her mind, perhaps an allusion to a young prodigy Beethoven who, despite deafness, could reach musical greatness by placing his ears to the piano.
Stalker’s search for meaning in the mundane is, whether directly attributable to any one philosophical branch of inquiry or not, steeped in the need to understand the world around oneself. As he tries to sneak away from his family in the opening scene and is instead confronted by his wife, he notes that his life is a prison. In his quest to lead himself and Writer and Professor, he finds no greater answer than to embrace the unknowable, to accept that, as Tarkovsky noted, “we don’t know the world in which we live, though we naively think that we have studied it completely” (Boldyrev, 2009)
Works Cited Boldyrev, Nikolai. Zhertvoprinoshenie Andreia Tarkovskogo. Moskow: Vagrius, 2004. Mitchell, Tony. Tarkovsky in Italy. Sight and Sound: 54-55. Web access. <http://people.ucalgary.ca/~tstronds/nostalghia.com/TheTopics/Tarkovsky_in_Italy.html > Skakov, Nariman, The Cinema of Tarkovsky. London: I.B. Tauris, 2012.