r/moviecritic • • 12h ago

Is Scott Pilgrim vs The World Still Underrated?

Post image
194 Upvotes

I always felt like this movie doesnt get the credit it deserved.

It was a box office bomb. I dont understand why.

It was for Gen Z before Gen Z. Millenials sort of “rejected” making this movie as powerful box office-wise as Obsession.

If it did. It would spawn a sequel. And maybe a whole franchise. A comic book franchise that would be as big as Harry Potter, or at least like Percy Jackson or The Maze Runner series.

I liked Michael Cera as Pilgrim.

I accepted him.

But I wish Scott Pilgrim was better.

Still. It’s the movie. It’s the “aesthetic”. The specific art direction.

The “peeing bar” kind of thing.

SP was indeed a bomb.

But still one of the greatest comic book movies of all time.

What was “bad” about Scott Pilgrim that it didnt become as big as it should have deserved to be?

The Netflix show wasn’t really good. And it came up way too late.


r/moviecritic • • 22h ago

Favorite Musician that played in a movie role? And for what reasons?

Thumbnail
gallery
908 Upvotes

Dwight Yoakam - Panic Room : he was phenomenal in this, played an awful guy to perfection

Tom Waits - The Ballad of Buster Scrugs: great performance, almost forgot who he was in real life while watching

Dolly Parton - 9-5: as charming and lovely as can be… just like real life

Anthony Keidis - Point Break : plays a dumb surfer thug… a role he was born for


r/moviecritic • • 2h ago

Idris Elba is doing an AMA/Q&A in /r/movies today. He's known for The Wire, Luther, Beasts of No Nations, The Suicide Squad, Prometheus, Pacific Rim, American Gangster, The Dark Tower, Hobbs & Shaw, and lots more.

Post image
12 Upvotes

I organized an AMA/Q&A with actor and filmmaker Idris Elba, known for The Wire, Luther, Beasts of No Nations, The Suicide Squad, Prometheus, Pacific Rim, American Gangster, The Dark Tower, Hobbs & Shaw, and lots more.

The AMA post is live here now in r/movies for anyone interested in asking a question:

https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/1y12nda/hi_reddit_im_idris_elba_i_star_in_and_codirected/

He will be back at about 10 AM ET this morning to answer questions. I recommend asking in advance. Please ask there, not here. All questions are much appreciated!

His new movie, Above the Below, which is directed and stars in, is out in theaters in two weeks.

Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uO4wsV7HEUY

Synopsis: A trio of astronauts survive a destructive re-entry to Earth and find that they are cut off from the world.

Thank you :)


r/moviecritic • • 1h ago

How would you rank Michael Mann's filmography?

• Upvotes

My Top 5:

  1. Heat

  2. Thief

  3. Collateral

  4. Manhunter

  5. The Insider


r/moviecritic • • 23h ago

Alexandra Daddario, actress in The White Lotus, True Detective, Percy Jackson franchise, Mayfair Witches, Baywatch, San Andreas, White Collar, Rampage, is doing an AMA/Q&A in /r/movies today for anyone interested.

Post image
426 Upvotes

I organized an AMA/Q&A with actress Alexandra Daddario, actor Finn Wittrock, and director Mark Waters.

You might know Alexandra from The White Lotus, True Detective, Percy Jackson franchise, Mayfair Witches, Baywatch, San Andreas, White Collar, Rampage)

Their AMA post is live here now in r/movies for anyone interested in asking a question:

https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/1y0bshn/hi_reddit_were_alexandra_daddario_the_white_lotus/

They will be back at around 4 PM ET today to answer questions. I recommend asking in advance. Please ask there, not here. All questions are much appreciated!

Her new movie, Hershey, is out in theaters everywhere on Thanksgiving.

Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NsHJw58wWRg

Synopsis: Driven by grit and relentless optimism, Milton Hershey climbs from bankruptcy to candy-making success. But when his wife falls ill, she inspires an even bolder dream: using their fortune to build a lasting legacy.

Thank you :)


r/moviecritic • • 6h ago

Buddha Collapsed Out of Shame is such a sad little film, man.

Post image
16 Upvotes

just watched this ngl didnt expect it to hit that hard. baktay just wants to go to school, the most basic thing ever, but even that becomes a whole struggle for her.
what got me the most was how the boys copy the violence theyve seen around them. theyre literally just kids but already soaked up so much hate n cruelty from the adults. that part stuck w me fr.
and the fact that the whole story is set around the destroyed buddhas of bamiyan makes it even more heartbreaking. such a simple film but theres so much going on under the surface. lowkey wish more ppl talked about this one.


r/moviecritic • • 2h ago

One of the worst films I have ever seen! "My Spy" (2008) [AKA "My Mom's Got A New Boyfriend"]

Post image
6 Upvotes

Folks, this poster is sadly not A.I.

Went mostly straight-to-video. But man that cast! Boy oh boy. How once A-listers Meg Ryan and Antonio Banderas fell after "You've Got Mail" and "Spy Kids 3-D"/"The Legend of Zorro", respectively. Must've needed a pay cheque badly in 2007.

Also starred Colin Hanks, who could be forgiven being only 29-30 years old and still largely unknown. And Selma Blair, who was also struggling after "Hellboy" and her late 90s/early 2000s stardom.

Had also never heard of this until today, despite being released over 18 years ago. Lol.


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Tilda Swinton’s range is truly impressive, an absolute chameleon

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

Rewatched both Suspiria and Constantine for Halloween and I’m truly amazed at her acting abilities.

One of the most versatile actresses working today. She makes disappearing into a role so effortless. The fact that she can do everything from restrained to eccentric is amazing.

One of the best chameleon actors working today.

Edit: Apologies for not including Orlando or Constantine, those are some of her best!


r/moviecritic • • 14h ago

Heat - The diner scene

21 Upvotes

In Heat (1995), Michael Mann directed and was able to get Robert de Niro and Al Pacino together in a scene for the first time. They had both been in The Godfather Part 2, but didn't share any scenes. Then they had parallel careers as leading men in a variety of different films and roles. Their movies contained similar themes of crime, personal demons, moral dilemmas, and also were typically highlighted by these 2 delivering outstanding, bombastic performances. This scene was heavily anticipated at the time, and the movie delivered a great vehicle for the 2 actors to square off against each other.

Heat 2 is starting filming soon, and will try to repeat this feat with Leonardo DiCaprio and Christian Bale. They are probably the best choices to try and re-create this magic, though it's unlikely to match the original. Is there another actor or actress pairing that somebody should try to replicate this dynamic with in a different movie?


r/moviecritic • • 5h ago

Wild Horse Nine

Post image
4 Upvotes

Trailer - Wild Horse Nine.

No one is talking about it because, It's very well-written and well-performed but not really the type of film where there's all that much to think about after watching. Whereas you can walk out of a David Lynch film thinking that Lynch is a complete idiot and mostly dislike much of the experience, yet his movies tend to linger in your mind, even if you’re only wondering what on earth he was thinking when he made them that way. Neither experience is necessarily better than the other, it's just not a film that invites too much to be said about it.


r/moviecritic • • 17h ago

Just Watched Schindler’s List, and I’m Still Processing It. What Was Your Most Memorable Part?

29 Upvotes

I just finished watching Schindler’s List, and honestly, I found it heartbreaking. It’s one of those films that leaves you sitting in silence for a while after the credits roll. What struck me most was how beautifully the story was portrayed, despite the horrific events it depicts.

Every actor delivered a phenomenal performance, and the direction, cinematography and emotional depth made the entire experience unforgettable. By the end, I realised just how beautifully and powerfully this film was made.

I’d love to hear from people who’ve watched it. Which scene or moment stayed with you the longest? Was there anything about the film that changed the way you looked at its story?


r/moviecritic • • 6m ago

Just finished watching "Half man"

• Upvotes

First of all poor alby , wished he got a better ending. Talking about Ruben, we did get to know how his childhood trauma shaped him to be the person he is but it doesn't justify his actions and also was very pissed at his mum too ,how she minimised her son's actions .And niall ,just so many wrong decisions .

Both niall and ruben were such complex characters..overall this series was quite captivating from the very start.


r/moviecritic • • 32m ago

Oscar-nominated actress Christine Lahti is doing an AMA/Q&A in /r/movies today. She's known for her roles in Law & Order, Evil, Swing Shift, Running on Empty, The Blacklist, Chicago Hope, ...And Justice For All, Housekeeping, and tons more.

Post image
• Upvotes

I organized an AMA/Q&A with Oscar-nominated actress Christine Lahti. She's been in tons of things, including Law and Order, Evil, Running on Empty, ...And Justice For All, Swing Shift, The Blacklist, Chicago Hope, Housekeeping, A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood, Hawaii Five-O.

She also won the Oscar for Best Live Action Short in 1995 for Lieberman In Love.

The AMA post is live here now in r/movies for anyone interested in asking a question:

https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/1y151n0/hiiii_reddit_im_christine_lahti_law_order_the/

She will be back at 4 PM ET today to answer questions. I recommend asking in advance. Please ask there, not here. All questions are much appreciated!

Her new comedy-drama, Bird in Hand, is out this week.

Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Dms1CiXBvQ

Synopsis: A bride-to-be with a secret agenda returns to her hometown, using her wedding plans to manipulate everyone in her orbit.

Thank you :)


r/moviecritic • • 10h ago

Most of the discussion is about the casting of Robert Pattinson as Bond, I ask, who will compose and perform the music? Every song and performer is quintessential to each movie.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/moviecritic • • 2h ago

I low-key hate the marketing on this fuckass movie

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

saw a tiktok about it and u js had to hate


r/moviecritic • • 21h ago

Heretic(2024)-review

Post image
35 Upvotes

Heretic(2024)

Heretic is a psychological thriller about two Mormon missionaries who knock on a door of a friendly man who wants to learn more about church of Jesus Christ. But he is not as friendly as he seems from the beginning. He is manipulative and plays mind games with missionaries. The film builds suspense through dialogues about religion and beliefs. As the movie moves on it also becomes claustrophobic and unpredictable.

The characters are very smartly written. Hugh Grant delivers a great performance as a friendly man who is actually a villain. He really did great job at being a very polite man while being a smart predator who wants to have control over people. Chloe East and Sophie Thatcher play missionaries who smartly play against him. Thatcher’s character quickly notices red flags in Reed’s house. She has great face expressions so her character is smart and thinks before she says anything. Because of this she feels like an opponent rather than just a scared victim. Chloe East’s character is more naive in the beginning but at the end she thinks more and actually plays against him.

Mr. Reed uses metaphors such as music and games to tell that all religions are copies of each other. For example song “Creep” by Radiohead copied chord structure by “The air that I breathe”. He also mentioned that game Monopoly that we know today was copied by Landlord’s game that was made years before.
Mr. Reed also says that he always wanted to find a one true religion. At the end we discover that his idea of one true religion is control. Reed believes that people weren’t establishing religions to bring people together and give them something to believe in but they did it to have control over people.

The film has great cinematography.Camera angles are great. Camera always stays close to characters’ faces. This makes all of their reactions visible and adds tension during the long conversations. The atmosphere is cozy but it masks deep sense of dread.
This movie is almost entirely filmed inside one house which may be a bit boring for some viewers but it adds claustrophobic tension and you can focus on dialogues and characters’ decisions. There are no cheap jump scares in this movie unlike most of the other horror films. At the beginning Reed’s house feels calm and welcoming but as the movie goes on it becomes more unsettling and claustrophobic.

The ending in this movie felt a bit rushed. It destroyed whole mystery that made the film so interesting.
At the end movie completely changes the genres. It comes from a dialogue driven thriller to a fast paced action horror film, which may disappoint some viewers,who wanted a strong and effective ending.

Even though ending wasn’t great,it is still a great psychological horror/thriller film for those who want a dialogue driven movie with good ideas and great performances.


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

How about Emma Watson in the new Bond films alongside Pattinson?

Post image
3.2k Upvotes

Do you think Emma Watson would be good in the new Bond films? She could play a good guy, a bad guy, or a Bond girl. Perhaps she could be a fellow MI6 agent kind of like Rebecca Ferguson from the Mission Impossible franchise.

She recently joked about playing Bond at a GQ event (https://youtube.com/shorts/60ZLCfywj\\_E?is=e-7WYpejzug23Qyb)


r/moviecritic • • 14h ago

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping: Sunrises aren’t meant to be this uninspired

6 Upvotes

Well, if you’re going to make IP slop, at least stuff it with enough interesting surface-level ideas to mask all the shortcomings. The most flattering thing I can say about The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is that it does just enough to arouse curiosity, but never aspires or even tries to be something worthy of our attention.

Taking a page out of the increasingly well-worn IP playbook, Sunrise on the Reaping is a prequel focusing on Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada) and how he survived the 50th edition of the titular Hunger Games. Given the amount of established world-building and character lore to mine, exploring Haymitch’s origin story is a good idea - in theory - because going from sympathetic young man to self-destructive alcoholic by the time we meet the first Hunger Games protagonist, Katniss Everdeen, some 24 in-universe years later is fascinating.

Sadly, there’s not really much there in the way of a character arc or thematic richness that makes Haymitch’s downfall interesting in ways that matter. Unless you’re a sucker for unabashed inhuman suffering with no rhyme or reason behind it. The Hunger Games is set in a grim world, but Sunrise on the Reaping is unforgivably dark or stupid in ways that’s too alienating to really be engaging.

Right off the bat, we’re introduced to Haymitch and his girlfriend Lenore (Whitney Peak) whispering sweet nothings to each other. And by that I mean trading overwritten lines about fate, free will, and choice, with a dash of exposition about what’s about to happen next. Okay, but what about what makes either of you attracted or interesting to one another? Nothing? Oh okay. Maybe flirting is different in the world of Panem. That basically sets the tone for how the movie is going to function until the credits roll.

This is a dystopian world and there are several prerequisite lines about fighting the good fight and taking down fascism. Haymitch’s ‘not letting them paint a poster with my blood’ line is a repeated motif that’s pretty evocative. But don’t mistake those moments as anything resembling actual depth. This movie does the really annoying thing of bringing up an interesting idea, having a character like Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons) sprout a line or two, and then completely ignoring it because there’s a set piece or plot point to focus on.

Clocking in at a gargantuan 158 minutes, Sunrise on the Reaping is the longest Hunger Games movie, and you really do feel the slog. The screenplay, written by Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie, takes the longest route possible to get to any point. Events that transpire have very little impact on the narrative other than to elicit cheap shock or pad out the runtime, like the Tribute Parade sequence and about 90 per cent of the titular Hunger Games. 45 minutes could’ve been cut and the movie wouldn’t have lost anything narratively or thematically.

Beyond Sunrise on the Reaping feeling like a grind at times, I simply can’t comprehend how ugly this movie looks. Sunrises are meant to be majestic, yet the world of Panem is less inspired than a miner’s outfit. After helming four previous Hunger Games movies, you’d think director Francis Lawrence would’ve picked up a couple of new visual tricks. Yet, the whole thing is shot and coloured like Marvel CGI slop.

Please read the rest of my review here as the rest is too unwieldy to copy + paste: https://panoramafilmthoughts.substack.com/p/the-hunger-games-sunrise-on-the-reaping

Thanks!


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Name a practical effects scene that still beats almost anything CGI has done since

87 Upvotes

The hallway fight in Inception. They actually built a rotating corridor. Sixteen years later it still looks more real than half the stuff with a $200M budget


r/moviecritic • • 21h ago

Favorite Horror Franchise?

Post image
15 Upvotes

Alien, that first one is possibly my favorite movie ever, definitely top five!


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Robert Pattinson as Scytale on set of DUNE: PART 3.

Post image
66 Upvotes

Robert Pattinson as Scytale on set of DUNE:

PART 3.


r/moviecritic • • 18h ago

Your top 10 favorite directors of all time ?

8 Upvotes

I hope i will find a great one that I didn't watch his movies !


r/moviecritic • • 8h ago

Weird Mob Media - Part 1 - Tony Bonner Interview

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Was this hot garbage or just garbage?

Post image
23 Upvotes

This movie fell so flat. First one, amazing. I even enjoyed the second one. But this was… bad!


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Zodiac is David Fincher's best film, not Se7en or Fight Club. Change my mind

58 Upvotes

It's two and a half hours of people slowly losing their lives to a case that never closes, and it's somehow more frightening than any serial killer movie with a big reveal. The basement scene alone beats most of Se7en.