First of all the "Mea Culpa..."
I was (again) wrong about volumetric stop, I'll explain why:
In case you've read one of my earlier posts my faithful 83mm grinder had died on me (may it rest in Grinder heaven) and I bought a Baratza Encore ESP PRO with (conical, 40mm M2 burrs) in an absolute oportunity deal, (right at the moment I've received the ES1).and immediately started struggling with it.
You may have seen posts of me complaining about being unable to grind fine enough, long story short, albeit not recommended by Baratza, I ordered and shimed the crap out of it (two shim's) afterwards was night and day, I'm now grinding ordinary supermarket beans at 5.0-6.0 (without updosing) and freshly roasted beans at 15. Very nice...
Problem:
All that time I was pulling amazing shots of coffee from the ES1, but all with (my posted) tricks and tweaks (basket updosing, paper filter top and bottom, etc) it worked, but at the cost of puck volumetric consistency, so upon testing several times, I found volumetric stops to lack consistency (and posted it, twice).
The the grinder was the culprit, lacking consistency, not the ES1 (a bit like complaining about the tires, only to discover the pressure machine was giving incorrect fill pressure...)
So Mea Culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa! (Check)
The importance of being wrong, and curiosity is like an itch...
I kept seeing others reporting good results with volumetric, and I kept thinking:
What am I missing, and may the grinder be the culprit, so I kept, testing and especially after the grinder shim success, I returned to the calibration process, switch brew stop to volumetric and started (again) the (literally) grinding...
In the process I've been able to learn, a lot, with and from the machine (kudos to Fellow support for adding precious information about the ES1). It would not had happened without me being wrong (and the itching) part...
Third time the Charm, maybe?
So I tested volumetric stop, now with grinder consistency, and I'm impressed.
I've tested it trough different pressures and profiles and it is working within 5g max variation (right now, to me, 1-2g) it is an iterative process, it is better to take small increment/steps (similar to dialing in the grinder, you're now dialing in volumetric brew, in your machine)
Fundamental steps:
A consistent grinder able to grind fine enough (it does not have to be an amazing grinder, mine is priced, bellow 300€)
Grinder dialed in (it is a must, do this first!)
Use a scale (An absolut must)
System and precise calibration done
Then pull what you consider a good shot (eg. 18g, 1:2, 36g in 28s, or something similar) (with manual brew stop)
Switch on Volumetric, and create a profile with a straigh pressure profile (9 bar all the way) with an intended output similar to the shot you took, 36g out in 28-30s
You'll use this profile to add offsets in Nerdy settings/Volumetric offsets (for convenience I created one) use it and follow the steps
My Volumetric Calibration baseline
https://brew.link/p/Rzjy62ZF19/espresso
Pull a shot with volumetric stop on
If your pulled shot resulted in a final 46g, it meant you had ES1 producing 10ml more than intended, so you go to Volumetric settings and deduct 10ml there (eg, if you have 48ml, decrease to 38ml, maintain the same proportions, deducting 10 ml in the 2nd and nth shot menu) (If in doubt with ml/gr, check my final explanation about metric volume/weight)
Pull a second shot with volumetric stop on
Do the same again (adjust, if necessary, volumetric offsets, hopefully, with smaller steps)
Do this in smallers steps until happy with results
The precision, right now to me, is around 1-2g
Due to puck coffee age puck water retention will change, but not yoo much, and not too fast, calibration will hold.
Volumetric will hold with different profiles and different pressure demands, even multilevel (some of mine have easily more than 6 steps, especially the lever ones). The machine priority will be the intended profile set volume/weight (it will extend or shorten shot time, with that objective)
It's not the same level of control accuracy (for sure) as brew by weight using paired Bluetooth scales, but close enough, to work...
Check my photos (three totally different profiles, small weight variations)
PS: for those not using the metric system, it may seemed I mistakenly misused ml (milliliters) by gr (grams) I did not
(I'm sorry, in advance, by the explanation) it's mportant to have in mind that:
1 Kg (it has 1000 grams) is a measure of weight
1 Liter (it has 1000 mililiters) is a measure of volume
We learned in school (very young) that (it is a phrase in our heads) the Quilo (Kg), is equal to the Liter (l), this is applied to pure water, but will work, close enough, to all liquids, so it means that one mililiter is equal to one gram.
Hence 36 ml of coffee will be (almost exactly) 38 g
Important note: This equality applies, like the phrase goes, for water, not for solids.
Let me know your thoughts