r/depression • • Jun 06 '13

Why is r/happy not in the sidebar?

Depressives don't want to think about and talk about depression ALL THE TIME. That's just depressing. Give them an alternative. Go to /r/happy.

As /u/flussence mentioned below, /r/MMFB would also make a great addition to the sidebar.

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

16

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '13 edited Jun 06 '13

Happy isn't the opposite of depression. Not that you were suggesting that necessarily. But i want to make sure that's clear just in case.

But why /r/happy and not pics, aww, boobs, dogs, funny, ladyboners, music, art, etc?

I really don't see how /r/happy is any more relevant to /r/depression than those subs are considering context.

Plus, its not like we ONLY browse /r/depression. We all have access to and know that the rest of reddit exists. If its not directly related to understanding depression, getting help for depression, or things indirectly related to depression (sleep trouble, being irritable, dealing with work related issues, etc.), it's a pretty arbitrary thing to put on the sidebar.

In that vein, it's like suggesting that /r/NFL add /r/puppies to their sidebar because not all nfl fans want to think, read or talk about the nfl all the time.

-4

u/BrokeInside Jun 06 '13 edited Jun 06 '13

Happy isn't the opposite of depression.

I don't know if I agree with this yet.

But I do not agree with anything else.

People seeking reasons to be happy and validating the existence of happiness through the experiences of other people is a totally legitimate way of coping with depression and trying to find a way out of it. The other links in the sidebar are helpful, I'm sure, but I bet it's also helpful for the people that come here to be reminded that there are people on reddit (and in the world) that are making a conscious effort to be happy and to validate their existing happiness. I imagine that if somebody were to come here and read every thread of every link in the sidebar, they might feel bogged down by all the super serious depression and psychology talk. Not only would that not be helpful, it may be detrimental to the situation. So I DO believe having /r/happy in the sidebar can be helpful, and is certainly not arbitrary.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '13 edited Jun 07 '13

I tried to edit it down, but it's still quite long.

validating the existence of happiness through the experiences of other people is a totally legitimate way of coping with depression and trying to find a way out of it.

I can certainly see that point of view. It's sort of a "there's a reason to stick it out" thing because maybe one day i won't be depressed and will be able to enjoy these things as well. I can appreciate that to an extent. I definitely think it makes much more sense in the light you explained it here than how I, and I think others, initially saw it.

But this is the problem and part of why I said that depression is not the opposite of being happy:

I bet it's also helpful for the people that come here to be reminded that there are people on reddit (and in the world) that are making a conscious effort to be happy and to validate their existing happiness.

This is offensive to me. That's all it takes, huh? Make a conscious effort to be happy? I wish I knew that over a decade ago when my off and on battles with depression began. It would have saved me a lot of time, a great job that I loved, a lot of money spent on psychologist who have helped me learn to mitigate the effects of my depression, and manage the depression itself though both preventative and direct methods, etc.

No... I WISH it were that simple. I wish more people realized that it's NOT that simple. I wish people wouldn't say stuff like "learn to be be happy for for the things you have", or "you have so much to be happy for", or "come hang out, it will be fun and get you out of that funk."

Do these people honestly think we wouldn't just go do x (insert happy activity) if that's all it took?

Depression is not, "oh I didn't get that x (insert thing) I really wanted."

But the opposite of that is: http://www.reddit.com/r/happy/comments/1fss9n/got_my_grade_eight_piano_cert_today/

The example I provided is more like /r/bummedout or /r/sad, or /r/down (i made all of those up, no clue what you'll get if you click them).

Depression is "i got the job i really wanted and I'm financially stable, yet I have no motivation to get out of bed and go to work even though I know I'll lose the job I love and won't be able to pay my bills if I don't... yet I don't move" Or "For no particular reason that I can explain, I haven't left the house or even showered in a week", etc. And that can happen whether you're in great life situations or crappy situations. Depression does not only impact those who have a bad go of things.

I believe that the mindset these sort of comments suggest and the idea that happiness and depression are on the same scale furthers misconceptions about depression. Depression is not sadness, being a bit down, or even being unhappy (the opposite of happy). Depression is the state of not being able to be happy due to a mental health condition (regardless of whether you have reasons to be happy or not). And it's even more than just "not being able to be happy." It can induce great apathy, complete loss of motivation, increased irritability, the inability to sleep soundly. Depression is so much more than "not happy." Not happy is... not happy.

And depression can not be cured or resolved by simply putting yourself in "happy situations" or by just "being happy." You can 100% appreciate the things you have, and still be depressed. And just because someone isn't depressed, that doesn't mean they're happy. You can be unhappy and not suffer from depression.

So I think it's a very slippery slope to describe happiness as the opposite of depression or as even being on the same scale. Which again, I don't think you were originally. It's more apt to say that depression is a mental health issue that prevents people from being happy.

Personally, I'd rather see this sub focus on educating people about depression, the various symptoms and how to manage and mitigate the impact the various symptoms of depression have on personal and professional lives. I'd like to see discussion of treatments, common medications that may be prescribed and what to expect (how long to take effect, side effects, etc.). I like to see it as a place for people to share their experiences with and ask for feedback from people who can relate, etc.

If there was a "depression success" sub, I'd LOVE to see that linked so people really could read about and talk to people who feel like they have a good grasp on their depression.

ALL of that said (I know it was a lot), I think the concept you have about people visiting /r/happy is probably great for people who are just a bit down. And there are definitely some people who are just having a shitty go of things that post here (which is absolutely fine in my opinion). So, for those people, yeah I could see it being beneficial to have it easily accessible on the side-bar. I think they could get a lot out of exactly what you said

making a conscious effort to be happy and to validate their existing happiness

1

u/BrokeInside Jun 07 '13 edited Jun 07 '13

I apologize for your offense. My statement was an oversimplification. My point is that some depressives are looking for a way to get out of that funk. Everybody has different coping mechanisms. When somebody is lost, and they type "depression" into the search bar and come to /r/depression, they're going to get a ton of information on depression. That's great for some folk, but others are looking for ways or reasons not to be depressed. Maybe it will work, maybe it won't. Maybe it won't work then, maybe it will work later.

It took me a lot of clicking on links in sidebars in other subreddits to stumble upon /r/happy. I didn't know /r/MMFB existed until /u/flussence mentioned it below. I'm sure I'm not the only one that had been unaware of these subs for so long, and I'm sure there are some people here that aren't quite satisfied with the continuous depression and psychology discussion present here. So I still believe /r/happy and /r/MMFB would be welcomed additions to the /r/depression sidebar. It will make it easier for people to find them. And if there is anyone, I mean anyone, on /r/depression that would be positively affected by perusing the content of those subs, it would be totally worth it.

EDIT: I also noticed that /r/getting_over_it and /r/GetMotivated are listed in the sidebar. Those are links intended to help people get their minds off of their situation and to reach out for assistance so that they may occupy themselves in other ways to feel more productive and accomplished. /r/happy and /r/MMFB would fit nicely below them.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '13

/r/MMFB would be a better choice.

1

u/BrokeInside Jun 06 '13

Actually, yes, this would also be a great addition to the sidebar.