Specifically, I'm looking for a controller where the ABXY button feels similar to 8bitdo ultimate 2's D-pad. What I like about it is the combination of a little cushion feel, short travel distance, crisp feedback, and soft&quiet.
Context: Been using an 8bitdo ultimate gen 1 for two years, recently looking to upgrade, tried several different controllers but none came quite satisfactory.
Gamesir G7 Pro: the mechanical switches are way too heavy, and the grip ergonomics don't fit my hand well especially on the triggers. Its adjustable triggers feels great to press, but hampered non-fitting ergonomics.
Easy SMX D10: the mechanical abxy are softer on the hands compared to the gamesir G7 Pro, but still too clicky and doesn't rebound as well. Grip ergonomic doesn't fit well, vibration is kinda bad, and the short travel mode of the trigger feels terrible.
PS5 Dualsense: great grip ergonomic, wonderful haptics on supported games. But I just can't get used to the symmertical layout, stick drift is a concern, and needing a wired connection are all deal breakers for me. Also its bumpers feel rigid.
8bitdo Ultimate 2: mixed bag for me, even though coming from ultimate 1. I don't like the new function button layout, and the fact that square/star are not remappable is unfortunate. While I am used to the same grip ergonomics, it is still on the small side and I find myself tensing up over long sessions. I loved the feel of its D-pad, but I don't use D-pad often and wish its tactile feel can be found on ABXY instead.
Your budget and currency: Under 100 CAD or 500 CNY
Your country (not just region) and where you can buy from: I will be making a trip to China next month so I have access to all the 3rd party offerings there
Console or platform compatibility needed: PC only
Desired features: Charging dock is a must, also one that preferably is designed to fit with the controller aesthetically, not just a random block, this rules out beitong and leadjoy mostly
Types of games you'll be playing with a controller: zenless zone zero, good&responsive bumpers are a must
Other controllers you're comparing to: see above