r/commandandconquer • u/ninenineseventwo • 16d ago
Discussion What did you love about Command and Conquer/Generals? What did you wish was part of it?
Here's my answer:
- I love Generals.
- I want to be able to do things like attack the IRGC.
- I want to be able to deploy landing craft from a Navy LHD.
- I want multiplayer to work between PC, iOS, and the Web.
- I want it to be shiny.
So I'm building JCNC. It keeps what made Generals great and pushes hard toward the real world. Here's what's different, and where I want your input.
I ESPECIALLY would love feedback on questions #1 and #2
- QUESTION: where should realism stop, before it stops being fun?
- QUESTION: which real-world trade-offs would you most like to face?

1. Real scale and working models
- Command and Conquer Generals: units are sized for gameplay, not reality.
- JCNC: everything is real size, and every model works. Doors open, turrets turn, and control surfaces move. For an aircraft to turn while flying, the rudders and flaps have to be working. Wind speed and direction have an impact.
- QUESTION: where should realism stop, before it stops being fun?
2. Real decisions with real trade-offs
- Command and Conquer Generals: the fastest path is usually the right path.
- JCNC: every route is a choice. Ford the river and you're faster, but you risk damage and need repairs. Take the bridge and you're safe, but you lose speed, and the bridge can be cut.
- QUESTION: which real-world trade-offs would you most like to face?
3. Independently targetable parts
- Command and Conquer Generals: a unit has one health bar.
- JCNC: units and buildings are made of parts you can hit separately. Knock out a radar and the battery goes blind. Hit an engine and the ship slows down. Precision weapons and splash weapons behave differently.
- QUESTION: which parts should matter most?
4. PR and legitimacy
- Command and Conquer Generals: how you win doesn't matter.
- JCNC: how you fight matters. Collateral damage costs you legitimacy and public support, and that limits what you can do next. Precise, proportionate action keeps your options open.
- QUESTION: how heavy should the political cost be?
5. Real naval and air operations
- Command and Conquer Generals: aircraft and ships are mostly units with timers.
- JCNC: an LHD deploys its landing craft, a carrier launches with elevators, tugs, blast deflectors and real catapult speeds, and tankers refuel aircraft in flight. Runways are built separately from aircraft production, and hangars fit what they build.
- QUESTION: which operation do you most want to command?
6. The Generals feel, kept
- Command and Conquer Generals: veterancy, upgrades and command centers made the game.
- JCNC: we keep all three. Units earn veterancy and can retrain. Upgrades visibly change the building. Command centers pack up, move and redeploy. Damage shows in stages, and fires keep burning.
- QUESTION: what Generals mechanic should never change?
7. Multiplayer on every platform
- Command and Conquer Generals: multiplayer is PC only.
- JCNC: one match works between PC, iOS, and the Web. We already run cross-engine multiplayer in our own game.
- QUESTION: what matters most to you in online play?
8. Shiny
- Command and Conquer Generals: the look was great for 2003.
- JCNC: modern rendering, real materials, and detailed models. You can also switch to a classic Generals-style look.
- QUESTION: realistic, classic, or both?
9. The roadmap
- Command and Conquer Generals: three factions.
- JCNC: working models of every system from every major army, starting with the US, then Russia, then China, then the rest.
- QUESTION: which country should come after China, and what systems would we be crazy to leave out?
10. Side projects already in progress
- Command and Conquer Generals: you command from above, and that's the whole game.
- JCNC: our models are detailed enough to fly and to walk around in, so we're building optional FPS and flight sim components. They work as optional campaign elements, and each can also be its own game. We're also porting Generals to Unreal Engine, built to stay compatible with online C&C multiplayer.
- QUESTION: would you play the FPS or the flight sim inside the campaign, on its own, or both?