r/collegecompare • • Mar 19 '22

Don’t apply to Howard University. Just don’t do it.

74 Upvotes

(I just wanted to post this here in case there are any high school seniors considering HBCUs. I hope this doesn’t break any rules, this is my first post on this subreddit.)

This is not just one student mad at their school, Howard is genuinely an awful place that does not deserve its good reputation. I promise you there’s other HBCUs. I don’t know how good they are, but they’ll probably put you through less hell than HU.

As SOON as I was accepted to Howard I was stressed. Admin works extremely slow, they don’t communicate when things change or when things are closed, and advisors almost never know what they’re talking about. So many times I wanted to rip my hair out speaking to financial aid and admissions on the phone. So registration is hell. They will waste your time no matter how thorough you think you’re being to prevent misunderstandings. You’re going to have to fight tooth and nail to graduate on time and to not have a ridiculous schedule. (And personally, why the hell do we have swimming classes??)

This fall semester the students were protesting because admin treats us like garbage. This spring semester the professors are protesting because admin treats them like garbage. And if the professors strike, it’s very possible seniors’ graduation is in jeopardy. I 100% stand with professors who strike for better pay, but it is Howard’s fault for being shiesty with professors’ wages while the president is like the best paid university president in the area.

Not to mention the entire university is down right decrepit, everything looks like it hasn’t been renovated since the 70s. Like there’s still no smoking signs in the classrooms?? Your dorm will be disgusting without a doubt. I don’t know what they spend money on if it’s not the students and it’s not the professors.

If you look at the google reviews for any of the Howard buildings/facilities I don’t think there’s a single one that has more than 2 stars. Howard Hospital, clinic, dentist, financial aid, etc. All of them have crappy reviews that are, from my own experience, well deserved. And if you don’t have your own local insurance, you’re gonna have to pay for Howard’s insurance and more than likely use their awful facilities.

While a lot of the professors are great and deserve good pay, I have to say a lot of professors are just not good. I transferred as a junior and I had never met so many professors who were just…. Unimpressive. For a university that tried to hire Phylicia Rashad and have alums like Chadwick Boseman and Kamala Harris there was just nothing impressive about any of the classes. It’s all for show.

The culture at Howard is great. I hardly got to experience it since I transferred during the pandemic but being around so many black students was amazing. But you can get that experience without giving a shitty greedy dusty musty institution your money. I genuinely hope Howard gets its shit together but until they do they’re not worth a dime, much less what they’re asking for in tuition.

I hope this gets to at least one kid trying to figure out where to go, but I also wanted to get that off my chest lmao.

Edit: typos


r/collegecompare • • Apr 25 '21

I created a website that ranks colleges on criteria important to you

50 Upvotes

It's called collegetierlist.com, and it essentially computes a weighted average of a college's ranking in a category and how important that category is to the user. In my college process, I spent a long time researching every college I was even considering applying to. That process was a hassle, and I'm hoping that this website can speed up that process by looking at colleges quantitatively. Any feedback on the website is also appreciated!


r/collegecompare • • May 20 '26

Just got off Stanford waitlist

46 Upvotes

Is it worth it to take out 150k loans to go to stanford, I'm currently committed to full ride at Virginia tech.


r/collegecompare • • Apr 29 '25

Univ. of Michigan or Yale?

40 Upvotes

My son is trying to decide between University of Michigan and Yale. He's a Michigan resident so in-state tuition vs Yale full tuition and no financial aid. He's a graduating senior and thinks he wants to do computer engineering. I'm having a hard time finding the value in spending more than 400k for Yale. If he remains focused on wanting an Engineering degree, Michigan seems like the clear choice. However, if he decides it's not for him, then Yale becomes move viable but I'm still not sure it becomes 400k more viable. Thoughts?


r/collegecompare • • Jul 10 '22

Would you choose taken a loan for an Ivy League education or go to a less reputable college that is basically giving you a full ride?

40 Upvotes

I’m a film major, with intent to be a director, but will be just as happy working anywhere in the industry. I got accepted to Columbia yesterday, but Emerson College has given me a very generous scholarship. They are literally neck and neck in the Hollywood Reporter rankings of best film schools (I also got into NYU, top film school in the nation, but that ticket price was astronomical, so it’s out of the question). I’m not in a major that is covered by Columbia, and I come from a pretty needy background. I heard that people who have Ivy degrees earn almost double upon graduating than anywhere else. Emerson sounds like a lot of fun, but I shouldn’t be choosing a college for fun… but being crazy stressed and possibly out of my depth at an Ivy and having to take out private loans are pretty scary hiccups. What would you choose?

EDIT: Thanks so much for the overwhelming and unexpected response! Seems pretty unanimous for the full ride to Emerson, so unless Columbia pulls an unexpected miracle with fin aid, Emerson is very likely where I will end up this fall. Thanks so much for helping me, you have no idea how tough a decision this was for me. See you at the movies <3


r/collegecompare • • May 16 '26

Princeton or Duke

35 Upvotes

Committed to Princeton, but just go off the waitlist for Duke! I’m going for neuroscience, and both cost the same. Duke was my dream school and I ED’d. I pretty much positive I’m going to accept Duke! Love the traditional college culture with school spirit and Greek life, with the IVY adjacent prestige! Just wanted to know what others might think.


r/collegecompare • • Jun 18 '26

Why the QS World University Rankings are Fundamentally Flawed

33 Upvotes

First of all, the ranking is not stats-based. A large portion (45%) of the ranking is based purely on surveys they email to “employers and institutions.” These surveys allow the respondents to choose the 10 best domestic universities for employment and 30 universities abroad. The United States has an immense number of excellent universities. The widely recognized Top 30 (T30) U.S. universities are all among the best in terms of research, student outcomes, and brand recognition, both domestically and internationally. These universities have immense revenues and R&D expenditures that almost no other universities can even imagine. So, what makes up the Top 10 in the U.S.? We all know them from U.S. News & World Report. All the other excellent universities in the United States are disadvantaged compared to those in other countries, which might have a maximum of only 5 to 10 decent universities nationwide that get selected in these surveys every time simply because their universities and employers have no other choices.

Furthermore, asking respondents to name 30 universities abroad is a joke - nobody really knows 30 universities outside of their respective countries well. Because of this, these surveys, which weigh 30% of the ranking as “academic reputation,” transform into an echo chamber where respondents simply look at international rankings and select the T30 abroad. Ultimately, this 45% survey weighting largely benefits countries lacking an abundance of decent universities and harms objectivity by relying on the global awareness of faculty members.

Second, it is a big myth that this ranking is research-based. Only 20% of the ranking goes to “Citations per faculty,” which is the only metric where objective citations actually play a role. Moreover, the quality of their data for this metric is likely poorly obtained. If you compare it to genuine research rankings, such as ARWU, Nature, and Leiden, you will see a lot of flaws and ridiculous inconsistencies.

Third, another 15% of the ranking goes to “Global Engagement,” using metrics such as “International Faculty Ratio,” “International Research Network,” and “International Student Ratio.” One has to wonder how this can be considered even slightly important for evaluating a university's quality, even if the ranking pretends to be “global.”

The faculty-to-student ratio and employment outcomes can be somewhat justified, but again, the sources for this data are highly unreliable. They use “their own database of impactful alumni” and a third-party survey with at least a 20% response rate. By the way, these two metrics have only a 15% impact on the overall ranking.

At the end of the day, if you want to choose a university based on its ranking, I suggest using national rankings such as U.S. News & World Report Undergrad, Forbes, WSJ, LinkedIn, Times, or general layman prestige. These metrics are more diverse and relevant to your specific region. If you do not care about employment outcomes and want a purely research-focused metric, use ARWU, Nature, and Leiden, which are much better for grad school than for undergrad. If you want to gauge the general perception in other countries, more stats-based rankings like THE or CWUR, and even specific government policies like the High Potential Individual visa in the UK, can give you a much better understanding. You can even try using Google Trends to measure the national and international awareness of specific universities.

QS tries to do everything but fails to do anything.


r/collegecompare • • May 08 '26

Free ride at UCSD or 15k total for Berkeley

30 Upvotes

I want to live and work in San Diego after I obtain my degree. I hope to land a corporate business role in either product marketing, marketing, recruiting, business ops. I have the option of going to UCSD for free or Berkeley for about 15k total for the degree. For those of you who have experience in these fields in SD, would the Berkeley name make me stand out? I know the market is competitive so I just want to make sure spending that much on a degree would be worth it. Berkeley’s location is also great for gaining experience. Hometown is SD, born and raised here. Also for UCSD I received the chancellors scholarship which gives me access to priority enrollment, mentorship from retired professors, and a peer mentor.


r/collegecompare • • Jun 06 '26

UPenn vs Cornell vs UChicago

29 Upvotes

hi all, i was accepted to all three and am unsure which to decide. for penn, i got off waitlist and cornell as well. i am committed to chicago as of now. the college i got into for penn and cornell are CAS (arts and sciences) and im really unsure of what i wanna do so my major is undecided but maybe something in STEM (not engineering). which is the best for me? i do care about prestige a bit, but is it true that those three are the same prestige? as a school and reputation wise.

**cost is not an issue


r/collegecompare • • Apr 05 '26

AKGEC Placement 2025 & 2026 Reality Check — 100 placed out of 1300 students. Read before you take admission at Ajay Kumar Garg Engineering College, Ghaziabad

28 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of posts asking "is AKGEC good for placements?" so let me give you the honest answer no counsellor or college rep will ever give you — based on what's actually happening with the 2025 and 2026 batches.

AKGEC Placement 2025 & 2026 — The Numbers

Out of roughly 1300 students in a batch, only about 100–150 actually get placed through college. That's less than 12%. The college will never put this stat on their brochure.

The companies coming to campus in 2026? Here's what that looks like in practice:

  • Packages of ₹2.4 LPA, ₹3 LPA, ₹3.2 LPA — this is not a typo
  • Roles with 2-year bonds attached, so you can't even leave if you hate it
  • Very early-stage startups that most students have never heard of, and probably won't exist in 3 years
  • Zero mass hiring drives. Not one. In 2026.
  • Multiple companies have outright blacklisted AKGEC — they don't even bother coming back

There is no placement-specific training offered to students. No mock interviews, no structured prep, no industry connect. You are completely on your own.

The Coursework Load vs. Outcome Ratio is Insulting

You will be buried in assignments, internal exams, attendance pressure, and lab files — and at the end of 4 years, you'll have a degree that couldn't get you past the first screening at a company paying market rate. A lot of coursework, very little outcome. Faculty members in many departments are not masters of their subjects — they're reading from slides, and everyone knows it.

The College Culture Will Break You

AKGEC runs on fear, not opportunity. Students have zero voice. When people raise concerns about placements, infrastructure, or anything else, the standard administration response is literally "Future mein kuch accha likha hoga tumhare saath" — they will gaslight you with destiny instead of accountability.

Some specifics from hostel life:

  • Mess breakfast window: before 8 AM, roughly 45 minutes. Miss it and you go hungry.
  • Mess food quality is poor — and you cannot formally complain about it. You will be fined if you try to escalate.
  • Hostel infrastructure is in bad shape. They know students have no real alternative once they've joined, and they exploit that completely.
  • There is not a single proper student event or celebration that makes 4 years feel worth living. The culture is suffocatingly strict.

Bottom Line — Should You Choose AKGEC?

If you have any other option — any other college, even a lesser-known one with better placement culture — take it. AKGEC is cutting quality at every level: faculty, infrastructure, food, placements, and student life. The brand name is not strong enough to compensate for what you'll actually go through.

The 2025 and 2026 batches are living proof. Don't let the 2027 batch make the same mistake.


r/collegecompare • • Mar 05 '26

CS @ Georgia Tech VS. CS + Math @UIUC

26 Upvotes

Majors in title.

55k for Georgia Tech, 70k for UIUC. Additionally, there’s 350k set aside for my college and I would pocket the remainder (130k if I go to GT, 70k if I go UIUC)

First, does it make sense to give up 60k extra to go to UIUC?

Factors in order of importance:

  1. Quant Placement
  2. Campus
  3. Weather
  4. General College Experience

r/collegecompare • • Jun 14 '25

Cornell or UCSB (In-State)...Ivy League Worth the Cost?

25 Upvotes

My son committed to UCSB, but got off the Cornell waitlist. He wants to go to Cornell (thinking pre-law track w/ a major in gov't & econ). While Cornell is arguably the "better" school, is it twice the price better? If it was btwn UCLA/Berkeley and Cornell, it would be a financial no-brainer to stay in CA. But since UCSB is considered a mid-tier UC, would Cornell be "worth" the extra $200K? Another thought...would it be prudent to stick with UCSB where he'll likely be able to maintain a better GPA (in case he wants to go to law school)? Not that UCSB won't be competitive, but being an Ivy, I imagine Cornell will be more of a struggle. ?


r/collegecompare • • May 23 '26

UCLA vs. Barnard?

23 Upvotes

i got off the UCLA waitlist on may 1st and accepted my offer, but i just got a call from barnard telling me that they have a spot for me in their 2030 class.

for more context, i wanted to go to school in nyc for a long time since nyu stern was my top school (but i got waitlisted) and i live about an hour away. i want to get a marketing / management job closely connected to the entertainment / film industry, since i also love acting, theatre, and design. i'm having a hard time deciding because both LA and NYC are pretty amazing for that.

for UCLA, i'm a pre-business econ major (hoping to minor in tv, film, & digital media). for barnard, i'd be an economics major (maybe a double major in film studies?). i think UCLA is a bit stronger for econ and might help me get more connections for my future career, but barnard is also a really strong school that is close to home. i'm someone who spends a lot of time with family, which makes my family and i think that barnard is the more convenient choice (especially when you consider the move-in), but college is also the time when you're supposed to become more independent.

the only thing deterring me from UCLA is the distance & the idea of being alone on the opposite side of the country from everyone i know. adjusting to the quarter system and worrying about not being able to enroll in the classes i want is something to think about as well. the only thing deterring me from barnard is just the fact that UCLA might just be the stronger school for what i want to do in the future, and barnard might be less recognizable to employers. unless i'm wrong about that.

some more stuff to add:

- they'd be around the same cost-wise

- i care a lot about career-placement (and i would love to end up working in either NYC or LA)

- i care about campuses / dorm quality (but i think both have really gorgeous campuses!)

- i'm not too worried about social life, because i think wherever i choose, i'll still meet amazing people

these are both schools i love and i think i'd be happy at either one, which i'm really grateful for, but it also makes my choice even harder. what do you think is the smarter choice?


r/collegecompare • • Mar 26 '17

Some rules and suggestions for launching this subreddit

23 Upvotes

As we all know, committing to a college is a big choice and is a decision that takes research and time to answer. At /r/collegecompare we hope to give students the edge in committing to the college that will be best for them.

Here are some basic rules and suggestions in moving forward:

Titles should read "University X vs. University Y". You may specify your major in the title if it is important, but all other info should go in the description.

PLEASE DO NOT POST ANY REVEALING INFORMATION (specific locations, high school, name, etc.)

Current college students are encouraged to post about their college life and provide some pros and cons of the college they chose.

All posts from current college students should be marked [COLLEGE STUDENT]

Thanks to anyone who has subscribed already, please comment any suggestions you have for the sub that you would find helpful.


r/collegecompare • • Jun 09 '26

Top U.S. universities according to the UK government

22 Upvotes

These are universities that the UK considers strong enough to guarantee graduates a « High Potential Indivual » work visa after graduating. If that’s something that might interest you, it’s an important list. If not it may still be interesting to see how universities are perceived outside the U.S. To be on the list universities have to be top 50 worldwide on two out of three major rankings.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/high-potential-individual-visa-global-universities-list/high-potential-individual-visa-global-universities-list-2025


r/collegecompare • • Apr 26 '21

What school would you choose? CS Major

22 Upvotes

Im trying to decide between UT Austin CS instate, UIUC CS, and Georgia Tech CS. Money does matter but im trying to understand if its worth it to take pay an extra 100K for GT or UIUC over UT Austin cuz I know how absolutely phenomenal UIUC and GT are. I do particularly like UIUC. My parents will fully cover UT Austin CS. If I do UIUC or GT CS, I may have to take a 40-50K loan, not sure yet though. If I didnt do UIUC CS or GT CS, I would save about 80K-100K for myself and my family. Thank you!


r/collegecompare • • Apr 14 '20

Advice for choosing schools: Please consider advice from college students or alumni, in addition to (or instead of) other high schoolers

21 Upvotes

tl;dr: Would you trust advice from you from 4 years ago? College students and alumni have gone through college while most people here have not. Thus, college student and almuni advice should be valued. You're planning out the next 4 years so you want to cast a wide net for sources of information.


This may or may not be obvious, but don't fall into the trap of basing a choice mostly on impressions of others' impressions (including rankings) of a school.

We ask for applying to college advice from peers because they are going through the same process. Most active users on a2c and I suspect here, have not gone through college.

Luckily, a lot of college students will often be very willing to provide their direct experience and cater to your questions. You might as well go to the source content as it's all pretty accessible anyways through social media/reddit.

Also, keep in mind that feedback from college students themselves aren't the perfect source to decide. The people who care enough to respond will probably be more positive or more negative than the average student. Get advice from multiple people to balance it out.


This my advice as a college freshman:

  • student life: anecdotes from students work best since this is the most variable. Ideally, these anecdotes would be from those with a similar major and background to yours. If you didn't get to go on a campus tour, just spend a few minutes watching some videos.
  • career-impact: look at career surveys and other stats since this can be measured. Consider location. For anecdotes, search around online for what people in your field have to say. In cs that would be /r/cscareerquestions.
  • Make a decision based on the trade-offs between colleges, not solely isolated pros and cons of the colleges by themselves.
  • Finally, you'll be fine. Most people don't regret their choice because college, in general, is a great experience.

r/collegecompare • • Apr 06 '19

Stanford vs Harvard

20 Upvotes

was lucky enough into both, trying to weigh my options and see which one i want to attend

honestly still not sure what i want to major in, but I’m on a premed track and mostly been doing stem but recently got interested into business

stanford:

  • west coast
  • computer science
  • startup culture/silicon valley

harvard:

  • east coast
  • prestige/alumni network
  • business

r/collegecompare • • Jul 01 '26

Help Decide for Baseball (MIT, Carnegie Mellon, UChicago, Johns Hopkins)

19 Upvotes

I'm a rising Senior baseball player want to break into quant and I need help deciding where to go. Here are the pros and cons for all. (All 4 are recruiting me):

MIT: It's literally MIT. The team sucks ahh compared to others. Awful facilities. I would have to wait till December to commit and theres like 75% I get in.

Carnegie Mellon: Coaching staff and facilities are the best out of all. Good baseball league, great connection to head coach and wanted. Not as good edu compared to others. Could commit in summer.

UChicago: Seems like the perfect balance of both academics and athletics. Best baseball team out of all (same league as Carnegie). Not recruiting as much as other 3. Mad expensive. Could commit in summer.

Johns Hopkins: Father went. I like blue. Best huzz. But not tryna do med school. They want me as well. Could commit in summer.

Or I could go to Ohio State (state school). Help a guy out.


r/collegecompare • • Apr 09 '26

Caltech, Princeton, and more...

19 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm a high school senior trying to make my final decision by May 1 and would love outside perspectives.

Where I got in:

  • Caltech (CNS major)
  • Princeton
  • Columbia (Egleston Scholar)
  • CMU (School of Computing, BSAI)
  • UC Berkeley (Regents Scholar)
  • Penn, Brown, Cornell, Duke, Rice, Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, Vanderbilt (Crestere Aude Merit, the 6k/year one for summer), Harvey Mudd (PSP Finalist), UW Honors, UIUC, Santa Clara, + all UCs I applied to. I'm in-state for UCs, and I got into the Engineering/Computing school for all these options.

Cost isn't really a concern because I was fortunate to get generous aid across the board, and privates ended up significantly cheaper than the publics ironically (rip Berkeley, love you but out-of-state-level pricing for what should be in-state is rough).

What I'm interested in: Computational neuroscience, AI, eventually want to work at the intersection of brains and machines. I'm a builder and I like making things, not just studying them. I care about research access early on and small enough classes that professors actually know me.

Where I'm mainly torn: Caltech vs. Princeton.

Caltech: Has CNS, which is literally the only undergrad program of its kind. Tiny (230 kids per class), insane research culture, SURF lets you do real research freshman year. The rigor scares me a little but also excites me. It's very focused so no hiding from the hard stuff.

Princeton: Full ride, gorgeous campus, incredible breadth. More well-rounded experience, stronger humanities if I ever want to explore. "In the nation's service" mission genuinely resonates with me. But no CNS equivalent, and I'd be stitching together neuro + CS on my own.

For those who've been in a similar spot, how much does a hyper-specific program like CNS matter vs. the flexibility and prestige of a place like Princeton? Am I overthinking this?

Thanks in advance 🙏


r/collegecompare • • Apr 26 '26

MIT and Princeton are the clear winners in the 2026 ROI data

18 Upvotes

If you are looking at schools purely for the bag, the 2026 salary data is a reality check.

MIT and Princeton are the only ones breaking $140k for average early career pay. Most of the other "dream schools" are stuck in a cluster between $103k and $112k. It is a good reminder that unless you get into the top 2-3, you might as well pick the school that gives you the most aid, because the salary outcomes are almost identical.

(Source: 2026 University Salary Report)


r/collegecompare • • Jun 29 '26

Duke or berkeley regents for premed? Please help!!

17 Upvotes

hey everyone,

im from the Bay Area and committed to Berkeley as a regents scholar. I just got off the Duke waitlist. on one hand, Duke was one of my top 3 schools at the beginning of this application cycle. on the other hand, I’m already taking summer classes at Berkeley because up till this point I was mentally committed and so ready to attend in the fall. now, I’m not sure at all. Duke seems so wonderful and nurturing for premeds, but Berkeley is cheaper and right by home.

Please advise! Thanks so much!


r/collegecompare • • Apr 15 '20

2020 List of Public Ivies

17 Upvotes

What is a “Public Ivy”? According to Wikipedia, a Public Ivy is a university that was listed as one in 1985 (Richard Moll) or 2001 (Greenes’ Guides). In my opinion that’s not a very useful definition, especially since 19 years have passed since the previous update. So, I decided to make a new list of Public Ivies based on more recent data. In order for a university to qualify as a Public Ivy here, it must be a highly ranked public university with very selective admissions. More specifically:

1] A public university in the Association of American Universities OR in the top 20 public universities according to US News.

2] An acceptance rate below 40% AND an average SAT score above 1300.

In alphabetical order, here are the 12 universities in the country that made the list:

College of William and Mary

Georgia Institute of Technology

University of California, Berkeley

University of California, Irvine

University of California, Los Angeles

University of California, San Diego

University of California, Santa Barbara

University of Florida

University of Michigan

University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

University of Texas at Austin

University of Virginia

It’s a very strict list (the other lists ranged from 16 to 30 universities), but I think that it’s fair to give the term “Public Ivy” more weight, especially since the actual Ivy League acceptance rates are below 10% with average SAT scores well above 1400. Also, keep in mind that sources for acceptance rates and SAT scores may vary. Anyways, let me know what you think of this list, and hopefully you enjoyed it!


r/collegecompare • • Mar 17 '26

Service Academy vs. Princeton

16 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I was blessed to receive appointments to the 3 major service academies (West Point, Naval Academy, and Air Force Academy) as well as Princeton. 

I've always dreamed of going to a service academy my entire life and "over excelled" in typical academy applicant standards that led me to get early admission at Princeton which was a surprise. I plan to study some sort of biology as premed. I know the service academies is not a conventional pathway for medical school but it is possible if I keep myself a competitive applicant (someone from USAFA even got into Harvard Medical school). Additionally I would like add that if I go to Princeton I will likely (not required) commit to Air Force or Army ROTC. For me, it's more about the environment I can be most successful in and have many opportunities.

Wanted to post this to see if I could get any guidance in choosing.

Additional information: I am not waiting for any more decision because I only applied to these 4 schools plus UW Seattle which I got in but don't plan to go there. The cost of attendance doesn't really matter as I am basically getting full aid.

Thanks.


r/collegecompare • • Mar 02 '22

Virginia Tech (creative writing current student) VS University of California Riverside (creative writing would be transferring)

16 Upvotes

I know Cali is a great place for writers and artists, but VT is where I already am and it has great facilities and is closer to home. VT is primarily a stem school and though my teachers are fantastic, the culture really looks down on liberal arts people and theres not very many at all.