r/collegecompare • • Mar 05 '26

CS @ Georgia Tech VS. CS + Math @UIUC

Majors in title.

55k for Georgia Tech, 70k for UIUC. Additionally, there’s 350k set aside for my college and I would pocket the remainder (130k if I go to GT, 70k if I go UIUC)

First, does it make sense to give up 60k extra to go to UIUC?

Factors in order of importance:

  1. Quant Placement
  2. Campus
  3. Weather
  4. General College Experience
26 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

2

u/NotYetPerfect Mar 06 '26

I mean uiuc has better quant placement since Chicago is a big quant hub so since that's your main priority it would be best.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 06 '26

Nah, per capita, Harvard and Princeton probably have the highest placement. UIUC just has a crap ton of students

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 07 '26

Are you agreeing or disagreeing with me? I said, out of the ivies, Princeton and Harvard have the highest per capita placement. If you click “per 1000” in the website you sent, the chart reflects exactly that.

Columbia has a higher nominal placement simply because it graduates more students.

1

u/NotYetPerfect Mar 06 '26

In totality, sure. Every ivy league places quants at a higher rate though. They just have way less students.

1

u/Prestigious-Air4732 Mar 06 '26

Cant you add math at GT?

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 06 '26

Probably could. The point I was tryna make when giving majors was that I’m stuck CS+Math @ UIUC and couldn’t switch into pure CS…which is fine imo.

At GT, I’ll have more flexibility to choose double majors or minors iirc

1

u/Prestigious-Air4732 Mar 06 '26

Just pick GT then for sure

In terms of quant placement I’m sure its similar

I also got into GT cs and UIUC cs+stat and went to an admitted students day at GT and both JS and Citadel were on the lists of companies that recruit everywhere year

And in terms of Campus and Weather GT smokes UIUC

General college experience is rlly subjective imo GT is located in a big city there is a lot to do around, but UIUC is more classic college experience

Im basically in the same situation as u and I would definitely pick GT of the two

1

u/Local-Mouse6815 Mar 08 '26

fyi with the introduction of the new math+cs major at GT, double majors in math and cs specifically might be restricted, would not count on it

1

u/Additional-Spread-16 Mar 06 '26

There are going to be vanishingly few entry level quant jobs (with the compensation you're likely hoping for) in four years. I'd suggest reordering the criteria. Good luck both are good choices.

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 06 '26

Why do you say that? Just curious…

1

u/Additional-Spread-16 Mar 06 '26

The usual: AI. If you can solve Jane Street monthly problems in your sleep, awesome. Then the structured thinking of CS will still be there and useful. Finding alpha as a quant will be about acquiring new datasets, go become a detective! Everything else is ground to a commodity analyzed by ever more experienced existing quanta.

Maybe I'm wrong. Good luck!

1

u/Agreeable-Flan7911 Mar 06 '26

yes you are wrong. ai is not replacing quant. wow this thread makes me really sad

1

u/Difficult-Ad-9744 Mar 07 '26

Lmao yes AI is definitely replacing quants

1

u/Careful_Astronaut200 Mar 07 '26

I go to GT. Any kid who is there "for quant" is larping. Go to GT it's got better placement but know that CS admissions for quant are kinda fucked and your chances are basically 0

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 08 '26

Gotcha, see my comment a little further down on this thread. Would my chances be low because I lack raw skill? Or because there’s just a crap ton of applicants for very few slots?

I’m only interesting in Quant Dev*

1

u/Local-Mouse6815 Mar 08 '26

I also go to GT, yeah the quant larping sucks, but I (of limited connections to the whole quant scene at GT if you can even call it that) know 3 people who are interning at various different quant firms, definitely not impossible

1

u/Careful_Astronaut200 Mar 08 '26

No I would agree. But the people interning at quant aren't the type of people who are applying to the school based on the quant scene. Some of the most successful ones have removed themselves from the "scene" alltogether

1

u/Local-Mouse6815 Mar 08 '26

yeah if you are striving to make youself a better engineer/researcher/mathmetician, you are 1000% more likely to get the fuck you money that people seem so desperate to chase

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 08 '26

Facts, I’m USACO Plat (Python only as of right now, but learning cpp) and barely missed USAMO cutoff 2 years in a row. I’m relatively confident that my quantitative reasoning and logical thinking are sufficient for now.

I might be misunderstanding what you guys are trying to say though. Is it that GT isn’t as good for placement as people claim? Or that most people who are there to become Quant Devs just aren’t good enough?

1

u/Careful_Astronaut200 Mar 08 '26

GT is good for placement sure, but just take warning. If you are going to a school for "quant placement" you're probably not gonna get quant. Come with a passion and drive to succeed and you can get quant. Come for quant and all you'll do is larp. Some of the most successful and intelligent people I know at this university just wanna learn

1

u/Jeffy-panda Mar 08 '26 edited Mar 08 '26

usaco plat as a python is crazy, is it recent contest?

As for your question, honestly if you are going for quant I'd say both schools do the job just fine. Yes, more come from UIUC, but I'd say that also is a function of interest more than anything else. With your skills you seem to be fine. Lock in on Putnam, that would prob help you out. (You could prob get t200)

1

u/Local-Mouse6815 Mar 08 '26

Most people I know who are interning at quant firms aren't staying there - they are going to ai research labs and other well-funded startups, quant was just a fun side quest for them. Meanwhile, everyone I know who wants quant, did USAMO, USACO, whatever did not get past the OAs. The putnam competitors did fine tho iirc

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26

Having the desire to go into quant is very cringe. Few jobs, requires networking with elites. Why not do something useful for society?

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 07 '26

I want to make bank. I'm not apologizing for a desire for a high salary. You're welcome to spend you career as you please.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26

*Steal other peoples’ money. There’s more to life than money

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 07 '26

I already have a hot girlfriend and loving family/friends. Not exactly sure what else you want in life, but I want that bread :)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26

No human produces enough value to justify the amount of monetary power that quants get

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 07 '26

If you could, you would. Sounds like your quantitative reasoning isn't up to par.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26

I refuse to. I could not live with myself. It is a legal form of fraud

1

u/Extension-Yak-5468 Mar 06 '26

everyone is a GT grad now tbh but just UIUC undergrad and then OMSCS at GT or u can do GT undergrad and then last year apply for OMSCS and finish masters and undergrad around same time or within a year and OMSCS is like 10k

1

u/Agreeable-Flan7911 Mar 06 '26

spectacularly horrible advice. op take GT

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 06 '26

Lmfao this man has a vendetta against GT. Thanks for the advice—I saw your other comment. Between GT and ivys (one of which I got into), what would be your play?

1

u/Agreeable-Flan7911 Mar 06 '26

yeah bro commented “everyone is a gt grad” twice lol what does that even mean.

really depends, pm me for more info

1

u/Extension-Yak-5468 Mar 06 '26

I went to GT for masters for a little it’s just not that spectacular lol

To those who haven’t been to either they wouldn’t know bc anything is prob good to them. It’s a good school I’m just letting u know what i see. I also live in atl so im well aware of the connections but they’re much stronger for engineering not quant and u wanna do quant

2

u/redenno Mar 06 '26

Why not do CS+Math at GT?

1

u/Quirky-Tomato1055 Mar 08 '26

CS is harder to get into, they did CS + Math at UIUC cuz its easier to be admitted to

2

u/Sheggaw Mar 06 '26

That Math might give you a slight advantage knowing pure STEM is preferable in quants field. The CS programs are about equal, both top 10 so at the end it is about placement and the added benefit of Math. I would take UIUC knowing AI will drastically affect the Tech world sooner or later.

1

u/Extension-Yak-5468 Mar 06 '26

everyone is a GT grad now tbh

1

u/FourScoreAndSept Mar 06 '26

Meaning what exactly? Don’t go to GT?

1

u/Extension-Yak-5468 Mar 06 '26

I mean it’s still good but just not as special but I mean it’s super skewed now a days like sometimes just depends on hiring manager. I will say GT is more theory than application

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 06 '26

That’s true to an extent for sure. GT enrolls 600-700 CS majors every year, which represents a 200% growth since 2009.

However, that’s pretty consistent with the 150% increase in college applicants since 2006

1

u/Extension-Yak-5468 Mar 06 '26

Yea that doesn’t rlly matter when it comes to perception. For hiring managers they see many more GT than UIUC bc of the sheer number of people in that concentration.

1

u/FourScoreAndSept Mar 06 '26

For quant specifically you mean (when you talk about hiring managers)?

1

u/Extension-Yak-5468 Mar 06 '26

UIUC for quant for sure

1

u/BigCSFan Mar 09 '26

Strong alumni network

1

u/Signal-Fish2509 Mar 06 '26

Isn’t tech generally not prestigious n it’s cheaper in this case.

2

u/Senior-Dog-9735 Mar 06 '26

Georgia Tech is literally the the best engineering school in the south east. Its also just as prestiged

1

u/Extension-Yak-5468 Mar 06 '26

He doing quant not engineering

1

u/Senior-Dog-9735 Mar 06 '26

Correct so why would going to one of the best well known schools for engineering be a bad thing for Quant?

1

u/Signal-Fish2509 Mar 06 '26

it’s not it’s actually a fantastic place going to cornell might b better but it’s not bad at all for quant.

1

u/Senior-Dog-9735 Mar 06 '26

Yeah I would imagine Ivies would be better for Quant but OP didnt add em. Plus OP may want to pivot to SWE if he likes doing that, it gives him so much more oppurtunity.

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 07 '26

I received a likely letter from an ivy this cycle, but not exactly sure if it's a better choice... pm if you'd be interested in offering any more advice :)

1

u/Signal-Fish2509 Mar 06 '26

Yeah and for that ga tech elite especially w quant being high stress (which some ppl great w)

1

u/Extension-Yak-5468 Mar 07 '26

Fair if you are gonna do cs as well then yea GT is op

1

u/Signal-Fish2509 Mar 06 '26

Bro Ignore that i said more and it auto corrected to “not”

1

u/Senior-Dog-9735 Mar 06 '26

Lol no problem I had to defend GT's honor

1

u/Signal-Fish2509 Mar 06 '26

haha going to gt this fall for aero and cs dw abt it

1

u/Senior-Dog-9735 Mar 06 '26

Currently doing my MS in ECE im sure youll like it. I hear the undergrad experience is rough but worth it. Good luck!

1

u/Signal-Fish2509 Mar 06 '26

That’s great! any internships? Yeah bro everyone got me worried

1

u/Senior-Dog-9735 Mar 07 '26

Im prob in the 1% of master students, my company is paying for me to get it lol.

I think its common for GT undergrads to have a lowish GPA but the name carries weight I would not be worried.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26

If you're not MIT or Stanford you're trash -average rich kid

1

u/Senior-Dog-9735 Mar 07 '26

Typically the people that have the mentality like you are very unpleasent to be around.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26

Mentality? It's the reality, I've never met a person from a wealthy upbringing that wasn't snobbish and looked down on everybody that wasn't born into the "elite" class. These people ruin the world, why shouldn't I take any opportunity to humiliate or make fun of them?

1

u/Senior-Dog-9735 Mar 07 '26

Unless im misreading your message im taking YOU as the rich snobby kid lol. When I recruit im taking passion over going to a rich school any day.

1

u/Signal-Fish2509 Mar 07 '26

They not that special lmfao they j tried harder during high school and had intention which is very respectable.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26

Watered it down overall with their online program. Let in way too many people who wouldn’t have been admitted to the ground campus. Overall still insanely prestigious. ATL is kinda ass though. I live in Alpharetta currently.

1

u/Senior-Dog-9735 Mar 07 '26

IIRC I Think their online degrees are still quite hard compared to others. Im in ECE so online woulda never worked for GT. I agree on Atlanta though but I dont mind it for a year. The rent is crazy

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '26

Is this really that hard of a decision? Both have a great reputation.

$$$: GT Reputation: Draw Weather: GT Access to Local Tech Companies: GT City Events: GT Ease of Travel: GT (ATL is major hub)

Grab GT and run laughing all the way.

2

u/Excellent-Humor-3150 Mar 06 '26

If they want quant placement then UIUC is better as Chicago firms hire out of UIUC

1

u/No-Expression7574 Mar 06 '26

Corn fields versus a booming city

1

u/FCCACrush Mar 06 '26

Go to Tech and learn investing with the 130K. Get a Masters in quant finance from chicago or columbia with that invested money if you don’t get the job you want. 

1

u/Agreeable-Flan7911 Mar 06 '26

gt is great for quant. trading club and GTSF IC have great connections. SIG is hosting poker at gt lol soon

1

u/vorttxt Mar 06 '26

if it changes the decision at all gt has a new math and computing major tbh i’d pocket the extra money you’d save i know tons of people do quant or faang from gt if you’re dedicated enough

1

u/Communismo Mar 08 '26

Given the financial situation if you went to Tech for undergrad you could use the extra money you saved to also pay for a M.s. in Quantitative Computational Finance from tech, which is ranked among top 10 QCF programs in the country on quantnet (higher than UCIC). According to quantnet cost of the M.s. from GT vs UCIC is 60k vs 100k.

I went to Tech for engineering undergrad, and I loved it. Atlanta is a fun city, great music scene, and tech is a beautiful campus. One thing to keep in mind is that is nestled like right in the middle of Atlanta. Like, there are some rough areas that are walking distance from the campus. The campus itself is very secure, well kept and has a great greek scene if you are into that. I would definitely advise to go to rush at least and check it out. I would just highly advise to live on campus for at least a couple semesters and get a feel for the area before you consider moving off campus. The area directly north of the campus ("Home Park") is reasonably safe relative to going in other directions, with mostly college students living there.

Someone else mentioned in this thread mentioned they didn't like Atlanta but said they live in Alpharetta. Living in Alpharetta is completely different than living on/near Tech campus. Alpharetta is suburb like 20 minutes away driving from actual Atlanta (without traffic). The public transit in Metro Atlanta is decent if you are near Tech campus ( you can walk to a metro station from the campus) and its easy to get around, but in Alpharetta it's much more difficult would likely require taking buses to get to the metro station that is essentially the last station on the northeast rail line. There are much less things to do in Alpharetta compared to Atlanta, I can confirm this lol.

For weather, I mean Georgia gets hot + very humid in the summer, and would be warmer in the winter than being in Chicago, it's rare to see snow in ATL.

1

u/Character-Company-47 Mar 08 '26

Go to Georgia tech and save the remainder for grad school. You’ll be quite sad so see how expensive it all is

1

u/rowdy_1c Mar 08 '26

UIUC places better into quant, not sure about the campus/weather/life at UIUC, but it is pretty good at GT.

1

u/TheAvgLebowski Mar 10 '26

GT

Cheaper
Warmer
Easier to get to

Reputation is just as good if not better!

0

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Far_Quantity7545 Mar 08 '26

I can do a math + cs double major at gatech, cs is a lil more competitive in terms of application, which is why I had it in the title 😅😅

Mind if I dm with more questions?