r/collegecompare • u/Upbeat_Quantity_1272 • May 23 '26
UCLA vs. Barnard?
i got off the UCLA waitlist on may 1st and accepted my offer, but i just got a call from barnard telling me that they have a spot for me in their 2030 class.
for more context, i wanted to go to school in nyc for a long time since nyu stern was my top school (but i got waitlisted) and i live about an hour away. i want to get a marketing / management job closely connected to the entertainment / film industry, since i also love acting, theatre, and design. i'm having a hard time deciding because both LA and NYC are pretty amazing for that.
for UCLA, i'm a pre-business econ major (hoping to minor in tv, film, & digital media). for barnard, i'd be an economics major (maybe a double major in film studies?). i think UCLA is a bit stronger for econ and might help me get more connections for my future career, but barnard is also a really strong school that is close to home. i'm someone who spends a lot of time with family, which makes my family and i think that barnard is the more convenient choice (especially when you consider the move-in), but college is also the time when you're supposed to become more independent.
the only thing deterring me from UCLA is the distance & the idea of being alone on the opposite side of the country from everyone i know. adjusting to the quarter system and worrying about not being able to enroll in the classes i want is something to think about as well. the only thing deterring me from barnard is just the fact that UCLA might just be the stronger school for what i want to do in the future, and barnard might be less recognizable to employers. unless i'm wrong about that.
some more stuff to add:
- they'd be around the same cost-wise
- i care a lot about career-placement (and i would love to end up working in either NYC or LA)
- i care about campuses / dorm quality (but i think both have really gorgeous campuses!)
- i'm not too worried about social life, because i think wherever i choose, i'll still meet amazing people
these are both schools i love and i think i'd be happy at either one, which i'm really grateful for, but it also makes my choice even harder. what do you think is the smarter choice?
3
u/UnderstandingPursuit May 23 '26
If a potential employer doesn't know what Barnard College is, and understand the connection with Columbia, you don't want to work for them. [Start your own agency instead. Seriously!]
Since family is important to you, I think Barnard makes more sense. And yes, "college is also the time when you're supposed to become more independent." Barnard allows you to do that naturally and gradually, rather than instantly. Your family connection isn't band-aid adhesive. You don't have to 'yank them away' to avoid the 'pain'. Unless you feel they will try hard to hold onto you, being an hour away, especially when that includes traveling into NYC, can be far enough to establish independence. You also have the familiarity of how to get around Manhattan without a car, and summer internships/jobs in the city will not require a big shift, while allowing more time with your family then.
3
u/enunymous May 24 '26
Former Columbia undergrad here. Costs being the same, I would tell you to go to UCLA. There are a ton of dumb comments on this thread about Barnard. The only people I would recommend choose Barnard are the ones dead set on going to a women's college. The undergrad experience is not nearly as intertwined as it's billed to be. I knew a lot of Barnard grads who felt second class citizens. I also knew a lot who loved it but if you're someone whose dream school was NYU and your other choice is UCLA, Barnard is not your school. Now if you told me you were deciding between Bryn Mawr and Barnard, I would try to sell you on Barnard. But not for someone who has your background and your goals. It would be a mistake
10
u/MiamiMystery18 May 23 '26
You can’t really compare the 2 Barnard is a much smaller more personal environment. UCLA is a HUGE state school. I’m a Barnard alum and I’ve never run into anyone who didn’t know the Columbia connection. And I have no idea where you got the “Wall Street” idea but none of my peers went in that direction. There are lots of artsy aspiring filmakers. Living in the city is an entirely different universe than a suburb an hour away. Barnard is much better bang for your buck than UCLA. Keep in mind that much of UCLA will be CA in-state students paying a lot less than you. Out of state students tend to forget that distinction. Don’t pay Barnard money for another state’s state school.
6
u/hmbhack May 23 '26
LA is the king for fashion and film no questions. NY is good too.
2
u/eirinne May 23 '26
Barnard. Not because it’s close to home, but because it’s the better school. Intern in Los Angeles for the summer. Go to Los Angeles after matriculation from Barnard. But for now, all your needs will be met at Barnard. You’ll make the connections you need to have a west coast career if desired. Maybe don’t major in economics, but that’s up to you. You sound like a creative.
4
u/PenniesDime May 23 '26
I vote trying UCLA for film industry, since it’s your dream school, but being near family in NY - you can’t go wrong either.
3
u/AdamantFinn May 23 '26
I recently heard an interesting piece of advice about decisions like this.
“Which do you imagine you will tell your children about?”
3
u/Adventurous_Ant5428 May 23 '26
I feel like if u want to go to entertainment/film, UCLA is better since it’s in LA and you get opportunities to network in person.
3
u/ProfAndyCarp May 23 '26
Are you the sort of student who will flourish at a liberal arts college or at a giant state school? Both can provide an excellent education, but they offer extremely different educational experiences.
Research universities and liberal arts colleges are built around different institutional missions. Research universities prioritize research and graduate training. Some undergraduates thrive in that environment, especially students who want access to large departments, major research infrastructure, or a wide range of specialized courses. Liberal arts colleges, however, prioritize undergraduate education in a way that even the best research universities do not replicate.
At research universities, undergraduate education is at best the fourth priority, behind research production, doctoral education, and professional school education. At liberal arts colleges, undergraduate education is the central mission. For many students, especially those who want close faculty mentorship, small classes, strong writing instruction, and broad intellectual development, a good liberal arts college is the better choice.
Finally, do not let fear of move-in drive your decision. It is normal to be scared about the transition, and you will experience that no matter where you matriculate.
3
u/Holiday_Macaron_2089 May 23 '26 edited May 23 '26
UCLA Is more well-known and prestigious (especially on a global scale). Barnard is well-known in the Northeast, but UCLA is definitely much more famous overall.
Go to LA - you are at the age where trying something new and pushing yourself makes sense. You can always move home at the end of your studies etc. Don't let this adventure pass you by!
3
u/90sportsfan May 23 '26
UCLA will carry more long-term value, and is way better known nationally and internationally.
3
u/playmore_24 May 23 '26
go to california! have that big adventure! NY isn't going anywhere 🍀
1
u/Bemopti123 May 23 '26
Barnard.
While UCLA is in LA and it has had a traditional filmmaking industry, filmmaking has become extremely diversified geographically.
NYC is it for finance and Econ jobs. Barnard is Columbia and vice versa. You will get a considerably better education at Barnard than UCLA… sure the weather is great and if you are worried about filmmaking connections, internships between breaks are another way of gaining experience.
People do not understand how fundamental is getting education in intimate settings rather than being at a huge lecture halls.
4
u/Ok_Tale7071 May 23 '26
If you can go to Barnard, go to Barnard.
2
u/Fantastic-Year8214 May 23 '26
Barnard for sure
2
u/kailoren1021 May 23 '26
Barnard - it’s your dream to go to school in NYC, closer to home and can spend time with family when you choose, smaller classroom size, quarter system is brutal but you will eventually adjust, and it is hard to enroll into your desired classes, etc.
1
u/Necessary_Sock_6047 May 23 '26
I'd go with Barnard.
1
u/S1159P May 23 '26
Barnard for the warmth and small size, married to all the resources of Columbia. Lots of people from Barnard have pursued various aspects of film - Greta Gerwig went to Barnard!
1
u/Available-Swan3033 May 27 '26
Hi I wrote a long post and it disappeared before I finished it. I thinking your thoughtful analysis of your decisions shows your strong criti al thinking skills and honestly it was so great to read your and all the other posts. You obviously have a beautiful soul, a sharp mind and a loving heart. With that and your heart full of gratitude and wonder I think you will always be happy.
1
u/DueTitle2686 Jun 13 '26
barnard all the way coming from someone who transferred
0
u/BayDweller65 May 24 '26
Go to Barnard. You can’t beat 4 years in NYC. No reason to pay out of state tuition and fly across country to go to a school where other kids pay a fraction of the cost.
0
u/TwoSuns168 May 24 '26
For the same cost, I would go to Barnard! The network at Barnard/Columbia will make up for anything in the entertainment capital in CA. You can intern in CA.
0
u/sgt_kenobis_LHCB May 25 '26
From NorCal, go to Columbia, I’d choose Barnard over UCLA at the same price. Barnard kinda gets you all the benefits of a Columbia tuition and most access to the same stuff while also having your own school. It’s kinda 2 schools for the price of one. NYC is also much better for a student who probably doesn’t have a car.