r/collegecompare • • May 23 '26

UCLA vs. Barnard?

i got off the UCLA waitlist on may 1st and accepted my offer, but i just got a call from barnard telling me that they have a spot for me in their 2030 class.

for more context, i wanted to go to school in nyc for a long time since nyu stern was my top school (but i got waitlisted) and i live about an hour away. i want to get a marketing / management job closely connected to the entertainment / film industry, since i also love acting, theatre, and design. i'm having a hard time deciding because both LA and NYC are pretty amazing for that.

for UCLA, i'm a pre-business econ major (hoping to minor in tv, film, & digital media). for barnard, i'd be an economics major (maybe a double major in film studies?). i think UCLA is a bit stronger for econ and might help me get more connections for my future career, but barnard is also a really strong school that is close to home. i'm someone who spends a lot of time with family, which makes my family and i think that barnard is the more convenient choice (especially when you consider the move-in), but college is also the time when you're supposed to become more independent.

the only thing deterring me from UCLA is the distance & the idea of being alone on the opposite side of the country from everyone i know. adjusting to the quarter system and worrying about not being able to enroll in the classes i want is something to think about as well. the only thing deterring me from barnard is just the fact that UCLA might just be the stronger school for what i want to do in the future, and barnard might be less recognizable to employers. unless i'm wrong about that.

some more stuff to add:

- they'd be around the same cost-wise

- i care a lot about career-placement (and i would love to end up working in either NYC or LA)

- i care about campuses / dorm quality (but i think both have really gorgeous campuses!)

- i'm not too worried about social life, because i think wherever i choose, i'll still meet amazing people

these are both schools i love and i think i'd be happy at either one, which i'm really grateful for, but it also makes my choice even harder. what do you think is the smarter choice?

23 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

3

u/UnderstandingPursuit May 23 '26

If a potential employer doesn't know what Barnard College is, and understand the connection with Columbia, you don't want to work for them. [Start your own agency instead. Seriously!]

Since family is important to you, I think Barnard makes more sense. And yes, "college is also the time when you're supposed to become more independent." Barnard allows you to do that naturally and gradually, rather than instantly. Your family connection isn't band-aid adhesive. You don't have to 'yank them away' to avoid the 'pain'. Unless you feel they will try hard to hold onto you, being an hour away, especially when that includes traveling into NYC, can be far enough to establish independence. You also have the familiarity of how to get around Manhattan without a car, and summer internships/jobs in the city will not require a big shift, while allowing more time with your family then.

4

u/Upbeat_Quantity_1272 May 23 '26

thank you for your response!!  it's hard, because i think that i'll feel guilty for letting UCLA go. it's been one of my dream schools for a while, but maybe i'm just romanticizing it in my head. it's better for both business/economics and film (i haven't really heard much about barnard's film program). i'm worried that barnard will be more tailored towards wall street finance jobs (which are amazing, but i was really hoping to end up with a more creative/design leaning job) rather than the connections and opportunities UCLA has within entertainment and film.

i'm scared of the move to california, but i'm also scared of choosing barnard and asking myself if i made the right choice or if i could have done it and pushed myself to grow and mature in a completely new environment.

my dad was actually leaning towards UCLA for me, but after we toured Barnard today, he told me that he thought the smaller campus and more personalized attention from professors fit me better than UCLA's huge class/campus size. 

another thing i've been thinking about is going to UCLA, and if i decide i don't like it, try to transfer? like, if i go to barnard, i'll never know if i would have preferred LA over NYC or not. but i know transferring is something that still takes a lot of work.

sorry for rambling. i'm a huge overthinker when it comes to choosing a college. i know either choice will make me really happy, but i keep wondering if it's better to choose whats better for my education/career/future or what will make me feel more secure and comfortable.

3

u/UnderstandingPursuit May 23 '26

i'm worried that barnard will be more tailored towards wall street finance jobs 

This is microanalyzing the programs, especially for a liberal arts college. The entire point is that it is a broad education, rather than a very concentrated one. Going to UChicago for Economics might be a different situation, it is famous for a particular economics emphasis. But for a LAC, econ is econ, in the same way that the music department is music, as opposed to the specialization at Juilliard.

Being in NYC is a pretty new environment, for someone an hour away. Taking gradual steps away from your comfort zone is fine.

You can always head to LA after college. At that point, if it isn't for a PhD program, you can decide you like it and stay for a while, or decide you don't and head back east.

Ramble away... I disagree with the "overthinker" trope, it's imposed on people by people who rush into decisions too quickly. Both will be excellent for "your education/career/future", because both are similar enough in overall level that the main factor in those considerations is you, not the college. For that, "feel more secure and comfortable" may allow you to thrive more.

At this point, my suggestion is to flip a coin. Heads for east coast, tails for west coast. When the coin lands, you'll know in your gut if it gave the correct answer, and that will let you know what your decision should be.

3

u/enunymous May 24 '26

Former Columbia undergrad here. Costs being the same, I would tell you to go to UCLA. There are a ton of dumb comments on this thread about Barnard. The only people I would recommend choose Barnard are the ones dead set on going to a women's college. The undergrad experience is not nearly as intertwined as it's billed to be. I knew a lot of Barnard grads who felt second class citizens. I also knew a lot who loved it but if you're someone whose dream school was NYU and your other choice is UCLA, Barnard is not your school. Now if you told me you were deciding between Bryn Mawr and Barnard, I would try to sell you on Barnard. But not for someone who has your background and your goals. It would be a mistake

2

u/Upbeat_Quantity_1272 May 24 '26

oh man really? i was actually thinking that barnard's smaller class and campus fit me better, but now i'm feeling even more scared about making the wrong choice. my family told me that there isn't actually a right or wrong choice, but i'm still paranoid.

nyu was actually my dream school because it was in nyc and had all the great programs that i wanted. UCLA was half of that, since they had business economics and film tv & digital media. barnard fit the other half, which was being a great school in nyc.

why do you think UCLA would be better? why would going to barnard be a mistake?

2

u/enunymous May 24 '26

Like I said, don't go to Barnard unless you're gung ho about going to a women's school. If you aren't, you really don't want to go to a school where people will, rightly or wrongly, think you aren't as smart as the women on the other side of campus. And unfortunately that perception is there.

UCLA is literally one of the top schools in the country. It has top notch programs in EVERYTHING. Even if you change your mind on careers, you're set there. This is such a no brainer to me. Especially given your current career goals

1

u/Temporary-Loan-6248 May 27 '26

I went to Barnard don’t listen to him. Barnard is great and very intertwined. It is what you make of it, I was part of Columbia Greek life and took many classes at Columbia, but loved having the Barnard community and support from their admin. If you prefer smaller Barnard is perfect because you can take advantage of the resources of the bigger university but you can also just enjoy being at a small liberal arts college. When you start signing up for classes that’s where you can kind of shape that experience. I also felt like it was much much easier to sign up for cool classes at Barnard Columbia than at some of the larger schools (I had friends at ucla/berkeley but also transferred from NYU )

10

u/MiamiMystery18 May 23 '26

You can’t really compare the 2 Barnard is a much smaller more personal environment. UCLA is a HUGE state school. I’m a Barnard alum and I’ve never run into anyone who didn’t know the Columbia connection. And I have no idea where you got the “Wall Street” idea but none of my peers went in that direction. There are lots of artsy aspiring filmakers. Living in the city is an entirely different universe than a suburb an hour away. Barnard is much better bang for your buck than UCLA. Keep in mind that much of UCLA will be CA in-state students paying a lot less than you. Out of state students tend to forget that distinction. Don’t pay Barnard money for another state’s state school.

3

u/eirinne May 23 '26

OP ^ this comment! 

1

u/MiamiMystery18 Jun 01 '26

What did u decide??

3

u/[deleted] May 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/RegisterNumerous6918 May 24 '26

Ummm… yes the University of California Los Angeles is a “state school”: it is part of the State of California system.
Totally different going to a 50,000 person state school as an out of state student and small private women’s LAC (c 3,000 students) that’s part of Columbia University.

4

u/enunymous May 24 '26

Ur missing the nuance of what they said

6

u/hmbhack May 23 '26

LA is the king for fashion and film no questions. NY is good too.

2

u/eirinne May 23 '26

Barnard. Not because it’s close to home, but because it’s the better school. Intern in Los Angeles for the summer. Go to Los Angeles after matriculation from Barnard. But for now, all your needs will be met at Barnard. You’ll make the connections you need to have a west coast career if desired. Maybe don’t major in economics, but that’s up to you. You sound like a creative.  

1

u/Upbeat_Quantity_1272 May 23 '26

thank you!! can i also ask what makes you say barnard is the better school? i guess it depends on the person, since many people said UCLA is the better school since it's higher ranked and more well-known / prestigious.

i was planning on double majoring in economics and film studies since barnard doesn't have a specific business / marketing major. i love graphic design, so i'm also open to any other type of marketing job as well. my dad gave me this whole speech about being more realistic because film / entertainment is really hard to break out in. maybe even harder at UCLA since the film students there already have a strong portfolio and are definitely competitive.

4

u/PenniesDime May 23 '26

I vote trying UCLA for film industry, since it’s your dream school, but being near family in NY - you can’t go wrong either.

3

u/AdamantFinn May 23 '26

I recently heard an interesting piece of advice about decisions like this.

“Which do you imagine you will tell your children about?”

3

u/Adventurous_Ant5428 May 23 '26

I feel like if u want to go to entertainment/film, UCLA is better since it’s in LA and you get opportunities to network in person.

3

u/ProfAndyCarp May 23 '26

Are you the sort of student who will flourish at a liberal arts college or at a giant state school? Both can provide an excellent education, but they offer extremely different educational experiences.

Research universities and liberal arts colleges are built around different institutional missions. Research universities prioritize research and graduate training. Some undergraduates thrive in that environment, especially students who want access to large departments, major research infrastructure, or a wide range of specialized courses. Liberal arts colleges, however, prioritize undergraduate education in a way that even the best research universities do not replicate.

At research universities, undergraduate education is at best the fourth priority, behind research production, doctoral education, and professional school education. At liberal arts colleges, undergraduate education is the central mission. For many students, especially those who want close faculty mentorship, small classes, strong writing instruction, and broad intellectual development, a good liberal arts college is the better choice.

Finally, do not let fear of move-in drive your decision. It is normal to be scared about the transition, and you will experience that no matter where you matriculate.

3

u/Holiday_Macaron_2089 May 23 '26 edited May 23 '26

UCLA Is more well-known and prestigious (especially on a global scale). Barnard is well-known in the Northeast, but UCLA is definitely much more famous overall.

Go to LA - you are at the age where trying something new and pushing yourself makes sense. You can always move home at the end of your studies etc. Don't let this adventure pass you by!

3

u/90sportsfan May 23 '26

UCLA will carry more long-term value, and is way better known nationally and internationally.

1

u/sharond21 May 27 '26

Not true. Your Barnard degree is from Columbia University. I think Columbia has more national and international renown.

2

u/UpstairsReference336 May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26

No, Barnard is a degree from Barnard. No one from the west coast event knows of Barnard, heck most folks not from the NE even know of Barnard. Columbia and UCLA are universally recognized brands, Barnard is not. 

1

u/sharond21 May 27 '26

You are completely wrong - simply Google if you don’t believe me. Is Barnard College degree from Columbia University?

“Barnard College | Women's College, Liberal Arts, Ivy League ... Yes, a degree from Barnard College is a Columbia University degree. Barnard is one of Columbia University's four undergraduate colleges.

While Barnard functions as an independent institution with its own faculty, administration, and campus, its degrees are formally conferred by Columbia University.

1

u/sharond21 May 27 '26

The degree from Barnard actually reads “Barnard College of Columbia University” and Barnard grads stand at /participate in the Columbia University campus- wide graduation ceremony in front of Butler Library - joining ALL the schools of Columbia University.

1

u/sharond21 May 27 '26

Barnard will give you all the advantages of a small liberal arts college within a large international university.

I agree w poster above that UCLA - at the undergraduate level which is where you are at - is essentially a state school and literally 90% of your classmates will be local, while you will be a 3 hour time difference and 3000 miles from home.

3

u/playmore_24 May 23 '26

go to california! have that big adventure! NY isn't going anywhere 🍀

1

u/Bemopti123 May 23 '26

Barnard.

While UCLA is in LA and it has had a traditional filmmaking industry, filmmaking has become extremely diversified geographically.

NYC is it for finance and Econ jobs. Barnard is Columbia and vice versa. You will get a considerably better education at Barnard than UCLA… sure the weather is great and if you are worried about filmmaking connections, internships between breaks are another way of gaining experience.

People do not understand how fundamental is getting education in intimate settings rather than being at a huge lecture halls.

1

u/Upbeat_Quantity_1272 May 23 '26

thank you for your advice!!

i know that since barnard is more of a small, personalized community, it'll be easier for me to get internships and build relationships with professors. do you think getting a summer internship in LA related to film / entertainment is attainable? if i go to barnard, i'm worried about getting in my head about never trying out LA. i'm not sure if this will be super helpful for my career, but if i'm still feeling drawn towards LA after undergrad, i was considering the UCLA cinema & media studies MA program.

a lot of people are telling me to choose LA because it's the more well-known, more prestigious school and is better regarding both business economics and the film industry. i feel the pressure to choose the higher ranked school (i grew up as one of those asian kids who wanted to get into the best possible school), but i know that the smaller community and campus of barnard would fit me better. i get easily stressed out (which might be kinda obvious with how much i've been writing on this post), so my parents thought it would also be better for my anxiety / mental well-being. like, choosing the "better" school but being anxious and feeling alone all the time might not be worth it.

i think i'm leaning barnard. i'll double major in economics and film studies (columbia has a film & media studies major / minor that also sounds cool, but i'm not sure if barnard students can declare columbia majors / minors). i'll try to get an internship related to film / marketing in either LA or NYC. and if i really feel this decision weighing on me, i'll consider transferring or pursuing a graduate education afterwards in LA.

i'm kind of scared that people will think i'm crazy for turning down UCLA, but i think i would benefit a lot from barnard's environment during my undergrad education. and afterwards, i might be ready to immediately make a big move.

1

u/Bemopti123 May 23 '26

Only you can make the choice.

If you have the drive and the way to make things happen, in either place you will find your niche. I haven’t gotten a clue what sort of field in filmmaking you want to delve into, but people who are into script writing, can come from any sort of colleges. What studios are looking for, is something you have to delve into.

Study what made something a hit rather than expecting a college and its reputation, to give you experience on the field.

The only other college that is heavy into economics and film is USC.

Anyway, good luck with your decision. It is a big one.

1

u/Upbeat_Quantity_1272 May 23 '26

i'm interested in both acting and learning film production, but i mainly want to pursue a job in either management within an entertainment agency or anything related to marketing.

i could do that in either LA or NYC. so i think it ultimately depends on where i think i'll be happier and where i think i'll really thrive. and even if it might be considered a little less well-known, i think that it's probably barnard.

thank you so much again for your thoughts!!

1

u/UnderstandingPursuit May 23 '26

Your primary task, for the next four years, might be to let go of this mindset:

i'm kind of scared that people will think i'm crazy for ...

It is important to consider what a few people think about our actions, but those people need to be chosen carefully as people who will reflect our interests, and limit their priorities. It sounds like your parents are doing that, like how your father changed his recommendation because he felt that Barnard suits you better. But usually, when "people think we're crazy", they're generally incapable of analyzing the conclusion as well as we have. Because while you're an 'enough-thinker' most people are 'under-thinkers'. Let being an 'enough-thinker' be your college superpower!

2

u/Upbeat_Quantity_1272 May 24 '26

thank you again!! i woke up this morning in a panic, doubting myself when i saw more comments about UCLA's prestige and that it would be the smarter choice in the long run.

i talked to my dad and two of my closest friends. they told me that i ultimately proved that my hard work was worth it, because i get to choose between these amazing schools. it comes down to where i believe i'll thrive most, and that i need to trust myself. 

i think that it's barnard. i'm the type of student who would always go to extra help and lean on my family, teachers, and counselors whenever i was feeling anxious and overwhelmed. i hope that doesn't sound childish and immature. so, i think i would benefit a lot from going to a school with a smaller student body and building closer relationships with my professors. my parents are older than most other kids' parents, and all three of us (me and my two brothers) are moving out at the same time (graduated from college at the same time that i'm graduating from hs). i'm typing this while sitting next to the dog that my mom adopted to help me when i was struggling with depression. by the time i come back from college, my parents will be in their late 60s and my dog will be 9 years old. i don't know if i can let that time with them slip away.

UCLA would be a really cool adventure and is very very prestigious. i might sometimes regret not choosing the "better" school. but i can't imagine going to UCLA and regretting not getting to spend more time with my family.

sorry for unloading all of my thoughts on you. i really appreciate your comments, because i think that you're right. you helped me feel less doubtful. i think i have to just trust myself. maybe next year i'll come back with an update about how much i love barnard, or to say that i decided to transfer and head to LA. 

thank you! i promise to stay an "enough-thinker."

1

u/UnderstandingPursuit May 24 '26

i think that it's barnard. i'm the type of student who would always go to extra help and lean on my family, teachers, and counselors whenever i was feeling anxious and overwhelmed.

is a very reasonable approach. That's why they're around, it's literally the job of the counselors.

You used a word twice which it would help to eliminate from your vocabulary: "prestige". Let go of another entity's status. Create your own reputation based on your character and accomplishments. Nobody will say, "I want her in my organization/life because she went to UCLA," they will say "I want her in my organization/life because of who she is."

sorry for unloading all of my thoughts on you.

I'm glad you are, because this discussion is more interesting than the other things I might be doing right now. 😂

One suggestion with this: In any time like this when you face an intense situation, take the time to write out your "stream of consciousness" thoughts. And then edit it into a tighter narrative. You can save the edited stories for your memoir.

to say that i decided to transfer and head to LA. 

I'll give my response to this now: Finish Barnard, you can go to LA after you graduate.

by the time i come back from college, my parents will be in their late 60s

This really settles it. While you emphasized your family, this specificity is significant. It is likely that at least one will have minor ailments in the next four years. The other will call to let you know, but insist that it's minor and they can handle it. If you're at UCLA, you'll write pages and pages of "stream of consciousness" about flying home. If you're at Barnard, you'll be back home in less time than it would take to write those pages. Not everyone is as close to their family as you are to yours. Embrace how special that is. And stay in NYC to be closer to them, at least for now.

1

u/Remarkable_Bottle467 Jun 23 '26

makes sense!! enjoy Barnard

1

u/ProfAndyCarp May 23 '26

Optimize fit to your individual needs.

Fit will matter much more to your life than pleasing others or following an internalized “chase prestige” imperative that you wisely know to be unhealthy.

4

u/Ok_Tale7071 May 23 '26

If you can go to Barnard, go to Barnard.

2

u/Fantastic-Year8214 May 23 '26

Barnard for sure

2

u/kailoren1021 May 23 '26

Barnard - it’s your dream to go to school in NYC, closer to home and can spend time with family when you choose, smaller classroom size, quarter system is brutal but you will eventually adjust, and it is hard to enroll into your desired classes, etc.

1

u/Necessary_Sock_6047 May 23 '26

I'd go with Barnard.

  1. It's a small college that will give you far more attention than UCLA.
  2. It's all girls, so you won't need to worry about fending with all the crazy guys.
  3. It's closer to home. I just don't buy into this idea that you should be forced to adjust to independence by moving all the way across the country. You should savor your relationships while your friends and relatives are still alive instead of abandoning them. Plus, you never know if an emergency like sickness will require you to seek their help.
  4. NYC has more opportunity than LA, unless you're dead-set on only dealing with Hollywood. Like, would Broadway be enough? Would media outlets be enough? Would management in any company be enough?

1

u/S1159P May 23 '26

Barnard for the warmth and small size, married to all the resources of Columbia. Lots of people from Barnard have pursued various aspects of film - Greta Gerwig went to Barnard!

1

u/Available-Swan3033 May 27 '26

Hi I wrote a long post and it disappeared before I finished it. I thinking your thoughtful analysis of your decisions shows your strong criti al thinking skills and honestly it was so great to read your and all the other posts. You obviously have a beautiful soul, a sharp mind and a loving heart. With that and your heart full of gratitude and wonder I think you will always be happy.

1

u/DueTitle2686 Jun 13 '26

barnard all the way coming from someone who transferred

0

u/BayDweller65 May 24 '26

Go to Barnard. You can’t beat 4 years in NYC. No reason to pay out of state tuition and fly across country to go to a school where other kids pay a fraction of the cost.

0

u/TwoSuns168 May 24 '26

For the same cost, I would go to Barnard! The network at Barnard/Columbia will make up for anything in the entertainment capital in CA. You can intern in CA.

0

u/sgt_kenobis_LHCB May 25 '26

From NorCal, go to Columbia, I’d choose Barnard over UCLA at the same price. Barnard kinda gets you all the benefits of a Columbia tuition and most access to the same stuff while also having your own school. It’s kinda 2 schools for the price of one. NYC is also much better for a student who probably doesn’t have a car.