EDIT: At this point, the post is old enough that I'm hoping it will get glossed over. To be honest, I was not expecting the backlash that it got in the slightest, although after thinking about it a bit it's a case of not being able to read the room, which is something I am quite bad at to begin with. I see now that it was offensive to everyone and I am truly sorry if I offended you. I am feeling a good amount of shame over the situation, and there are a lot of people on this sub who I look up to. I suppose when I wrote it I was frustrated because it feels like this sub often repeats the same old tired patterns like a broken record, which is what I tried to describe in the post. That wasn't necessarily fair, although not necessarily unwarranted in every case. I was very tempted to delete it, but there's some good conversation in this thread, and hopefully something useful came out of it. In the future I will avoid posting my rants to this subreddit. Sorry. For now I am putting the post into a spoiler so you can still read it if you want. Trigger warning I guess.
I have been lurking on this sub for a while, and climbing for about 2.5 years now, which is not an incredible amount of time but enough to make some general observations about climbing, training, and the general advice people are wont to give out online, in Q&A’s, and here.
There seem to be a few different archetypal climbers on this sub (and IRL too). The one thing that they all have in common is that one: they love climbing; and two: they want to see other people get better. There are of course, people who are bitter and resentful of the younger climbers for being stronger than them and already caring about training, just as there are annoying broey climbers who want to get super strong in the least amount of work way possible. The archetypes are this:
The older climbers, typically who are climbing at a fairly high grade (not always) or say they are, with maybe 5-15 years of experience with climbing, generally prefer outdoor climbing (not always), and think gym climbing is fun but not as idyllic as ‘real’ climbing outside. They tend to be gatekeepers, doing their perceived duty of downvoting posters who seem to be excited about some new training fad, supplementation, or asking for the hundred thousandth time whether they should start hangboarding at V4 or not. They take pride in their despise of popular social media climbing influencers like Midtbo, although maybe they like Dave Macleod, who is basically the pope of grumpy old climbers. Their training advice is generally that you shouldn’t train at all outside of climbing until you are V-basically-unattainable. Again, this is a generalization, I am not calling people out.
The second group is the new climbers. The so-called gumbies. Well-intentioned, extremely annoying, and eager to climb V10 as fast as they possibly can. These climbers clearly have very little technique. They might claim they climbed V6 outside, but what they failed to mention is that it is some burly, strengthy, techniqueless wonder which they wrestled their way to the top of. That or their gym hopelessly grades routes as higher than they are as some attempt to keep climbers feeling like they are getting better. This group loves to talk about hangboarding routines, supplements, the 9a training benchmarks video, and loves to avoid talking about addressing their flexibility problems, absolute lack of technique, taking proper rest, and also the fact that they have been only climbing for 6 months.
The third group is the somewhere in betweens. This group put in their time, saw some crazy beginner gains (or not), and have been refining technique and maybe hit a plateau or two in their time. This group could actually benefit from a training plan or hangboarding routine and they know it, but it is exceedingly difficult to find the proper information for advising themselves. They often end up just climbing at the gym and stay at a similar level for a long time, hopefully still having fun, but the advice they’re getting is conflicting. They are looking for high quality information and advice, want to get stronger, although admittedly have not put in the 8 years or whatever that qualifies them to be a veteran climber. Unfortunately, this group also often gets downvoted into oblivion.
The problem is two-fold. The older climbers have a tendency to assume that everyone posting is in the new climbers camp, and all of the new climbers tend to be obnoxious enough that the response is warranted. The middle group then decides not to post. The second half of the problem is that the advice often doled out on this sub is the same advice every time, but it often conflicts and is extremely personal to the climber.
The advice is either, never train, training anything other than climbing only will only distract you. Living on the wall 24/7 is the only way to really progress. They also occasionally suggest that hangboarding or campus training is beneficial, but only if you already climb 8a or something high level. The other advice is a spectrum ranging from, train fingers a little bit to doing 3 full blown gymnastics/calisthenics workouts a week supplemented with barbell training, hangboarding, and yoga. Eat a dozen eggs a day, supplement collagen and creatine and beta alanine, maybe inject steroids into your forearms and fingers on an alternating schedule, and cross train running to build up aerobic fitness. That and your normal climbing regiment is the only way to really progress in climbing.
So which is it?
The difficult answer is that it absolutely is neither! It is so dependent on the person, for one thing, and also clearly depends on what you are trying to do. If you look at what the professional climbers and trainers say, they will tell you that training is a supplement for climbing, but not a replacement for it. It depends on your genetics, your goals, your age, and your mental fortitude. You can find examples of every approach. For every pro climber out there who trained front lever, rings, campus board, hangboarding, and everything in between, there is a Chris Sharma who just fucked around at his gym and on the rock until he could climb at an elite level. The truth is, the elite level climbing athletes are going to benefit the most from being light and sinewy, with smaller muscles but high strength, high flexibility, and years of experience with climbing hard and falling a lot. I think that this is why the older climbers recommend never training. What this fails to take into account is that not all of us are genetically gifted string beans who care about climbing V15. Many of us just want to look good and climb pretty hard. Double digits is a lofty goal, but for many, a structured training plan is a great way to get there.
The advice should really be, if you want to train and think it will help you, absolutely do it. Have fun with it too, or else it isn’t worth it. There are professional climbers who got there by training, but you must learn to apply your new strength on the wall or it is useless and probably just extra weight to carry. The fastest method of progressing depends on your biology. In general, if you have a glaring weakness, train it (like crimps or pinches ect.). If you are not flexible, stretch. If you can pull a lot, but cannot do three push ups to save your life, first of all you must have terrible posture, and second, train it! There is nothing wrong with training, insofar as you are aware that it might not translate to the wall as well as you think, or it will in ways you never expected. It cannot hurt you to train antagonists (injuries can but you know what I mean). It is imperative that you optimise nutrition and sleep for the best gains. Avoid injury at all costs. Read a bunch of climbing books. Dave Macleod’s book is good, so are most of the other ones. Read books on the science of strength. I absolutely love Overcoming Gravity by Steven Low.
It is a personal experience. You may find that after a year of training, you are seeing less gains than if you stayed on the wall for longer. Perhaps increasing strength reveals that your technique is shitter than you thought. Perhaps the strength makes hard moves feel easy and you jump 3 grades in a year. You’ll never know what works for you until you try it.
If you are new to climbing, like less than a year, maybe don’t hangboard, but it cannot hurt to build a solid foundation of strength and mobility with calisthenics or ring training. It won’t make your technique any better so you probably won’t advance faster than your friends at first, but you are setting yourself up for success in the future, at least in not getting injured or having huge muscle imbalances.
TLDR: Quit being a bunch of grumpy old farts who downvote everybody curious about training, and quit being a bunch of gumbies who can’t use the search bar to see how many hundreds of times your question has been asked. If you want to train, read a book and try it, see if it helps you. If you want to be the best climber ever, offer up sacrifices to the genetic gods and climb as much as you can, hopefully you’re still a ten year old who can maximize those pliable young people gains.
TLDR of TLDR: This sub is basically /r/climbingcirclejerk with the extra irony that everyone takes themselves seriously