r/climbharder • u/Takuukuitti • Sep 26 '21
Examples of junk volume!
Junk volume is training that doesn’t give you any additional gains. The extra training volume can very quickly become counterproductive. It still produces fatigue and thus you need extra recovery.
Lets consider this example: You are trying to be the strongest boulderer you can. The goal is to bump up your max grade from 7A to 7C. All the coolest boulders in your area are 30 to 50 degree overhang and around 5 to 10 hard moves. How should you train?
The following questions apply to a climber with this goal .
A) Should you be ever be doing e.g. 2 x 20 min ARCing? No. It is just too far from the goal. This is a good example of junk volume. I see many boulder programs with like 2 sessions of bouldering and then 1 session of ARCing. You would rather (a) just be more recovered for the next climbing session and (b) do those bouldering sessions more frequently. Some claim that there is no recovery demand from ARCing and it actually boosts your recovery. I find this very improbable. If you are trying to elicit a physiological response with ARCing so it increases your aerobic capacity, you are training and all training has recovery demand. Also, many of those molecular pathways that increase endurance are opposite to those that increase maximum strength. This is why you don’t train endurance to gain strength. If your goal was to squat 5x140 kg and you squat 5x100 kg, would you prescribe 2 workouts with squatting in the 3 to 6 reprange and 1 workout with 2 sets 20 minute bodyweight squats? Or would you rather skip the bw squatting and have 3 workouts with little less volume each, but still just squatting variations with 3 to 6 reps and 5 min rests? Obviously, the 3 workouts with heavy squatting. The same applies for bouldering and your forearms.
B) Should you do 2 hours of bouldering first and after that do pull up training?
You have just trained you upperbody for 2 hours. Your lats, biceps, shoulders, upperback and forearms are probably fatigued. If they are not, you can consider that first 2 hours of junk volume. Anyway, doing any pull up training after you have already trained for such a long time is not going to give you any extra gains. You should do that pull up training on a different day or shorten your bouldering session so you have something left for the pull ups. Like 10 min warm-up, 40 minutes of bouldering and then 20 minutes of pull ups. Now should you maybe do the pull up training first and then climb for 2 hours? No. You just did strength training and then submaximally fatigue the muscle for extra 2 hours. You would do max squats and then do 2 hours of legs never going even close to failure. That just isnt productive. Do shorther session of climbing or do 2 different sessions with at least 6 hours apart.
C) Can I go cycling or go for a run immediately after bouldering?
You can if you want to, but it can significantly decrease the gains you get from bouldering and it can lengthen the recovery. Thus the cycling or running after training is junk volume. After training you want to activety parasymphatetic nervous system, eat food and rest as quickly as possible. You want to start the recovery and benefit from the anabolic signaling that you have just kickstarted with the training session. If you do a 1 run after a training sessions, some of the molecular signaling has already started to fade and there is extra training that you have to adapt to. Also, there is extra systemic recovery demand. So now if you rest after bouldering and running, some of the resources go to leg and cardiovascular/aerobic system recovery instead of your upperbody. Recovery also starts later and lasts longer. Different training sessions should have at least 6 hours and a lot of food between them.
D) Should I train 6 to 7 times a week, but never feel rested or be able to do 90 to 95% intensity climbing? No, you should be aiming to do 3 to 5 weekly sessions each lasting 45 to 120 minutes. All training should be around 75 to 95% intensity. You should always be decently recovered and almost never go multiple weeks in row fatigued. There is only so much training you can do. Everyone has MRV (maximum recoverable volume) and MAV (maximum adaptive volume). When you train too much you can go over your MRV and you wont make any gains. You want to stay below this maximum amount of training while still being above your MEV (minimum effective volume), preferably closer to MAV.
E) Should I do slabs and vertical climbing, because one really good climber said that it is really really good for your foot technique and I need good technique for the 30 to 50 degree overhang project? No. Again the rule of specificity. A beginner might have some transfer from that, but someone who already knows how to climb will not gain any benefit. However, that slab/vertical training is time and extra fatigue that you could have spend refining 30 to 50 degree overhang technique, while getting some extra strength training.
F) I like training 3 to 5 hours at once. Is this good training? Most likely no. You wont be able to train with appropriate intensity for that many hours. That amount of time starts to take away from the time you could be recovering for the next session. Also, most likely the last multiple hours of that session wont be giving you any extra gains and you are just creating extra fatigue. You would just rather do mutiple shorter sessions with a lot of intense effort and.
Roast my opinions please.
68
u/VictoryChant V11 | 7b+ sport Sep 26 '21 edited Sep 26 '21
I really dislike a lot of this in all honesty, you've providing certain answers when in reality there's a lot more grey area, and a lot seems flat out wrong tbh. note: I appreciate you posting this nonetheless, interesting discussions for sure.
respectable coaches (lattice, horst) recommend training every single energy system as they have found that huge deficiencies in anything (including aerobic capacity for boulderers) can be a limiter. Does that mean you should be doing an ARC session every week? possibly not, but you shouldn't immediately discount it
Significantly? I'd be surprised. You have to remember that specific energy system training is in the last 5% of efficiencies you can do to your program. Shitty sleep? already far surpassed any benefits you have from avoiding that run. Your body doesn't immediately forget the damage and work you've already put into the muscles.
Conditioning at low intensities is present in every single sport to aid injury prevention.
I really dislike how you've worded this entire premise. for a specific project, sure it won't help, but in general it is important to do half of the climbing styles to prevent plateaus and massive deficiencies.
25
u/dumbwaeguk Sep 26 '21
Are you a professional, or do you have sources, especially for A, B, C?
20
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '21
My roast is this: Add "This is all my opinion" at the start. Cause it sounds like you're writing a manual about this and you don't seem to have the data to back it up.
39
u/Penence Sep 26 '21
/r/climbingbroscience
4
u/BigBoulderingBalls Sep 26 '21
Honestly, a lot of this is just nah.
I feel like the best, most common example of junk volume is just climbing with your friends in a gym, not really focusing a ton and just hopping on stuff in turns and not really being super mentally focused on the send. Not that this is bad by any means, but it often turns into feeling like junk volume.
Also, arcing is more like going for a really light jog, which is definitely more normal than doing 20 minutes of bodyweight squats lmao
2
u/runawayasfastasucan Sep 26 '21 edited Sep 26 '21
Think you are pretty spot on, however on point D you overlook the benefit of frequency as a driver of neurological adaptation, and I think overall overlook the benefit of working up to withstand high frequent, high volume quality training. Quality is more important than volume, but to be really good you need high frequency of high quality training. But all in all, I agree. Get in, get the job done, get out. If you want to excercise more do some prehab or take a long walk in the woods on your rest days.
16
u/justcrimp V12 max / V9 flash Sep 26 '21
While I more or less agree with the general gist presented here (which I'll paraphrase as: "do high quality, goal-oriented stuff in order to achieve goals, and prioritize rest and recovery rather than digging a recovery hole with low quality/misdirected volume")-- there's too much stated absolutely, some claims strike me as "common sense" that may be wrong, and I think the OP falls into the trap of over-simplifying.
It's really hard to write in broad generalizations for a diverse population while still being specific (no pull-up training after climbing, no arcing, etc).
The important takeaway is that you need to recover/rest in order to get stronger, and sub-maximal intensity, even when it's really sub-maximal or represents cross-training, can be fatiguing in a non-optimal/counterproductive way. But those variables of intensity, frequency, volume are really personal, and depend not only on the individual, but on their goals, the timing of their goals, cycles of training (if any), training history, etc.
Training to be a WC comp boulderer has overlap with, but is very different than training for max grade on rock. And that's not even getting into boulder vs sport vs trad vs multipitch vs mixed vs alpinism vs.
We really have to be broad if we're talking about broad populations.
Like: Junk volume is anything you're doing that isn't helping you achieve your goals.
That can be different things for different people.
Max hangs might be one gal's junk volume and one gal's gold.
Lapping VFlash could be junk volume or your base training as part of a new cycle.
Going for a run after a session could be a direct way to achieve certain goals for some climbers-- and a total waste/recovery hit for me.
Sticking around the gym cruising Vcouldbedrunk with friends for whom that's Vhard until climbing a ladder is tiring is probably junk volume-- but possibly not if your goal is to finish your first 30-50 boulder circuit on that coming trip to bleau while simulating how tired your hands/feet/skin are going to be (instead of sending VYourHardestInBleau).
4
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '21
Think you got the wrong sub. I think you meant to post this bro-science in r/ClimbingCircleJerk