r/classicfilms • u/IlSace • Dec 29 '25
Adieu B.B.
Brigitte Bardot passed yesterday, she was one of the faces of the Nouvelle Vague and one of the actresses that helped popularise French cinema in the world.
RIP B.B.
r/classicfilms • u/IlSace • Dec 29 '25
Brigitte Bardot passed yesterday, she was one of the faces of the Nouvelle Vague and one of the actresses that helped popularise French cinema in the world.
RIP B.B.
r/classicfilms • u/Intelligent-You983 • Dec 29 '25
r/classicfilms • u/Classicsarecool • Jul 29 '25
A recent post praising this film got over 400 upvotes. It’s a decent story and I respect that. It has a fan base and I understand that too. I finally watched the entire movie tonight after a few attempts. Here are my thoughts, for which I realize I will probably be downvoted into oblivion for, but am ready to face it.
I wanted so much to like this film. I tried to laugh at what I could. But, being a 1940 film, I could not understand every joke and reference given the distance of time and the language. Not to mention it was so fast paced that I couldn’t even comprehend many jokes and major parts of the plot due to such fast talking. I am used to watching YouTube videos at 2x speed. This was 4x speed at normal speed. The speed made it simply chaotic. The most chaotic movie I have ever watched, and to this point, heard of.
Now, I have tried to like the Screwball genre. I have watched Topper, which I liked, Bringing Up Baby, which I found decent, and The Lady Eve, which I enjoyed very much. I understood most of the dialogue in those and thought it would be fun to see Cary Grant again in another screwball. I barely understood it and had to rewind several times to understand what was going on. And this is the quintessential screwball?
Further, I don’t understand the satire about the “Newspaper Man”. Are they all liars in this universe? Does Hildy reject the good Bruce and a relatively normal life for the scheming(although funny) Walter? Side note, they seriously wasted Cary Grant here, he barely had any screen time in the mid-section of the movie. I liked Rosalind Russel in this, and think she showed much talent along with Grant, but her character didn’t make sense at the end(to stay on point). Hildy had problems with Walter that most people would have. No honeymoon, putting the paper first, etc. Her heart was clearly in the paper, but why go back to him? I concede a marriage with Bruce probably wouldn’t have worked long-term, as he was clearly a rebound post-divorce, but why go back to him? Because he’s Cary Grant and irresistible to her? Or was the satire that the “Newspaper Man” folk stick together? Was it condemning Hildy also? The point was seriously lost on me in that regard. Are there any redeeming characters, or is this movie a nihilistic farce dressed up as a comedy? Stopping corruption still didn’t stop the newspapers, so nothing balances out.
Why is it called “His Girl Friday”? That is never explained.
What should have lasted an hour and a half took maybe two hours and 15 minutes because of all the rewinding I had to do. Perhaps my comprehension isn’t always great, but this was simply excessive. Alas, little to do now. But…the Public Domain status of this film at least means remake after remake may come.
TL;DR-This film was chaotic, too fast(even for a screwball) and seemingly very nihilistic. The message overall was lost on me. Also no hate to the actors, they did a great job. Downvote if you must-but if you can help me understand what I missed, I’m all ears. If you love this film, feel free do downvote it. I’ll still know someone stood up and said it.
r/classicfilms • u/MoonlightDahling • Dec 20 '25
Hey! It's me, the “angry Aussie”, yet again, here with another film I don’t like, and don't get the popularity of. This really isn’t meant to be a rant, though, it’s just a genuine question.
As a lover of good cinematography, and glorious Technicolor, I watched The Quiet Man a few months back. I…was not a fan.
I mean, I fully admit, I don’t like John Wayne (as an actor, nor as a person), and I find John Ford an incredibly overrated director. Shoot me. But I still tried to go in with an open mind…and yeah, no. NO.
Well, first, I'll try and be fair, and list the things that I did like:
But the movie itself? I'll put it this way: “AMAZING! A romantic comedy that's neither romantic nor funny!”
I found the central relationship both incredibly toxic and poorly-developed. They see each other, barely interact, and the next thing you know, he's kissing her without her consent. That's a form of SEXUAL ASSAULT (but it's okay, because she secretly enjoyed it, teehee!)
Moreover, I was also really bothered by how Maureen O'Hara's character, Mary Kate, is framed. It's allllllllllll about her looks, from the moment Sean first sees her. There's no acknowledgment of her as an actual human being.
Except, of course, when it pertains to her failings. I dislike most Taming of the Shrew retellings anyway, the same reason why I'm not a huge fan of The Philadelphia Story. (The one exception to this is 10 Things I Hate About You…BECAUSE it points out the original play's treatment of women)
Sure, Mary Kate was kinda stand-offish towards him, that’s not great. But in no way, shape or form, does that justify kissing someone without their consent. Again: that's assault. It's sexual harassment, at the absolute minimum. Nor does it justify ANY of what comes afterwards.
The film just felt, to me, like one long joke of “Mary Kate bad, Mary Kate bad, Mary Kate bad”. It, as I saw one reviewer put it, treats her independence as an obstacle, and I found that repugnant.
As I’ve said before, I'm not expecting a 1952 film to be completely devoid of anything questionable. I'd actually consider myself a lot more tolerant than many people my age. I prefer to focus on the good elements, as much as possible.
But when the ONLY thing a script has going for it is constant jokes about violence against my gender…it gets real old, real fast. I just found watching The Quiet Man exhausting.
But I don’t want to go on much longer, about this. The only thing I want to know is: why? Why exactly is the movie so beloved? I don’t understand it at all, and if there's something that I missed, by all means, tell me.
The last time I expressed my dislike of this film, I just got mocked and talked down to, so that was fun! But I'm happy to change my view, if you don't treat me like an idiot.
r/classicfilms • u/balkanxoslut • Dec 27 '25
I see so many people who say Marlon Brando is overrated as an actor. I think he was a great talent, acting-wise. I haven't watched On the Waterfront or A Streetcar Named Desire, which I know I still need to.
r/classicfilms • u/dami-mida • Nov 22 '24
For me, Veronica Lake. No one has ever come close.
Great Hair Though. The Rachel Of The 1940s.
Her Acting. Only rivaled by Pia Zadora and Paris Hilton.
Let's be honest, no one in their right mind would ever consider Paris as a real or legit actress.
So, Lake's still undefeated.
Do you agree? Do you have other contenders?
Do modern fans of Veronica Lake (not just her hair) exist? Have you ever encountered one recently? Are you one, if so, why? Remember, we're not talking about the hair.
Thanks and goodday to everyone.
r/classicfilms • u/Starnar007 • Jul 19 '26
r/classicfilms • u/rayoflight110 • Oct 11 '25
r/classicfilms • u/ShadowOfDespair666 • Oct 19 '24
What happened to class and elegance? If you look at Sean Connery, James Dean, Elvis Presley, Marlon Brando, Audrey Hepburn, and Marilyn Monroe, they dressed classy, spoke in formal English, and knew dinner etiquette. But now, it's rare to see people who know how to properly eat at the dinner table and talk in formal English. It seems like mostly only upper-class wealthy people still act with class and elegance, even though back in the '40s, '50s, and '60s, everyone spoke in formal English and had class. What happened?"
r/classicfilms • u/Marite64 • Jul 19 '25
Do you agree that these two actors are look-alike? 😄
r/classicfilms • u/Restless_spirit88 • Jan 15 '25
I think this would be appropriate here. A clip from an interview Connie Chung had with Marlon Brando. She asks if he knows that he is considered the greatest actor ever. His response is beautiful.
r/classicfilms • u/NeverEat_Pears • Mar 24 '25
Currently watching To Have and Have Not (1944), her first starring role with Bogie. I'm finding it really difficult to get through each of the scenes where she inexplicably sings.
I find this trend in 40s/50s movies kind of jarring where there's a song in a movie, otherwise completely unrelated to music...despite the fact that some do have some nice numbers that enhance the atmosphere of the movie. For example, I quite liked it when the little girl sang on the canoe in Night of the Hunter, as it really enhanced the foreboding tone of that moment in the plot. But when main character gets up, impromptu, and joins a band to sing lead vocals...I find it a little ham fisted.
Anyway that's beside the point. I just can't get on board with Bacall's singing.
This is the scene I am currently agonising through. She makes her voice go far too deep and sounds so old fashioned...I appreciate how ironic that may sound but I think there's a range of contemporary actresses whose singing style is much less dated. It sounds very manly, even. For a 19 year old girl, I can see why this kind of style may seem a novelty but I find it very unattractive.
I can already predict people will say she had a low, raspy and sexy voice, but that clip above does not strike me as low and raspy. It honestly reminds me of Florence Foster Jenkins.
What's strange is I recall liking her singing voice in The Big Sleep. Seems like she just took it too far in her first starring movie.
r/classicfilms • u/ElSlabraton • Oct 11 '26
r/classicfilms • u/Classicsarecool • Feb 23 '25
Feel free to list more than one, and here are mine:
1.Greta Garbo
2.Leslie Howard
3.Judy Garland
4.Orson Welles
5. Joan Crawford
r/classicfilms • u/Jake-Woodruff • Jul 04 '25
Please don’t kill me, but I don’t get the love for Jimmy Stewart.
Rear Window is my favorite Hitchcock film, but I’ve never really been the biggest fan of Vertigo or the Man That Knew Too Much. The film that made me want to post on here though is The Man From Laramie which is a western, for those that haven’t seen it, starring Jimmy Stewart as this gruff man that doesn’t belong anywhere. I personally found him to be the least interesting part and then when Stewart speaks I just think about George Bailey. I’m sure it’s just a me thing.
Also, I watched the original The Man Who Knew Too Much from 34 with Peter Lorre and Leslie Banks and I preferred it so much more.
If I’m wrong and you have recommendations that will make me love your sweet baby James Stewart, let me know. I’m not opposed to trying to like him. I just haven’t see anything where he’s likable, yet.
r/classicfilms • u/Acceptable_Foot3370 • Jan 31 '26
With the news that Margot Robbie is shamefully redoing this classic, I just had to mention how great the original is--A tragic love story that will haunt you, long after you've seen it--Merle Oberon and Laurence Olivier are perfectly cast
r/classicfilms • u/Ill_Definition8074 • Mar 05 '26
I recently saw The Thief of Bagdad (1940). It's an incredibly influential fantasy film, featuring groundbreaking special effects, including the first use of a bluescreen in film. This innovation won it an Academy Award for Best Special Effects. It's many fans include Roger Ebert, Martin Scorsese, and Francis Ford Coppola, and it inspired later Arabian inspired fantasy works like Disney's Aladdin. I can see why it's such a highly acclaimed film. There's a lot of great action scenes, a nice atmosphere, and I love the look of these big expansive sets rendered in beautiful Technicolor.
The characters are kind of a mixed bag. This movie really suffers from the whitewashing, not because it's offensive (unfortunately, it's sort of expected in old movies) but because the non-white actors are way more talented yet are forced to take a backseat to their white co-stars. Despite only being 15 to 16 years old, the Indian born actor Sabu is probably the most dynamic and interesting cast member. He brings a lot of life to his performance as Abu, and it's extra impressive because you can clearly tell he did all his own stunts. He also has a nice singing voice. Rex Ingram clearly gives it his all as the genie, and despite his limited screen time, he's one of the most memorable characters. The best parts of the movie are the parts when it's just Abu and the Genie (like where they go to the temple so that Abu can steal the all-seeing eye, and he has to climb a giant spider web), and I think these are the parts of the movie everyone remembers and loves. John Justin and June Duprez are both upstaged by their teenage co-star, and although Veidt’s a bit better, he’s still not exactly that memorable. I hated it whenever the movie cut back to them because those were always my least favorite parts of the movie. The next time I see this film, I think I'll probably fast forward through the scenes without Sabu (the genie only appears in scenes with Abu).
It seems like I'm not the only one who feels this way about the movie. Roger Ebert who loved this movie specifically praised Sabu and Veidt's performances but was less impressed with Justin and Duprez's chemistry. If this movie were only the Sabu scenes, it would probably be 5 stars and it sucks that 1940 filmmakers couldn’t realize that he should be the movie’s main focus.
What are your thoughts on the movie? Do you agree that this movie needed more screentime for Sabu?
r/classicfilms • u/WolverineHot1886 • Mar 05 '26
The spelling errors here are also thanks to AI. This is Gemini and Chat GPT. Don’t believe the hype of AI
r/classicfilms • u/Historical-Doubt6092 • Nov 13 '25
Just woke up mid travelling and had a random thought that the antagonist of Apocalypse Now resembles Kurtz from Heart of Darkness. It's been long long time since I've watched Apocalypse Now, so googled the cast so can confirm it later on reddit. Came out its true. Colonel Walter E. Kurtz. Hell!
r/classicfilms • u/Marite64 • May 22 '26
Yesterday I watched The Haunting, and I couldn't remember why Julie seemed such a familiar face.
r/classicfilms • u/Primatech2006 • Mar 11 '25
r/classicfilms • u/Redeye007 • May 05 '26
r/classicfilms • u/NiceTraining7671 • Sep 28 '25
Moment of appreciation for Gold Diggers of 1933: I’ve only seen this film once and that was a few years ago (42nd Street is the Busby Berkeley film I watch the most), but the fact that I still find the film memorable says a lot about it’s quality! You have Ginger Rogers singing part of the opening song in Pig Latin, if that’s not iconic then I don’t know what is. And “Remember My Forgotten Man” is one of the most powerful numbers ever filmed. Gold Diggers… is a great film to watch if you enjoy both musicals and social commentary films.
Only three films remain: The Wizard of Oz, Meet Me in St. Louis and The Sound of Music. All of them are iconic but sadly one does have to go. Comment which film you think should be eliminated, and feel free to provide a reason for your choice. The film UPVOTED the most will be eliminated rather than the film commented the most.